Monday, November 30, 2020

How NFL Teams Should Hire With 7-10 Open Head Coaching Jobs

 There are presently 3 open Head Coaching Jobs in the NFL: The Lions, Falcons, and Texans. There will be anywhere from 2 to 6 more jobs opening up in the next 5 weeks. Adam Gase, Zac Taylor and Doug Marrone are dead men walking, waiting for seasons to play out with as many losses as possible for the Jets and Jaguars to secure future Franchise QB's. Anthony Lynn, Matt Nagy and Mike Zimmer have boiling seats right now, with teams making tough decisions based potentially on these last 3 weeks. Joe Judge and Vic Fangio will be fired by January 2022, and their teams may decide to move on from them a year early.

There will be no shortage of Head Coaching Openings in 2020 (unlike the small number of 4 last year). There are 2 routes every single one of these 7 teams should go down (after Eric Bieniemy scoops up one of these Head Coaching jobs).

1. College Head Coaches paired w/ great Offensive Coordinators. If College Coaching hires have proven anything over the last decade, from Pete Carroll to Jim Harbaugh to Bill O'Brien, it's that they are great at seeing a process through. The Seahawks started with nothing, and in 5 years built a Super Bowl champion. Same for the 49ers, winning the NFC Championship and playing in another. For the Texans, they won 2 playoff games, 4 AFC South titles, and drafted a generational Quarterback. It all fell apart when they took away the checks and balances on Bill O'Brien's Power.

We're seeing now what seeding total control of your organization does to organizations. It allows Jon Gruden to make hard, correct decisions in trading Khalil Mack and Amari Cooper for a long rebuilding process. It allows Sean McVay to build a RB core that best suits Jared Goff's limitations, and for GM Les Snead to piece together players around Aaron Donald like Leonard Floyd and Dante Fowler (now in ATL). And, it allows Matt Rhule, the 1st year coach from Baylor, to tear down the Panthers roster and build it up from scratch with Teddy Bridgewater, Robby Anderson, 3 1st Round Picks on offense, and draft 7 defensive players with your 1st 7 draft picks, the first time such an event has ever happened. Time will tell on Matt Rhule, but the underlying processes are in place that give him the best possible chance to succeed.

There's a reason that 4 teams (DET, ATL, HOU, and JAX) fired GM's along with their Head Coaches. I see what the Panthers, Raiders, Rams, 49ers, Bills, and others are doing with seeding total control to their people. Maybe Arthur Blank and Shad Khan see this as well. College Coaches are already coming from a place they have total power, and where they work in unison with an Athletic Director type body. They are great NFL hires, while NFL coaches are often bad fits in the College system.

This is why, when hiring a College coach, you can't get the best of the best coaches. There are 10-13 College Coaching jobs that are more desirable than any NFL Head Coaching opportunity. The best example of this was Nick Saban leaving the Dolphins to go to Alabama in 2007. Those 10-13 jobs include:

Locks: Alabama, Clemson, Ohio State, Oklahoma, Notre Dame, Florida, Georgia, LSU, Wisconsin, and Jimbo Fisher w/ Texas A&M money. Debatable: Being coach at Michigan State, Auburn and Penn State are debatable jobs on whether they'd leave for an NFL job, but neither Mel Tucker, Gus Malzhan or James Franklin are in the running for NFL jobs.

If none of those coaches are going to leave for the NFL, that leaves a small pool of candidates left behind for NFL teams to trust. Not everyone is going to get a College Coach (unless someone convinces Lincoln Riley to leave w/ a Gruden-esque $11 million a year deal) but here's some of the names they can pick from:

Jim Harbaugh, Michigan        Pat Fitzgerald, Northwestern,         Mario Cristobal, Oregon      

PJ Fleck, Minnesota (my favorite option)     Matt Campbell, Iowa State

All of these coaches get me excited for NFL teams. Sure, they may not be sexy hires or big names. But with the exception of Harbaugh, they've found lots of success at obscure College Football teams. For those who don't follow College Football, I can't stress enough how impressive of a job it is to win, and win consistently in the wastelands of College Football. All of these coaches should excite NFL teams who's jobs are 2nd tier when compared to the 10-12 jobs I listed above.

2. Hire Joe Brady. Joe Brady was a typical 29 year old assistant coach with the New Orleans Saints in 2018. Like so many assistant coaches, Brady was paying his dues towards becoming a future NFL coach, maybe in 10 or 20 years. Across the state, Ed Orgeron needed to improve LSU's lackluster passing attack, which had been the case for the 5 years he'd been at LSU (they're all time leading receiver was Dwayne Bowe, with 12 TD's in one season and an average NFL career). In a bold move, Orgeron hired Joe Brady as his passing game coordinator (Co-OC title).

The rest is history. Joe Brady's system embraced the spread offense, and it brought out the talent in Joe Burrow that Ohio State and even LSU couldn't bring out in 3 seasons. Justin Jefferson, Jamar Chase and Terrence Marshall all broke single season school records for passing TD's. Joe Burrow broke the All Time TD's record. Brady had cracked the code with his offense, adapted from the 2018 Saints whom outproduced a 50 TD MVP season from Patrick Mahomes.

Brady translated his success with Burrow into the OC job with the Carolina Panthers under our buddy Matt Rhule in 2020. Brady is youngest OC in the NFL at 31 years old. While the win-loss results are a mixed bag, the offensive results can't be ignored. Mike Davis, the 4th Round Backup who'd been cut twice, is one of the 10 most productive running backs in the NFL. Robby Anderson and DJ Moore were both Top 5 in the NFL in receiving yards (Last week Moore was #5 and Anderson was #7). Teddy Bridgewater, who has never finished higher than 14th in passing yards, is the #3 leading passer in the NFL.

Joe Brady has simply been paying dues, and it does not matter whether Carolina is failing to put up points. Brady has something unique in his offensive play calling. The only way to pry him from Carolina is to offer him the Head Coaching Job for your franchise. It's the same move the Rams did when hiring Sean McVay, and it was a genius move. I see hiring Brady similarly to the Rams call to hire McVay at age 31 (Brady will be 32 next September). Brady is young, he has an offense that has proven success in 2 places as a play caller. Someone needs to make him their next head coach (And quite frankly, it should be the Bengals).

Saturday, November 28, 2020

Time for Detroit to Make a 2nd Hard, Right Move and Cut/Trade Matthew Stafford

 The Detroit Lions, led by new chairwoman of the board Sheila Ford Hamp, made the hard, right move on Saturday. GM Bob Quinn and Head Coach Matt Patricia were fired following a 41-25 loss on Thanksgiving that all but eliminated the Lions from playoff contention. Sheila Ford Hamp will now hire her 1st GM and 1st Head Coach since taking over ownership of the Lions from her mother (Jim Harbaugh and Thomas Dimitroff??)

The Lions now must do the hard, right move and cut 12 year QB Matthew Stafford. If the Lions release or trade Stafford by March 12th, when Free Agency opens, they will take a $20 million dead cap hit in 2021 (equal to the Patriots dead cap on Tom Brady this year) and then be free of Stafford's contract. If they retain Stafford past March 12th, Stafford's last 2 years and $64 million will be fully guaranteed.

Any new Head Coach gets 3 years in the NFL to build their team before evaluation. Sometimes, it's obvious a year or even 2 in advance that the evaluation is complete. For example, we know Adam Gase won't be able to turn the Jets into a contender in 12 months, so he will be fired. For Patricia, this was Year 3 of the evaluation process. The Ford's were debating getting rid of him last season, but ultimately were willing to see the process through. It did not work, obviously. GM's often get 2 head coaches to build with, and for Quinn that 2nd Coach was Patricia.

There are 3 main ways failures of Head Coaches comes from. A. Being forced into scheming around a particular quarterback. B. Coach and GM picking the wrong quarterback. C. A small handful of Mike McCarthy/Dan Quinn examples where the voice becomes tedious and there is a refusal to innovate.

The Lions certainly DO NOT have to give a coach a 3 year window to prove themselves. They can give out 6, 7, or 10 year deals like Oakland/Las Vegas gave to Jon Gruden or Carolina did for Matt Rhule. If the Lions can land a big fish who's process you emphatically trust, you should hire them and give them job security. If you're going to give a coach 3 years to build a winner you cannot allow them to keep Stafford as a mandatory holdover for 2 years.

Let's first view the scenario of a traditional coaching hire. If the Lions hire the snazzy Offensive Coach, say an Eric Bieniemy or Brian Daboll, and give them a 4 year contract, then the Lions are in essence giving them 3 years to build a winner. If you trust the coach enough to hand over the keys to your football team, you should trust them to make the necessary personnel decisions for them to implement their vision. If you don't trust them to do right by your team, why hire them to do the job in the first place?? Lacking trust in your appointed leader means immediate failure from the start. If you trust them to do right by your organization, that should mean allowing them, if they so choose, to move on from 32 year old Matthew Stafford who makes $32 million a year. 

Maybe Bieniemy, Daboll, or Robert Saleh thinks they can get the most of an expense, mid-30's Stafford, despite the fact a quarterback making more than $20 million has never won a Super Bowl. If such is the case... then I wish that coach good luck. More likely than not, the coach is going to pick their own Young, 1st Round quarterback. If the Packers trust Brian Gutekunst and Matt LaFluer enough to move on from Aaron Rodgers for Jordan Love, it's likely a GM/coach tandem will move on from ANY QB, given the chance. Plus, why wouldn't you want to pick your own QB??? Because the QB they pick might be a bust?? If that's the case, then this GM/coach tandem was doomed to fail from the beginning.

Therefore, if the coach/GM are going to pick their own QB anyways, why not rid themselves of Stafford now while they have a chance. There will never be a better time than right now, first of all because 70% of Stafford's contract is not guaranteed until March, and secondly because you are wiping the slate clean for, hopefully, the next 10 years.

Now, let's operate in a world where the Lions make a splash hire. They learn from the Raiders and Panthers, along with the large, 6-7 year extensions given out by the Rams, 49ers, Bills, Chiefs and Seahawks, that it's smart to give a long contract to your coach/GM so they have the security to make the Hard, correct decisions. Most coaches/GM's are risk adverse because they don't have the job security to take risks to win Super Bowls. For 70% of teams in the NFL, their mission is to keep their job first, then worry about winning a Super Bowl second. It's why teams are so risk adverse in resigning their own players to overpay contracts, buying them years in the 7-9 purgatory like the Falcons, Vikings, Bears, Eagles, Texans, among others.

For Shiela Ford Hamp, this is also being more prone to risk. If you give out a 7-8 year contract, there is still the chance everything blows up in 3-4 years, and the firing of a coach becomes more expensive. This is a financial risk (to the tune of $20-40 million more than with Patricia/Quinn) Shiela and the Lions must be willing to take. The losses are potentially $20-100 million in lost revenue paid towards this failed regime 5-10 years from now. The benefits are a Football team that makes more hard, correct decisions over their adversaries, a direct competitive advantage that will allow the Lions to gain a leg up on their competition.

The risk adverse situation is to reevaluate in 3 years w/ less risky buyouts (only about $12 million for a coach/GM). The more risky choice is to give a big contract to a coach you trust the way the Raiders and Panthers trusted Jon Gruden and Matt Rhule (those other teams I listed only gave 6-8 year extensions after seeing proven results). Of course, the riskier choice has a higher upside, in that the Lions can break their curse of obscurity and make some difficult, correct choices they otherwise wouldn't be making, like moving on from their QB who's #9 will be retired one day. The downside is having to be back here in 5 years, which they'll likely have to do if they choose the less risky option.

Let's give a massive contract to a College Coach (Jim Harbaugh) or someone who's offensive schemes are absolutely McVay-ian (maybe Joe Brady of LSU/Carolina fame). Hire a GM who's getting his first crack at running a team, and give him the job security he needs to make the hard choices, like cutting Matthew Stafford. Your 2024 selves will thank you for it, or simply be writing a bigger buyout check than before.

Whichever way they choose, it'll be obvious from the get go what the Lions will be looking like for the next 3-5 years based simply on their choices on Matt Stafford.

Thursday, November 26, 2020

The Raiders Need to Find their "Patrick Mahomes"

 Derek Carr is at the "Alex Smith Chiefs" stage of his career. His next starting job will likely be for a rebuilding team, moving from their franchise QB (maybe even Kirk Cousins in Minnesota, like Smith for the Racial Slurs). The Raiders offense has been highly effective with outside runs complimented with a passing attack that has made Nelson Agholor a #1 WR. If Jon Gruden weren't so old, we'd be thinking about him the same way we think about Sean McVay and Kyle Shanahan in regards to offensive playcalling.

What Gruden and the Raiders need now is their version of Patrick Mahomes. The Raiders need their young, cheap QB with a higher ceiling than Derek Carr (who to his credit, will probably finish Top 12 in the MVP Voting). While their QB probably won't be as good as Mahomes, it's not like Mahomes was this otherworldly talent. Mahomes was regarded as the #3 QB in his draft class. He was drafted at Pick 10 because the Chiefs were willing to sell the farm to get Mahomes. Mahomes also benefits from being in a system that tailors to his gifts, with the best run organization in the NFL not named New England. Had Mahomes been drafted 1 pick earlier by the Cincinnati Bengals, I doubt Mahomes is viewed nearly as highly as he is now.

For the Raiders, there will be no shortage of Quarterback options in the 2021 Draft Class. There are 7 "Patrick Mahomes" 1st Round QB's available for grabs in this offseason. 6 Rookies are expected to be drafted in the 1st Round of the NFL Draft: Trevor Lawrence, Justin Fields, Zach Wilson, Trey Lance, Kyle Trask, and Mac Jones. The 7th is the availability of 2018 #3 Pick Sam Darnold for a 2nd Round Pick. All of those QB's represent the Raiders version of "Patrick Mahomes" to their Alex Smith, that being Derek Carr.

Carr, the Raiders longest tenured QB, has looked as good as the teams he's played for. Carr was an MVP candidate in 2016, when the Raiders snapped a 14 year playoff drought. In 2018, Gruden took over and tore down the Franchise and rebuilt it. Talented players like Khalil Mack and Amari Cooper were traded for 1st Round Picks. Carr looked perfectly average without any of the talented players of 2016. Famously, Carr began crying after taking a sack in London. Now, the Raiders have talent again, and cheap talent. They are one of the brightest futures in the sport, and Gruden finally has pieces to run an effective offense spearheaded by Carr and 1,000 yard Running Back Josh Jacobs.

If the Raiders are ever going to reach the mountaintop, it is going to be via the strength of their offense. Carr is a fine QB, better than all but 16 or so QB's in the sport. He's also making $25 million a year to be the Bengals Andy Dalton of 2020. The Raiders need to be thinking bigger than Andy Dalton.

The logical choice for finding their "Patrick Mahomes" actually comes from the guy who is 37 year old Mahomes: Aaron Rodgers. Sooner or later, the Packers are going to move on from Rodgers, and the Raiders should give up the farm to acquire Rodgers. In the meantime, Carr is a nice contingency plan, but you won't be winning AFC West's and Super Bowls with Derek Carr at the helm.

If the Raiders draft QB in the 1st Round of 2021, they don't have to dump Carr right away. Much like with Mahomes in Kansas City, Trey Lance/Mac Jones can sit behind Carr for a year/8 weeks, before taking the keys to a high powered offense. QB's are not innately "busts", the infrastructure around them makes them into great QB's. It's why the Browns went through 20+ QB's in 20 years, while the Patriots turned their Backup QB into an NFC Champion with San Francisco. Or why Sam Darnold is a bust and Mahomes is a HOFer, despite the fact ALL draft scouts had Darnold graded higher than Mahomes.

The Raiders, for all the shit they've gotten over the last 2 years, are a very well run organization. Mark Davis is a more hands-off owner now that he's given Gruden the keys to the Death Star. Gruden has proven he is still a GREAT offensive mind. His playcalling and schemes this year have been right up with the Shanahan's and Stefanski's of the NFL. 

I have very strong conviction that, no matter which QB the Raiders end up with, he will be at least a serviceable NFL Starter. That's basically what Carr is at this point. The difference for Las Vegas: This rookie QB will make $13 million over 4 years, with a higher growth potential than a 30 year old Carr who, like Andy Dalton, will not be an NFL starter in 4 years.

Whether or not the Raiders make the playoffs (30% chance right now) doesn't have an impact on their plan going forward. No more Alex Smith. No more Derek Carr. Think bigger, take some risks. That's how the Raiders can take the next step and become Super Bowl contenders.

Wednesday, November 25, 2020

What if Matthew Stafford Never Went to the Detroit Lions

 The hype surrounding the 2021 NFL Draft and Once-In-A-Generation QB Trevor Lawrence could be foretold 12 years ago, during the 2009 NFL Draft. In 2008, the Detroit Lions became the 1st team in NFL History to go 0-16 (Played 16 games since 1978). They're poor season was all in an effort to land a Once-In-A-Generation QB from Georgia named Matthew Stafford.

12 years later, the marriage between Stafford and the Lions is still intact. I question how this franchise hasn't driven Matt to the brink of insanity yet. Before I begin listing stats, take note that WINS ARE NOT QB STATS!!!! It's not a Stafford problem, it's a Lions problem.

Over 12 years, the Detroit Lions have won 0 NFC North titles. They've made the playoffs 3 times, going 0-3 on the road as a Wild Card. In 12 years, the Lions have produced 1 Top 10 defense (They're best season of 11-5 in 2014) and only 2 top 15 defenses (#13 the year Jim Caldwell was fired). The Lions forced Calvin Johnson, the best WR of his generation, into early retirement, replacing him with a blend of Marvin Jones' and Golden Tate's. This despite the fact Stafford has been Top 10 in Passing Yards 4 times, is the fastest in league history to 10K, 20K, 30K, 40K, and 50K passing yards, and that Stafford has more comeback wins in the 4th quarter than any player in NFL post-2008.

So on this lovely Thanksgiving, a yearly celebration of Lions mediocrity, I wanted to dive into the question "What if the Lions never Drafted Matt Stafford??" Would Stafford be viewed as an All-time great. Would his career go differently than now?? What is Stafford had done what many think Trevor Lawrence should do: Say under no circumstances he would play for the Lions??

To answer this question, I looked at other teams at the Top of the 2009 NFL Draft and what could've been if they had drafted Stafford at #1.

St Louis Rams

The Rams held the #2 Pick in the NFL Draft, so let's envision they had gotten the #1 Pick over the Lions. The Rams hired Steve Spagnuolo before the 2009 Draft, and 1 year later they drafted Sam Bradford. In this world, Spagnuolo gets Stafford w/ the #1 Pick in 2009, then after 1 year of 4-12 football the Rams get the #4 Pick and draft future HOF LT Trent Williams to protect Stafford.

In real life, Stafford gets hurt in the 2010, replaced by Shaun Hill en route to a 6-10 season. In this version of events, the Stafford injury knocks the Rams down to either the #8 or #9 pick in the 2011 NFL Draft (roughly 5-11). In 2011, the real #8 Pick (right after Julio Jones) was Jake Locker. Rams don't need him. Pick #9 was Tyron Smith. Rams don't need him, they took Trent Williams. Pick #10 was Blaine Gabbert. Don't need a QB. So, the Rams go with the guy originally taken at Pick #11: Defensive End JJ Watt. 

With a healthy Stafford, a Spagnuolo defense headed by the Rookie of the Year, and protection on the Offensive Line (Bradford's biggest problem) the Rams finally put it all together in 2011. The Rams make the Wild Card at 10-6 (just like the Lions did) and lose to the Saints. In 2012, they face the Falcons in the 2nd Round, and fall to a Mike Smith #1 seed and a high powered offense of Matt Ryan, Roddy White and Tony Gonzalez. In 2013, they are the 2nd best team in the NFC (only behind the Legion of Boom Seahawks, in their own division). Because of the Wild Card rules, the Rams have to play Seattle in the Divisional Round vs. the NFC Championship game. They lose to the Legion of Boom, who goes on to win the Super Bowl.

In 2014, the Rams regressed to a middle of the pack team. JJ Watt's 2nd Defensive Player of the Year helped them sneak into the playoffs, where they were routed by Tony Romo and the Cowboys (just like the Detroit Lions did in 2014). By 2015, Watt was again DPOY, but the Rams failed to make the playoffs. In 2016, the wheels fell off for the Rams. Spagnuolo was fired, Watt got hurt, and the Rams got the #5 Pick in the NFL Draft (like they did in real life, just without the Jared Goff pick). Sean McVay gets hired as the Head Coach of the Rams in 2017.

For the sake of this conversation, let's say McVay chooses Stafford as his QB (I REALLY want to make the case for McVay drafting Patrick Mahomes with the #5 Pick in the Draft). Although the Rams don't have Todd Gurley, the Rams do the #5 Pick in the NFL Draft. In a bold move, the Rams pass on Jamal Adams for a Running Back from Stanford named Christian McCaffery. Paired with a defense led by JJ Watt (not Aaron Donald, who plays for Houston), the Rams Offense is ranked #1 in the NFL in 2018. Stafford's stats look fairly similar to Jared Goff's numbers in 2018, and he makes the Pro Bowl with more highlight reel plays than Goff.

Stafford and the Rams play Brees and the Saints in the NFC Championship Game to play the Patriots in Super Bowl 53. After a missed pass interference call on Nickel Roby-Coleman, the game goes to Overtime. After a Drew Brees INT to start OT, Stafford leads the Rams down to the 14 yard line, where McCaffery breaks through the front 7 and scores the NFC Championship touchdown. In that Super Bowl, Stafford and the Rams offense is able to counter the Patriots defense better than Goff and CJ Anderson. By a final score of 27-13, Matthew Stafford is a Super Bowl MVP. The Rams celebrate with confetti as JJ Watt, the greatest defensive player of his generation, captures his 1st Super Bowl to put a stamp on his legacy.

Kansas City Chiefs

The 3rd Pick in the 2009 NFL Draft belonged to the Kansas City Chiefs. They fired Herm Edwards and hired Todd Haley as Head Coach. Let's say Stafford demanded the Lions not pick him, and with the #3 Pick the Chiefs can swing a deal to get him. Stafford is paired with a star Running Back in Jamal Charles. Haley improves the offense in year 1, and Stafford wins Rookie of the Year. KC goes 7-9 and with the #12 pick selects Jason Pierre Paul. 

In 2010, the Chiefs win the AFC West. In this scenario, they win the division handily. They still lose to the Baltimore Ravens in the Wild Card, but KC shows signs of improvement. In 2011, Stafford gets hurt, the wheels fall off, and Haley has an ugly exit from Kansas City. The team hired Romeo Crennel, and in 2012 the Chiefs, while not getting the #1 Pick, missed the playoffs again. Realizing Crennel is the wrong coach for Stafford and Charles, the Chiefs fire him and draft Ezekiell Ansah.

This is where things get interesting. Andy Reid, the best coach in the game not named Belichick, joins a Chiefs team with a star QB who carried a pitiful team to 5 wins in 2012. In 2013, Reid and Stafford have a formidable attack that wins 11 games in year 1 (just like w/ Alex Smith). The Chiefs fall to the Indianapolis Colts after holding a 38-10 lead (which actually happened, watch it on YouTube). In 2014, the Chiefs turn into a Superb team. Stafford finishes 3rd in the MVP race, the Chiefs win the division. The Chiefs beat Pittsburgh before losing to the eventual champion Patriots in the Divisional Round.

2015 is when the Chiefs go off to end the season. Stafford and co. win 12 straight games to cap off a 13-3 season (they won 10 straight to end 2015 w/ Smith). Stafford and Cam Newton engage in the MVP race of a lifetime, with debate shows going on and on and on about Newton or Stafford. Stafford or Newton. While Cam ultimately prevails (15-1 record), the Chiefs get the #1 seed in the AFC over division rival Denver. In the playoffs, Kansas City plays the #6 seed Pittsburgh without Antonio Brown (Burfict hit). The Chiefs make it to the AFC Championship vs. the Denver Broncos. Everyone starts fantasizing about a Stafford-Newton Super Bowl 50. Unfortunately, the "No-Fly-Zone" defeats the Chiefs on their home field, and the Broncos go on to win the Super Bowl over Carolina with broken Peyton Manning.

In 2016, the Chiefs again win the AFC West at 12-4. In the Divisional Round, the Chiefs lose at home to the Killer B's (just like in real life). At this point in time, Reid would be trading up for Patrick Mahomes. There would be no such move with a QB who has finished Top 5 in the MVP 3 straight seasons. Instead, Kansas City stays at #27 and Draft the guy Buffalo took with their pick post-Mahomes trade: All-Pro CB Tre'Davious White

Just like the 2017 Chiefs, Kansas City started 8-0 with Kareem Hunt and an above average defense. Stafford is the #1 for MVP, before injuries start to short circuit his and the Chiefs season. The Chiefs finish 11-5, getting the #3 seed in the AFC. They beat the Tyrod Taylor Bills in the Wild Card, setting up a matchup with the Pittsburgh Steelers. Just like the 2018 Jaguars, the Chiefs won to force a matchup with the Patriots in the AFC Championship. Stafford, who would finish 3rd in the MVP to Tom Brady and Todd Gurley, would battle injuries in that game and lose to the Patriots, who would lose to Nick Foles in the Super Bowl.

The 2018 Chiefs (what would be the 1st Mahomes year) get off to a rocket start. After 4 years of being "just short", Stafford wins his 1st MVP in 2018, leading the NFL with 43 TD's (Mahomes had 50). After losing to the Patriots a year ago in the AFC Championship, the Chiefs defeat New England in Overtime (by winning a coin toss) and advance to play Jared Goff, CJ Anderson and the Rams. The Chiefs defense was much better than their real life 2018 version, thanks to Tre'Davious White anchoring the secondary. Ultimately, tickertape falls on Andy Reid, Stafford and the Chiefs for the 1st time in 50 years.

In 2019, Stafford and Kansas City again won 12 games. While Stafford didn't finish Top 5 in MVP (for the 1st time since 2014), Kansas City's defense was Top 5 in the league, thanks to additions of Tyrann Matheiu and Frank Clark, going along with superstars like Tre'Davious White and Chris Jones.

The Chiefs get some easy playoff matchups vs. the Houston Texans and (thanks to an upset of the Ravens) the Titans in the AFC Championship. The Chiefs become back to back AFC Champions, and face the 49ers in Super Bowl 54. Thanks to a big play to Tyreek Hill, the Chiefs become the 1st Back to Back Champions since the Patriots of 2003-2004. Stafford wins his 2nd Ring, and makes plans for a 3-Peat in 2020, along with his 2nd MVP award. He is the best QB in the NFL, and Stafford is a 1st Ballot Lock for the HOF.

Monday, November 23, 2020

The Ravens Are at a Crossroad in The Lamar Jackson Era

 Last week, I was infatuated by the Titans-Ravens Matchup, given both Tennessee and Baltimore were freefalling in the standings (Titans 1-3 in last 4 and Baltimore 1-2 in their last 3). The loser of this game would be out of the AFC playoffs, with a matchup vs. @Indy (TEN) and @Pittsburgh (BAL) to avoid falling to 6-5. Any playoff team in the AFC will need to get to 10-6 this year, so the team that falls to 6-5 would be facing long odds (finishing 4-1 or better) simply to get back in the conversation.

Well, the Titans beat the Ravens 30-24 in overtime on Sunday. Both teams were evenly matched, that part wasn't a question headed in. But playing a numbers game, this loss would've been brutal for both teams. It's especially hard for the Ravens, who one and only path to the playoffs goes through the Wild Card. Now, Baltimore finds themselves in a fight just to stay relevant in the AFC. This coming just 1 year after the Ravens were literally unbeatable (12 straight wins to finish w/ the Best Record in Football) in 2019. While I hope for more Titans vs. Ravens debauchery down the road, they likely won't see each other for 2-3 years. And the Titans are still neck and neck w/ Indianapolis for the AFC South title.

The Ravens are the big story here. They have some serious soul searching to do in the coming weeks and months. Baltimore's Passing Offense is totally broken. Against Tennessee, the Ravens looked like they were "going through the motions" on offense, without much creativity in play calling. Star LT and potential 2038 HOFer Ronnie Stanley is recovering from knee surgery. And the Ravens defense, which has been pretty good in 2020, just got gassed by Tannehill, Henry, and AJ Brown on the last drive of regulation and the only drive of Overtime, costing them a great defensive showing for 3 1/2 quarters.

The Ravens have lots of Cap Space this offseason (roughly $30 million available before trades/cuts, 10th best in the NFL). They have their own draft picks this year (apart from 1 Yannick Ngakoue 3rd Round Pick). The Ravens have put themselves in a position of success, specifically for a situation like this. The Ravens need to decide what kind of team they want to be in 2021, and if it is even possible for them to recapture that magic they had in 2019 (not super likely).

If I were Baltimore, there are a few steps I'd make sure I take care of to ensure some improvement.

1.  I would sign Yannick Ngakoue to a 3 year contract. He won't command top EDGE rusher numbers in Free Agency, and the Ravens need him and Calais Campbell up front. It's been the strength of their team for years, they should keep them together.

2. Matthew Judon is under franchise tag in 2020. They can franchise tag Judon again in 2020 for Top 2 ILB money. For 1 year, this shouldn't be a large issue for the Ravens. Let him walk following the 2021 season for big money (or not). You drafted Patrick Queen for a reason. If you got the right price for Judon in the trade market, consider that as well.

3. After taking care of your in house pieces, you NEED to work on that WR Core. Hollywood Brown is not a #1 WR the same way Henry Ruggs and Michael Gallup are not #1 WR. Everyone except Hollywood Brown (and maybe Willie Snead) need to be out of there. First of all, there are a number of great WR's in this year's draft class. The Ravens don't even have to draft WR in the 1st Round (likely with Pick 17-23). Draft a RT. Maybe a Defensive Player. But make sure you get a WR with one of the first 2 picks that you have. Maybe a Rondale Moore, Chris Olave, or Rashad Bateman makes sense for the Ravens to add alongside Brown.

In Free Agency, the Ravens need to spend big on a WR. Even if that WR goes with a 1 year deal for more money (a la Indianapolis Colts).  While I'm not a big fan of paying big for a WR, it's clear Baltimore needs to revamp their WR core. Start with a Devin Funchess, a good compliment on the outside for interior Hollywood Brown. Look for a Will Fuller or a Marvin Jones, both of whom I think the Ravens should've traded for at the Trade Deadline.

There is, actually, one big fish the Ravens should be looking to give up the farm for. This coming from me, who doesn't like the idea of drafting WR's in the 1st Round or signing them to big contracts. That big fish is Michael Thomas. The Saints have been shopping Thomas around since June, including a Schefter report around Week 4 that the Saints made Thomas available in trade. The Ravens could use a legitimate WR1 much like the Cardinals and Bills needed one to complete their teams last year. As it turns out, having Cole Beasley as a WR2 and WR3 is actually a big difference.

Right now, the Ravens passing attack runs primarily through Mark Andrews. While he is undoubtedly one of the 5 best TE's in football, offenses can't work primarily through a big TE with limited explosiveness. Travis Kelce works so well in Kansas City because they have Tyreek Hill, Sammy Watkins, Mecole Hardman, and others to keep the defense on it's toes. Right now, the Ravens need that through Devin Funchess, Marvin Jones, and, potentially, Michael Thomas. Here's an offer within reason, as voted on by over 600 voters on @comical_sports_memes

Ravens Receive: Michael Thomas, 2022 Conditional 7th Round Pick

Saints Receive: 2021 1st Round Pick, 2021 4th Round Pick

4. Do you extend Lamar Jackson??? The Ravens have the ability to extend Jackson this offseason, 2 years before he hits Free Agency. In my head, I'm having a real debacle about whether or not to extend Jackson. Do I believe, with a better receiving core, Jackson will look like a QB who led the NFL in TD's in 2019?? Absolutely, yes. That's why I think the Ravens should extend him early, for just less than what Mahomes and Watson got. At the same time, this could be a devastating move if the answer to that question is no. 

There are worse situations to be in than Lamar Jackson being extended and struggling (look at the Rams and Eagles). That's why I, reluctantly, answer yes to that question. I also envision a world in which QB's hit the open market with more frequency than they do now, and the Ravens could go 2 seasons + 2 Franchise Tags with no long term risks. And all of those prospects entice me the GM as well.

Ultimately the Ravens will pay Lamar the same amount for those 6th and 7th seasons, franchise tag or extension regardless. The question ultimately comes down to whether Lamar Jackson will be worth $40 million or more for those extra 2 seasons. I'd swing yes. Get him that 4 year, $160 million extension this offseason.

Saturday, November 21, 2020

The Kings Should Follow the Suns' Rebuilding Model w/ De'Aaron Fox

 An hour after Free Agency opened, the Sacramento Kings made their big transaction of the offseason. They signed PG De'Aaron Fox to a 5 year Supermax contract that could pay him north of $45 million a season. Fox, who averaged 21 PPG in 2019-20, including over 9 PPG in the 4th quarter, is a future star drafted by the Kings, a franchise not known for drafting stars. In fact, they've passed on Damian Lillard, Klay Thompson, and Luka Doncic, only to see them be drafted with the next pick.

In their transition from Vlade Divac to Daryll Morey prodigy Monte McNair, the Kings inherited Fox with a roster that will finish bottom 3 in the Western Conference in 2021. Buddy Hield and the Kings have a contentious relationship, and are headed to a breakup once someone wants to pay for his contract. Bogdan Bogdanovic was supposed to be in Milwaukee, and he might be headed to Atlanta by the time you read this. The rest of the roster is an overpaid Harrison Barnes, overpaid Cory Joseph, and a bunch of young players that don't get anyone excited, from Tyrese Haliburton to Marvin Bagley to fan favorite Harry Giles and Alex Len.

With the changes in the Western Conference, the Kings will be down with OKC in the bottom of the West. The Timberwolves, Spurs, Suns, Grizzlies, and Pelicans all show growing promise, both in 2020 and in the bubble. The Kings are selling off assets and trying to reset w/ a new regime. Like it or not, they are headed towards a 2-3 year rebuild.

The good news for the Kings: We've just seen the perfect model for rebuilding around a Young star. In summer of 2017, the Phoenix Suns gave Devin Booker a nice new 5 year Supermax contract. This came just after the Suns sold off Eric Bledsoe and Isaiah Thomas for pennies on the dollar, and the season before finishing w/ the NBA's worst record in the regular season. The Suns, with Booker, committed 3 seasons towards assembling a young core around Booker, one that could combine with Free Agent signings to build a contender out West.

Some of the Suns picks hit (#1 Pick DeAndre Ayton, Cam Johnson, Mikal Bridges) while others didn't (Josh Jackson over De'Aaron Fox and trading 2 1st Rounders for Marquese Chriss). Ultimately, they had enough 1st Round "Ping Pong Balls" that it was almost impossible to not get young talent.

And that they did. The Suns patience paid off in the NBA Bubble, where they went undefeated 8-0 through the Play in Round, jumping from the 13th seed to a tie for 9th in just 8 GAMES!!! The Suns now have expectations. Playoff expectations. Along w/ 3 more seasons of Booker in Phoenix before his inevitable departure.

Booker was patient enough to stick out the rebuild (and he could make $200 million while doing it). Fox is showing Sacramento the same level of patience. This is his team now. Not Buddy Hield. The Kings are going to now build that young core around De'Aaron Fox. I'd say they should be trying to trade off all their assets a la Sam Presti, but quite frankly they don't have many great assets. Buddy and Bogdan will net 1st Round Picks and another player, which will help in the assembling of the young core. After that, it's just a bunch of guys like Barnes and Cory Joseph and (maybe) Kent Bazemore and young players on their last stops in the NBA.

So, Sacramento will build. They have blocks and assets to do that. Monte McNair is an analytically driven GM with a young star and trade chips. At the very least, it should go better than the Vlade Divac years. At the same time, nothing is guaranteed. The model Sacramento is following is there in Phoenix. It seems to be relatively successful for a small market team. Ultimately, it may net them a Chris Paul-type player of their own to put w/ Fox and another Top Draft Pick (which should be this year for them). 

The model's there. You might as well use it as a template in Sacramento.

Thursday, November 19, 2020

The Warriors are Still "Lightyears Ahead"

 The defining theme of the Golden State Warriors dynasty, the defining team of my generation, came from the words uttered by Owner Joe Lacob in 2015: The Warriors are "Light Years Ahead".

The emotional connection the franchise made to Stephen Curry, Klay Thompson, and Draymond Green carried them to 3 Championships in 4 years, and a 4th had Kevin Durant not gotten hurt in 2019. All 3 of them entered their primes at the exact same time, winning a championship (without contest) in 2015. At that time, Curry was 27, Thompson 26, and Green 25. The average physical prime of an NBA Player: 28-32 years old.

The supporting cast has changed over the years. Strength in Numbers gave way to a bench of mostly Javale McGee, Zaza Pachulia, and Swaggy P's for 2 championships. They brought in the best player in the sport during his prime. All of it was totally unheard of for this generation watching and covering basketball.

Now, the Warriors have become largely predictable. Compounded now by a 32 year old Klay Thompson tearing his Achilles, missing the 2021 season and going 2 1/2 years without playing a game of professional basketball. When Klay tore his ACL in 2019, the Warriors gave Thompson a pity contract, based on his past accomplishments. Anything else would have been nothing short of cruel. It also would've been, from a basketball standpoint, nothing short of the right thing to do. Durant vanished to Brooklyn after an NBA Finals that felt like the most bare naked breakdown of a dynasty and era in NBA History. Catastrophic injury from Durant. Catastrophic injury from Thompson. Back to back games. Series ends, new Champion crowned.

So now, the Warriors find themselves in a similar place as many dynasties past their prime. The Warriors are going to wallow their way to a 1st Round Exit and/or 2nd straight missed playoff appearance in 2021. Curry will be 34 next year, a lifelong Warrior who's going to, at the very least, explore other options. Draymond Green has been worn down by 10 years of scrappy Pro Basketball, and unlike Curry he will not age very well. Like Thompson, the Warriors overpaid for Green knowing he wasn't worth what he was getting. The reason Green got a $100 million contract in 2019 was because of past accomplishments. The Warriors were going to take care of their stars who, because they were all so young, couldn't make tons of money during their winning window.

Maybe this is the new version of lightyears ahead. The humanity of this situation. Thompson and Green were going to go lose wherever they got their money. It's what happens when you dedicate a large portion of your cap to players who simply can't play up to that level, as Green has shown over 2 years and Thompson has unfortunately had via 2 catastrophic injuries. The Warriors chose to take care of their guys. From a business standpoint, the Warriors didn't "owe" it to Thompson to get him paid. They didn't "owe" Draymond a contract extension. They CHOOSE to take care of those guys, who because of NBA market rules couldn't cash in during their primes.

The mercenary Front Office side of me thinks about the Spurs and Patriots, who's stone cold roster constructions helped them win lots of Championships. When I initially thought about the Warriors being "lightyears ahead", I thought of that in terms of winning basketball. But in actuality, this is a different kind of change that logical corporate America lacks. The Warriors are far ahead on showing a level of humanity and kindness. Of treating employees like family. Giving Klay Thompson and Draymond Green and Steph Curry all the security and benefits in the world.

Maybe this wasn't Joe Lacob's intended message when he said Golden State was "Lightyears ahead". In fact, it probably wasn't. His comment was likely in reference to winning, and the style of basketball the Warriors play w/ analytics in mind. Yet, I have so much respect for the model the Warriors are employing, which truly is "lightyears ahead". 

Yes, we may not be champions anymore. You 3 stars may be exiting your primes, and you aren't worth what you're being paid. Sure, we're gonna continue to pay the luxury tax and do our best to build a winner around you 3. Yes, we are going to fail, because quite frankly you aren't as healthy or as good as you once were. That doesn't matter to us. Money doesn't matter. Winning doesn't matter. We love Steph. We love Draymond. And, most importantly today, we love Klay Thompson. He may be injured again, but were gonna love him and embrace him and let the fans shower him with the love he deserves. 

Life is going to be really hard for Klay Thompson. How could you not go through a mental health battle when you have to go through rehab, a grueling process, right after going through that process again. I empathize with Klay. I wouldn't wish that kind of sadness, frustration, and anxt on anybody, especially someone as well liked as Klay Thompson. At least he doesn't have to go through this for a team that doesn't want him. Much like the Lakers did for Kobe Bryant, the Warriors are going to sacrifice winning and saving money for letting Steph, Klay and Draymond feel like legends. When they decide to move on, then the Warriors will move on. Much like the Lakers did following Kobe Bryant's retirement. 4 years later, they built an NBA Champion. 

The Warriors are taking a similar approach. It might be going against all of our impulses and knowledge of business and capitalism, but this approach is more humane. It may not have even been what Lacob intended. But he's going to see this out with Steph, Klay and Draymond, and I have immense respect to him and everyone in Golden State for seeing it out. This level of empathy and gratitude truly is "lightyears ahead".

Monday, November 16, 2020

The NBA needs James Harden on the Brooklyn Nets

From the title, you can discern where I'm going with this, so I'll be frank. James Harden, the Houston Rockets MVP and greatest offensive weapon of my lifetime, is available for trade. This was predictable earlier this offseason (in fact, we did call it back in August). The Rockets got rid of HOF Coach Mike D'Antoni and HOF GM Daryl Morey in exchange for a 1st Time GM Rafael Stone and 1st Time Head Coach Stephen Silas. If it walks like a rebuilding duck and quacks like a rebuilding duck, it's probably a Rebuild.

James Harden holds the balance of power for the NBA in 2021. Harden in 31 and exiting his prime, so let's not raise the bar for MVP Harden to lead anyone to a title. If Harden is your best player, you will be the 2nd Round exiting Rockets. If Harden is your 2nd Best Player, then you have the best 1-2 tandem in the league. Better than if not equal to LeBron James and Anthony Davis in Los Angeles, who's 3rd best player is now PG Dennis Schroder.

For the sake of entertainment, the NBA needs Harden to join a team where he is the 2nd best player on said team. Any such team would add a 2nd Championship contender (I won't go as far to say Superteam) with a Lakers team that won the crown via absolutely coasting in the NBA Bubble.

There are only 5 teams which Harden could join where he is the 2nd best player on that team. Those are the 5 teams who have a Superstar capable of being the best player on a Championship team (of which Harden was from 2015-2019). Those 5 players are LeBron James (LAL), Kawhi Leonard (LAC) Giannis Antetoukounmpo (MIL) Nikola Jokic (DEN) and a healthy Kevin Durant (BKN). The only other cases I could make are the Mavericks and Warriors, who would have Harden w/ Luka Doncic and Steph Curry, which I can't say for certain would make it farther than the Rockets w/ the 1-2 punch of Harden and Westbrook. For the other 22 Franchises, James Harden is your #1 guy. Those teams won't be relevant for 2021 NBA Championship conversations (even the Heat, considering they'd have to trade two of either Herro/Goran/Bam)

Now, let's play matchmaker for those 5 teams.

Lakers: They're out on Harden. Hard Stop

Clippers: Conceivable they could trade Paul George in a Harden deal, but highly unlikely considering their lack of Draft Capital to trade from

Nuggets: Do they have the cojones to trade Jamal Murray, a 23 year old All Star, for Harden?? I'd LOVE LOVE LOVE to see it happen, but not likely at all

Bucks: They need to be pitching in calls to Houston over the next few days. However, Houston is trying to slash payroll and rebuild. Acquiring 4 years and $135 million of Khris Middleton is not as desirable (even though they might end up doing that w/ Tobias Harris anyways). The Bucks would be going all in on 1 season, then tearing it apart the next offseason. They'd also be trading for a James Harden who doesn't want to play for their franchise, so they'd have to give Houston an offer they can't refuse. Doable, but understandably a longshot.

This leaves us with the Kevin Durant-Kyrie Irving Brooklyn Nets. Harden has said that Philadelphia and Brooklyn are his preferred destinations, with Daryl Morey in Philly and Mike D'Antoni w/ Steve Nash in Brooklyn. If we are going to create a contender in 2021, Brooklyn is your destination for James Harden.

If the NBA landscape is going to have any changes in 2021, we need Harden to end up in Brooklyn. Anything else would just recreate the Rockets in another city, especially in Philly w/ Embiid/Harden. With the void created by 0 Superteams in the NBA, the league desperately needs another contender to avoid a boring stinker of a Postseason like 2020. We need someone to try and take down the big bad Warriors or the big bad Cavaliers or the evil Big 3 Heat. Since we won't be getting that, we'll settle for a Nets/Lakers (along w/ maybe the Bucks and Clippers) duel late in the Postseason. Without Superteams, we desperately need intrigue from watching the exact same shit as 2020, which in the grand scheme of NBA History was one of the worst Conference Finals/NBA Finals matchups of all time.

Superteams are great for sports. Look at what the Chiefs did in the playoffs in 2019. Or the Warriors/Rockets series of 2018-19. 2 Superpowers make the Sport intriguing. 3 or 4? That's gonna be must watch come the postseason.

Anyone rooting for James Harden to dissolve the last years of his prime into mediocrity isn't a fan of great basketball. Or James Harden. Either way, it doesn't make a lot of sense. James Harden is the single greatest weapon I've watched in my lifetime (which, to be fair, only includes Kevin Durant, Steph Curry, and the last 2 Kobe Titles). While his time as a #1 on a champion has passed him by with age, Harden can still be 1B to Kevin Durant's 1A. And with Kyrie Irving as a #3, the Nets are the favorites to win the whole NBA Finals. Josh Hart, the Pelicans guard, went one step further to state that "We'd have to skip to 2022, cause the Nets winning this shit". While I don't view Brooklyn that way wo/ seeing KD back healthy, knowing the limits of Kyrie Irving's game, and the fact that such a Harden trade would leave Rodions Kurucs as the Nets 4th best player, I understand people that view them as a Superteam w/ 3 of the 9-12 best players in the league. That is what we need. That's what we all need. Otherwise, it's gonna be 6 months of Giannis rumors and Load Management questions.

We need James Harden on the Brooklyn Nets. Anything else (apart from a Bucks or Nuggets trade) continues this awful disillusionment NBA Fans seem to have about Superteams being "bad for the sport".

Friday, November 13, 2020

Philip Rivers is the Last Living Pocket QB of the 80's/90's

The Indianapolis Colts have the #1 Defense in the NFL. They are ranked 3rd in Rush Defense, led by a DLine led by Deforest Buckner, Grover Stewart and Justin Houston. They are ranked 3rd in Passing Defense in the NFL, led by CB Xavier Rhodes, who PFF ranked as the #10 Corner through 9 weeks (We ALL owe him an apology). Any team with a top defense becomes an instant playoff team.

The Colts defeated the Titans 34-17 in Nashville on Thursday Night Football. The Colts overtook the Top spot in the AFC South, with a 2nd must win matchup headed their way 2 weeks from Sunday. Indianapolis looks to be one big dynasty with one Andrew Luck-sized hole from winning a Super Bowl and appearing in more AFC Championship Games over the next 5 years.

Their offense has largely become a quagmire, led by 38 year old Philip Rivers, who ranked as QB #20 through 7 games (moved up to #18 with his TNF game). Rivers, the future HOF quarterback, comes from a generation passed by long ago. A time of Quarterbacks who threw largely from the pocket, gun-slinging deep across the field, and never missing a single start for 15 seasons. Philip Rivers is the last of the QB's who made 20 year HOF careers out of 25 TD and 15 INT seasons, a type of football that has the same chance of returning as the I Formation offense, fullbacks, and straight-line kickers.

Philip Rivers became the NFL's 5th All time leading passer yesterday. Accounting for era, it's going to be Rivers' great claim to the HOF in 6-10 years. Sure, 8-12 Quarterbacks currently playing will one day break Rivers' career passing yards. Yet for the era that Rivers played in, this was the typical mold of QB. In a pre-analytics NFL, the best QB's were the ones who threw lots of Interceptions in exchange for lots of big TD's. Joe Namath made the HOF with more INT's than TD's. This was the standard when the running game was used to move the ball and set up the passing game.

This trend continued from Joe Montana to Dan Marino, over to the Troy Aikman's Brett Favre's, and Kurt Warner's of the 1990's/early 2000's. After Favre, there were less and less of these QB's in the NFL, which meant less good, gun-slinging QB's. The emergence of Drew Brees in New Orleans, Michael Vick in Atlanta, combined with the analytics revolution of Moneyball was the ideal storm for Football's evolution. We still had the Donovan McNabb's and Kurt Warner's of the world, but also had Tom Brady and Peyton Manning, who like Michael Vick would change the way we viewed the Quarterback Position for 2-3 generations of Quarterbacks.

Let's go back to 2003. The tug-and-pull of Gun-slinging, 400-yard-2-INT throwing old guard QB's and the evolution of the sport came to a head in 2003. In 2002, Michael Vick emerged as the next great Football QB. In 2003, Peyton Manning and Steve McNair were the Co-MVP's of the NFL. The perfect mold of quarterback for scouts was no longer Joe Montana, it was now everyone looking for the next Peyton Manning. Big strong pocket presence was, beginning in 2004, less desirable among NFL Scouts, GM's, owners and even coaches. Everyone wanted the next Peyton Manning.

The 2004 Draft came 2 1/2 months after Peyton Manning won MVP. The top prospects of 2004 were all built in the Joe Montana/Brett Favre mold of quarterback. It's what teams scouted that year. They had no idea Peyton Manning would change the game in 2003. The 2004 NFL Draft Class had 3 Tall, Gun-slinging, Brett Favre type quarterbacks with 1st Round Grades. If said draft class had flamed out, we would've been able to clearly point to that year as the death of the Old Guard Quarterback. It just so happened that all 3 QB's would go to a great home, and they'd each win a LOT, which set the stage for HOF careers for all 3.

First, the New York Giants, whom 2 years later would have the #1 defense in the NFL, traded for Eli Manning from Ole Miss. The Steelers, who in 2005 would have the #2 defense in Football and would win the Super Bowl, took Miami Ohio's Ben Roethlisberger. And the San Diego Chargers, with HOF Running Back Ladinian Tomlinson and 2006's #1 Offense in Football, took Rivers out of NC State.

In 2005, prospects were able to find 1 QB in the Peyton Manning mold: Utah's Alex Smith. Smith was dubbed the next Peyton Manning, with extreme accuracy and an ability to push the ball down the field. In reality, everyone missed on who the next Peyton Manning really was in that class: #2 Prospect Aaron Rodgers from Cal.

Like Steph Curry in the NBA, there were tons of Peyton Manning's on the way. They were just HS quarterbacks who needed 3-4 years to make it to the NFL. This is why, from 2006-2008, the QB's taken in the draft was just "The best Quarterbacks in College Football". The top 2 QB's in 2006 were Vince Young and Matt Leinart, who finished #2 and #3 in the Heisman in 2005 (#3 was Jay Cutler at Pick 12). In 2007, Jamarcus Russell got picked #1 in what still goes down as the worst QB class in NFL History (I think Brady Quinn would've been better if the Browns hadn't picked him). In 2008, Matt Ryan and Joe Flacco were taken as hybrid Manning-Favre type molds, both containing Favre's cannon of an arm with elements of Peyton Manning's risk adverse nature. Fortunately for those two, they also ended up in good homes, and Flacco played his 3 best games at the right time.

By 2009, the "Peyton Manning Generation" had made it's way to the NFL Draft. That began with a Once-in-a-generation talent from Georgia. A QB a team went 0-16 for the 1st time ever to select: Matthew Stafford. Stafford was the 1st Child of the Peyton Manning era of Quarterbacks. The type of QB scouts had been waiting 4 years to get their hands on. The Lions took Stafford with Pick #1. The 1st disciple of Mike Vick arrived unceremoniously in Bucs QB Josh Freeman.

The next year, Sam Bradford followed Matt Stafford in the Peyton Manning/Drew Brees mold of Quarterback. Then in 2011, it was Superweapon Cam Newton going to the Panthers. In 2012, Andrew Luck became a "once-in-his-generation" Quarterback, with Robert Griffin III coming in at Pick #2. Deep in the 3rd Round of that draft would be overlooked and undervalued Russell Wilson, who would be the Peyton Manning for the next generation after him. Wilson's HOF success led to the 1st Round Prospects for Deshaun Watson, Patrick Mahomes, Baker Mayfield, Kyler Murray, Josh Allen, Tua Tagovailoa, and Joe Burrow.

While the NFL evolved, the Steelers, Giants, and Chargers saw success with the last crop of Joe Montana-Brett Favre style of big, strong, pocket passing QB's. The Steelers won a Super Bowl in 2005 and 2008, with Big Ben never being the Super Bowl MVP. As an even funnier irony, two WR's (Hines Ward and Santonio Holmes, respectively) won the Super Bowl MVP awards. In 2007 and 2011, the Giants won fluky Super Bowls with Eli Manning. Eli Manning was 0-4 the rest of his career in playoff games outside of those 2 seasons. The Giants became perpetual rebuilders after giving Manning a huge contract in 2013 and firing Ben McAdoo after attempting to replace Manning. For the Chargers, well they won 4 division titles in 5 years. They lost some heartbreaking games vs. the Patriots and Jets in 2006, 2007, and 2010. While they never got to the Super Bowl, they were a very good team from 2006-2011. They won 2 more playoff games with Rivers, over Cincinnati in 2013 and Baltimore in 2018.

Today, Roethlisberger has been forced to change his game with age. Ben averages 9.8 yards per completion, which ranks 29th in the NFL. The Steelers have a #2 Defense that is carrying Ben (aka Jimmy Garothlisberger) to the best season of his career. Post Elbow-surgery, Ben Roethlisberger no longer plays in the style he used to play with for 16 seasons. Eli Manning has been forced out of the game entirely, retiring in 2019 after being benched for Daniel Jones.

For Rivers, he has 1 more mediocre season left in him out in Indianapolis. Rivers takes what the defense gives him, and he can make the big plays when called upon. While there are 15-20 Quarterbacks playing better than Rivers in 2020, things could be a lot worse for both Rivers and the Indianapolis Colts. If this is Rivers' last season (he has already accepted a HS Coaching Job in Alabama, where his son Gunnar is a top HS recruit), he will be the last great QB of an era that is now extinct. 

The Brett Favre, Philip Rivers, Eli Manning type of quarterback is not being recruited anymore. They aren't getting 1st Round Draft Grades. It just isn't valued in the NFL anymore. That became 100% official when Jameis Winston, who led the NFL in Passing Yards in 2019, could only get a 3rd String QB job for the Saints (to be fair, he may be the starter next year).

Watch and, just maybe, marvel at this last ride for Philip Rivers. Must like QB's smoking cigs at Halftime and Kickers with flat toed shoes, we won't be seeing a QB from a bygone era again after Philip Rivers. The breed had long been endangered, and they haven't been reproducing strong offspring since Joe Flacco. 2020 will be the time we officially declare the gun-slinging Pocket QB of the 1980's and 1990's officially extinct. The last remaining creature is Rivers. He'll get 1 last playoff run with a #1 Defense to go out with a BANG.

Wednesday, November 11, 2020

The 10 Month Freefall of Ed Orgeron and LSU

 10 Months Ago today, Ed Orgeron was about to coach the biggest game of his life. The LSU Tigers, led by Joe Burrow and an array of NFL bound talent, were playing Clemson for the National title. Orgeron, a Louisiana native who frequently regards Head Coach at LSU as his "Dream Job", had turned around one of CFB's premier programs from the grips of perpetual mediocrity at the end of the Les Miles era. In his Heisman speech, Joe Burrow said LSU needed to give Coach O a "Lifetime Contract". This from Burrow, a 23year old from Athens, Ohio who is outspoken on social issues and racial unity, talking about the most respected man in his life, a 60 year old man from the rural backcountries of Louisiana. Football provides such opportunities to cultivate these relationships we otherwise would've never had.

Today, the LSU Tigers are the incumbent national champions. Joe Burrow is gone. So is Offensive Coordinator Joe Brady. Also, DC Dave Aranda, who is now the coach at Baylor. Plus, Running Back Clyde Edwards-Helaire. And K'Lavon Chaisson. And CJ Henderson. And a dozen starters from the National Championship team. What is left in Baton Rouge is Orgeron, who is loosing his luster both among his players and the fanbase taking a long, hard look at the future.

While Orgeron won't be fired this year, or next year, or the year after that, it doesn't mean he's headed towards that Jim Harbaugh territory of "College Football Nuisance". If Harbaugh does finally leave Michigan for a return to the NFL, we will all turn to the next guy to criticize for winning ONLY 8 games a year w/ a premier program. That next guy in line is Ed Orgeron at LSU (assuming Tom Herman is headed out the door in Texas). It's quite jarring given where we were just 10 months ago, moreso when we think about what could've happened this year if Orgeron weren't protected by a Ring and a new 6 year contract extension.

In Orgeron's personal life (and this has nothing to do with the LSU Program) he went through a divorce in February, just 2 months after winning the National Championship. After that, the global COVID pandemic put the College Football straight into the political arena. Very quickly, the COVID-19 Pandemic became the most politicized issue in America. In College Football, the politics of money and the politics of a whole America came full circle.

College Football coaches are always in a unique mediator position. Football locker rooms are usually between 75-80% Black, and almost always lean progressive. The players choose to play for coaches with the cliched promise they will "look out for them like a father away from home". The coach must always take the side of his locker room, because without the locker room he runs the risk of a revolt against him, transfers, and an eventual decline in talent.

At the same time, the CFB coaches' bosses and fans skew to the farthest right sides of the political spectrum. College Football is the premier economic vehicle for some of the United State's most ruby red states. The coaches in the sport, who are almost entirely White, often come from traditional background in rural/suburban areas of these Ruby Red regions. Mike Gundy, for instance, was calling for the unpaid labor to return in May, saying "they're young, they'll be alright if exposed". Mike Leach, the Mississippi State coach, recently said "our freedoms are being impinged" days after an outbreak occurred at HIS school. Dan Mullen, coach at Florida, uttered similar sentiments when he wanted Florida to "pack 90,000 into Ben Hill stadium". These coaches are not the exceptions, they are the rule.

All of these comments go over wonderfully for them, because the people paying the bills for the coaches, sometimes to the tune of $200 million a year budgets, overwhelmingly agree with such statements on COVID. College Coaches think they have to play a fine game of being pro players while not offending their overwhelmingly conservative fans and bosses.

All of this mediation came to a head in June, during the protests following the murder of George Floyd and Breonna Taylor. LSU made headlines bc the players felt that Orgeron didn't have their backs when discussing Police Brutality and systemic oppression. Other schools took the brunt of the headlines, specifically Oklahoma State, Florida State, and Iowa. But LSU was quietly in the background of the conversations. Nick Saban and Dabo Swinney at least showed up to lead protests on their campuses (a small yet not insignificant gesture). I don't know what Orgeron's personal beliefs on the police and race are (I have some assumptions based on reputation) but given the choice between his locker room and Louisiana political establishment, he chose conservativism when addressing police brutality.

So, flash forward to August. All across College Football, we were hearing that players didn't really trust their schools to protect them from outbreaks (claims now founded by evidence of 25+ outbreaks in DI Football alone). LSU, much like the Patriots in the NFL, just happened to be the team hurt most by players either opting out or declaring early for the NFL. That set the tone for an Opening weekend drubbing at Home by Mississippi State, who then lost 4 straight games right after that win.

LSU then lost a game at Missouri 2 weeks later. Then, they lost by 37 to an unranked Auburn team. 2 easy wins (0-5 Vandy and 2-4 South Carolina) got them to a tie for Last Place in the SEC West. Myles Brennan, the QB slated to replace Heisman winner Joe Burrow, hasn't played in 3 weeks, and today it was announced that his season is over. In advance of this weekends Alabama-LSU game, it was LSU's turn to have an outbreak of COVID-19. It was probably better for them to NOT lose by 45 at home on Primetime in front of 8 million viewers on CBS.

Then, on Saturday, LSU WR Koy Moore announced that he had guns pulled on him by 3 Baton Rouge Police Officers. (Read the Full Statement from Moore here). Orgeron's responded with a statement including multiple problematic remarks that signified Orgeron didn't entirely believe Koy Moore. Again, a tell tale sign that Ed Orgeron isn't fully committed to having his players backs when it comes to Black players experiencing harassment by a White Police Force (The 3 officers have been placed on administrative leave)

All this leaves LSU in a wasted year that may set the program back 2-3 years. Orgeron's championship buys him a grace period, and tension will grow as Championship expectations begin to mount on him and LSU Football. Joe Burrow and Joe Brady aren't marching back into the locker room. It's on Orgeron to navigate a new challenge, and so far he not receiving passing remarks.

Sunday, November 8, 2020

Is Anyone Great in the NFC??

 Does anyone know what is going on in the NFC??? Week to week, game to game, it appears the NFC as a whole is scrambling to find a Super Bowl-caliber representative. One of them likely exists. In fact, 4 or 5 or even 6 of them exist. The difficulty is trying to decipher which of the 2 or 3 will pull away from the rest of the pack.

5 weeks ago, the New Orleans Saints were 1 overturned call from being 2-3 and seeing "The Last Dance" implode. Now, in true 1998 Bulls fashion, are the #1 seed in the NFC. The Seattle Seahawks, with 2020 MVP Russell Wilson, have lost 2 of 3 and dropped to a more than respectable 6-2. As have the Green Bay Packers, who's loss to the Vikings will come full circle as we come down the Playoff seeding stretch. The Tampa Bay Buccaneers, whom many had pegged at #1 through 8 weeks, lost in spectacular fashion to the Saints on SNF (personally, I was a Seattle guy). The Arizona Cardinals and Los Angeles Rams are both 1 game out on the NFC West, while also being in the running for the NFC's Final 4, since 1 of them is in line to play the Eagles in the Wild Card Game.

We know all these teams are talented. With the exception of LAR, all of them have won gigantic games that only good/great teams can win. Where we're having trouble is trying to decipher which of these teams are among the NFL's elite. Almost all of us view the Steelers and Chiefs ahead of all 6 aforementioned teams, and this is well deserved. Many of us, including myself, view the Baltimore Ravens ahead of all NFC teams too. Even the Buffalo Bills have a legitimate claim to the NFC's #1 seed, if they played in that conference.

Since the Patriots 1st Super Bowl 19 years ago, the AFC has been a Top Heavy Conference. From 2001-2020, only 6 QB's have made the Super Bowl in the AFC. 1 was Rich Gannon in 2002. 1 was Joe Flacco in 2012. 1 was Patrick Mahomes in 2019. The other 16 are a combination of Tom Brady (9), Peyton Manning (4) and Ben Roethlisberger (3). The AFC has won 13 of those 19 Super Bowls, which is anticipated when you have dynasties that last for 5, 10, or even 20 years at a time. By the way, the Chiefs are extending that trend into a new decade.

In those same 19 years, the NFC has been a deep conference with a High turnover rate. Since the Bears Super Bowl 14 years ago, the NFC has had 11 DIFFERENT FRANCHISES make the Super Bowl. The Bears, Giants (2), Cardinals, Saints, Packers, 49ers (2), Seahawks (2), Panthers, Falcons, Eagles and Rams have all played in a Super Bowl since 2007. The only true "dynasty" in that mix is the Legion of Boom Seattle Seahawks, who made the Super Bowl in Back-to-Back years, winning 1. Even THEY have their controversies, bc Aaron Rodgers was a freak 2 point conversion and an onside kick recovery from beating Seattle in the 2014 NFC Championship Game. The NFC has won 6 of the 19 Super Bowls since 2001, and teams like Rodgers' Packers and the Payton-Brees Saints never get back to the Super Bowl.

Why does all this matter for 2020?? Well, it appears the same trend is following the NFC and AFC divide this year. And 20 years of history gives us a better idea of how this whole season will go down. Specifically, whether the AFC Championship Game will be our Super Bowl-caliber matchup like it's been in past years.

Let's focus specifically on the NFC's 6 Super Bowl Champions in the last 19 years. They were 

1-3. A dynastic-level season for the 2009 Saints, the 2010 Packers, and the 2013 Seahawks

4. A #1 Seed Eagles team getting hot w/ Nick Foles at the right time

5-6. A pair of Fluky Giants Championships

Every few years, we have a Fluky NFL champion who "gets hot at the right time". Joe Flacco and Nick Foles both did it. So did Eli Manning. It's entirely possible this year is that year. The more Super Bowls the Chiefs appear in, eventually they'll have to start losing some of them. A loss by Mahomes to, say, Aaron Rodgers would certainly be an eye turner the same way Denver beating a 15-1 Carolina team was in 2015.

However, it is more likely than not this season will go to the elite 2-3 teams. All of those 2-3 elite teams reside in the AFC. There's still time for these teams in the NFC to separate themselves. We are now at the NFL's Halfway point, and none of them have done so thus far. We haven't seen something like this in recent memory, where there are 5-6 teams with a legitimate path or paths to the top of a conference and an advantage en route to the Super Bowl. While we do have some idea (We'd all be fairly surprised to see Arizona as the #1 seed in the NFC over GB and SEA), we don't have clarity like we do in most years. We don't even have clarity like we do for the 2020 AFC Playoffs. 

Saturday, November 7, 2020

We All Need Cincinnati in the College Football Playoff

 College Football has gone off the rails in 2020. There have been over 20 CDC defined "outbreaks" in the regular season, including 3 more this weekend. The PAC-12 kicked off this weekend (without 4 of their 12 teams) while the ACC is 8 games into their season. Trevor Lawrence has COVID, top NFL picks are opting out midseason, and Indiana is a legitimately good football program.

What I'm proposing would be the perfect finish on the 2020 season: The AAC's Cincinnati Bearcats making the College Football Playoff. The Group of 5, the conferences with less money and less respect that the "Power 5" schools, gets one team in the New Year's 6 every year. Sometimes it's #11 Houston. Sometimes it's a fun team like Western Michigan. Last year, we got Memphis getting 53 dropped on them by Penn State. It's almost a pitty game given as a gift to a conference viewed as peasants by the College Football elitists.

That's why we all mustn't just root for Cincinnati to make the Playoff... we NEED Cincinnati to make the College Football Playoff. The Bearcats being the #4 team in the CFB Playoff is the ultimate middle finger to the establishment. An establishment which, by the way, conducts themselves like the Oligarchs they are over a sport which they profit from in the Billions.

The Bearcats lost to Memphis to miss that program-building Cotton Bowl vs. Penn State. This year, they returned almost all their starters and Head Coach Luke Fickell, and what we're seeing is the best team from the Group of 5 since UCF's Self Declared and 100% legitimate Championship.

What it takes for a Group of 5 team to make the CFB Playoffs is beyond impossible to understand. First of all, you have to recruit to an entirely smaller base of players. 4 star recruits to these schools are the same as 5 star recruits to the Power 5: You might have 1-2 on your team, and 3-4 teams will have rosters full of these recruits. In the Group of 5, Houston, Boise State, and Memphis are the equivalent of Ohio State, Alabama and Clemson. Everyone else wins big with 3 star recruits and a 4 star quarterback playing above his play scale.

If a top school has a great season, expect the coach who turned things around to be poached by a school with more money. At UCF, Scott Frost parlayed their 2017 Championship into a $7 million job at Nebraska. Appalachian State, who has 3 straight 11 win seasons, had their coach hired by Louisville, then his replacement hired by Missouri. Even Memphis, after being drubbed by Penn State, saw Mike Norvell be hired by Florida State. Group of 5 schools are usually just stops along the way to a bigger goal in College Football.

As a result, these schools go up and down in cycles. Since the implementation of the CFB, only 1 of 6 schools (UCF) made it twice to a New Year's 6 bowl game. They even did it the 2nd time with a Head Coach. As soon as someone succeeds in one of these places, the whole staff and team break apart and head to a Power 5 school, the Transfer Portal, or the NFL. Those who are left behind sink w/ the program like the Titanic. Appalachian State has been the best example of a program who keeps building winners without the same coaches or same players. Because they play in the Sun Belt, the worst of the Group of 5 conferences, they haven't gotten enough big wins to get to a New Year's 6 Bowl Game.

Cincinnati is a rare example of a school who, following a 2nd Place finish among the Group of 5, didn't disband for an array of reasons. Desmond Ridder had 2 years of eligibility left vs. the traditional 0 or 1 year. Coach Luke Fickell was passed up for every Head Coaching Vacancy last year. The defense lost 0 NFL caliber players. As a result, Cincinnati is good enough to make the CFB Final 4.

However, the selection committee will do everything in their power to avoid this. Especially in a year where they need to recoup Television dollars. The money is guaranteed no matter who plays in the Playoff, which is good. However, they'd have to explain to the PAC12, Notre Dame, or Georgia why they won't be playing the CFB over a Cincinnati team they'd probably be 10 point favorites against.

This is where I, the fan-archist and avid Group of 5 supporter, need Cincinnati in the CFB playoff. Yes, the Bearcats would have to finish unbeaten. Yes, they still need Clemson to beat Notre Dame twice. And if those things happen, they'd still be holding out hope for a 4th Playoff spot.

The symbolism of Notre Dame, the former Golden Child of College Football, missing the playoffs behind a small time Cincinnati program would be the greatest thing I've seen in a long time. We all need this. We need Cincinnati to give a giant ass middle finger to College Football.

Wednesday, November 4, 2020

Adam Thielen's Journey

As We've Discussed Before, the Minnesota Vikings are in Year 1 of what is about to become a 3 year rebuild. Win in Green Bay aside, the Vikings have a 0% chance of making a playoff push in 2020, and their prospects don't get that much better in 2021. This offseason, the Vikings will make long term decisions on GM Rick Spielman and coach Mike Zimmer for the next 5 years, which I anticipate will lead to both of them getting fired (nicely) by the Vikings.

Naturally, trade rumors swirled around Minneapolis at the Trade Deadline, and they will continue in February and March. Many of them will be founded in some truth (Danielle Hunter, Harrison Smith, and Anthony Barr will likely be shopped), many will be speculation (Kirk Cousins won't be available until 2022). The Vikings will make some hard decisions, much like they dig with Xavier Rhodes and Stefon Diggs in March.

The one piece they will not be trading is star WR Adam Thielen. I may be wrong, but I'm fairly certain he will be a Viking until he can no longer play like a WR1 or even a WR2 in the NFL. That day probably won't come for another 4-7 years, at which time the Vikings will be back to a Playoff team. Thielen, who is 30 years old, is a Viking for life, or at least for the bulk of his career. This time, it's absolutely personal. Both to the Vikings, to Minnesota, and most of all to Thielen.

....

Sports leagues and teams are in the emotions business. Sports fans, especially at the highest levels of Sport, are very emotional about the sports we follow, like they are religions. The Stadiums are our places of worship, and the players/teams are where we give our praise, emotional stability and (most importantly) our money. From time to time, we sports fans, including myself, feel emotions romanticizing about the Underdog story. At this point, underdog stories has become a classic part of Americana, right up there with the Hot Dogs, Apple Pies, and overthrowing foreign governments.

In Football, the Underdog story is the classic "Rudy" story: A player overcoming some major obstacle, then scrapping his way to the Pros, then going from Player 100 and working up. Or it's like Taysom Hill, who had 4 season ending surgeries and blocking punts to make the Saints roster.

Adam Thielen is another one of these cases, and it all happened in the Vikings' Backyard. Thielen is from Detroit Lakes, Minnesota. It's a remote town of 8,000 that is often a vacation area for wealthy people during the summer months. Adam Thielen was a 0 star Recruit in High School, playing 4 sports for the Detroit Lakes Lakers. He got a $500 scholarship (yes, like 5 $100 Bills) to play football, his 3rd best sport behind Golf/Basketball, at D2 Minnesota State. Obviously Thielen would have no prospects for an NFL future at Minnesota State. Those chances were reduced to nothing after Thielen didn't even START at Minnesota State for 2 Full Seasons (1 redshirt and a Sophomore year).

Eventually, Theilen did find the field. He was 20 years old during his first start at a D2 school. Minnesota State was coming off of 2 straight Quarterfinal losses in the D2 championships, and they were rebuilding their recruiting base. Thielen caught 700 yards for a team that went 6-5 in D2. At 21 years old, while WR's his age were being drafted by the NFL, Thielen was the WR2 in something called the Mineral Water Bowl.

It was only during Theilen's 5th year senior season that he broke out. He had 1,200 yards in 14 games and was a D2 All American. His best impact was actually as a Punt/Kick Returner, especially during his last year at Minnesota State. Theilen left Minnesota State with some level of maybe-NFL potential, and those NFL dreams were shattered for one simple reason: No NFL scouts knew him.

Thielen had to pay to attend a combine in Chicago for regional College Seniors. Again, he had to pay to get in, he was not invited to this event. Nobody was. This was a chance to put up measurements that would be sent in a chain email to NFL scouts. If those scouts were doing their jobs correctly, they would at least read that email and maybe see something that intrigued them. For Thielen, it represented the only chance he had for scouts to know who he was before the 2013 NFL Draft.

Thielen got invited to a 2nd combine with about 4-6 NFL scouts present. This event in Dallas was 12 days before the NFL Draft, so the few scouts that were there were down on the totem pole within organizations. The only way for him to even have a shot was for one of these scouts to REALLY believe in him, or at least pass his name on to a scout who really believes in him. His claim to fame came in a 4.45 40 yard dash, which was better than WR's who would be drafted weeks later. All of a sudden, scouts were asking him for his tape, and his name was, at least, being passed around through NFL circles. Not much, and something Thielen probably deserved given he could run a 4.45 40-yd. Yet, the kid from Minnesota State, was finally on the map.

Thielen, unsurprisingly, went undrafted in 2013. 26 WR's were drafted over Thielen in 2013, including some who never started in the NFL. Thielen got a tryout with the hometown Vikings just before 2013 minicamp. If he couldn't get a contract after this tryout, it was off to a Dental Sales Internship for Mr. Thielen (He tells the story of how he had that internship lined up before his tryout, and I suspect the CFL would've given Thielen a call at some point).

After the workout, Thielen got 2 invites to Training Camp: His Hometown Vikings and the Panthers (a fun what if, considering the Panthers made the Super Bowl 2 seasons later) . Thielen signed up for the Vikings immediately, even though it would be harder for him to make the Vikings. Thielen wound up getting cut. He spent the entire 2013 season on the Vikings practice squad.

For 2014 and 2015, Adam Thielen took the best route for NFL players hoping to stay in the league: Being a special teams player. Players across decades talk about how much respect they have for the special teams players, and how many job opportunities those 7-8 plays a game create. It's why they were so adamant that the play not go away when the league was contemplating how they would revise kickoffs, considering kickoffs are the #1 cause of head injuries in a sport dealing with a Head Injury crisis. 

Thielen was the 7th Wide Receiver on the Vikings depth chart in 2014, and he spent most of his playing time trying to block punts and tackling the opponents kickoff returners. During Week 17 of a meaningless 7-9 season, Thielen, at 24 years old, caught his 1st Touchdown in the NFL. In 2015, Thielen occasionally got to be that return man, but again was mostly blocking punts (he did block 1 for a TD) and tackling kickoff returners. The retirement of Greg Jennings led to the drafting of Stephon Diggs, and Thielen was penciled in as the WR6 at the start of the season. In Week 7, Thielen had the breakout game he'd waited 4 years in the NFL and 5 years in D2 Football for: He had 70 yards and a TD in one of those wacky "that screws over your fantasy team" games.

In 2016, Thielen was into the last year of his 3 year Vikings contract. As great a specialist as he was, the Vikings wouldn't be able to pay him an NFL veterans contract to be a specialist (he made about $1.6 million over 4 years). If his career were going to continue, Thielen was going to have to earn a new contract as a WR. If the Vikings weren't going to pay him, it was less probable someone else would.

It didn't help that the Vikings were a returning 11 win playoff team (2015 was the Blair Walsh game). It hurt even more than the Vikings had spent their 1st Round Pick on WR Laquon Treadwell. Thielen needed to see the field to get a contract, and the Vikings were simultaneously keeping him off the field.

Theilen's opportunities came as a result of right place at the right time. Treadwell got hurt during Training Camp, and wound up missing the first 7 games of the season. Stephon Diggs missed 5 games early in the 2016 season as well. Thanks to those injuries, Thielen went from playing on 21% of snaps in 2015 to 75% of snaps in 2016. Him, Cordarelle Patterson and Jarius Wright became the only healthy WR for the Vikings for a team that started the season 5-0.

2016 was the year where Teddy Bridgewater was out the whole year following reconstructive knee surgery. Sam Bradford was acquired for a 1st Round Pick to be the QB for the reigning NFC North Champions. Bradford is a WR's dream, because he is an extremely accurate passer with lots of opportunities for YAC on short catches. That combination of Bradford and no healthy WR's meant Bradford could look to Thielen for an array of catches the way the Vikings intended for Laquon Treadwell. With Diggs sidelined, Thielen got to start a Week 5 game vs. the Texans. No Diggs. No Treadwell. If this was going to be Thielen's time to shine, it was now or never.

Theilen finished with 7 catches, 107 yards, and a TD in a victory that kept Minnesota undefeated. Despite the fact everything was falling apart at the seam, Thielen kept getting starts in place of injured WR's. Thielen caught a TD in Week 10. Then got to start 1 game over an injured Treadwell, and caught a 3rd TD. In Week 16, Thielen had 1 final audition for that new contract. With the Vikings out of the playoff picture, Thielen went for an INSANE 200 Yards and 2 Touchdowns. Theilen got his 3 year contract that offseason. It basically spelled the end of Laquon Treadwell's career, bc Laquon Treadwell was drafted to be Adam Thielen.

From there, the rest is history. Thielen was the first Viking to go for 1,000 yards in 8 years. He made a Pro Bowl in 2017. The Vikings made the NFC Championship Game with Case Keenum. Theilen made the Pro Bowl. He made it again in 2018. He got a $64 million contract with his hometown team. The Vikings traded Stefon Diggs to clear some cap space and draft younger. The Vikings made Thielen the focal point of their passing attack, choosing his big contract over Stefon Diggs.

So there's very little chance the Vikings give up on Stefon Diggs. Maybe that will change with the firing of Rick Spielman and Mike Zimmer, the GM and Coach who originally signed Thielen. At the same time, the best thing Thielen has going for him is that he is still a Top 10 Reciever and a true WR1. WR's in their 30's stick around through regimes, as long as they can still play like WR1's or WR2's. Larry Fitzgerald hasn't been elite for a decade, yet he's survived half a dozen coaches and multiple GM's. The same will be true w/ Julio Jones in Atlanta. Thielen has gone from 0 star recruit to NFL star, and he never left the Vikings backyard to make it happen. He will be a Minnesota lifer, and that you can write in pen.

Monday, November 2, 2020

How the Patriots Got to Where They Are Now

Headed into Sunday's game vs. the Buffalo Bills, ESPN's Football Power Index had the Patriots on track to finish with 7.7 wins in 2020. This put them below the playoff line in the AFC, but did have them slightly ahead of the 7.4 Miami Dolphins, whom they beat back in Week 1.

The Patriots had the Bills in their grasp. Josh Allen has been tamed like a lion in the no-longer-existing circus vs. the Chiefs and Titans. The Patriots took care of John Brown, daring Josh Allen to beat them without the homerun ball. Their offense, led by 2nd year Damien Harris, did just enough to get NE to a 24-21 deficit. Then, we all watched Cam Newton fumble the ball away on a drive where New England was already in chip shot field goal range. A fumble that, when picked up by Buffalo, was a metaphoric passing of the torch in all the senses of the cliché.

This was, by all measures, a winnable game and the Patriots lost. FPI now projects the Patriots to win only 6.6 games in 2020, playing them in 10th place in the AFC and securing the 13th pick in the NFL Draft. At a 6-10 mark, the Pats would secure as high as the 8th Pick in the NFL Draft.

Before Sunday, we knew the Patriots were resetting in 2020. We're now watching to see how far the Patriots will freefall before then.

During the Patriots 10 year hiatus of Super Bowls, they never had a season worse than 10-6. The last time they were sub .500 was 2000, Bill Belichick's first year. They've had down years before, but never quite like this. Something had to have changed decade over decade, champion over champion in Foxboro.

Conventional Wisdom suggests the thing that changed was Tom Brady. However, Tom Brady is not the difference between 11-5 and 5-11 year over year. In fact, Tom Brady was a big part of why New England wasn't BETTER in 2019. As we also know by now, conventional wisdom is easy, straightforward, and 95% of the time WRONG.

The bigger explanation is what was going on while the Patriots were hoisting Lombardi Trophies in 2014, 2016 and 2018. And it involves "The Patriot Way". The "Patriot Way", quite simply, is the most sustainable roster construction model in Sports History. After 15 years, the Patriots front office, led by Bill Belichick, couldn't keep sustaining the rosters they'd been doings for decades. Bill Belichick has simply been BAD at evaluating young talent.

During the late 2000's-early 2010's, Bill Belichick was accumulating players who would be instrumental in the Patriots 3 titles in 14/16/18. Rob Gronkowski was a 2nd Round Pick turned HOFer.  Jamie Collins: 2nd Round of 2013. Donta Hightower was the Star MLB drafted 1st Round Pick in 2012. Nate Solder and Marcus Cannon were 1st and 5th Rounders in 2011 to replace Super Bowl OT's Sebastian Vollmer and Matt Light. 2010's 1st Rounder: Devin McCourty. 2009's Picks: Patrick Chung and Julian Edelman. Even Aaron Hernandez was worthy of the richest TE contract in NFL History.

After the 1st Super Bowl, the Patriots stopped drawing good prospects in the 1st and 2nd Round. The late round gems were still showing up (Trent Brown, David Andrews, Rex Burkhead, Chris Hogan, and Malcom Butler were all undrafted) and it appears (with hindsight) those players were compensating for a lack of talent coming into Boston.

Beginning in 2015, the Patriots took a DT named Malcom Brown. Brown started in 2 Super Bowls for the Patriots, and was a fantastic piece on the Patriots Defense. After 4 years, Brown signed with the New Orleans Saints, where he has started for the last 2 seasons. From there, the Patriots have not only missed on great players like Hightower, Chung and Solder. They've actually picked a large number of straight BUSTS.
In 2018, the Patriots were forced into a trade for Jimmy Garoppolo, another 2014 2nd Round Hit. Instead of waging a bidding war between the Browns and 49ers, both of whom were desperate for a QB, Belichick took less to send Garoppolo to a good home w/ Kyle Shanahan (The Browns would draft Baker Mayfield 6 months later).

Belichick then mixed and match draft picks around, famously turning that 2nd Round pick into 7 different players. During the 2018 Draft, everyone praised Belichick for netting 7 picks for a soon-to-be-Free Agent, calling it a "classic Bill Belichick move". Fairly enough, we never did circle back around to what became of that Jimmy G trade. Until this research, even I assumed the Patriots got back some good fortune from Jimmy G. I'm guessing most of you assumed so too.

What could've been a perfect "Patriot Way" trade, 7 Day 2/3 Draft Assets for an expiring contract, turned into a whole lot of nothing. This for the coach famous for pulling Pro Bowlers out of Walmart Shopping Lines and the 7th Rounds of Drafts. The best thing the Patriots ended up with was Damien Harris, who, to be fair, has emerged as a legitimate #1 Running Back for the Patriots in 2020. At the same time, Harris is becoming a #1 because of the shortcomings of Sony Michel, the 1st Round Pick from that same 2018 Draft.

The rest of the picks turned into Jarrett Stidham, backup CB JoeJuan Williams, and 4 players (Yodny Cajuste, Christian Sam, Byron Cowart, and Duke Dawson) who no longer play for the Patriots. Those 6 players have a combined 0 starts for the New England Patriots, and only Stidham and Williams still have a chance to start.

After Super Bowl 53, the Patriots lost Chris Hogan and Danny Amendola to Free Agency, leaving only Super Bowl MVP Julian Edelman on the roster. The Patriots used a 1st Round Pick on WR N'Keal Harry, who in 2 seasons has played in 11 games and has 31 career receptions. Belichick then traded NE's 2nd Round Pick in 2020 in exchange for the last 9 games of Mohamed Sanu's Contract. Sanu, meant to temporarily fill a hole for 1 more Super Bowl run, was a no show apart from 5 games during his short stay in Foxboro.

Which brings us all the way back to 2020. The Patriots 1st and 2nd Rounders from 2009-2014, a 6 year period, netted 13 Pro Bowl Seasons (only Chandler Jones outside of New England) 5 All Pro Seasons, and 7 Full time starters with the Patriots. From 2015 until 2020, the Patriots have turned in just 2 Full Time Starters (a third potentially in SS Kyle Duggar) 0 Pro Bowls, and a handful of bad busts of Picks. The Patriot Way fell apart because the Patriots couldn't add the young talent necessary to sustain winning. 

No single player can add 7 wins one way or another to a team, not even Tom Brady or Patrick Mahomes. The Patriots holes go well beyond the QB position, and Tom Brady at times helped to mask some of those issues on offense. The Patriots had the #1 Defense for 11 weeks in 2019, and that helped them outlast the Buffalo Bills in 2019. Without that defensive safety net, (6 players, including Hightower, opted out due to COVID) combined with 3 catastrophic fails at Wide Receiver (Antonio Brown, Mohamed Sanu, N'Keal Harry), the Patriots finally succombbed to what all NFL franchise have for years: The Difficulty of sustaining winning.

After two decades, it happened to the San Antonio Spurs and Gregg Popovich too. They drove out Kawhi Leonard after being so singularly focused on the 2018 season. For the Patriots, they lost their edge because of their draft picks, which are the NFL's version of a "Max Contract" in the NBA. Draft Picks are the way to beat the flaw in the NFL's system, because you can get the amazing talent for cheap. The same hack is true in Baseball, and the Astros have exploited it better than any franchise in MLB. In the NBA, their loophole is getting the Superstars at less than market value (whatever the Max contract is in a given year).

If you can't keep sustaining the hack, then all of a sudden you become just like everyone else. This is what happened to the Pats. The explanations for this are plentiful and all intersect in some way. Maybe the Patriots couldn't dedicated enough time to the Draft Process bc of Super Bowl seasons. Maybe it was Belichick losing an edge on evaluation. Maybe it was a lack of opportunities for top picks to see the field. All are plausible, and I don't have the data to find any conclusions either way.

For the foreseeable future, it appears Bill Belichick and the Patriots have become just like everyone else, no matter how many Walmart employees he can start at Linebacker. The core of talented players simply isn't there anymore in New England, and that is how we got to where we are now with the Patriots.