There are presently 3 open Head Coaching Jobs in the NFL: The Lions, Falcons, and Texans. There will be anywhere from 2 to 6 more jobs opening up in the next 5 weeks. Adam Gase, Zac Taylor and Doug Marrone are dead men walking, waiting for seasons to play out with as many losses as possible for the Jets and Jaguars to secure future Franchise QB's. Anthony Lynn, Matt Nagy and Mike Zimmer have boiling seats right now, with teams making tough decisions based potentially on these last 3 weeks. Joe Judge and Vic Fangio will be fired by January 2022, and their teams may decide to move on from them a year early.
There will be no shortage of Head Coaching Openings in 2020 (unlike the small number of 4 last year). There are 2 routes every single one of these 7 teams should go down (after Eric Bieniemy scoops up one of these Head Coaching jobs).
1. College Head Coaches paired w/ great Offensive Coordinators. If College Coaching hires have proven anything over the last decade, from Pete Carroll to Jim Harbaugh to Bill O'Brien, it's that they are great at seeing a process through. The Seahawks started with nothing, and in 5 years built a Super Bowl champion. Same for the 49ers, winning the NFC Championship and playing in another. For the Texans, they won 2 playoff games, 4 AFC South titles, and drafted a generational Quarterback. It all fell apart when they took away the checks and balances on Bill O'Brien's Power.
We're seeing now what seeding total control of your organization does to organizations. It allows Jon Gruden to make hard, correct decisions in trading Khalil Mack and Amari Cooper for a long rebuilding process. It allows Sean McVay to build a RB core that best suits Jared Goff's limitations, and for GM Les Snead to piece together players around Aaron Donald like Leonard Floyd and Dante Fowler (now in ATL). And, it allows Matt Rhule, the 1st year coach from Baylor, to tear down the Panthers roster and build it up from scratch with Teddy Bridgewater, Robby Anderson, 3 1st Round Picks on offense, and draft 7 defensive players with your 1st 7 draft picks, the first time such an event has ever happened. Time will tell on Matt Rhule, but the underlying processes are in place that give him the best possible chance to succeed.
There's a reason that 4 teams (DET, ATL, HOU, and JAX) fired GM's along with their Head Coaches. I see what the Panthers, Raiders, Rams, 49ers, Bills, and others are doing with seeding total control to their people. Maybe Arthur Blank and Shad Khan see this as well. College Coaches are already coming from a place they have total power, and where they work in unison with an Athletic Director type body. They are great NFL hires, while NFL coaches are often bad fits in the College system.
This is why, when hiring a College coach, you can't get the best of the best coaches. There are 10-13 College Coaching jobs that are more desirable than any NFL Head Coaching opportunity. The best example of this was Nick Saban leaving the Dolphins to go to Alabama in 2007. Those 10-13 jobs include:
Locks: Alabama, Clemson, Ohio State, Oklahoma, Notre Dame, Florida, Georgia, LSU, Wisconsin, and Jimbo Fisher w/ Texas A&M money. Debatable: Being coach at Michigan State, Auburn and Penn State are debatable jobs on whether they'd leave for an NFL job, but neither Mel Tucker, Gus Malzhan or James Franklin are in the running for NFL jobs.
If none of those coaches are going to leave for the NFL, that leaves a small pool of candidates left behind for NFL teams to trust. Not everyone is going to get a College Coach (unless someone convinces Lincoln Riley to leave w/ a Gruden-esque $11 million a year deal) but here's some of the names they can pick from:
Jim Harbaugh, Michigan Pat Fitzgerald, Northwestern, Mario Cristobal, Oregon
PJ Fleck, Minnesota (my favorite option) Matt Campbell, Iowa State
All of these coaches get me excited for NFL teams. Sure, they may not be sexy hires or big names. But with the exception of Harbaugh, they've found lots of success at obscure College Football teams. For those who don't follow College Football, I can't stress enough how impressive of a job it is to win, and win consistently in the wastelands of College Football. All of these coaches should excite NFL teams who's jobs are 2nd tier when compared to the 10-12 jobs I listed above.
2. Hire Joe Brady. Joe Brady was a typical 29 year old assistant coach with the New Orleans Saints in 2018. Like so many assistant coaches, Brady was paying his dues towards becoming a future NFL coach, maybe in 10 or 20 years. Across the state, Ed Orgeron needed to improve LSU's lackluster passing attack, which had been the case for the 5 years he'd been at LSU (they're all time leading receiver was Dwayne Bowe, with 12 TD's in one season and an average NFL career). In a bold move, Orgeron hired Joe Brady as his passing game coordinator (Co-OC title).
The rest is history. Joe Brady's system embraced the spread offense, and it brought out the talent in Joe Burrow that Ohio State and even LSU couldn't bring out in 3 seasons. Justin Jefferson, Jamar Chase and Terrence Marshall all broke single season school records for passing TD's. Joe Burrow broke the All Time TD's record. Brady had cracked the code with his offense, adapted from the 2018 Saints whom outproduced a 50 TD MVP season from Patrick Mahomes.
Brady translated his success with Burrow into the OC job with the Carolina Panthers under our buddy Matt Rhule in 2020. Brady is youngest OC in the NFL at 31 years old. While the win-loss results are a mixed bag, the offensive results can't be ignored. Mike Davis, the 4th Round Backup who'd been cut twice, is one of the 10 most productive running backs in the NFL. Robby Anderson and DJ Moore were both Top 5 in the NFL in receiving yards (Last week Moore was #5 and Anderson was #7). Teddy Bridgewater, who has never finished higher than 14th in passing yards, is the #3 leading passer in the NFL.
Joe Brady has simply been paying dues, and it does not matter whether Carolina is failing to put up points. Brady has something unique in his offensive play calling. The only way to pry him from Carolina is to offer him the Head Coaching Job for your franchise. It's the same move the Rams did when hiring Sean McVay, and it was a genius move. I see hiring Brady similarly to the Rams call to hire McVay at age 31 (Brady will be 32 next September). Brady is young, he has an offense that has proven success in 2 places as a play caller. Someone needs to make him their next head coach (And quite frankly, it should be the Bengals).
