The New Orleans Saints "Last Dance" is not off to the greatest start, with the news that Alvin Kamara has been holding out of Saints camp from the last 3 days. Kamara is a former 3rd Round Pick who, like Dak Prescott, has been one of the most valuable players in the NFL relative to the Salary Cap. Kamara has totaled 4500 all purpose yards over 3 seasons, 2nd only to Christian McCaffery, while making a grand total of $3.5 million in his NFL Career. Kamara is a Free Agent after 2020, barring a Franchise Tag Situation.
The Saints are in a lose-lose situation. Really, it's a Lose-Lose-Lose-Lose situation. Either they A. Pay Kamara the money he deserves and regret the decision immediately after he signs the deal. B. Let Kamara hold out in their last season of competitive football C. Call his bluff and push the holdout down the road after they inevitably Franchise Tag Kamara D. Kamara has a catastrophic season and they let him walk in Free Agency.
But, this was inevitable for the Saints. Players that brought great value in the past inevitably age and command large amounts of money on the Open Market. All of a sudden, those players that enabled you to ascend to the top of the NFL become thorns in your side as the years pass on. This is what allows for so much team turnover at the Top and Bottom of the NFL, unlike Sports like the NBA, College Football and the MLB, which have smaller rates of turnover.
As We've Discussed Before, this season is the Last Dance for the New Orleans Saints. Drew Brees is on his way out the door and into an NBC Broadcast Chair. Kamara is a Free Agent, along w/ 8 starters who are either Free Agents or at risk of being cut. Replacing those guys becomes nearly impossible in an offseason which has less options than 2019, and paying them will lead to the same kind of mediocrity the Vikings, Bears, Titans, Eagles, Rams and Giants have been experiencing.
It's not like the Saints haven't put themselves in a position of success, though. Emmanuel Sanders is the first true WR2 they've had over the last 3 years. They drafted Cesar Ruiz to hopefully replace Max Unger, and the defense hasn't lost key pieces. The Saints are really good, but they'll only be really good for another season.
Despite the success of the Tampa Bay Bucs offseason or the Atlanta Falcons hopes of an improved defense, the Saints are still the favorites in the NFC South. In fact, their the traditional pick to win the NFC all together. The Saints should embrace that "Last Dance" mentality because of the realities of sustainability in the NFL and having a lack of deep draft picks. Sure, the Patriots have replaced players over the years, but they have a harsh system of player evaluation that makes everybody expendable and tradable, regardless of their merits.
The Saints are not that. In fact, they might fold to Kamara's requests and give him a wonderful new contract that will haunt them for years to come. Yes, they haven't made any big long term commitments, but that's because the right player hasn't come around yet. And they shouldn't start with Alvin Kamara, even if they have the available Cap Space. Just because the money is there doesn't mean a new contract should be given out, because a day will come where that money won't be there. Just ask the Vikings about that, as they try to mingle their way to a Yannick Ngakoue contract and reworking Kirk Cousins deal to clear short term cap space.
The Patriots are the model franchise for sustainability, and they achieve this by being strategic about who gets a new contract. The star FA Corner Stephon Gilmore gets one, but not Trey Flowers or Jamie Collins. Donta Hightower at MLB is extremely valuable, but not Nate Solder or Trent Brown. Or paying a premium for a decade of Stephen Gotskowski, but not a decade of Chris Hogan and Kyle Van Noy.
The Saints have been great at this practice... So Far. Now is when they really get tested. Yes, they gave Michael Thomas a 5 year Contract, but they can get opt out of the last 2 years of the deal. Star Players like Kamara, Marshon Lattimore and Ryan Ramzyck have contracts coming up soon, and the Saints would be wise to let them walk and replace them with young players.
Any contracts handed out in the next year will only be damaged goods that will take longer to recover from. And that patience now should reward the future Saints' GM's/Presidents and Sean Payton with a faster climb back to the Top of the Sport.
There's no shame in what the Saints have accomplished over the last 4 years. They've won 11, 13 and 13 games over the last 3 respective seasons. Winning a Super Bowl in 2020 rewards the sustained in building the team back up from the NFL's ridiculous BountyGate penalties. It also gives Drew Brees the perfect ending to a storybook career.
If you don't win it, there's no shame in not winning it all. Things bounced the wrong way for the Saints (All 3 seasons, might I add). It doesn't take away from the fact New Orleans has been the best team in the NFL over the last 4 seasons (yes, that includes 2 AFC titles from the Patriots). But don't dig yourself a hole like the Rams did in 2019, or the Jaguars did in 2018. It'll make the fall a lot more painful than it needs to be.
Here's to one "Last Dance" for Drew Brees, Sean Payton, and this era of the New Orleans Saints.