On Sunday, we'll be treated to some intense Football Matchups. The Ravens-Steelers game is on at 10 in the morning out West. As will be the Patriots last grasp at the AFC East over Buffalo. Then, the Saints-Bears and 49ers-Seahawks in the Afternoon.
On Sunday Night, we will be treated to.... Ben Dinucci, the worst defense in the NFL (even over Atlanta) and the 2-5 Dallas Cowboys. They will lose unceremoniously to the Philadelphia Eagles. The Eagles will jump to a competent 3-4-1, and will be on their way to the 4th seed in the NFC. As for the Cowboys, they have some serious soul searching to do over the next year.
What kind of team do they want to have?? The team who was young and great 3 years ago, hoping to squeeze out the greatness of such players entering their supposed "physical primes"?? Is it a teardown, a new young team, and the hopes of future successes?? Or, is it some combination of the two??
While the Cowboys haven't drawn a great hand for themselves, there is a path to competitiveness again sooner than later in Dallas. It's gonna take some hard choices and difficult decisions, but there is still parts that can be salvaged from a Cowboys team that is falling apart right in front of our eyes.
REBUILDING THE DALLAS COWBOYS
January 2021: I'm getting rid of Mike McCarthy as soon as the Cowboys walk off the field in Week 17. The move was meant to build upon what the Cowboys did in 2020, and it has failed spectacularly so far. I'd stick with Kellen Moore as the Offensive Coordinator, however. I believe Moore is a great coordinator, learning at the helm of another great coordinator in Jason Garrett for 8 seasons. Moore the play caller had the #1 Offense in 2018 in every category (except Points), and the 2019 Cowboys only had 4 weeks of Dak Prescott, who avg. 450 yards bc of high scoring losses early in the season. My hire is Minnesota Vikings Coach Mike Zimmer, who I expect Minnesota will move on from in either 2020 or 2021. Let's guess it's this year, and the Cowboys can hire Zimmer. As the DC, I'd go with either Matt Patricia or Dan Quinn, just bc of their past successes and recent shortcomings as coaches. It doesn't really matter who I choose in the long run, so I'll go for name recognition (Another good name: Gus Bradley on the Chargers)
February 2021: My intent of doing these rebuilds are to be cold, heartless, and ruthless in order to make the necessary moves to win. In this case, I wouldn't let Dak Prescott walk into Free Agency this way. Dak will get a 2nd Franchise Tag for $37 million in 2021, and that's Jerry Jones' call. They'll let him go following 2021, which we'll discuss in a little bit. They'll also resign Andy Dalton as an above average backup for next season.
March 2021: I'm shopping Zeke Elliott and Amari Cooper to the highest bidders. Both contracts look to be grand mistakes, since the value they are providing is not equal to what they are being paid. The player I'm most interested in moving is Elliott, and not for the level of play he's put forth. The RB position is totally interchangeable, as Mike Davis and Giovani Bernard are once again proving this year. While Elliott is the best example of a player doing well on his 2nd contract, the Cowboys have to pay him through 2026. Anyone who will take him for, say, a 2nd Round Pick is a win for the Cowboys. Especially for a team that has 2 2nd Rounders, like the Jacksonville Jaguars. (Both deals were passed overwhelmingly w/ over 800 votes on @comical_sports_memes)
Jaguars Acquire: Zeke Elliott
Cowboys Acquire: 2021 2nd Round Pick
For Amari Cooper:
Broncos Acquire: Amari Cooper, 2021 6th Round Pick
Cowboys Acquire: 2021 2nd Round Pick, 2022 3rd Round Pick, Phillip Lindsay
April 2021: Let's play it safe and say the Cowboys finish 2021 with a 6-10 record. That would net the Cowboys the #10 Pick in the NFL Draft. In addition, the Cowboys have the #40 Pick from the Vikings, the #43 Pick from themselves, and the #47 Pick from the Denver Broncos. Since they won't be able to trade up to get Trevor Lawrence or Justin Fields, we'll just use the Picks we have to draft.
#10 Pick: Gregory Rousseau, EDGE Miami
#40 Pick: Israel Mukuama, CB South Carolina
#43 Pick: Josh Myers, G/C Ohio State
#47 Paris Ford, S/CB Pittsburgh
#73 Chris Olave, WR Ohio State
#100 (Compensatory Pick): Kary Vincent Jr, CB LSU
Big time commitment was made to the secondary in this draft, which should help Mike Zimmer and the incoming DC, who are both Defensive minded coaches. The Cowboys biggest strengths are also ILB Leighton Vander Esch and OLB Jaylon Smith, which will lay the foundation for a young, strong defense in 2022-23.
September 2021: The Cowboys will roll out in 2021 picked as the 3rd Place team in the NFC East, only ahead of the Giants. The prevailing storyline will once again be about Dak Prescott, who will be returning from injury on a 1 year rental. In reality, Dallas won't be resigning Dak Prescott, and in 2022 they can't afford the franchise tag anymore. This is the difficult yet rational decision for the Cowboys.
In 2021, they will put around Dak this team: Tony Pollard, Phillip Lindsay and 6th Round Pick Rakeem Boyd from Arkansas. CeeDee Lamb is now the Cowboys true #1, along w/ Michael Gallup, a healthy Blake Jarwin, and Chris Olave, who is a big play threat like Amari Cooper (also $97 million cheaper over 5 years). The OL will bring back All Pros Tyron Smith and Zach Martin. They also have an emerging LG of the future in late round steal Connor Williams. La'ell Collins will return too, despite some of his shortcomings.
Their defense will be a work in progress, but should look a good bit better in 2021. They will have depth at positions like CB, their issue this year, and put Demarcus Lawrence alongside Gregory Rosseau to rush the passer. Gerald McCoy has a couple years left on his deal, and I'd try to trade him for a 4th or 5th Round Pick around the Deadline. In Free Agency, I'd sign one of these $6 million OLB's like Vic Beasley, Oliver Vernon, or Avery Williamson as a stop gap for 1 season, going alongside Jaylon Smith outside.
December 2021: The Cowboys offense will be in the Top 10 again, and the defense will be in the bottom third. The Cowboys will waltz in around 6-10 or 5-11, and that is besides the point. The rebuild from there will progress with draft picks and a Dak Prescott departure in Free Agency. The Cowboys will then A. Be in line to draft a QB in the 2022 Draft B. Sign/Trade for a cheaper QB in Free Agency (Matthew Stafford coming home to Dallas????)
Dak Prescott signs with the Washington Football Team for 4 years, $150 million
April 2022: It appears Sam Howell of UNC will be one of 2 prize QB's in 2020. With the #7-#11 Pick, the Cowboys will draft Howell as their QB of the future. Not sexy, but still a great QB. Their Defense will jump with more draft picks/development/free agent signings.
January 2024: After meticulous drafting, getting their QB through the draft, and being alright with missing the playoffs, the Dallas Cowboys are kings of the NFC East once again. They went 12-4 in 2023 with one of the 7 best defenses in the NFL, including Pro Bowlers Jaylon Smith, Leighton Vander Esch, Gregory Rousseau, and (either) Israel Mukuama, Kary Vincent, Trevon Diggs, and/or a Free Agent Safety.
The Cowboys have a lot of work to do, and starting a 3 year rebuild in 2021 is one of the best ways to proceed. Now that they have seen the repercussions of their Zeke Elliott and Amari Cooper extensions, let's hope, for their sake, they make the moves to trade them for Draft Capital. And, finally, the Cowboys need to reinvest in the CHEAP young QB, instead of the expensive young QB in Dak Prescott. Let the market reset itself for the Cowboys to turn the page with a new QB.
No, Ben "Gucci" Dinucci is not any kind of option for them. Maybe one day, we'll see him coaching on an NFL/College Sideline. However, the symbolism of Ben Dinucci and the 2-5 Cowboys shows us that, while difficult to fathom, the Cowboys young core has peaked. Dak, Zeke, and Amari have all aged out in Dallas, and it's time to move on to the next rebuild, the next winner, the next Super Bowl team. Otherwise, you're pushing for 8 wins every season until it all comes crashing down like it has in 2020. The Cowboys tried that for 2 years, both with Tony Romo and Dak/Zeke/Amari, and they already got 1 lucky, seamless transition (they found a Top 10 QB in Round 4). I don't suspect they will get as lucky a 2nd time around.
The time is right for the Cowboys to start a 3 year rebuild. It will be difficult, but also doable. No more fooling around with tractor driver Mike McCarthy or Ben Dinucci's. They need a restart right about now in Dallas, especially in reconstructing that defense. This year is lost, but the future can be a bit better.