Saturday, January 29, 2022

Sean McVay, Aaron Donald and the Los Angeles Rams

 February 3rd, 2019: 4:24 left in Super Bowl LIII. New England Patriots 10, Los Angeles Rams 3.

Bill Belichick (66 years old) calls a play of defense for 2nd and 10 from the NE 27 yard line. The Patriots have, surprisingly, shocked the NFL by getting even this close to a Super Bowl. The Patriots offense is nothing like the high-powered attacks of Drew Brees' New Orleans Saints, who averaged 31.5 points per game in 2018, or the Kansas City Chiefs, led by 2018 MVP Patrick Mahomes and his 50 TD passes.

They didn't even have the offense of their opponents in the Super Bowl, led by Todd Gurley, Jared Goff and Brandin Cooks. Over the past 2 seasons, Gurley recorded 3,900 yards of offense, 47 TDs, and a 2nd place finish in MVP in 2017. Goff, in his 3rd season, made the Pro Bowl after throwing 4,600 yards, 32 TDs and 12 INTs, with a QBR of 101 for the 2nd consecutive season. Cooks, who played for the Patriots in 2017's Super Bowl 52 loss, recorded 1,200 receiving yards in 2018, and already had 120 yards in a Super Bowl where the Rams only had 3 points.

Alternatively, the Rams defense was pitching a masterpiece at stopping Tom Brady and the Patriots. Led by Aaron Donald, the NFL Defensive Player of the Year, and Ndamukong Suh, the Rams were suffocating the Patriots vaunted rushing attack, holding them to under 100 yards as a team. In the secondary, linebackers like Cory Littleton, Sam Ebukam and Michael Brockers were taking away Rob Gronkowski, the Patriots HOF Tight End, at all costs. The cost, today, was Julian Edelman, who had 11 catches for 141 yards. It was only on the last drive, when, with 7 minutes to go, Gronk caught a 20-yard pass from Brady to set up 1st and Goal, immediately leading to the 1st touchdown of the game.

The Patriots were exposing the Rams offense by taking away an injured Todd Gurley, who didn't play in the last 2 playoff games for the Rams in favor of CJ Anderson. Gurley had 10 carries for 35 yards. The Patriots were DARING Goff to throw the ball across the field. So now, on that final drive, that's exactly what Goff did. He completed a 15-yard pass to Cooks, then another 15-yarder to Robert Woods. The Rams were driving on the Patriots defense for the 1st time today, sensing the desperation of the game falling out of their grasp.

And so, on that 2nd and 10 from the NE 27, Bill Belichick called an all-out blitz. Linebacker Kyle Van Noy acted as the 5th pass rusher for the Patriots, drawing the blocking protection of Gurley. This created a free rush at Goff for Patriots Safety Duron Harmon, a rare 6th pass rusher on a play where the Rams were almost certain to go deep down the field.

It was the 2nd time all game Bill Belichick called an all-out blitz. And against the better QBs of the NFL, like Mahomes and Brees, the play likely would not have worked. Brees would have had the foresight to check down to his WR sitting on a 5 yard route (for the Rams, this was Josh Reynolds) or throw the ball away. Mahomes would have used his unique rushing ability to escape the rush from Harmon, and buy himself enough time for one of his WRs in single coverage to break off their defender. 

Jared Goff threw from his back foot towards his 1st target Cooks. And the pass came up 6 yards short of the end zone. Cooks didn't even have time to turn around and track the ball before it was intercepted by Stephon Gilmore at the 4 yard line. The Patriots had the ball, up 7 with 4 minutes to go in the Super Bowl. As close to a death sentence as there has been over the last 20 years of NFL Football.....

As the confetti fell, a celebratory Belichick went over to dap up his adversary, Sean McVay. The 33-year-old 2nd-year coach of the Rams had taken a team that didn't make the playoffs for 12 years and won 2 straight NFC West titles, made a Super Bowl, all while going 24-8. The running joke was that every assistant who had ever known McVay, from Matt LaFluer to Kliff Kingsbury to QB coach Zac Taylor, were being hired as NFL Head Coaches during the 2018 coaching cycle. McVay looked like the next great NFL coach, turning a perennial loser into a near-Super Bowl champion in 2 years, all before the age of 33.

However, it wasn't as simple of a "magical run of success" for a team looking for an identity in Los Angeles. McVay was hired by the Rams for one reason specifically: To work with Todd Gurley. McVay had spent 4-5 years studying the zone-running scheme of Kyle Shananhan with the Washington Football team. The Rams were one of the rare run-heavy teams in the NFL, with Gurley being a Pro Bowl RB and Goff being a rookie QB who had 5 TDs, 7 INTs and the worst passer rating in the NFL among qualified starters.

It also didn't hurt that McVay inherited the greatest defensive player of his generation, who would win Defensive Player of the Year in both of McVays 1st 2 seasons. 

McVay was regarded as a genius coach in 2018 because of the work he did with Todd Gurley. As we mentioned earlier, Gurley had 3,900 yards of offense and scored 47 Touchdowns in those 2 McVay seasons. Only Priest Holmes (55) and LaDanian Tomlinson (51) had more TDs in a 2 year stretch than Gurley, in an era where the NFL rules incentivized teams to pass the ball more than using an RB 40 times a game. And his defenses were fantastic because they had stars like Donald, Suh, Marcus Peters and Eric Weddle.

Of the 52 players on the 2018 Rams Super Bowl team, 73% of them were acquired, drafted, or signed under previous Head Coach Jeff Fisher. There were little moves that McVay and GM Les Snead made in the 2 years, like bringing in Robert Woods on waivers and making him a 1,200 yard, $64 million WR. It can also be true that Sean McVay maximized Todd Gurley's potential with his offense, AND also won an NFC Championship with Jeff Fisher's players.

This is not meant to slight Sean McVay, this was the job he was SPECIFICALLY hired to do. And it worked (with the help of a missed pass interference call against the Saints).

Flash forward to the end of 2019. The Rams made the classic mistake teams make after winning a Super Bowl: Thinking you could bring back every player, destroy your cap space, and recapture the magic of the previous year. Jared Goff got a $131 million contract before the 2019 season (which I said on the earliest days of this Podcast was a terrible idea). Todd Gurley was still looking at $66 million over 3 years, Brandin Cooks had 4 years and $57 million, Robert Woods went from making $1.1 million to $12 million a year, Aaron Donald went from $6 million (crazy cheap) to $17 million to $23 million against the salary cap. The Rams also couldn't find the $14 million to resign Ndamukong Suh, who went to join the Tampa Bay Buccaneers after the Super Bowl.

2019 Final Record: 9-7, missed playoffs.

Flash forward 2 more years. The Rams are back in the Super Bowl. Compared to 73% of Jeff Fisher's players in Super Bowl 53, the 2021 Rams team has 3 players from the Fisher regime: Donald, Punter Johnny Hekker, and a 2016 rookie practice squad player named Tyler Higbee.

.....

In the 1970s, Steve Jobs and members of Apple visited Xerox Park to view a pitch for a new invention: A computer interface device. The concept was that, in order to easily navigate the computer interface, people could use a magical device called a "mouse" in order to "click" on little bits of information called "icons" on the computer screen. This idea seems like a silly, simplistic concept now, because this is the way all computers have worked for 40 years. But before the 1970s, only computer programmers could access giant points of data from computers. 

Steve Jobs left that pitch saying that Apple needed to invest every resource they had available in this technology because it would make the computer technology infinitely easier for the common person to use. His fellow investors told him that Apple didn't have the money to invest in this because they were investing in so many other projects. They would go bankrupt if they invested the type of money Jobs was talking about.

As legend has it, Jobs responded to them "Better that we blow ourselves up than let the market do it for us." After investing in this technology, the 1980s created a demand for the computer interface Apple and Xerox perfected, and the technological revolution kicked into high gear. Apple is now worth $3 trillion.

The underlying point is that change is inevitable, and the best leaders have the foresight to see that, while what they're doing now may be working, it may not be the best path going forward. In a weird way, the story of Sean McVay and Les Snead is a story like the story of Steve Jobs and leadership. 

The job of the NFL team is to navigate a cutthroat business designed to legislate parity, thanks to the institution of the salary cap in 1994 to suppress wages and maximize profits. The Rams made all of the mistakes that lead to teams falling from the top of the mountain, wasting years sulking at the mistakes and seeing coaches and GMs getting fired. More often than not, watching generational talents like Aaron Donald go and play for other teams.

Think about the case of the Hoston Texans. Just 2 years ago, the Houston Texans were up 24-0 on the Kansas City Chiefs in the AFC Divisional Round, getting ready to host the 9-7 Titans in the AFC Championship to play the 49ers in the Super Bowl. In 2 years since they've not only gone 8-25, they've also helped fuel 3 DIFFERENT NFL TEAMS most successful runs in 10-15 years (5 1st Rounders to the Dolphins for Laremy Tunsil, DeAndre Hopkins and JJ Watt to the Cardinals for a 2nd Round Pick + whoever trades for Deshaun Watson).

Or, in a cliche transition, think about the Jacksonville Jaguars. In 2017, 1 year before the Rams Super Bowl run, the Jaguars went to the AFC Championship Game and were 8 minutes away from the Super Bowl. And by extending Blake Bortles, trading Calais Campbell, and not resigning Yannick Ngakoue, the Jaguars went 5-11 the next season.

The Jaguars also decided not to extend Jalen Ramsey, the best Cornerback in the NFL, amid a contract dispute and impending tear down the organization was planning. And so, on October 25th 2019, the Rams gave up 2 1st Round Picks to the Jaguars to acquire Ramsey, without any cap space available to sign Ramsey to an extension in 2020. The Rams also had to trade Pro Bowl CB Marcus Peters to the Ravens just to even have enough space to add Ramsey in 2019!!!! Trading 2 1st Round Picks when you're team is strapped for cash and on their way to a 9-7 season is the type of move that could set your team back years if it doesn't work. (Think Odell Beckham with the Browns, Jaylen Waddle with the Dolphins, or Jamal Adams with the Seahawks)

The Rams then up and cut Todd Gurley before the 2020 Free Agency. Gurley had over 1,000 yards in an injury-plagued 2019, but the idea the Rams would just cut one of the great running backs in the NFL, 1 year after he had 1,850 yards and 23 TDs, was dumbfounding. Considering the Rams also had to eat $20 million in dead cap, it was a type of move that signifies teams are punting on the next season.

The Rams also let 8 of the 11 defensive starters from that Super Bowl team leave in free agency (Corey Littleton, Ndamukong Suh, Trumaine Johnson, Michael Brockers, Dante Fowler Sam Ebukam, Troy Hill, John Johnson) without so much as a couple compensatory draft picks coming their way. Los Angeles was not going to fall into the trap of keeping players around at too expensive of price tags, because they had so many players to keep under a salary cap.

Mainly, that concern surrounded Jared Goff. Goff regressed during the 2019 and early 2020 seasons. For years, it had been public knowledge that Sean McVay was feeding Goff audibles at the line of scrimmage up to when their headphones cut off with 15 seconds left on the clock. Without a healthy Gurley, Goff's passer rating declined to 86.5 in 2019 (league average is 91) and 90 in 2020. The Rams were paying Top 5 QB money for average-sub average Quarterback play, which gave them a massive competitive disadvantage relative to the rest of the NFL.

And so, in 2020, things started to fall apart for Goff in Los Angeles. According to Lindsey Thiry of ESPN, Sean McVay and Jared Goff did not speak to each other for the final 6-7 weeks of the 2020 season. When Goff went down with a hand injury, McVay turned to backup QB John Wolford and had relative success. When Goff was healthy enough to return, McVay still started Wolford over Goff but didn't announce it as such. McVay had reached a point where, if he was going to get suboptimal QB play, why not go with a QB that McVay actually enjoyed working with.

Many times in the QB-coach relationship, the high-priced QB ends up winning out in the battle simply because the QB is often a huge financial money-maker for the Franchise. In 2001, Drew Bledsoe signed a $100 million extension with the Patriots because "He was the New England Patriots". In 2016, Ben McAdoo and the 2-11 Giants benched Eli Manning in favor of Geno Smith, snapping Manning's consecutive starts streak, before a meaningless road game vs the Raiders. 10 days later, McAdoo was fired, and the Giants haven't made the playoff since. Just last year, Carson Wentz ended up being benched by Doug Pederson, and 2 months later it was Pederson, a Super Bowl-winning coach, who was gone in Philadelphia. 

McVay and Les Snead, however, were both in agreement that Goff was not the answer. And while the Rams ended up sneaking into the playoffs in 2020, thanks to a Week 18 injury to Kyler Murray costing Arizona a playoff spot, the Rams were STILL thinking bigger and better when it came to their QB position. 2 weeks after losing a Divisional Playoff Game to the Packers, the Rams had their man: Matthew Stafford, who was acquired for ANOTHER 2 1st Round Picks, a move unheard of in the NFL over the last 20 years.

The Rams traded 2 1st Rounders to get Jared Goff in 2016, then traded their 1st in 2018 to acquire Brandin Cooks, who had since been traded to Houston for a pick swap in the 2020 Draft, then traded 1st Rounders in 2019 and 2020 to get Ramsey, and 1sts in 2022 and 2023 to upgrade from Jared Goff to Matthew Stafford.

Sean McVay and the Rams also abandoned their identity on offense. Because the Rams had Todd Gurley, one of the greatest running backs in the 21st century NFL, and Jared Goff, a QB with the worst passer rating in the NFL as a rookie, their identity was built in the running game for years. Everyone applauded McVay as a genius for his zone-running scheme and ability to outthink opposing defenses. 

In 2021, the Rams had Darrell Henderson, who was the backup before Cam Akers tore his Achilles in training camp, and Sony Michel, who was traded for a 6th round pick as a salary dump for the New England Patriots. The Rams ran the ball less than any of the final 8 playoff teams in the NFL, and were one of just 3 teams with an above .500 record that lost the time of possession battle in the 2021 season (teams that run the ball are more likely to lead in time of possession because incomplete passes stop the clock from running, while every run play allows the clock to keep running)

And this was purely an example of what players the Rams have. Cooper Kupp had his 1st Pro Bowl and All-Pro season in 2021 for the Rams, recording 1,947 yards receiving when his previous career high was 1,100 yards. Robert Woods was on pace for 1600 yard receiving before tearing his ACL in Week 8 of the season. Van Jefferson, who was drafted with the pick they got for Brandin Cooks, recorded 802 yards receiving in the Rams offense.

The Rams also signed Odell Beckham Jr after his fallout with the Cleveland Browns, which was seen as another "all-in" type of move, given Beckham's perception as a bad teammate who forced his way out of Cleveland. In reality, Beckham was in a bad situation was a less-than-average QB, and the Rams got an advantage from the rest of the playoff teams (specifically the GB Packers) in not seeing the promise/possibility of a former All-Pro WR.

Defensively, the Rams proceeded to extend Leonard Floyd, the former 1st Round Pick from the Chicago Bears, to pair alongside Aaron Donald. The Rams defense was not the same team it was in 2018, or 2019, or even 2020. They finished 15th in DVOA in the 2021 season, yet their strength was having Ramsey, the #1 Cornerback in the NFL, and Donald, the 3x Defensive Player of the Year. Then, once Floyd wasn't the signing they had intended (finished 45th among edge rushers according to PFF) the Rams didn't accept their mistake and have a bad pass rush. They went out and acquired HOFer Von Miller from the Denver Broncos for their 2 highest remaining Draft Picks over the next 2 years.

When one of these all-in moves might define the legacy of a coach/GM pairing, the Rams have made all-in move after all-in move. Personally, I don't even like using the term "all-in" to describe the Rams moves, because it's all within the constructs of the NFL system. The great untold market inefficiency in the NFL is that we all place too high of values on Draft Picks in the NFL. Like a new car, those draft picks immediately lose value as soon as they are taken off the board. Think of Lynn Bowden, the Raiders 3rd Round pick in 2020, who was traded for a 4th round pick to the Dolphins before ever playing a single game in Las Vegas. 

The Rams have made correct moves without fear of ridicule or fear of blowing themselves up in the process. Like with Steve Jobs, the Rams saw the path they were currently on as unsustainable, and so trading picks for Von Miller, Matthew Stafford, Van Jefferson, and others is a trade off that, if successful, gives them a competitive advantage against the very best of the best NFL teams.

Low and behold, it worked!!!! The Rams retired Tom Brady on the strength of their pass rush, led by Donald and Von Miller. In a 27-27 game, with 40 seconds left, Matthew Stafford connected with Cooper Kupp for a 50-yard play that set up the game-winner for the Los Angeles Rams. These were moves specifically made for that moment, to get the Rams back to that point. Even if they collapse and lose that game to the Buccaneers, it wouldn't have been because the Rams made bad moves in trading those picks and getting rid of the players they did. It will have been because the Rams had an epic collapse with a missed FG, 4 fumbles, and a snap that flew 25 yards backward after a strip-sack.

The fact the Rams are playing in a 2nd Super Bowl in 4 years is ridiculous. The fact they're doing it without a Franchise QB makes it even more remarkable. And the fact they've done it with 2 different teams in 3 years is pretty incredible. Sean McVay and Les Snead are fascinating experiments in leadership in this weird arena of sports. Yes, none of this is anywhere close to possible without having Aaron Donald, because every great team has to have really great players.

Yes, Andrew Whitworth is also still on the team, and Cooper Kupp was on the 2018 team before he tore his ACL in November. For the most part, The Rams have taken their 2 anchors, their 1st Ballot HOF Defensive Tackle, and one of the best coaches in the NFL at 35 years old, and rebuilt an entire roster from scratch capable of beating some of the greatest QBs and greatest defenses in the NFL.

With the foundation of Aaron Donald and Sean McVay, the Los Angeles Rams went from a crumbling dynasty with a bad QB contract, broken RB, and roster of players leaving in Free Agency to an NFC Champion with a completely new team in just 3 years. It took every top draft pick they had, and some slick salary cap navigating, and yet here they are, again. 

It's an absolutely remarkable feat that should be celebrated, regardless of how the Super Bowl goes for them. Getting back to this point is legendary enough for a team that was destined towards a fate of the Philadelphia Eagles, Atlanta Falcons, or Carolina Panthers.

Willingness to accept change, even when things are going wrong, is a great lesson in leadership we can take away from this run of Rams football. Leadership can even come from a coach who has been the youngest in the NFL for all 5 years he's been a coach.