Saturday, October 31, 2020

Rebuilding the Dallas Cowboys

 On Sunday, we'll be treated to some intense Football Matchups. The Ravens-Steelers game is on at 10 in the morning out West. As will be the Patriots last grasp at the AFC East over Buffalo. Then, the Saints-Bears and 49ers-Seahawks in the Afternoon.

On Sunday Night, we will be treated to.... Ben Dinucci, the worst defense in the NFL (even over Atlanta) and the 2-5 Dallas Cowboys. They will lose unceremoniously to the Philadelphia Eagles. The Eagles will jump to a competent 3-4-1, and will be on their way to the 4th seed in the NFC. As for the Cowboys, they have some serious soul searching to do over the next year. 

What kind of team do they want to have?? The team who was young and great 3 years ago, hoping to squeeze out the greatness of such players entering their supposed "physical primes"?? Is it a teardown, a new young team, and the hopes of future successes?? Or, is it some combination of the two??

While the Cowboys haven't drawn a great hand for themselves, there is a path to competitiveness again sooner than later in Dallas. It's gonna take some hard choices and difficult decisions, but there is still parts that can be salvaged from a Cowboys team that is falling apart right in front of our eyes.

REBUILDING THE DALLAS COWBOYS

January 2021: I'm getting rid of Mike McCarthy as soon as the Cowboys walk off the field in Week 17. The move was meant to build upon what the Cowboys did in 2020, and it has failed spectacularly so far. I'd stick with Kellen Moore as the Offensive Coordinator, however. I believe Moore is a great coordinator, learning at the helm of another great coordinator in Jason Garrett for 8 seasons. Moore the play caller had the #1 Offense in 2018 in every category (except Points), and the 2019 Cowboys only had 4 weeks of Dak Prescott, who avg. 450 yards bc of high scoring losses early in the season. My hire is Minnesota Vikings Coach Mike Zimmer, who I expect Minnesota will move on from in either 2020 or 2021. Let's guess it's this year, and the Cowboys can hire Zimmer. As the DC, I'd go with either Matt Patricia or Dan Quinn, just bc of their past successes and recent shortcomings as coaches. It doesn't really matter who I choose in the long run, so I'll go for name recognition (Another good name: Gus Bradley on the Chargers)

February 2021: My intent of doing these rebuilds are to be cold, heartless, and ruthless in order to make the necessary moves to win. In this case, I wouldn't let Dak Prescott walk into Free Agency this way. Dak will get a 2nd Franchise Tag for $37 million in 2021, and that's Jerry Jones' call. They'll let him go following 2021, which we'll discuss in a little bit. They'll also resign Andy Dalton as an above average backup for next season.

March 2021: I'm shopping Zeke Elliott and Amari Cooper to the highest bidders. Both contracts look to be grand mistakes, since the value they are providing is not equal to what they are being paid. The player I'm most interested in moving is Elliott, and not for the level of play he's put forth. The RB position is totally interchangeable, as Mike Davis and Giovani Bernard are once again proving this year. While Elliott is the best example of a player doing well on his 2nd contract, the Cowboys have to pay him through 2026. Anyone who will take him for, say, a 2nd Round Pick is a win for the Cowboys. Especially for a team that has 2 2nd Rounders, like the Jacksonville Jaguars. (Both deals were passed overwhelmingly w/ over 800 votes on @comical_sports_memes)

Jaguars Acquire: Zeke Elliott

Cowboys Acquire: 2021 2nd Round Pick

For Amari Cooper:

Broncos Acquire: Amari Cooper, 2021 6th Round Pick

Cowboys Acquire: 2021 2nd Round Pick, 2022 3rd Round Pick, Phillip Lindsay

April 2021: Let's play it safe and say the Cowboys finish 2021 with a 6-10 record. That would net the Cowboys the #10 Pick in the NFL Draft. In addition, the Cowboys have the #40 Pick from the Vikings, the #43 Pick from themselves, and the #47 Pick from the Denver Broncos. Since they won't be able to trade up to get Trevor Lawrence or Justin Fields, we'll just use the Picks we have to draft.

   #10 Pick: Gregory Rousseau, EDGE Miami

   #40 Pick: Israel Mukuama, CB South Carolina

   #43 Pick: Josh Myers, G/C Ohio State

   #47 Paris Ford, S/CB Pittsburgh

   #73 Chris Olave, WR Ohio State

   #100 (Compensatory Pick): Kary Vincent Jr, CB LSU

Big time commitment was made to the secondary in this draft, which should help Mike Zimmer and the incoming DC, who are both Defensive minded coaches. The Cowboys biggest strengths are also ILB Leighton Vander Esch and OLB Jaylon Smith, which will lay the foundation for a young, strong defense in 2022-23.

September 2021: The Cowboys will roll out in 2021 picked as the 3rd Place team in the NFC East, only ahead of the Giants. The prevailing storyline will once again be about Dak Prescott, who will be returning from injury on a 1 year rental. In reality, Dallas won't be resigning Dak Prescott, and in 2022 they can't afford the franchise tag anymore. This is the difficult yet rational decision for the Cowboys.

In 2021, they will put around Dak this team: Tony Pollard, Phillip Lindsay and 6th Round Pick Rakeem Boyd from Arkansas. CeeDee Lamb is now the Cowboys true #1, along w/ Michael Gallup, a healthy Blake Jarwin, and Chris Olave, who is a big play threat like Amari Cooper (also $97 million cheaper over 5 years). The OL will bring back All Pros Tyron Smith and Zach Martin. They also have an emerging LG of the future in late round steal Connor Williams. La'ell Collins will return too, despite some of his shortcomings.

Their defense will be a work in progress, but should look a good bit better in 2021. They will have depth at positions like CB, their issue this year, and put Demarcus Lawrence alongside Gregory Rosseau to rush the passer. Gerald McCoy has a couple years left on his deal, and I'd try to trade him for a 4th or 5th Round Pick around the Deadline. In Free Agency, I'd sign one of these $6 million OLB's like Vic Beasley, Oliver Vernon, or Avery Williamson as a stop gap for 1 season, going alongside Jaylon Smith outside.

December 2021: The Cowboys offense will be in the Top 10 again, and the defense will be in the bottom third. The Cowboys will waltz in around 6-10 or 5-11, and that is besides the point. The rebuild from there will progress with draft picks and a Dak Prescott departure in Free Agency. The Cowboys will then A. Be in line to draft a QB in the 2022 Draft B. Sign/Trade for a cheaper QB in Free Agency (Matthew Stafford coming home to Dallas????)

Dak Prescott signs with the Washington Football Team for 4 years, $150 million

April 2022: It appears Sam Howell of UNC will be one of 2 prize QB's in 2020. With the #7-#11 Pick, the Cowboys will draft Howell as their QB of the future. Not sexy, but still a great QB. Their Defense will jump with more draft picks/development/free agent signings.

January 2024: After meticulous drafting, getting their QB through the draft, and being alright with missing the playoffs, the Dallas Cowboys are kings of the NFC East once again. They went 12-4 in 2023 with one of the 7 best defenses in the NFL, including Pro Bowlers Jaylon Smith, Leighton Vander Esch, Gregory Rousseau, and (either) Israel Mukuama, Kary Vincent, Trevon Diggs, and/or a Free Agent Safety.

The Cowboys have a lot of work to do, and starting a 3 year rebuild in 2021 is one of the best ways to proceed. Now that they have seen the repercussions of their Zeke Elliott and Amari Cooper extensions, let's hope, for their sake, they make the moves to trade them for Draft Capital. And, finally, the Cowboys need to reinvest in the CHEAP young QB, instead of the expensive young QB in Dak Prescott. Let the market reset itself for the Cowboys to turn the page with a new QB.

No, Ben "Gucci" Dinucci is not any kind of option for them. Maybe one day, we'll see him coaching on an NFL/College Sideline. However, the symbolism of Ben Dinucci and the 2-5 Cowboys shows us that, while difficult to fathom, the Cowboys young core has peaked. Dak, Zeke, and Amari have all aged out in Dallas, and it's time to move on to the next rebuild, the next winner, the next Super Bowl team. Otherwise, you're pushing for 8 wins every season until it all comes crashing down like it has in 2020. The Cowboys tried that for 2 years, both with Tony Romo and Dak/Zeke/Amari, and they already got 1 lucky, seamless transition (they found a Top 10 QB in Round 4). I don't suspect they will get as lucky a 2nd time around.

The time is right for the Cowboys to start a 3 year rebuild. It will be difficult, but also doable. No more fooling around with tractor driver Mike McCarthy or Ben Dinucci's. They need a restart right about now in Dallas, especially in reconstructing that defense. This year is lost, but the future can be a bit better.

Monday, October 26, 2020

The Chiefs Have Made the NFL Regular Season Useless

 We really don't bat an eye at the Chiefs anymore.

Sure, their 43-16 victory over the Broncos came in a forgettable afternoon set of NFL games. Sure, the Chiefs only had 1 passing TD on the Broncos defense. And of course, everyone I hear keeps treating the Raiders beating the Chiefs 2 weeks ago like the sky is falling in Kansas City, as if Football doesn't have crazy moments like that happening all the time.

Football fans want to keep giving themselves the illusion that this season has merit and meaning. That there is going to be great competition for the next few months, and they can come in every Monday and do armchair analyst about the state of the Baker Mayfield's and Russell Wilson's of the world.

In order to keep that illusion alive, NFL fans have to convince themselves the Chiefs aren't what they are: A Franchise with the best coach in the sport, the best QB in the sport, the best roster in Football, and INNOVATION on their side. The Chiefs are totally overwhelming and, barring injury, they are far and away the best team in the NFL.

Does this mean the Chiefs are going to win the Super Bowl? Not 100%, but they are on the fast track to a Super Bowl. Randomness happens in the playoffs all the time. Heck, 3 1st Quarter plays doomed the 14-2 Baltimore Ravens to the Henry-Tannehill Titans. It does mean that the Chiefs have deemed the entire regular season wholly irrelevant as we simply wait to see if anyone can knock off the behemoth in January, when 1 loss can end your entire season.

This means the NFL has the same situation the NBA has been battling for years: The Super-Team syndrome. The Chiefs are the NFL's Super-Team, and all that matters for them is getting to games in January. As a result, it has rendered the entire regular season irrelevant, just like in the NBA.

During the Warriors run, the NBA postseason generated insane interest in the Sport. The Warriors-Rockets WCF was the most watched (non-Finals) game in the NBA's History. Everyone had to see whether a David, whether it be the Cavs, the Rockets, or the Raptors, could knock the Super-Team from it's perch.

Having Superteams is great for the NFL, all we have to do is wait the 2 months to get to those great moments. The byproduct of this interest was a decline in relevancy of the regular season. There will always be storylines to talk about, like Russ vs. Harden in the MVP, Load Management, or LeBron James' trading the whole Cavs roster. When there's 24/7 news coverage of Sports, like ESPN or an NBATV type, there will always be conversation topics, even if they are made out of thin air. It doesn't mean they are important or relevant. They are meant to fill time until we get to the relevant parts.

The 2020 NFL Season follows this same paradigm, but with everything jacked up on Steroids. The regular season is largely irrelevant. I suppose we can look at the standings and seeding, but all of that is largely irrelevant until days before Week 17. Case in point, the Seahawks-Cardinals game was a big deal for the standings, but we won't know the implications until the end of the season (FPI says Seattle is still 1.5 games better than Arizona). We will argue the merits of NFC East teams until the cows come home, when in reality they won't be making it farther than the Bill O'Brien Memorial Divisional Round of the Playoffs.

We will argue meticulously, for no reason, whether the Bears will win 9 games or 10 games. We will ride or die with every week of Browns football, when we already know they'll be playing the Titans or Bills in the Wild Card round. The games themselves are fun, and that's why Football's speculation is so much more intense.

It doesn't detract from the fact Kansas City is so far ahead of everybody else. As 2019 showed, it doesn't matter whether the Chiefs are a 1 or 2 seed, they are still superior. Sure only the #1 team gets a bye, and that only matters in the event of injuries. In reality, I'd rather watch 1 extra Chiefs playoff game than see a 1st Round Bye. It will be one more cocaine-shot of NFL Football in January.

The Chiefs beat Buffalo with 200 rushing yards last Monday. This week they beat the Broncos by 27 with a Kick return TD and a Pick-Six, along with another 200 passing yards from Mahomes in 3 1/3 quarters. Much like the Warriors of past years, there's no incentive for the Chiefs to go all out in regular season games, especially those in October/November. Their entire loaf of bread will be buttered in January. They are so far ahead of the entire AFC West, and fighting with the Steelers and Ravens for an irrelevant #1 seed in the AFC, considering we already saw them beat the living crap out of the Ravens in Baltimore a month ago.

Again, this doesn't mean the Chiefs are going to win the Super Bowl. It means that the NFL won't be relevant until 4 weeks in January. In the grand scheme of things, we won't remember how many games the Bears won in 2020 or Justin Herbert's magnificent rookie year. 10 years from now, we'll remember the Super Bowl Champion, the team they beat, and a couple meaningful moments and playoff games. I encourage you to do that with the 2009 NFL season: The Saints beat the Colts in the Super Bowl. What else do you remember???

Football is fun to talk about, and the conversations about Jimmy G and Matthew Stafford bring great joy and entertainment to me. But, let's not detract from the fact Kansas City has rendered the entire regular season meaningless. We know they are better, more innovative and well coached than everything and everyone in the NFL. We don't need 16 regular season games to know that. Yet every week we watch shows us just how far ahead the Chiefs are from everyone else. Rain, Snow, Lamar, Deshaun, it simply doesn't matter. The Chiefs are the Warriors, and the Warriors and Chiefs rendered the Regular season useless. Everything we discuss in between is fluff meant to advance us to the next week of games until we get to meaningful games in January. This is a good thing for the NFL

Sunday, October 25, 2020

Dodgers-Rays World Series is Better than an Unrealistic Movie Script

When the World Series gets to a 3 Game series, the team that is favored is put at a disadvantage. In MLB, the Worst teams in MLB history still win 1 out of every 3 games. A 3 game series tells us little to nothing about who is a better baseball team. Over many 3 game series, we learn which teams are better than others.

The Dodgers missed their best opportunity in 32 years to all but close out a World Series on Saturday. They are the more talented team. They are playing better than the Tampa Bay Rays. Dodger pitching had held the Rays in check for 3 games. Corey Seager and Justin Turner deserve Co-World Series MVP's for their batting in the World Series. The Rays are the 2nd best team in Baseball, yet the Dodgers play at such a higher level than the Rays.

Now, all of those stats, those facts and games on paper matter a whole lot less. The Rays walked off Game 4 in a moment that, if the Rays win the World Series, will be remembered the way Alex Bregman's 2017 Game 5 12-11 Walkoff is remembered. If the Rays do lose in 6 or 7 games, like a majority of baseball fans anticipate, that moment will likely be lost to history like Max Muncy's 18th inning walk off in 2018.

Andy Freed, the Rays radio broadcaster, said in Game 4, while referencing Kirk Gibson's 1988 HR: "The Rays may need some magic of their own to get back in the series". Here you go. This is the best case the Rays could've asked for. Not just a Game 4 win, but THAT Game 4 win. A walk off that left the Dodgers in anger and frustration and made Dodgers fans feel like maybe they are truly cursed.

Just 12 hours ago, Clayton Kershaw was going to pitch a World Series closeout game to rectify his legacy. Now, he's pitching Game 5 to try and keep the Dodgers ship from a most bizarre sinking. While it's true the narrative around Kershaw isn't fair to his postseason abilities (he's an average Postseason pitcher), you couldn't script better drama. 

Imagine writing a script to a Hollywood Baseball movie. In that script, a World Series game ended on a booted ball in the outfield, the winning runner fell down around 3rd base, and the catcher missed the ball to lose the game. The series is now tied 2-2, and the ace pitcher with a reputation as a Postseason choker takes the mound in what could be chalked up to a must win Game to break Baseball's most famous World Series drought. He's also pitching against a team who's star player is making $90,000 Dollars in 2020 (that's not a typo, only 90K) and their entire starting lineup makes less than the ace pitching against them.

You'd be laughed out the room because that script is too unrealistic. As Spike Lee said "That's why movies are fake. Sports are real."

So here we are, with the most intense World Series Games in 3 years in the books. A walk-off that will live forever, and a Game 5 that hold more hype than the last game. This hype comes from one simple reason: The Rays have a chance in the series for the 1st Time. When the Rays tied the series at 1-1, most experts viewed this as a logical step towards Dodgers in 5 or Dodgers in 6. Through Game 3 and 8 innings of Game 4, it felt like that was the trend. Then the last play of Game 4 happened. And the Rays get a random 3 game series to win what would be the most improbable World Series in my lifetime (even over the Nationals of 2019). The Rays vs. The Rays with money. Featuring Clayton Kershaw avenging demons of World Series past. 

Again, you can't script drama this good.

Tuesday, October 20, 2020

Look to Football's In-Division Matchups for Clues and Patterns

 The NFC East is bad. That's been one of the most obvious takeaways from the 2020 season. There's a reason for this outcome: The natural cycles of the NFL have been thrown out of order. This is what the 2020 (and 2019 NFC East, for that matter) are supposed to look like:

Washington Racial Slurs: Normal rebuilding after a period of (relative) success w/ Kirk Cousins.

Dallas Cowboys: Team won 13 games in 2016. Dak, Zeke and Amari go from making $11 million a year combined in 2019 to $66 million a year in 2020. Team loses talent, falls into the 3rd Place Range.

Philadelphia Eagles: Super Bowl 52 champions who've overpaid players for 3 years, leading to 1 Playoff Win and a Wild Card Exit. Team falls apart in 2020 to become a 7-9 or 6-10 team.

New York Giants: Year 4 of a 3 year rebuild. Supposed to have the young talent, young QB and winning 11-12 games to win the NFC East.

These are the most likely and predictable outcomes. As you'll see, 3 seem relatively correct, and 1 glaringly obvious hole for the New York Giants (Click Here to Learn how the Giants got to now). As Bill Belichick proved most blatantly over 2 decades, the most likely still has a less-than-majority chance of happening.

From here, teams have to adjust expectations and play the standings in the present. It's my job to then laugh (and cry a little) at the Giants' Colossal F**k Ups.

Playing the results of the 2020 season, we know that A. The NFC is historically bad B. We don't understand a lot of what we're watching and C. We'd like to better understand what we're watching. A and B are statements that are universally agreed upon, based on data of "predictions" as well as the statements of humble supposed "experts" (like myself 😉) C is an aspiration, and one I'd like to contribute my beliefs to a possible better understand.

For the Dallas Cowboys, who will watch Thursday Night's Giants-Eagles game to see who joins them in 1st Place at 2 wins, getting smoked by the Cardinals doesn't matter. It doesn't matter for their season. It doesn't matter for their ineffective Andy Dalton. It doesn't matter for next week. 

If you had high hopes for the Cowboys to start 2020, you've had to reassess your expectations through 5 weeks. In the last 13 months, I've said the 2020 Dallas Cowboys would fall apart and they'd get the 1 seed, so I'm all over the place in previous expectations. Now, the Cowboys and I have reassessed the 2-2020 Cowboys, and both realize something critical in "playing the results"... 

The Cowboys only have 5 games that matter in the final 11 weeks of 2020: 2 Eagles Games, 2 Washington Games, and 1 New York Giants game

The Cowboys only have to show up for those contests, get to 8-8, and host a playoff game at home in the season when the franchise inevitably fell apart (That's what happens when you give a QB/RB/WR Trio each giant contracts). Divisional games tell you a lot about how good teams actually are, and better understand how the playoff pictures will play out the closer you get to those games.

Does a 4th seed in the NFC East matter at all from a macroview??? No, not at all. The great thing about patterns is that they work across a range of industries and, in our case, these division races. The Chargers, Raiders and (maybe) the Broncos will play 6 games against one another towards the end of 2020. Those results will decide 1-2 playoff spots in the AFC. 

What about the Cleveland Browns and the AFC North? They're 4-2, with two big beatdowns by Baltimore and Pittsburgh, both with better records. Despite boasting as much cheap, young talent as the 49ers, the Browns mostly resemble the Buffalo Bills of last year, who were 1 game short of hosting a playoff game vs. Tennessee bc they went 4-2 in the AFC East while New England went 5-1.

Yet nowhere does divisional games matter more than in the NFC West. All 7 NFC Playoff spots (except maybe the 4th Seed) will be impacted by Cardinals/49ers/Seahawks/Rams games. Just this last week, the 49ers victory over Los Angeles changed around seeds 5-10 in the NFC with just 1 result. The Cardinals-Seahawks game next week affects spots 1,2,3,5,6,7,8, and 9 seeds in the NFC with just one result. Data suggests through NFL history, these same patterns tend to continue from Week 7 on to Week 17 and beyond. It's the reason the Saints played Minnesota instead of getting the #1 seed in 2019's Playoffs.

So going forward, look out from when the Cowboys play a divisional game. They'll give you a great representation of how an NFC Playoff spot is going. Watch the Cardinals-Seahawks on Sunday. Or the Dolphins vs. the Bills. Or Steelers vs. Ravens. Or, and I can't believe I'm suggesting this, even the Giants-Eagles Thursday Night dud in a couple days. Again, they give a great representation of how teams are doing in any given season, especially when figuring out which teams have a chance to turn a corner in the next 5-10 weeks. Which means, unfortunately, the Houston Texans don't have much of a chance at getting back in the mix. Yet somehow the Eagles do have a chance.

It's a strange phenomenon, yet the patterns suggest both cases to be true. Patterns are the best tools we can use for better understand of these random events we're all witnessing together.

Sunday, October 18, 2020

Sean McVay's Finally Coaching the Team He Built

 Sean McVay legacy is already long and illustrious. He, along with Kyle Shanahan, the LaFluer Brothers (Mike and Matt) Mike McDaniel and Zac Taylor are the leaders of Mike Shanahan's revolution of offense in the NFL, one predicated on outside zone runs and an intense focus on the running game. Their revolution, which in 2016 got the Falcons to a 28-3 lead in the Super Bowl, was the reason McVay was hired by the Rams a week before that Falcons-Pats Super Bowl. McVay was hired bc. A. The Rams wanted Kyle Shanahan, but he already had a "wink wink" under the table agreement to be the head coach of the San Francisco 49ers. B. McVay was a disciple of that same Washington scheme from RGIII and C. GM Les Snead wanted someone w/ that system because the Rams had Todd Gurley, the best RB in the NFL.

Despite the fact McVay played in a Super Bowl at 33, or that he's never had a losing season in Los Angeles, 2020 is far and away Sean McVay's best coaching season of his career. The Rams hired Sean McVay to scheme for Todd Gurley, and 4 years later Sean McVay is scheming for Sean McVay's Los Angeles Rams. The Rams are no fluke. They are really good. Maybe even good enough to topple the Seahawks. To that, all the credit goes to Sean McVay for his patience, knowing what his vision is for a winning team, and sticking to it.

The 2018 Rams looked like some funky combination of a high powered passing attack w/ a running game that could break off big chunk plays, and it won the Rams a lot of games. They, Kansas City and New Orleans looked like they were the revolution of Football, albeit in 3 different styles, all putting up 35-45 PPG and winning 13, 12 and 14 games each, respectively. The Rams were the only one of the 3 to make it to the Super Bowl, losing 13-3 to the defensive master, Bill Belichick. A success no doubt, but not what McVay had in mind for his team schematically.

15 years ago, Bill Belichick laid bare that you can win with any running back. Literally, any running back. Interchanging of the running backs is a great way to maximize value at the least valuable position of the 14 Offensive/Defensive positions, which is a must in a salary cap sport. The best of the best coaches learned from Belichick and implemented his practices in new ways. The Eagles won with Corey Clement at running back. The Broncos turned CJ Anderson into the Offensive MVP of Super Bowl 50. The Giants won 2 Super Bowls with Ahmad Bradshaw. John Harbaugh figured out how to make the QB also the RB, and only pay the 2 positions $1.6 million.

Mike Shanahan figured this out before Belichick. Terrell Davis was a 6th Round Pick who won an MVP and Super Bowl MVP, en route to the HOF. Shanahan did it again when he draft Mike Anderson, who won the 2000 NFL Rookie of the Year. When Shanahan got to Washington DC, RGIII became the Running Back who was also the QB, just like Lamar Jackson last year. After RGIII tore his ACL in the Seahawks playoff game, the Racial Slurs didn't feel comfortable with him being a running QB. Shanahan was fired, Jay Gruden was hired, and Gruden wanted Kirk Cousins over RGIII.

Created out of those 4 years in DC was a new generation of coaches, like McVay, who knew Shanahan's system and would recreate RGIII, Mike Anderson and Terrell Davis all across the NFL. Building systems out of cheap, disposable running backs that could beat defenses off the edge was a revolution of the sport, and it could be done at cheap. The QB didn't have to be elite, the running backs weren't making anything, which freed up tons of money for the Offensive Line and Defensive Line.

Just last year, the 49ers showed us success with the Shanahan system. With the #1 defense in the NFL, acquired from High Draft Picks over 4 years of mediocrity and injuries, Shanahan rolled out with Jimmy G, a Tier 3 NFL QB, and running backs Tevin Coleman (a bit of a punchline in Atlanta) Raheem Mostert, and Matt Breida. All of them had explosive, 150 yards games in the season. Mostert did it in the NFC Championship Game. Breida was the star from Weeks 1-6. Coleman from Weeks 9-16. The 49ers were 6 minutes away from winning the Super Bowl, before they lost to, you know, Patrick Mahomes and... undrafted RB Damian Williams.

Now, back to McVay.

In 2017 and 2018 McVay was coaching players that he had inherited. Over 70% of the starting 22 for the Super Bowl were players that had come to the Rams via. Jeff Fisher's regime. McVay was coaching to the players that he inherited, most importantly an All-Pro Running Back with 2,000 yards of offense, 22 TD's in 11 games, and creaky, arthritic knees that were falling apart fast.

Todd Gurley was a great Running Back, with HOF paces through 4 seasons. I'm tempted to say he was "the perfect RB" for McVay's system, and in reality Gurley was the most talented RB in the NFL, playing in a system that was built around the running game. Obviously, this was not done by mistake. Snead wanted to hire Shanahan, and ultimately hired McVay, for the express purpose of maximizing Todd Gurley's generational gifts at running back.

Yet, the perfect RB for McVay's offense was not any particular running back. It was actually 3 running backs. And not just any running backs.... well actually yes, any running backs. Preferably 3 running backs with different skillsets, but not a requirement. Just like Kyle Shanahan and the 49ers, McVay's good friend and colleague from Washington from 2010-2013 (Mike was fired, and Kyle became the Browns OC. McVay became Jay Gruden's OC).

By Year 4, McVay, with Les Snead, has gotten to build the roster he wants. Sure, the QB was chosen for him, a limited but respectable Tier 3 QB Jared Goff. And he was paid a lot of money, like a LOT of Money. But the rest of the roster was McVay's child to mold. While his 2018 offense had 9 of the 11 players picked by Jeff Fisher, the 2020 team has 8 of the 11 Spots filled by McVay (I'd round up to 9, bc Robert Woods was a practice squad guy with Fisher before becoming a star w/ McVay).

1 of those 11 is a combination of 3 Running Backs, all selected by McVay. Darrell Henderson, Cam Akers, and Malcom Brown are now McVay's Coleman, Breida (now Jerrick McKinnon) and Mostert. McVay's outside runs create explosive plays to move the ball, while counting on Goff to be extremely accurate in the short field. Much of that is dependent on the Offensive Line, which is ranked #6 in the NFL through 5 games. The Rams can then craft a Super Bowl-level defense like San Francisco did last year. Through 5 weeks, Pro Football Focus ranks the Rams as the #4 defense in the NFL.

The 2020 Rams are the closest thing to a 2019-49ers team in the NFL. They are also the closest thing to a Mike-Shanahan-scheme McVay has had in his 4 years as a coach. This is not a coincidence. This is McVay finally putting his imprint on the team he couldn't do in 2018. This year, 75% of the Rams were drafted or signed under McVay, vs. the 70% in 2018 who were Jeff Fisher signings.

If you had a 100% honest McVay, he'd tell you he wants a QB better than Jared Goff. He'll also tell you that he can and will win with an expensive Jared Goff. That's what this system was designed for in 1995, when an old, limited John Elway was the NFL's Highest Paid QB. The Broncos tailored their system to give Elway the softest landing pad possible to win a Super Bowl. As it turns out, that system is in demand every year for the 25 NFL Franchises who don't have Mahomes, Wilson, Watson, Rodgers or Lamar. The system was made for the Jared Goff's, Jimmy Garoppolo's and Jordan Love's of the World.

The Rams are 4-1, and just might beat the 49ers to go to 5-1 on Sunday Night Football. I wouldn't be surprised to see these two teams meeting in the Divisional Round of the Playoffs in January. For a guy who said the Rams would go 5-11 in 2020, I'm not doubting Sean McVay again. It was silly in the first place, because I believe in McVay as a coach as much as I believe in any NFL coach. I held resentment for the Rams for paying Jared Goff $33 million dollars, and wanted to see that system fall apart. And after last year, it seemed that was happening. Yet, they still won 9 games without any RB that McVay wanted desperately to bench for Malcom Brown. 

I see the light now. The Rams aren't looking for Justin Herbert or Joe Burrow or Aaron Rodgers. The system taking the NFL by storm, with the Rams, 49ers, Packers, Bengals and Titans specifically, was built for 37 year old John Elway. It was built for Matt Schaub and 38 year old Peyton Manning, whom Gary Kubiak won with (Kubiak was Mike Shanahan's OC in Denver in 1997-98). This system wasn't built for Aaron Rodgers, it was built for Jared Goff's and Jimmy Garoppolo's and Jordan Love's all across the NFL. And we know from Denver's 3 Super Bowl Trophies and San Francisco's 2019 Super Bowl run that the system works. It's an innovation of the NFL that the Rams have now taken full advantage of, and LaFluer wants to work into Green Bay for the next decade.

Thursday, October 15, 2020

Daryll Morey's 3 Very Distinct Legacies

 Nobody ever gets to decide their legacy. There are people who are obsessed with manipulating the narrative to try and control their legacy. People in power desire to dictating their "importance", from Kevin Durant to Donald Trump and everywhere in between.

Which bring me to, of all places, Daryll Morey. Morey "stepped down" as Rockets GM today, which is the same as "taking a break" when you break up w/ someone. Daryll Morey will be remember by three groups of people in three very, VERY different ways. Where you fall on that spectrum depends on what type of a Sports fan you are.

I've talked much before about what the future of the Rockets looks like. The Rockets traded 2 Draft picks and 2 pick swaps for Russell Westbrook, and traded another pick for Robert Covington. Tillman Fertita is cash broke, and 1st Ballot HOFer James Harden is exiting his prime at 31 years old. The D'Antoni-Morey-Harden era is over in Houston, and if they were smart they would tear it all down a year early instead of a year late, like OKC did to get 11 1st Round Picks in 6 years.

Those will be questions to answer with a new head coach and a new GM (Odd timing considering the Top Choice for Morey's replacement just left for Sacramento). Let's focus on Daryll Morey's 3 Legacies, and how each of those groups came to their collective conclusions.

1. The NBA's Billy Beane: Daryll Morey was the 1st great pioneer of an Analytics-Driven Front Office. While the Warriors, Houston's arch rival, are the most successful analytics-model, Morey was the pioneer before everyone else. He was named Houston's GM in 2008, inheriting an aging team of Yao Ming, Ron Artest, and Tracy McGrady. It wasn't so much the results that were revolutionary as much as the style and the process by which the Rockets were ran.

Morey wanted to build a 3 Pt juggernaut, the likes of which had never been seen before. He couldn't take advantage of this until acquiring James Harden from the Oklahoma City Thunder. The Rocket's have broken every conceivable 3 Point team record in NBA history. Since acquiring Harden, the Rockets took more 3's over an 8 year stretch than any other franchise. The gap between them and 2nd Place, Golden State, was equal to the gap between Golden State and team 24!!

While Morey rebuilt the Rockets (and traded away Kyle Lowry) he also co-invented the MIT Sloan Sports Analytics Conference. This yearly congregation was used as propaganda to show Franchises the importance of analytics and for new ideas to be shared among large groups of people. In 2017 they even got Obama to give the opening speech for the conference.

Full disclosure, this is where I fall among the 3 legacies of Daryll Morey will lie. I love sports, and I love innovation. This guy was the pioneer of the greatest sports innovation of our lifetime, and it allowed him, along with Sam Hinkie, Bob Myers and Andy Ellisburg to build the great NBA dynasties of our lifetime. Morey never got the big trophy, but neither has Billy Beane. His legacy, for myself, will be that Daryll Morey knocked down the Brick Wall so the Myers, Hinkie's and Sashi Brown's could come after him.

2. The "0-27" guy trying to make Sports Boring

When someone holds sports as a sacred cathedral, the thing they hate more than anything is the guy who disparages that cathedral. When Morey talks about "passing up layups for 3 Point Jumpers" it goes against everything we are trained from the earliest age to think about basketball. Morey had ideas that nobody else was focused on, and he said things nobody else was saying.

When you approach that sacred Sports cathedral with any weapon, in this case numbers and data, the guardians will meet you with hostility. It's their best tactic to attack your ideas that don't agree with what they've been taught from the youngest ages. Call it ignorance. Call it emotion. Call it whatever you feel it is. The bottom line is that people will protect this cathedral with everything that they've got.

The side effects of hostility include disparaging, discrediting, and finding any excuse to say "Why should I not care about what is happening??" This is at the heart of all forms of discrimination, especially when it comes to the subjugation of Non-White People, by White People, or the subjugation of Gay People by Straight-cisgender people. These are all real societal conflicts that have been fought for dozens of generations now. Tribalism passes these ideologies down to the majority, and we don't ever force the majority to change. We often promote them into positions of power.

Sports reflect our society, and the Rockets were the "different" group, discredited by people who don't like things that are different. The Rockets of the last 3 years were ripped apart for being "boring", despite the fact James Harden is the greatest offensive weapon in my (short) lifetime. James Harden finished Top 2 in the MVP for 4 straight seasons, winning 1 title. I always bring that up as a counter to the masses saying "Harden was a fluke MVP". Not that it really matters. They will discredit Harden. They will discredit Morey. Why? Because they are different, and different disrupts the sacred cathedral of Sports.

This was never on fuller display than when the Rockets went 0-27 in a Game 7 of the 2018 WCF, losing to a worse Warriors team by 8 points. If they had simply shot bad and not historically bad they would've won an NBA Finals (and not had a hit on them by the NBA wanting Golden State in the NBA Finals).

3. The Non-Sports Fans who use Morey's Hong Kong Controversy to further their own agenda.

This story has less to do about Morey and more about America's Political Climate as a whole. The NBA is a Political Organization. This is a good thing. They are a predominantly Black League with a lot of influence in Popular Culture. They should be using their platform to push Pro-BLM messages and policies.

Only 1 of 2 major Political Party in America is supporting such ideas, the Democratic Party (keyword supporting, not advancing). The Republican Party has their own agenda to appease groups who will give them a vote every 2 Novembers. Therefore, they are going to use tactics to disparage the competition, as both political organizations do.

Daryll Morey handed them a case in the breadbasket last year with the Hong Kong tweets. Morey's tweet will cost the league more in lost revenue than Coronavirus. China is a major global superpower who has a lot of money. With money comes power, and with power comes influence. Unfortunately for the NBA, they got caught in the crossfire between China and Pro-Capitalism Americans, the same group who elected President Trump.

Now, even a year later, the What-about-ism tactic is being used to discredit the NBA's effort to affect domestic policy and domestic race relations. Their argument says that if the NBA doesn't care about the broad human rights violations in China, then they should be discredited from commenting on the broad human rights violations in America.

Morey and the NBA get caught up in this mess less than a year in advance of the NBA taking the largest stand on racial injustice by a Sports Corporation in the last 50-60 years. The groups pushing back on this will discredit the NBA as a winning tactic for their election campaigns. The truth is, they are appealing to a certain group of voters to come out and cast votes for them. 90-99% of the time, it's pandering to the same people who fall under "Group 2" we discussed earlier.

Wednesday, October 14, 2020

The Dodgers are Back, At Least for 1 Night

In Game 3 of the NLCS, with arguably their best season of the last 8 years on the line, the Dodgers scored not 1, not 2, not 3, not 5 or 8 or 10... but 11 RUNS on the Atlanta Braves. The Dodgers had to win this game, the Braves were playing with house money. Yet, for those who have watched, we can't help but shake the fact that the Dodgers are clearly the Superior team to the Atlanta Braves.

Yet, this is baseball. It just doesn't matter who the better team is, the results are more random than any other sport. We can count on the best teams in the NFL and (sans Miami Heat) the NBA to make it to the Championship Game. Baseball has playoff sample sizes that are too small for the best team to advance. This is what makes October Baseball so fantastic. You have to watch the games to know what will happen, and you will almost always see 6 and 7 game series that entertain you (4 of the last 6 World Series' have gone to 7 games). The worst teams in the history of Baseball still win 1 out of every 3 games. In Basketball, that number is about 1 to 7. In Football (Pro and College) that number can be anywhere from 1 in 6 to 1 in 16. The sample sizes in Baseball aren't large enough for the most talented roster to (always) advance.

This fact made it so strange that we were seemingly headed towards a couple of routes in the NL and AL Championships. The Rays and Braves were 5-0 headed into Wednesday. The Rays could close out the Astros tonight and take home some hardware. The Braves couldn't all but sealed their and the Dodgers fate (only 1 team has ever come back from down 0-3). The Dodgers responded to the call. They woke up.

Technically, they woke up last night. Los Angeles scored 4 runs in the Bottom of the 9th to make a 3-8 game down to just 7-8. They got the tying run on 3rd base before a game ending ground out. Combining that 9th inning plus the first 3 innings in Game 3, the Dodgers outscored the Braves 19-0 in just those 4 innings. The Braves starting pitching was already thin, and it's looking even thinner after Kyle Wright left in the 1st after 6 of the 11 runs. The Braves will have to empty their bullpen just to get through Game 3, which can only hurt them as they head into a pivotal Game 4 on Thursday (ask the San Diego Padres how that feels). They'll be asking 22 year old Bryce Wilson to go head to head w/ (presumably) Clayton Kershaw in a game both teams need badly.

The winner of Game 4 goes on to win the series over 90% of the time. When a series gets to 2-2, a best of 3 series doesn't bode well for Atlanta, for no reason other than it's a super random outcome. The Braves are in better control when all they have to do is win 2 of 5 games to advance. When that becomes 2 out of 3, it's anyone's guess how that series will pan out. (Note: The Winner of Game 5 in a 2-2 series wins the series 81% of the time, so Atlanta should feel good as long as they're up 3-2).

Maybe all of this was unfair to Atlanta. They were behind the Dodgers coming into this NLCS series. This was almost universally agreed upon. After collectively playing the results of Games 1 and 2, we all turned from viewing the Braves beating LAD as an upset to an expectation. They punched back at Walker Buehler in Game 1 w/ ace Max Fried. Then they crushed the Dodgers for 8 runs in Game 2. Kershaw's injury game them the edge in the starting pitching department, and that was enough to put them over the edge.

What we are now witnessing are the two best offenses in Baseball sprinting for a 4 game stretch for their entire season and, for both teams, their best shot going forward at a World Series berth. The Braves have won 3 straight NL East titles. The Dodgers 8. Baseball is a sport that doesn't bode well for sustainability, even with all the analytics and numbers-driven decision making involved. The randomness of the playoff format, combined with the fact that (until 2020) only 8 teams got a series in October. 

The Braves have not made it this far before. Despite all their talent, I don't feel confident saying they'll get back to this point again, just 2 games away from the World Series. 2020 is the prime of their winning window. They match up very well with the Tampa Bay Rays. The Braves have now transitioned from the future of the sport to the present. Very soon, this team will become the sports' past. Such is the nature of time passing.

The Dodgers know all too well about time passing. The past 2-3 years have felt like borrowed time for the Dodger Blue. After going to Game 7 of the 2017 World Series, they've slowly declined from the mountaintop. They lost via a 5 game route in the WS to Boston. They lost in the NLDS to the Nationals in 2019 after their lowest win total since 2016. Each of the last 4 World Series Champions have beaten the Dodgers en route to their WS. The core of their team keeps getting changed out, and soon they will lose players like Justin Turner, Corey Seager, Kenley Jansen, Kike Hernandez, and an aging Clayton Kershaw. They may be competitive during this transition time, and adding Mookie Betts only resets the clock on another Dodgers' Postseason run. It doesn't mean they haven't won 8 straight NL West titles and haven't claimed that illusive championship. They know pressure. It's been on them and the Yankees for longer than any franchises in recent Baseball history.

And so, for at least 1 night, the Dodgers are back. They've made it a series again. People will say they have the upper hand. Dodgers fans must be feeling confident again. All will be answered in Texas over a most exciting 4 days this week.

Tuesday, October 13, 2020

The Falcons Escaped "Kemba Walker 9th Seed Purgatory"

Let's get this out of the way first: Yes, I said the Atlanta Falcons were a defense away from being a Super Bowl Champion. Yes, I said the Falcons would make the Playoffs in 2020. Yes, I was wrong about the Atlanta Falcons. And yes, I who was loud wrong about the Atlanta Falcons (and who bet the Falcons vs. Dallas, Chicago and Carolina) is going to tell you where the Falcons should go from here.

The Falcons were an interesting situation even before they punted on the 2020 season by firing GM Thomas Dimitroff (who will have another job very soon in New York or Detroit) and Dan Quinn (who will NOT be getting a HC job again soon). The Falcons seemed like a fluke 0-4 team after 2 bad losses where they had 16 point leads in the 4th quarter. Their loss to the Panthers sealed the franchises fate. Without Julio Jones, the Falcons Passing Attack offense looked more like the Los Angeles Rams, deciding to run the entire offense through Todd Gurley and win a 24-17 game. 

The reason Dimitroff and Quinn got fired is a simple one: The inability to replace a Top 10 defense from Super Bowl 51 over 4 seasons. It's the reason the Falcons have been the exact same team for 4 years: A team who throws 400 yards, 3 TD's and 1 INT while both them and their opponent score 30 points, and there's a 50-50 chance they hold at the end of the game. Blank, and myself quite frankly, were sick and tired of watching this mediocrity for years and years.

Their defense, for 3 years the worst franchise in PPG Allowed, can't hold teams to 17 points. The only times in those 3 seasons they've showed life was when they saved Quinn's job for 5 games in 2020. For Arthur Blank, it came down to a classic case of "fool me once (finished 2019 6-2) shame on you. Fool me twice (0-5 start in 2020) shame on me."

Speaking of Blank, he made headlines yesterday by not committing to Matt Ryan beyond the 2020 season. While I agree this story is an overblown "Flavor of the Week" topic, it's not like there isn't some underlying truth to the rumors. Ryan is 35, making $35 million a year, and has been one of these 50 passes, 5000 yards and low completion % QB's that are going the way of onside kicks and fullbacks: Extinction (Just ask 3rd String #1 Yards/TD Champion Jameis Winston).

The Falcons are finally moving out of what I call "Kemba Walker 9th Seed Purgatory". The Falcons (and the Hornets) were always good enough to finish just outside the playoffs, but never bad enough to get a top draft pick. The Falcons are finally committing to a full scale rebuild. 3 years, tear it down, finish near the bottom of the NFL every year (especially this year).

In January, Arthur Blank will hire a new GM and that GM will hire a new coach. Maybe it's Eric Biennemy. Maybe it's Brian Daboll. If I were in charge, I would keep Dirk Koetter, one of the best OC's in the NFL, and hire either A. Robert Saleh or B. PJ Fleck from the Minnesota Golden Gophers.

Which brings us to Matt Ryan. Why wouldn't Blank commit to Ryan beyond this season?? Simple. That GM will get full control of personnel decisions. If Falcons GM decides he wants to draft QB in 2021, Blank won't stop them from picking QB in the Draft. This is very possible if they get their hands on Trey Lance, Justin Fields or Trevor Lawrence. We will know in January what the Falcons draft position is, and if they get one of the Top 2 Picks in the Draft (they sit at #3 right now), we will see Matt Ryan get traded before Free Agency in March.

If the Falcons decide to begin by rebuilding their defense w/ new GM's 1st Draft Pick, then Matt Ryan will be the Falcons QB in 2021. If they decide to draft a QB in 2022, then Matt Ryan will be traded then. If they decide to draft QB in 2023, they'll let Matt Ryan walk in Free Agency then. The idea is such that Matt Ryan is being replaced. When that happens will be up to the General Manager to decide.

Blank did the same thing when the Falcons drafted Ryan in 2008. When Michael Vick went to jail, the Falcons didn't wait for him to claim the job back Even though he was still a very good NFL starter, the Falcons drafted Ryan in 2008 with the 3rd Pick. Now, as if by a stroke of luck, the Falcons are presented with the exact same situation again. They have the luxury of having a Top 10-12 QB in the NFL, and they can draft his replacement whenever they feel the time is right.

For Ryan, there will be plenty of opportunities coming his way. His fate will be very clear (or at least clearer than Cam Newton's) by the time the Super Bowl Trophy is handed out in February. At that time, if the Falcons will be preparing to move him, there will be no shortage of suitors for Matt Ryan, especially when Atlanta eats a chunk of his remaining contract. The Colts have a QB-sized hole in their Super Bowl ready core. The 49ers will be seeking a Jimmy G upgrade this offseason. The Raiders might not be able to get a Top Pick, but won't be starting 2021 with Derek Carr at QB. Or what about New England?? Maybe the Broncos?? Steelers?? There are no shortage of options.

For those who might still be confused at what I'm laying out, just wait it out. All of this will play out in a matter of months, the firings of Dimitroff and Quinn made that official. All we have to do is let this play out over January, February, March and, ultimately, the NFL Draft in April.

The biggest takeaway we can make is this: The Falcons are finally going from mediocre to bad. In the long run, this is the best way things could've gone. My blunder in saying they'd make the playoffs was thinking that a playoff run would've been the start of something bigger in Atlanta. These first 5 games have revealed the Falcons are going to tear it all down and start again from scratch. Ultimately, a tear down for a mediocre team always (with a couple 2019 Titans exceptions that prove the rule) pays out in the long run.

Sunday, October 11, 2020

How We Got to Now: New York Giants

The phrase New York Football Giants now feels more sarcastic than a namesake we've previously associated with success and 4 Super Bowls. The New York Giants have fallen into that territory no franchise wants to enter, and it takes a really long time to escape from. The Giants have become Perpetual Rebuilders.

With their (anticipated) loss to the Dallas Cowboys on Sunday, the Giants are 0-5 on the 2020 season. Playing in the worst division in Football, the Giants now have the #34 ranked QB in the NFL (based on PFF and QBR ratings across 6 platforms). After the firing of Dave Gettleman and (anticipated) firing of Joe Judge, the Giants will have gone through 4 Head Coaches, 3 GM's and 4 QB's in a 5 year stretch that won't be ending anytime soon, because they have to rebuild to get there.

How did we get to this point? Well, it's been as straightforward as any descent Sport's have seen among a model franchise. Ironically, the starting point for this decent begins on a Yacht in Miami, the week before the Giants most recent playoff game in 2015.

Background: The New York Giants were one of the model NFL franchises for decades. They were the Steelers but with slightly less winning. The Mara family has owned the team since it's founding, and the franchise has seen success translated over decades. The Giants have made a Super Bowl in every decade since the 1970s, winning 4 of them. Since the turn of the century, the Giants have been the only success New York City has in Sports, they've won 2 of the cities 3 Championships since 2001.

After their Super Bowl title in 2011, the Giants fell into the trap nearly all Super Bowl Champions fall into: Playing risk aversion and overpaying your champions. The Giants gave big contracts to Justin Tuck, Jason Pierre-Paul, Hakeem Nicks and, of course, Eli Manning. As great a QB as Eli Manning was, he was an extremely limited QB who was never really in the Elite QB discussion in the NFL. He'll be a HOF because of his Championships and his family, but trying to build a team around him as the highest paid QB post-Super Bowl became a futile effort.

The Boat: While the Giants were mediocre following their Super Bowl (missing the Playoffs from 2012-2015 w/ a 30-34 record) they weren't doing things wrong. What they needed was to reset their books, and that they did over their 3 year retool. In the Draft, they netted a generation Superstar at Pick #13 (no, not Aaron Donald) in Odell Beckham Jr.

After the 2015 season, with a 6-10 record and a 4th straight missed playoffs, the Giants were flush with Cap Space and an owner ready to make it back to the playoffs. The Giants did what mediocre franchises always do with cap space: Hired Ben McAdoo to replace Tom Coughlin, then gave all their money to mid-level free agents. Janoris Jenkins, Snacks Harrison, Johnathan Hankins and Oliver Vernon all joined the Giants on Top 5 contracts. These contracts bought the Giants wins, but didn't buy them any value. The Giants went 10-6 in 2016, netting the #5 Wild Card Spot behind Dak and Zeke's Rookie Cowboys, and got a Wild Card Matchup w/ the #4 seed Green Bay Packers.

That week, the Giants WR's and DB's were spotted on a Yacht in Miami. While the "crime" in question was only a crime in the court of public opinion (OBVIOUSLY the Giants didn't do anything wrong), that moment does serve as a symbolic turning point for the organization. The turn into perpetual rebuilding.

In that Wild Card Game, the Giants lost 38-13. The score wasn't so much symbolic as was the play of Eli Manning. Manning completed 23-43 passes for 293 yards, putting up a mediocre QBR of 72. He was the weak link of a young offense including Victor Cruz, Sterling Shepard, and of course Odell Beckham, one of the league's 3 best WR's.

In 2017, the Giants fell apart because, you know, that defense was predictably overpaid and mediocre.

The Eli Manning-Ben McAdoo Debacle: While Ben McAdoo has become a perpetual punchline, I struggle to name a coach that got screwed over more than Ben McAdoo. When the Giants hired Ben McAdoo, it would seem the Mara's were adamant that Eli Manning was their QB. But nobody told Ben McAdoo that. In fact, McAdoo was certain that he was gonna have the say in who the new QB was for the Giants. Why else would the Giants hire him? 

McAdoo was realistic in the fact the Giants weren't Super Bowl contenders. And of course they weren't. Jenkins and Snacks and Odell are great pieces, but obviously that team wasn't as good as the Eagles, Cowboys, Seahawks or Vikings. The Mara's convinced everyone that they were Super Bowl caliber, and that Eli Manning was still an Elite QB when, in reality, he never was.

Before a game vs. the Oakland Raiders, McAdoo benched Eli Manning for Geno Smith for ineffectiveness. It broke Eli's Ironman record of 234 straight starts to begin a career, and it wasn't even for injury. The Giants, and more specifically Mara, was PISSED!!! The Giants lost, because of course the Giants lost. They were a rebuilding franchise. The benching of Eli Manning was not because he was worse than Geno Smith (even if he was 1 year later), it was because the Giants wanted a high enough draft pick to draft Baker Mayfield or Sam Darnold, whom McAdoo could mold into his QB of the future.

Instead, the Giants made McAdoo the fall guy. They cleaned house with him and their GM, and brought in that grizzly bearded face we all can't ignore now.

The Dave Gettleman Experiment: Strangely, the Mara's had no problem letting Dave Gettleman pick the new QB of the Giants after Ben McAdoo got fired for trying to do so. With the 2nd Pick in 2018, the Giants didn't take Sam Darnold or Josh Allen. They took Saquon Barkley, an amazing player for whom it was immediately impossible for him to match his value at where he was drafted. RB's just don't add that much value to your team, and their primes are usually the 1st 4 years of their career.

For context on RB's in the Draft, Ezekiel Elliott was a bad value for the Cowboys at Pick 4. His pick looks a whole lot better than Saquon bc A. Elliott's Cowboys won 13 games in his Rookie Season. The Giants won 5. B. Zeke's production has not declined significantly after getting his big 2nd Contract (FO ranks him as the #5 RB in the league over the past 1 1/4 seasons.

The thing that dug in the Giants officially was picking the wrong QB. That decision to draft Daniel Jones was a byproduct of Bad Free Agent Signings (Nate Solder... Ouch) and bad Draft Picks (Eli Apple is gone, Oshane Ximines is a 3rd Round Pick, and Will Hernandez/Dexter Lawrence are good-not-great).

The Daniel Jones-Saquon Barkley Experiment: The Giants desperately want Saquon and Daniel Jones to work out. Under the 3 year rebuilding model, they were supposed to win the NFC East this year (one of the reasons the NFC East is so bad, the cycle has been broken). For the 2nd straight season, Saquon Barkley is hurt by a combination of bad O-Line/Bad Luck usually associated with Running Backs. The Giants have zero offensive line, and it's not for a lack of trying. Their defense is below average, with no discernable stars apart from Blake Martinez.

I give Daniel Jones a lot of slack for the bad numbers he's putting up. Look at the team around him. At the same time, it's not like he's actually that good to begin with. There's a lot missing in Jones' game, and it gets pressed on a lot. There's also a lot to like in Daniel Jones' game. The reality is, however, that as good as Jones' perks are, there are about 20-25 franchises that have or are about to draft a Daniel Jones-or better player. The Giants have a QB. So do about 27 other NFL Franchises. He's just another guy with a lot of crap built around him.

There is hope for the Giants to escape from Perpetual Rebuilding. It only takes 1 Good GM hire to right the ship of decades of failure. The Bills got that recently with the hire of Brandon Beane, and now they look to be on the precipice of a deep playoff run. The bad news for the Giants: They don't have that hire right now. Not Dave Gettleman. Not Joe Judge.

This means the Giants are another 3-4 years away from being competitive. They are going to have to hire a new coach, hire a new GM, Draft new Rookies, and clear their salary cap again. I know that's not what any fan base wants to hear. However, it's that lack of listening that F***ed up the Giants back in 2017, and put them years in the hole with a failed regime.

The Giants are going to have to swallow their pill and start all over again. If they don't have that plan, we'll be having this same conversation again in 3 years. Such is the cycle for the perpetual rebuilders.

Saturday, October 10, 2020

Tampa Bay's Best Shot at Sport's Most Unprecedented Crown

Last night, the Tampa Bay Rays pulled off the quintessential moment of the "Moneyball" revolution. Sure, the Rays have their sights set on winning the whole World Series, and that's a realistic goal for a really good baseball team. However, the Rays Game 5 defeat of the New York Yankees, with a starting pitcher in Gerrit Cole who makes more money than the Rays entire roster, is the pinnacle that proves, irrefutably, that Moneyball and "Rays-Ball" has changed the game.

The Tampa Bay Rays, owned by Stuart Sternberg, are smarter than everyone. They use analytics better than any other organization (right there with Oakland) and they innovate new strategies based on what players they have and where analytics find inefficiencies in the sport. Defensive Shifts on the infield: First implemented by the Rays in 2010. Starting a reliever and pitching a full bullpen day: Began by the Rays with Sergio Romo in 2017. The Rays are now implementing a 4th outfielder, which I'm certain will become common practice within 5 years.

Tampa Bay is amazing at developing it's players. Despite being above .500 for 3 straight seasons, the Rays have the #1 Farm System in all of Baseball. They have a legitimate star on the way in Wander Franco. For now, it's the pieces around the edges that Tampa Bay trades, signs and develops into amazing value. This concept of value is so important in sports roster construction, but often gets overlooked by those who run teams or root for teams.

The best example of this is the pitcher Tampa Bay couldn't hit all Friday Night: Gerrit Cole. Cole is the best pitcher in Baseball, or at the very least one of the 2 best (Jacob DeGrom). However, the Yankees are paying him $324 million over 9 seasons. It is impossible for Gerrit Cole to be a valuable player, because he is the #1 Paid Pitcher in all of baseball. He can be of 0 value to the Yankees by being the #1 Pitcher he was paid to be.

Value and worth are 2 very different concepts. Obviously, Gerrit Cole makes any baseball team better, and by a large margin. Gerrit Cole has significant worth in terms of wins and losses, his WAR in 2020 was 2.2 Wins Above Replacement Players. At the same time Gerrit Cole has 0 value to the Yankees in terms of adding value to the Yankees, relative to the salary cap.

The team who wins the World Series, Stanley Cup, NBA Finals or Super Bowl Trophy, among others, is the team who has the MOST valuable players. Always. In all of these sports (except Baseball) teams are playing with the same amount of money, and have to work within the salary cap. Therefore, the teams that get the most value relative, to the cap, will win the Championship.

Baseball is unique because it has a soft cap, the luxury tax, but it also has different rules in finding value than any other sports league. The best example of this is the arbitration period, where a player makes the league minimum for their 1st 3 years before making much of their money on the back end of their contracts. The Yankees happened to have the most valuable player in Baseball, because Aaron Judge made $2 million total in the 1st 3 years of his MLB Career, before making a prorated $3 million in 2020. Even Mike Trout, who is the Best Player in Baseball, is making $44 million a year, an impossible number for him to maximize his value (much like the NBA's Max contract, it's possible Trout is worth $100 million a year or more on the open market).

The Athletics were the 1st team to start the "Moneyball" revolution, where they used analytics to find value where other teams didn't. The Rays used analytics the same way, while also using them to find new strategy, make trades, and even develop their own players better than others. This year's Rays team is the quintessential example of finding value within the margins. They make moves to add/subtract value, and aren't afraid to shake up their entire roster year over year. All of this comes in an effort to compete as the poorest franchise in Major League Baseball.

Their Highest Paid Pitcher, Charlie Morton, makes $15 million for just 2020. Blake Snell, the 2019 CY Young Winner: 7 Million. Mike Brosseau, the hero from Game 5, made just $205,000 in 2020. Randy Arrozarena, the Rays postseason hero hitting .550 with 3 HR in 6 games, made just $90,335 in 2020. That's less than some of you (or your parents) reading this article made in 2020. Closer Nick Anderson: $211,000. Diego Castillo: $213,000. Tyler Glasnow, Game 5 Starter, $2 million. The Rays 1-4 Hitters (Lowe, Meadows, Arrozarena, and Ji Man Choi) make a combined $1.1 MILLION.

This is how Tampa Bay defeats the New York Yankees, a team with a $113 million Payroll in a shortened season, with just 23% of the Yankees payroll. Money can win you games, but value can win you championships. Usually, the team that wins the championship has both: The Astros (Springer, Correa, and Bregman all making $4.5 million total in 2017), the Red Sox (Rafael Devers and his $2 million w/ WS MVP Steve Pearce's $888,000 dollars) and the Nationals (Juan Soto's 550K and Howie Kendrick's $1.5 Million) compliments the ability to "buy wins" with big contracts like Justin Verlander, Mookie Betts, Chris Sale, and Patrick Corbin.

If you wanted to imagine "How good would the Rays be if they had money to spend??", well that team exists already. Andrew Friedman and his staff pioneered the Rays "Moneyball" revolution that led to a World Series berth in 2008. In 2014, Friedman became the President of Baseball Operations for the Los Angeles Dodgers. Since then, the Dodgers have been the ideal model for sustainability in Baseball. They win divisions year after year, but rarely ever give out big contracts to their players. They have a steady influx of prospects to replace players once they exit in Free Agency/Arbitration. The Dodgers have let go of players like Adrian Gonzalez, Yasiel Puig, Rich Hill, Hyun Jin Ryu, Yu Darvish, Manny Machado and more. They're about to do it again with Joc Pederson and Corey Seager. Friedman has built the Rays with money in LA, and it's only been by a stroke of Baseball bad luck that the Dodgers haven't won the World Series.

This year could change all of that in Tampa Bay, but standing in the way might just be the Tampa Bay Rays, the team Freidman learned the tools of the trade from. A Dodgers-Rays World Series would be the ultimate testament to a revolution begun 15 years ago that extends to this day. The 2 model organizations of Baseball. One with money, one without money, yet they still end up in the same place. In a sense, we already saw that happen in San Diego yesterday. The Yankees, a meticulous organization with the best GM in the game in Brian Cashman, falling short to the Tampa Bay Rays in the ALDS.

Tampa Bay has planted a flag somewhere they hadn't done so before: Right on top of the gold standard New York Yankees, doing it with only 23% of their money. Now, they face the Astros, whom they have 30% of their money. The smartest organization finally figured out a formula to take down the rich organizations head-to-head. Let's see if this Rays team can go all the way.

Thursday, October 8, 2020

The 2020 NBA Season, 10 years from now

 The Los Angeles Lakers are getting ready to become NBA Champions once again. This has been a near inevitability for about 3-4 weeks, or however long it's been since the Nuggets beat the Clippers in 7 Games (Time is just an illusion at this point). LeBron James has been rewarded for a career of being underdogs in the NBA Finals with an easy NBA Championship. This was only the 2nd time in LeBron's 10 NBA Finals appearances that his team was the favorite entering the series, the other being the 2011 loss to the Dallas Mavericks. He has had Super teams, but he's never been part of THE Super team. Even during Back-to-Back NBA Titles in Miami, the Spurs and Thunder were favored entering their Finals series'.

2020 was LeBron's long-earned reward for putting up with the Warriors' crap for 5 seasons. The Warriors were the Gold Standard of the Sport, dominant in a fashion most recently seen by the Shaq-Kobe Lakers of 2000-2004: Tested, but ultimately very little competition. LeBron James' Cavs were the 2nd Superteam, and they made 4 straight Finals appearances out of that. They lost 3, and probably should've lost 4 without a Draymond Green Suspension in 2016.

So now, with the NBA stuck in a weird purgatory following 2 catastrophic Warriors injuries, Kawhi Leonard's Free Agency, and the wasting away of "The Proccess", LeBron's Lakers got to be the gold standard. Do I believe Kawhi Leonard and the Clippers would've beat LeBron in the WCF?? Absolutely. I suspect it would've gone 6 games with a 34 point closeout game by Kawhi. That didn't happen. It doesn't mean the Lakers championship is any less legitimate, much like the Spurs title in 2003 over the Nets/Kings.

I told you back on September 16th the Lakers were you're NBA Champions, and this is LeBron's reward for a Decade of being an underdog, yet still making the Finals every year (sans injury) for an entire Decade. Sure, the Lakers never had to play a team more challenging than the 8th best player in the NBA. And sure, that team had a superstar that looks like a Loaf of Bread who makes full court passes to Denver Nuggets players you couldn't game 2 months ago. All of that will be irrelevant 7 years from now, if not 7 months from now.

The Bubble experience was be the legacy of this playoffs, and 5 years from now we won't even remember that time apart from the neutral courts on occasional highlight reels. This had nothing to do with a pandemic more than it had to do with a lack of great matchups (in a historic sense). The lasting memories of this bubble are not of epic OKC-GSW matchups, or Rockets-Warriors Game 7's or Kawhi Leonard bounces. It will be a Damian Lillard stretch of dominance, Luka Doncic's Buzzer Beater, a Nuggets 3-1 comeback and some Miami Heat wins to get to the Finals. None of those moments inspire memories or even highlight reels.

In regards to LeBron, this title probably won't be included in his career highlights. It'll be mentioned briefly like one of those forgotten Boston Celtics Finals in the 80's or Lakers-Nets. Only brief mentions will be made to the title in documentaries and HOF speeches, even fewer of which if the Lakers end up going on to win the NBA Finals again in 2020. Sure, there's a Kobe Bryant element too, and maybe some people will choose to recognize that more than the Lakers accolades.

Over all, this season, this bubble and this Champion will be forgotten in the grand scheme of NBA History. That history is littered with teams like that: From the 2nd Warriors title to the 2014 Spurs winning unimpressively. 2009's Lakers over Orlando rarely ever gets mentions, much like the 2007 Spurs sweep of LeBron of 2007. Side note: I dare you to tell me who the Spurs beat in the 2005 NBA Finals.

Bottom line: This season will be forgotten in the grand scheme of NBA History. Even LeBron winning the title won't fix that. We've seen LeBron losses that look more impressive to us than this Championship. At the same time, most of us aren't even watching these Finals Games. The Finals reflects that of a glorified 2nd Round Matchup, because that's basically what it is. The Heat needed big Bam and Tyler Herro games to have a chance at upsetting LA, then Bam got injured and lost his presence in the series. The Heat have much to build on, but building is what we tend to expect from 2nd Round Exits, not Eastern Conference Champions.

History will look fondly of the Lakers and Heat, especially so if they end up back here in 2021/2022. However, History won't look fondly upon this 2020 season. Congrats to the NBA for the execution of this bubble, and for finishing the season with a champion. All of this just happened to occur in a season in which the Basketball was already on shaky ground, and that only because more painfully clear when the Bucks and Clippers failed to make the Final 4.

This was the Lakers to lose, and of course they got it done. Only a historic falling out would've doomed this franchise against the likes of the Nuggets and Heat, two teams who overachieved by making the Final 4 and 2. There is nothing wrong with this, LeBron earned this chance to coast to title 4. Just don't expect history to remember this season very fondly 4, 7, 10 and 20 years from now.

Wednesday, October 7, 2020

Astroball is Still Alive... And I LOVE IT!!!!

A perfect storm of chaos has blown through the Astros organization since they walked off the field as losers in Game 7 of the 2019 World Series. The sign stealing scandal was the biggest of which, they lost both their manager and "head of the Astroball Snake" Jeff Luhnow. However, their 12 months of chaos began with their ace Gerrit Cole departing in Free Agency to join the New York Yankees, their archrival "Little Brother (The Astros are 3-0 vs. the Yankees in the Postseason). After hiring James Crick, an outsider from Tampa Bay, to replace Luhnow, COVID-19 cancelled, among other things, the entire 2020 Minor League Seasons. Minor league baseball as we know it is being reshaped as staff was furloughed, entire teams futures were up in the air, and prospects weighed their futures with an ability to make money and stay in shape, despite having no light to find at the end of the tunnel. All of these reasons, combined with the end of Justin Verlander's Astros Career, impacted the Astros future, but none quite as strongly as their sign stealing punishment.

I am a person with no moral complications with the Houston Astros sign stealing scandal. From my 14th floor vantage point, I recognize it is impossible for Baseball to legislate sign stealing, and if MLB is only punishing because of public relations then it's clear that people aren't actually that outraged by the scandal at hand (just look at DeflateGate, SpyGate, the Tim Donaghy Scandal and Bountygate, to name a few).

So for myself, the biggest takeaway from January's MLB sanctions, in which 3 MLB Managers and the head of the Astroball Snake, Jeff Luhnow, were fired, was that which was mentioned latter: The end of Astroball as we know it. Over a decade at the helm in Houston, Jeff Luhnow built Baseball's version of the Patriots Way and the Spurs Way: An ice cold mercenary style of talent evaluation that sacrifices feelings and fun for success and sustainability. From the lowest levels of the minor leagues to the 2017 World Champions, the Astros were a well oiled machine that kept producing MLB talent in bunches. They used analytics and modern strategy as well as any organization in Baseball, and turned around the careers of such players as JD Martinez, Jose Altuve, Michael Brantley, Ryan Pressley, Josh Reddick, Zack Grienke, Justin Verlander, and Gerrit Cole. It has also launched the careers of home grown talent such as Alex Bregman, George Springer, Carlos Correa, Yuli Gurriel and Yordan Alvarez, among others.

This week was a revelation in the Baseball World. The Houston Astros, who stumbled to an injury-plagued 29-31 record and the #6 seed by virtue of a crap AL West. They entered the playoffs as the 4th biggest underdogs to win the World Series.

And they haven't lost a single game since. The Astros crushed the AL Central Champion Twins in a 2-0 sweep, then swept the Oakland Athletics to advance to a 4th straight ALCS. They anticipate a matchup with the Yankees, their little brother arch rivals, or the Tampa Bay Rays, a team they beat in 5 games last season.

The question I wanted to know was "Is Astroball dead as we know it?". 2020 has not quite answered that question, only time and sustainability will answer that. We have certainly, however, been given more information and context to make guesses from.

Astroball is not dead, but it also isn't thriving, either. There are holes that, with time, need to be proven that they can be filled. Jose Urqidy and Frankie Valdez go a long way to answering some of those questions, but the Astros will have to find ways to replace FA's like George Springer (2020) Michael Brantley (2021) Carlos Correa (2021) and Alex Bregman (2022). 

The face that we can confirm Astroball has a chance to survive is a positive sign for anyone who like great Baseball and Innovation, as I do both. I couldn't be more excited to see it well and alive.

Tuesday, October 6, 2020

Everyone's Going To Ignore Lamar Jackson for the Next 5-6 Weeks

 Through 4 games, Lamar Jackson has completed 68% of his pass attempts for 769 yards, 7 Touchdowns and 1 INT. For the season, he has a 113.1 QBR, and he's added 236 of his trademarked rushing yards. By all statistics, Lamar Jackson is a very good Quarterback, a surefire Pro Bowler who has improved his accuracy from 2019.

I suspect everyone will write off Lamar Jackson for next month or so, however. As great as his numbers look, even if they aren't MVP level, we all watched that Chiefs-Ravens game last Monday. The game was certainly the matchup of the year in the NFL. I hyped this game to an unhealthy level, then saw Patrick Mahomes go nuts in a route of the Baltimore Ravens.

The Ravens don't play a primetime football game again until Week 10, when the play New England on Sunday Night Football. Before then, Baltimore has losable matchups against the Steelers and Colts, combined with a bye week. Lamar Jackson is going to be largely ignored in the month of October, even slandered depending on how those games go vs. Pittsburgh and Indianapolis.

As unfair as it seems, national NFL fans expect Lamar Jackson to win every game that he plays in. It's the standard that he set last season, when he LITERALLY won every single game that he played en route to the league's 1st Unanimous MVP (it took a 4 game tune up for their offense to start humming). This is combined with Lamar's 7-1 record in 2018 replacing Joe Flacco. Over 2 years and 3 season's, we've come to expect Lamar Jackson to win every time he steps on the field. The only times we've seen Lamar Jackson lose have come in what we've deemed "Big Games", which are essentially defined as games Lamar Jackson has lost. 2 Playoff Games and 2 Matchups against the Chiefs have been the only stains on Lamar Jackson's resume, and the sports fan can easily train their mind to weed out the good, the same way they do to Clayton Kershaw, James Harden, and every American President one doesn't agree with (regardless of which side of the coin you fall).

Obviously, these expectations can't be attained. It's simply impossible for a player to win every game he plays, and Lamar Jackson's reputation must now work to those impossible standards. Part of this is the plague affecting all Black Industry Stars: In America, you often must work twice as hard to get half as much. I encourage you to listen to the ways White people talk about Lamar Jackson in the last 2 weeks and before his NFL Draft if you'd like more evidence on what I'm talking about. (Specfically in regards to "Traditional QB" and "Running Back Jokes").

So, everyone is going to write off Lamar Jackson for the next few weeks. Then he'll dazzle us again in November and December, and people will be reminded just how good Jackson is at QB. He probably won't win MVP in 2020, narrative won't allow that to happen with the Chiefs loss and slightly declining numbers from his perfect 12-0 finish to 2019. While this is going on, it will be important to see just how much Lamar Jackson improves his accuracy from 2019, and a larger sample size will help us gauge those numbers.

So while everyone gushes over Patrick Mahomes, Russell Wilson and Josh Allen (as they rightfully should), the next month of the NFL season will be remarkably Lamar-less, and then people will remember him again once we get the epic performance in a primetime slot. It's how those 2nd Tier QB's like Wentz, Matt Ryan, Dak Prescott and Cam Newton make their reputations. It's about time we welcomed Lamar Jackson to that world, at least for now.

Monday, October 5, 2020

The Eagles have failed Carson Wentz

 I'm just gonna be frank with this one: The way the Philadelphia Eagles have treated QB Carson Wentz is a downright abomination. The Eagles have not been a competitive football team, trotting in at 1-2-1 after the 49ers gave them a game back with Duck Hodges--- I mean Nick Mullens. The Eagles WR core is the greatest NFL atrocity since Andrew Luck had to spend 3 seasons in 2015-17 behind the Colts O-Line. Wentz is in a strange purgatory among the NFL's generational talents, the same way Derrick Rose was in the NBA after 2013, and how Andrew Luck was preceding his retirement.

The reason the Eagles are 1-2-1, instead of 3-1, is the play of Wentz. He has the worst QBR among all NFL QB's, including Daniel Jones. He has thrown 4 TD's and 6 INT's on the season. The Eagles are paying him $110 million guaranteed. Wentz will get better as the season progresses, this is guaranteed. At the same time, as Wentz starts playing better the Eagles will start to lose more games.

How is this possible, you may ask? This is the result of a strange trend known as the "Post Super Bowl Blues", where franchises have to make tough decisions about which pieces of a championship core get extended. Most GM's in the NFL are prone to risk aversion, and they pay as many of their safe players as are willing to resign. For the Eagles, this included Malcom Jenkins, Alshon Jeffery, Jason Kelce, Brandon Brooks, Jason Peters, Lane Johnson, and Tim Jernigan. 

When a team extends a great player, they extend the position they play on their roster. Once these players get paid, they no longer provide value to the team, only their expectations. Example #1: If Lane Johnson is the #2 Highest Paid LT in the NFL, he can only equal the value he's being paid by being one of the 2 best LT in the league. When Lane Johnson tears his ACL, or Brandon Brooks tears his Achilles, they still get paid. Now, the LT position is costing the Eagles $20 million in 2020 while being filled by Jordan Mailata, who ranks as PFF #40 Tackle in 2020. Conclusion: The Eagles are paying Top 2 Money for the #40 Tackle in the NFL.

This problem extends well beyond the Eagles, and I'll list some of those teams in a bit. This problem has hit the Eagles especially hard in the last 3 seasons. Example 2: The Eagles paying #3 RG money in the NFL for Matt Pryor, the #27 G in the league. Example 3: Paying Top 10 WR money for Alshon Jeffery, which has now become Greg Ward and 3 Practice Squad Players.

At the same time, the Eagles gave their QB a record setting 2nd contract. This is the ultimate sign of A. Your belief in building a champion around this QB or B. Your risk adverse tendencies and extending someone who can't play up to what their being paid. In the case of Wentz, he falls under an unprecedented C category, because his situation hasn't been all black and white.

The Best Example in the last Decade of an A team is the Indianapolis Colts. Ryan Grinson was hired in 2012 as the Colts GM, and inherited the #1 Pick that led to Andrew Luck. The Colts were flushed with Cap Space to sign Free Agents, had tons of openings for Rookies to develop and grow. When all 3 of those things are combined with the NFL's unique ability to legislate parity, it's a guarantee that your team will be good within 3 years, even if Mitchell Trubisky or Jared Goff are your QB. 

When you have an elite QB under a rookie contract, it's almost impossible for a GM to mess up. Even when you trade a 1st Round Pick for Trent Richardson. The Colts made an AFC Championship Game in 2014, then all fell apart very quickly. The Colts had little available cap space, and an Offensive Line that was either old or injured or both. For 2 seasons, Grinson simply refused to address the Offensive Line, in part bc he had no money (Luck got a $25 mil a year contract extension, a record at that time for both dollars and % of cap) and because he did a poor job at drafting (Drafting Philip Dorsett and Djoun Smith in 2015, combined with the aforementioned Richardson Trade).

As a result, Andrew Luck was sacked more times in 2 seasons than any QB in the NFL. The Colts limped to 7-9 in 2016, Grinson was fired, and Andrew Luck had botched surgery that ended his 2017 season before it even started. Chris Ballard was hired and, after all of the bad contracts expired, purged the salary cap and had one of the best drafts in NFL History (Quenton Nelson and Darius Leonard w/ your 1st and 2nd Picks). All in all, Luck retired bc the Colts ruined his shoulder and love for the game all at once.

There are infinite examples of B teams and their QB's. In fact, most of the QB contracts handed out in the post Jay Cutler/Joe Flacco contracts are teams paying whatever it took for the safe option. Philip Rivers, Ben Roethlisberger, Matthew Stafford, Derek Carr, Jimmy Garoppolo, Kirk Cousins, Cam Newton, Matt Ryan, and Jared Goff were all the #1 Paid QB's in the NFL. Every single one of their contracts made their GM's lives infinitely harder. The reason those contracts kept being handed out was because, as strange as it seems, those contracts helped all those GM's buy more time at the job. All of the aforementioned QB's were paid because your favorite team's GM's goal was to keep their job, not to win a Super Bowl.

The only QB's who's big contracts that pay out are the 4-5 who's game transcends roster: The truly elite talents of the sport. We're talking about Andrew Luck, Patrick Mahomes, Russell Wilson, Deshaun Watson and Aaron Rodgers. It is only for those HOF talents where we can start talking about paying them at market value.

Which brings us back to Wentz. Less you had forgotten, Carson Wentz in 2017 was "The White Patrick Mahomes". He was Patrick Mahomes before Patrick Mahomes. Wentz had over 3,200 passing yards, 300 rushing yards, 33 TD's and only 7 INT's. He also did that in 12 GAMES!!!! He was the lock for MVP, the Eagles were the #1 seed and would've won the Super Bowl with him instead of Nick Foles. He was a Torn ACL from being MVP, Super Bowl Champ, and Super Bowl MVP at 23 years old. Mahomes didn't accomplish all that until he was 24.

His 2018 Eagles team wasn't nearly as healthy as 2017, and Wentz hurt his back after 13 games. At that point, the Eagles lasting memories were of Wentz and his Mahomes level gifts on display in 2017. Wentz was truly an elite QB, and if healthy he could recapture that again. Just the hope of Wentz recapturing that Mahomes-before-Mahomes ability should've been enough to sign him to a record contract. Howie Roseman and the Eagles were one of the lucky ones. They drafted one of the 2-3 QB's of his generation. They were right to extend Carson Wentz. In the aftermath of that Super Bowl/Extension, the Eagles signed all the aforementioned players, leaving them with the highest paid team in the NFL, along with one of the oldest in the league. A deadly combination. They desperately needed to influx young talent to keep that ship afloat.

Everyone was crushing the Eagles for drafting Jalen Hurts in the 2nd Round of the 2020 Draft. They had so many holes across their roster, why were they drafting a QB when QB felt like the most stable position they had?? The truth is, the Eagles have TRIED to draft at every other position in the last 3 years, desperate to influx their young talent. They drafted an edge rusher in Round 1 of 2018, Derek Barnett. Solid, but not a standout player. They drafted a TE to help Wentz in Dallas Goedert. He's now on IR. To protect Wentz, they took a LT Andre Dillard in 2019. They drafted a Running Back in Miles Sanders. They drafted a Linebacker. They drafted a standout corner. They traded picks for the Lions Star Corner. They drafted Sidney Jones. They drafted Jalen Mills. They spent 2020's 1st Rounder on Jalen Reagor as a WR. Most of those picks have either been underwhelming, injured, or flamed out spectacularly. 

The Eagles have failed to fill their gaps with young talent, but it hasn't been for a lack of trying. By the time the Hurts pick rolled around, they deemed their biggest hole was a Backup QB for the Oft-injured Wentz. Now, it's becoming apparent that Wentz will struggle to regain that once-promising form, starting the season with the 4 TD-7 INT ratio and a team that has 2 healthy O-Lineman, 3 Practice Squad WR's, nothing sexy on Defense, and Boston Scott.

Watching Sunday Night Football, I marveled at just how bad a team Carson Wentz and Miles Sanders had around them. They won bc the 49ers entire D-Line is hurt (what a season, huh) and Mullens-Beathard are the new Mason Rudolph-Duck Hodges. Through all this, the Eagles could be 3-1 and coasting in a Weak NFC East. The reason they aren't is because of Wentz's poor performance.

I haven't been able to separate whether this is the new Carson Wentz or the Eagles are just so broken around him. I tend to think that if this is the new Wentz, the Eagles will limp their way to a Matthew Stafford-esque 5-10-1 season. I'll leave that up to the rest of you to make the call for yourself on the Wentz vs. Eagles blame game.

Regardless, the Eagles have no doubt failed Carson Wentz miserably over the last 4 seasons. This season is going to be a long one for a guy I so desperately want to see regain his MVP form. Much like Andrew Luck's early retirement, we would all be losing a Carson-Wentz sized hole in our football hearts by missing out on one of the 3 generational Quarterbacks from the last 7 years. Like Derrick Rose in the NBA, I will ask 5 years from now what Carson Wentz would've been if indeed we never get that MVP player again.

All questions would be resolved if we had a stable, healthy Eagles team. Unfortunately, it appears we are years away from that happening again.