Saturday, January 30, 2021

Superstars Flexing Their Power: Nolan Arenado, LeBron James, James Harden and Deshaun Watson

We are living through an era of athlete empowerment. In a Post-LeBron "Decision" world, in combination with the rise of social networking, it has never been easier to take control of your own brand and your own fate. This has especially become true in the NBA, where the best players make more money than any other sports league, and more money = more power.

From LeBron James (3 times) to Kevin Durant in 2016, to Chris Paul, Kyrie Irving, Kawhi Leonard, Jimmy Butler, Kyrie Irving again, the NBA superstar has used their free agency to their own power, and decided to push their way to the city they want to play in.

Now, Anthony Davis and James Harden have taken that power to a new level. Davis and Harden forced trades out of their previous homes, with multiple years on a contract, and were able to achieve everything they wanted and more. For Davis, that meant getting a trade, an NBA Championship, and a new $180 million contract playing for the Los Angeles Lakers. For Harden, that was a trade to Brooklyn while continuing to be the face of Adidas (other than Messi) and make $45 million a season under the supermax he signed with Houston.

Because of the NFL's popularity, it was only a matter of time before this trend trickled on down to the NFL. That first major star to take control of his fate, just like James Harden and Anthony Davis, is Deshaun Watson. Watson got his $200 million extension from the Texans, with a full no trade clause. And he is going to be traded from the Texans before the contract ever goes into effect. He's going to be able to have his cake and eat it. No matter what, Deshaun Watson will make the max amount of money and play for exactly the team he wants to.

Yet, because of it's declining popularity, we missed the fact that Major League Baseball players make more money than the NFL Players (thanks to Collective Bargaining Agreements) but less than NBA players. And right underneath the noise of Deshaun Watson, Nolan Arenado just did the exact same power move to the Colorado Rockies.

Arenado flexed his power with the Rockies, got traded to the team he wanted in St. Louis, and even got a restructured contract for an extra year. And this isn't even the 1st time this has happened in recent MLB history, either.

The first real case of an MLB player flexing their leverage came in 2017, before Anthony Davis and James Harden getting everything they wanted, when Giancarlo Stanton was coming off of his 60 Home Run MVP season for an 81 win Marlins team. The Marlins had been sold to the Bruce Sherman-Derek Jeter group, and the new ownership was intent on moving Stanton's 10 year, $280 million contract while his value was the highest.

2017 was Giancarlo's first fully healthy season since 2014, when he earned his 13 year, $325 million contract in the first place. The Marlins wanted to move all of Stanton's money as he entered his age 29 season, so that the franchise could cut costs and start a rebuild with new President Derek Jeter. The Marlins negotiated a deal with the St. Louis Cardinals, where St. Louis would take every penny of Stanton's contract and give back some prospects in return.

And then Stanton decided he didn't want to live in St. Louis, which has an awful history of racism.

And the deal died right there. Stanton used his power of a no-trade clause to void a trade that took months to create.

Next up, the San Francisco Giants set up a deal to take on Stanton's contract. Stanton was a California kid, so the idea of returning to the West Coast was believed to be intriguing.

Stanton rejected the deal, because the Giants had the 2nd worst record in the MLB in 2017. He wanted to be traded to a winner.

So the Marlins went back to work, this time asking Stanton where he wanted to play. His list: The Astros, Yankees, Dodgers, and Cubs. The 4 Teams who made it to the ALCS and NLCS the previous season.

So Stanton would only accept a trade to one of the 4 best teams in Baseball, knowing that there was a 0% chance he was playing another game with the Miami Marlins. Ultimately, he got a deal done with the New York Yankees, who took every penny of his $280 million, paid out until Stanton turned 38.

Then, 3 years later, the Nolan Arenado situation came along. While there had been other trades in the between (Mookie Betts, Yu Darvish, Francisco Lindor), none of them contained a No Trade clause AND a 10 year contract already signed, sealed and delivered.

Back in March 2019, after the crazy offseason where Manny Machado got $300 million from San Diego and Bryce Harper got 13 years, $330 million from Philadelphia, Nolan Arenado got a 9 year extension for $324 million from the Colorado Rockies. It was clear that the Rockies were not going to be contenders in 2020, as they purged their roster that lost in the NLDS to Milwaukee to make room for Arenado's contract. But Arenado knew he was risking a LOT of money playing out the final year of his contract in Colorado.

Predictably, the Rockies finished 4th place in the NL West at 71-91. Then, the Pandemic hit, and the Rockies finished 4th in the NL West again, 4 games out of the final playoff spot and 12th place out of 15 in the NL.

The Rockies knew they needed to rebuild after Arenado's extension. The Rockies couldn't kid themselves into believing they could build a winner around Arenado with 1 year contracts and a bottom 10 farm system in Baseball. Arenado knew he wanted a trade out of Colorado, since they weren't going to be contending for 4-5 years, if ever again, under his contract.

Plus, after seeing how well the Marlins rebounded after moving Stanton's contract (and Stanton predictably playing 41 total games over the last 2 seasons), it was clear the Rockies and Arenado needed to go their separate ways. In all honesty, they needed to do that back in 2019, but Arenado was willing to sacrifice a year or 2 in order to get that record-setting money.

The truth is, Nolan Arenado knew that no franchise valued him as much as the Colorado Rockies did. It's where he was going to get the most money on his one big chance at Free Agency. When Colorado offered him the most money per year of any player in MLB history, along with a full no-trade clause, he would've been idiotic to not sign on the dotted line.

In the changing landscape of sports, players with real leverage and power can have their cake and eat it. LeBron James did it. So did Kevin Durant. And Anthony Davis and James Harden. And Giancarlo Stanton. They got the ridiculous record setting contracts, AND got to navigate trades/salary caps to go to EXACTLY the team they wanted!!!! 

So, after 2 years of a failed marriage going south, combined with a poor 60 game season from Arenado, Colorado realized they had to trade Arenado this year. The Rockies either A. Went to Nolan and asked him who he'd like to play for, at which point Nolan said the Cardinals. or B (and Most Likely): Negotiated a deal with the Cardinals, before going to Nolan, for $278 million, instead of the $324 million the Rockies valued Nolan Arenado at.

After negotiating the terms of the money (and getting 4 of Blake Snell signature "slapdick prospects") the Rockies went to Nolan Arenado and asked him if he would wave his no trade clause to join the St. Louis Cardinals. To which Nolan likely said that, in order to wave the no trade clause, the Cardinals would need to add an extra 1 year and $33 million to set up a full 10 year, $360 million contract (Arenado played the 1st year of that contract in 2020). The Cardinals agreed, and a deal got done.

And THAT is the power that the modern athlete possesses. Deshaun Watson is going to flex the same power on the Houston Texans, and he's going to join exactly the team he wants to. James Harden made the same flex two weeks ago. And, right under all of our noses, Nolan Arenado just flexed that same Harden-Watson-LeBron power on the Colorado Rockies. 

Not only did Nolan get traded to a contender, with an all-MLB teammate in Paul Goldschmidt, but he got an EXTRA YEAR extended on his record setting contract, coming off one of the worst seasons of his career at a time when players start to decline.

And he deserved every penny of it. Because Nolan Arenado has power. And Nolan Arenado has leverage. And he used all the power he had to get everything he wanted and more. Just like James Harden. Just like Anthony Davis. Just like LeBron James. Just like Giancarlo Stanton. And, in the coming 6 months, just like Deshaun Watson.

When you have a gift like these players, you should use every ounce of your leverage to your advantage. And we're seeing that power finally being flexed, birthed by a LeBron James Decision from 2010.

Wednesday, January 27, 2021

What's Next for Aaron Rodgers and the Packers????

 The Green Bay Packers lost in the NFC Championship Game for the 2nd consecutive year. This year's game was definitely closer than in 2019, when Raheem Mostert went for 230 rushing yards in a 49ers route. However, the realities of the NFL are starting to set in for the Packers: Their winning window is closing.

Most NFL teams don't get back to Championship weekend after two consecutive losses. This is especially true in an NFC where new champions get churned out every year. The Packers are going to have Aaron Rodgers for the next 2 years, but they also have an aging roster that only had 1 player from the 2020 Draft Class take a postseason snap (AJ Dillon). The Packers need to take care of a few things this offseason, and they don't have the cap space to do it.

The Running Game

Aaron Jones and Jamaal Williams are Free Agents. This is why the Packers drafted AJ Dillon with their 2nd Round Pick in 2020, and why I'm so high on Dillon and LaFluer even after both of their playoff duds. The Packers can add a disposable running back in Free Agency, dishing out $2 million for a Daryll Williams or, maybe, Jamaal Williams.

Jones, however, has played his last game as a Packer. And this is what the Packers prepared for. It's a tough situation, but that's where they are. It's time to plug in AJ Dillon and replicate Aaron Jones' production, like he did against the Titans in Week 16.

While we're on the topic of Running Backs, let's talk about the Packers O-Line situation. Pro Bowl Center Corey Lindsley is a Free Agent. The Packers are (by cutting Preston Smith and Christian Kirksey) are $25 million over the salary cap. This doesn't mean they can't pay Corey Lindsley, but the Packers have to make this decision right now: Do they want to go all in on these next 2 Aaron Rodgers years, then go through a rebuild, or shoot for sustainability and think you can retool on the fly???

I don't have tons of faith in the Packers to rebuild on the fly, even if Jordan Love becomes the next great thing since sliced bread. The Packers have set themselves in this position, and their best option is to keep spending and suffer the consequences 2 or 3 years from now, when you collapse under your own salary cap space.

Rushing Defense

The Packers are going to cut Preston Smith this offseason to save $8 million. They are also going to cut Christian Kirksey, after they signed him as a temporary replacement for Blake Martinez. This subtracts from an already depleted front 7 that really struggled for much of the 2020 season.

Good news: 2019 1st Round Pick Rashan Gary was starting for Smith at the end of the season. If the Packers are going to get over the hump, a breakout season will be in store for Gary. In terms of a ILB replacement, we mocked a ILB to Green Bay in our 1st Take It Easy Mock Draft. That fills a hole vacated by a really good MLB in Blake Martinez, and the Packers felt his absence this year.

Aaron Rodgers

Ultimately, the Packers go as far as Aaron Rodgers goes. Him and LaFluer had the #2 Offense in the NFL in 2020, and there's good reason to believe they can replicate their success again. The Packers are going to feel the sting of the Buccaneers loss for a while, because anyone who knows football recognizes that Packers team was more talented than the Buccaneers. The post game comments by everyone, from LaFluer to Rodgers to the chairman say that everyone was looking at everyone else to find some of the blame.

In actuality, everyone messed up for the Packers in some way in the Bucs game. The Offensive Line was injured and crushed by Shaq Barrett. Aaron Jones fumbled and never returned for the Packers in the 3rd Quarter. The secondary dropped an INT before halftime, then let Scottie Miller beat them deep with 1 second left. The Front 7 couldn't pressure Tom Brady to save their life. Aaron Rodgers didn't scramble for a TD on 3rd and Goal, electing to throw into triple coverage. And Matt LaFluer decided to kick an idiotic FG down 8 and 2:11 left in the game, then kicked off to the Buccaneers instead of going onside.

The Packers lost what might go down as their best opportunity to get to the Super Bowl. Like I mentioned before, there's no reason to believe Aaron Rodgers can't do what he did in 2020 again next year. If so, the Packers are automatically one of the 5 or 6 best teams in the NFL. All that buys the Packers is another NFC North title, a 1st Round Bye/easy Wild Card matchup, and a 3 game gauntlet on their way to the Super Bowl.

So yeah, this MIGHT have been the Packers best chance to make the Super Bowl. I emphasize that might for a reason, because they still have Aaron Rodgers on that roster. The new Front Office and Coach had a great 1st Offseason, then had an atrocious 2nd Offseason. The improvements we saw were not because of any big additions, but the improvements in the offense from Year 1 to Year 2. 

Let's see what adjustments get made in Year 3, considering there's only 2 more years to go.

Monday, January 25, 2021

Should you Trade Two 1st's for Matthew Stafford??? The Case for 3 Teams

 Matthew Stafford and the Lions are headed for an amicable divorce, which I told y'all was going to happen 8 months ago. Anyways, the Lions are looking for trade partners before March 11th, when Stafford's final 2 years and $64 million becomes guaranteed for the Lions. The market dictates that Matthew Stafford is worth 2 Mid-Late 1st Round Picks, plus additional compensation. It's a great time for the Lions to make the move, considering Stafford is coming off of back-to-back injury plagued seasons and enters his late prime at 33 years old.

So, if 2 1st Round Picks is what it will take to land Stafford for 2 years at $32 million a season, for which teams would such a move be worth it??? Let's evaluate

Here's the NFL Teams who would consider making a QB change this offseason: Patriots, Dolphins, Jets, Colts, Steelers, Broncos, Washington, Saints, Panthers, Falcons, Bears, 49ers, Rams (I'd personally include the Raiders and Giants, but it seems clear they won't be making QB changes).

1. Salary Cap Space

The key with any Stafford trade: Which NFL teams have created enough cap space to take on a $32 million Quarterback?? Stafford is not an ideal option for a team struggling with cap issues, since they won't be able to make other improvements around Stafford. This takes out the Falcons, Rams, Saints, Steelers and Chicago Bears (not that Detroit would've traded Stafford to Chicago anyways).\

Teams Left: NE, MIA, NYJ, IND DEN, WAS, CAR, SF

2. Willingness to Part with Draft Picks (AKA Winning Window is Open Right Now)

The price tag for Stafford is high for a player with an extensive injury history that can walk in just 2 seasons. The Seahawks gave up 2 1st for 2 years of Jamal Adams, and I have a feeling that contract is not going to age well. The Rams did the same for Jalen Ramsey, and they were able to resign him. The Rams have been able to remain semi-competitive with the #1 rated Defense in 2020. I'd say that deal was a win for the Rams.

In the case of Stafford, no team should part with a Top 10 pick to acquire Stafford. He's a win-now option, and losing that draft capital would lead to a Lions-esque situation all over again. So take out the Panthers, Broncos and Jets.

Teams Left: NE, MIA, IND, WAS, SF

3. Would Stafford be a Worthy Upgrade at QB??

Football fans (myself included) like dreaming up all the different teams a player can join and how great a fit they would be. What doesn't get asked enough... is it worth it for (insert X team) to make the trade?? For some of these teams, you'd be going all in on Matthew Stafford. If you can't meet your goals with Stafford, probably in 2021, you have no real room to pivot. 

By trading for Matthew Stafford, your fate would be essentially carved in stone for 2021 AND 2022. With that in mind, answer each of these questions for yourself:

Would you trade 2 1st Round Picks to upgrade from Jimmy G to Matthew Stafford??? My answer is no. Your answer may be different. If that's the case, I'll knock out the 49ers.

Would you trade Tua Tagovailoa and the #17 pick in the Draft for Matthew Stafford???? My answer is, surprisingly, yes. Your answer may be different, so maybe take the Dolphins off the board..

The Case for the Indianapolis Colts

If I'm the Colts, I'm asking for the Lions price and taking the deal immediately (within reason, no Anthony Davis 3 1sts and 3 2nds for Stafford).

Andrew Luck was 1st in QBR in the last 12 games of 2018. He's Andrew Luck, he was an elite QB. With the same O-Line and weapons, Philip Rivers finished 17th in QBR in 2020. Philip Rivers was a fringe starter who looked washed behind a bad Chargers O-Line one year earlier.

Stafford is not Andrew Luck, but he's a significant upgrade over Philip Rivers. With, if my rough math is correct, makes Matthew Stafford a Top 7 Quarterback in the NFL on the Colts. Yes, the Colts won't be able to Draft a Left Tackle to replace Anthony Costanzo, but guess what: Even by adding Stafford's $32 million contract, the Colts still have 4th Most Cap Space available in Free Agency.

The Colts have no QB on their roster, and they are firmly within their Super Bowl winning window. You get Matthew Stafford and you overpay for Matthew Stafford. Either that or trade 3 1st Rounders to go up and get Zach Wilson at Pick #3. I very much prefer a surefire Top 10 QB for 1 less 1st Round Pick.

The Case for the Washington Racial Slurs

Like the Colts, the Washington Racial Slurs do not have a QB on their active roster. There's not much of a route to a top draft pick, and unless you want to hope Trey Lance falls to Pick 20, I'd suggest thinking big swing with your Draft Picks.

For all the crap going on in the Racial Slurs organization (hence why I continue calling them the Racial Slurs), they've already nailed 2 of the 3 steps to any great rebuild: 1. Acquire Cheap, Young Talent, so that they all enter their primes at the same time. and 2. Reset your salary cap, so that you have money to spend once your window opens.

The 3rd step of any rebuild is find a solution for your QB Position. Sometimes that happens through the Draft (Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen), Free Agency (Tom Brady) or both (Carson Wentz and Nick Foles). For the first time in recent memory, the NFL trade market is finally opening up for Quarterbacks, and the Racial Slurs can capitalize on this opportunity, given that Deshaun Watson DEFINITELY doesn't want to play for your team.

In the case of Stafford, he has a legitimate #1 WR in Terry McLaurin, a Top 10 ranking offensive line in 2020, and a defense who's Front 7 ranked #2 in the NFL. Stafford has never had a Top 10 ranked O-Line and 1 Top 10 defense in his entire career. He can get both in Washington. Washington would have to part with some draft picks, but great drafting over the last few years means they have the young talent to survive those losses.

The Case for the New England Patriots

Let me preface Stafford talks with this: If the 49ers find a QB to take over Jimmy G, it'll be an easy decision for New England to sign Garoppolo and keep their Draft Picks. If he stays in SF, I would use my 1st Round Pick to draft a QB if I were the Patriots.

With that said, here's the case for the Patriots. The infrastructure is there to build a winner. The Patriots won 7 games with a team that had a 3 week COVID outbreak, had no cap space, and will get back Donta Hightower, Patrick Chung, and Marcus Cannon from COVID opt outs. The Patriots are probably in a winning window right now.

They have reset their cap space to, if they so choose, having nearly $71 million available to sign players with. And, because they have #15 Pick in the Draft, New England will get to keep some of their 2nd and 3rd Round picks. They can also flip Stephon Gilmore to get back their 1st Round Pick, who has become kind of expendable with the breakout of JC Jackson as a Top 5 PFF Corner in 2020.

New England can lock down the QB position, then use some of their extra $40 million in cap space (assuming Julian Edelman retires) to sign a WR like Kenny Golladay, Allen Robinson or Corey Davis. The Patriots also have a Top 10 Offensive Line, which Stafford has never had, and a defense that just 12 months ago was ranked #3 in the NFL. 

With a top WR, Jakobi Myers, and one of these 1 year old guys like AJ Green or T.Y Hilton, Stafford can be the Top 10 QB we all know he could always be, regaining that Pro Bowl form we all know he has.

Saturday, January 23, 2021

The Case for Trading Nick Chubb, Plus 4 Playoff Teams Selling And Remaining Competitive

 The Pivot is one of the hardest tasks ever great NFL team is faced with. It's nearly impossible to sign every player from your elite core to a contract extension, and it often goes poorly for the teams who try (I'm looking at you, Cowboys and Falcons fans).

So, here's 4 trades playoff teams can make as sellers, while still remaining competitive in the near future. Some of these names might be more shocking than others... including a legitimate NFL Superstar.

Ravens Trade Matthew Judon to the Bills for Ed Oliver and a 2nd Round Pick

    So, the Ravens are the sellers in this trade, but they are negotiating with another AFC powerhouse. In fact, it's the same team that just eliminated the Ravens last weekend.

The Ravens franchise tagged Matthew Judon last offseason, and despite a few injuries, he was extremely productive in 2020. Judon made it known (in a report his camp likely leaked) that Judon is looking for a contract around $20 million a season. The Ravens made it pretty clear they don't intend to give Judon that contract.

Instead, the Ravens can tag-and-trade Judon to the Buffalo Bills, who are very much looking for Linebacker help this offseason. The reason the Bills deal seems more enticing than even a 1st Round Pick is those two potential starters on defense. Oliver, who seems headed towards a breakup with the Bills, can be placed next to Calais Campbell and the Ravens can run some 4-3 defense next season. That 2nd Round Pick could be another defensive player who, sooner than later, can become a starter on the Ravens.

For a player headed for a departure anyways, the tag-and-trade strategy makes too much sense for the Ravens. For Buffalo, they have the cap space to invest big money to lock down the OLB position and improve the defense that will (probably) be what keeps them from making the Super Bowl.

Steelers Trade Bud Dupree to the Buccaneers for the 29th Pick in the NFL Draft

The impending Free Agency of Shaq Barrett means the Tampa Bay Buccaneers are in the market for an Edge Rusher. Enter Bud Dupree, the Steelers Linebacker who was having an amazing season before tearing his ACL. 

Dupree is also a free agent, and like Matt Judon the Steelers would be really smart to tag-and-trade Dupree, allowing him to pick the team he'd like to play for, and allowing that team to negotiate a deal for him. This deal closely resembles the Dee Ford trade from a couple years ago, where the Chiefs sent Ford to the 49ers for the 33rd Pick in the NFL Draft.

As for Dupree's contract, I assume Bud Dupree will get a smaller contract than the record setting deal Shaq Barrett is set to get from some team (probably the Giants). Dupree is a plug and play guy for a team that we all assume will be a Super Bowl favorite in 2021. When healthy, Dupree could replicate the production of Shaq Barrett almost identically. It would be a worthwhile investment for the Bucs' 1st Round Pick, given Tampa Bay shows very little pressing needs right now (They could also tag and trade Barrett and get their 1st Round Pick back)

As for the Steelers, it's time to pivot into the next era of Steelers football. There are still tons of pieces on your defensive core, the best of which being TJ Watt, Minkah Fitzpatrick, and Devin Bush. Pittsburgh needs help rebuilding their offense, and 2 1st Round Picks will go a long way to replenishing some of their young talent.

Buccaneers trade Chris Godwin to the Colts for Michael Pittman, a 4th Round Pick and a 5th Round Pick

Most NFL people suspect the Buccaneers will franchise tag Chris Godwin this offseason. Either Godwin will play next season on the Franchise Tag or the Bucs and Godwin will reach a contract north of $15 million a season. If Tampa did extend Godwin, he would be the 2nd WR making over $15 million on their team.

Let's say, just by chance, Godwin makes it clear he does not intend to play 2021 under the Franchise Tag. What could the Bucs get for him in a tag-and-trade??? Maybe a team would give up a 1st Round Pick (Baltimore??? Tennessee?? Miami???) but I don't think such a deal is in the works. Plus, I assume Tampa Bay wants to win now, so draft picks may be less enticing than proven commodities.

Enter the Indianapolis Colts. The Colts are flush with cap space, as they tend to be every year under the frugal (I mean the good kind) Chris Ballard. T.Y Hilton is a Free Agent, and appears to be something close to washed at this point. Let's assume the Colts give Hilton a 1 year contract at WR2 money to be their WR2. At this point, that means Michael Pittman Jr. is expected to be the Colts WR1, as he was for much of the season last year.

Why not use some of your cap space to upgrade at the WR position??? Clearly a WR isn't highest on Indianapolis' list of priorities in the 2021 offseason, that would be finding a Left Tackle, QB, and extending Darius Leonard. But in this trade, the Colts wouldn't have to give up any top draft picks. Godwin, Hilton and Zach Pascal sounds like a formidable WR trio for whoever the new Colts QB ends up being.

As for the Bucs, Michael Pittman is a better compliment for Mike Evans, Antonio Brown and the TE gauntlet they have. Many times, Chris Godwin was getting lost in the WR shuffle during the season, and much of that had to do with Brady's tendencies of throwing the ball down field. Pittman represents a strong horizontal threat that may work out well for the flow of the Bucs offense. Plus, there's a chance they lose Godwin for nothing. Might as well add a 23 year old WR with 1 season and 500 yards under his belt.

Browns Trade Nick Chubb and a 3rd Round Pick to Atlanta for the #4 Pick in the Draft

Alright Cleveland, how much do you believe in the Kevin Stefanski system??? Because Nick Chubb has 1 year left on his contract, and paying the running back is the single riskiest proposition in the NFL. Regardless of how the rest of Nick Chubb's career goes, Chubb's value will never be higher than it is right now, and the Browns can make an epic pivot to keep themselves competitive for many years to come.

What is Atlanta's motivation for making this trade??? The opportunity for Nick Chubb to be Derrick Henry. To have an Arthur Smith offense that dominates on the ground and gets Matt Ryan in play action. It's not like the Falcons defense is going to be fixed overnight anyways, so just say f*** it and build an elite offense right now. Plus, it's not like the Falcons weren't a 7-9 team that happened to have 3 historically bad collapses in the 2020 season. They may not be as far off as we think, and if Atlanta is going to commit to Matt Ryan being on the team beyond the NFL Draft, they better COMMIT to Matt Ryan right now.

So let's say the Cleveland Browns get that #4 pick in the NFL Draft. What next?? First and foremost, start a bidding war for anyone who wants Zach Wilson or Justin Fields. Accumulate more and more and MORE draft picks. Not because you are starting a rebuild, but because you can replace Chubb with a rookie RB, make Kareem Hunt the RB1, AND build a defensive core around your Top 3 edge rusher (Myles Garrett) and Top 10 CB (Denzel Ward). If you keep the #4 pick, take best Defensive Player available, but if picking by position, take Linebacker.

The Browns could buck the trend of awful RB contracts, which to be fair is being bucked by Derrick Henry and, to an extent, Ezekiel Elliott. They had the best RB duo in 2020, but I feel confident they could replicate Top 2 production with Hunt, D'Ernest Johnson and another Day 2-3 running back.

Thursday, January 21, 2021

Why Sunday's Game Just Means More for the Bills Mafia

 The Buffalo Bills will play Sunday for a chance to advance to the Super Bowl. Not sure if that's a jarring sentence for y'all, given that Josh Allen, Stefon Diggs and the Bills have been expected to be here for 3-4 months now. But for the franchise that spent 17 years waiting for a single playoff game, 21 years for a home playoff game, and 27 years for a chance to get back to 1 game away from the Super Bowl, this will be a seminal moment for the Bills Mafia.

I hold true that when you have to wait for your success, the success simply means more. In my own life, I  waited 15 years to watch my first San Diego Padres playoff game (I was 5 during their last playoff game). And for the Bills Mafia, this game on Sunday simply means more. They've waited so long for this game.

The Bills Mafia sat through 2 decades of incompetence in the front office, changing coaching staffs and quarterback changes. The times they got close (or at least over equally incompetent New York and Miami), it was losses at the hands of Tom Brady and Bill Belichick that put you in your place.

The 21st century went from Wade Philips and his Field Goal on 3rd Down that set up the Music City Miracle, to Gregg Williams 8-8 season with Patriots reject Drew Bledsoe. Then the failed tenure of J.P Losman and Mike Mularkey (Here's a fun game, guess which is the coach and which is the QB...).

In 2006-2008, it was 3 straight 7-9 seasons with 3rd Round Pick Trent Edwards and some guy named Dick Jauron at coach. Teams that were pretty good, but bad enough where, twice a year, the New England Patriots could put you in your place on Monday Night Football. 

After a decade of feeling like a perpetual rebuilder, hope came your way with a 1st Round Pick named CJ Spiller and Ryan Fitzpatrick, who cast his "Fitzmagic" upon filling in for Edwards. But, with Chan Gailey's archaic offense (which the Dolphins were running to make a playoff push THIS YEAR) you learned the beautiful chaos of Fitzmagic: Sometimes the magic keeps you in a game, and sometimes the magic makes your chances of winning disappear.

All of a sudden, the Buffalo Bills had fallen way behind on the Offensive revolution of the NFL. The Bills decided it was time to, instead of playing former backups of Trent Edwards, J.P Losman and Ryan Fitzpatrick, that we actually start investing in the young QB. The Bills decided to start picking young QB's in the most dead period for drafting Rookie QB's. From 2011-2016, the best rookie QB to be drafted in Round 1 was.... Ryan Tannehill???? (It's actually Andrew Luck, but he's retired).

The Bills fell victim to this trend: They picked EJ Manuel and paired him with College coach Doug Marrone, who after leaving Buffalo made an AFC Championship Game with, of all teams, the Jaguars. Marrone won 9 games in Buffalo in 2014, the most in 15 years in Buffalo. He got fired after just 2 seasons.

Why was this??? Because the Buffalo Bills had just been sold. After the death of Ralph Wilson, the Bills were going to be sold. And there were concerns the Bills would not remain in Buffalo, depending on who bought the team. Jon Bon Jovi (yes, like the musician) was the front man for a group trying to purchase the Bills for $1.3 billion. He was bidding against... you're never gonna believe it.

So yeah, Trump trashed Bon Jovi's group in an effort to knock them out of the running. Trump convinced everyone that Bon Jovi was gonna move the Bills to Toronto (which Bon Jovi has denied to this day).

Ultimately, the Pegula family, which owns the Buffalo Sabers Hockey team, bought the Bills over Bon Jovi and Trump. One year later, Trump announced his run for President. The rest is, as they call it, history.

The Pegula's decided to do a uniquely AFC East thing: Rehire the coach who came the closest to knocking Belichick off his perch 5 years earlier. That would be Rex Ryan (even I lowkey forgot the Bills had a Rex Ryan era).

Rex Ryan also had another QB after the bust of Manuel: A 6-1 mobile QB from Virginia Tech (and a backup tutoring with Joe Flacco) named Tyrod Taylor. Taylor went 7-6 in 2014 before the firing of Marrone, and Ryan put Tyrod in the best position to succeed by hiring Greg Roman as his Offensive Coordinator. Roman had tremendous success with Colin Kaepernick in 2012-2013, and was now bringing the option offense to Tyrod Taylor.

The Bills went 8-8, then 7-8. The Bills fired Rex Ryan after it became clear this was all falling apart. That last game of the season ended with... with... Well, just watch it for yourself.

Then enters Brandon Beane and Sean McDermott. McDermott has no intention of rolling with Tyrod Taylor, so much so that he benches Tyrod in the middle of the Bills 1st playoff run in 20 years. The result of that is the legend of Nathan Peterman, who in his 1st start threw 5 INT's in the 1st Half against the Chargers. Then came back in for an injured Taylor in the snow.... and got benched for Matt Barkley, who went and won the game.

But through all that, the Bills got back to playoffs. Thank to Andy Dalton, OJ Simpson was partying with crazy Bills fans in Jacksonville for a playoff game. That game ended with Peterman again replacing an injured Taylor, who preceded to, in the 2 minute drill, recover his own fumble, throw an incompletion, and a INT on the last play of the game.

Then the Bills found life. They discarded Tyrod Taylor in a semi-racist undertone, moved up to draft Josh Allen, and Allen.... STUNK!!!! Like, really stunk in his rookie year. He had 52% completion his rookie year, then 58% his 2nd year. Both of those were worst in the NFL. Thanks to the work of Beane, the Bills made it back to the playoffs last year. They then blew a 16-0 lead in the Wild Card against the Texans. Ouch.

This prompted me to say that Josh Allen would need to improve his completion % by 10-15 points, and that had never happened in NFL history year over year. Because I knew the Bills defense was unsustainable (2nd in the league, remarkably healthy in 2019), I said the Bills would finish 6-10 and replace Josh Allen with Dak Prescott. This might be the most wrong I've been in my life (I also have a fun story with Jesse Hahn and Jacob Degrom that probably tops it.

And here are the Bills, being back without any contests. The Bills are fantastic, they are wonderful, they are really, REALLY good. Josh Allen looks something below Mahomes but above anything I've seen in the sport for the last 5-10 years. The Bills have won 11 of their last 12 games, and the only loss was on a "Hail Murray". And they find themselves playing a Kansas City Chiefs superteam that they just might beat.

And for the Bills Mafia, this game simply means more. More to the city. More to the fans. When you have to wait for success, the success just means more. The same was true for the Chiefs, more specifically Andy Reid, in last year's Super Bowl. But this year's Chiefs team had to wait 12 months to try and win again. The Bills have had to wait 3 decades to get to this place again.

So to the Bills Mafia, I salute you. Best of luck to you on Sunday. Prove me more wrong than anyone has ever been wrong.

Tuesday, January 19, 2021

The Saints' Rebuild Starts Today

Maybe I should have seen this ending of the Saints coming, given the mid-2010's New Orleans Saints always finished one round short of expectations.

In 2017 it was the "Minneapolis Miracle" swiping away their trip to the NFC Championship Game. Then it was the OT Loss in the NFC Championship Game to, in hindsight, an inferior LA Rams team. Then a 13-3 team lost in the Wild Card to an underwhelming 10-6 Vikings Team.

In the end, The New Orleans Saints won more games over the last 4 seasons than any team in the NFL. More than the Chiefs. More than the Patriots. More than the Ravens. More than anyone. The Saints have 4 straight NFC South titles and memories to remember it by. No NFC Championship Banners. No Super Bowl Rings and Banners flying through the Super Dome. Only those division titles.

Rarely has an impending rebuild seemed so obvious as with these New Orleans Saints. Drew Brees is headed into retirement, getting set to one day replace Cris Collinsworth and Tony Dungy on the NBC Broadcast. The Saints are $105 million over the salary cap, the highest number in the NFL. That will go down significantly with Drew Brees' retirement (about $24 million or so), but from there the Saints will need to make some adjustments to their roster the way the Patriots have over the last 2 seasons.

The Saints are going to part with some people who look like staples of the organization. Anyone who holds value can and should be shopped this offseason. It will be a brutal breakup, and one that will point to the "greed" of ownership. In reality, this Saints roster presently isn't good enough to win a Super Bowl anyways. This is the pivot teams need to make to avoid ending up in the 9-7, bloated salary cap purgatory of the Dallas Cowboys, Atlanta Falcons, Minnesota Vikings and Chicago Bears, among others. The Saints have so much value on their roster that starting the rebuild now so they can have a legitimate shot at making a Super Bowl again.

The 3 goals of every rebuild are as such: 1. Acquire cheap, talented players all at once via the NFL Draft, that way they can all enter their prime at the same time. 2. Reset the salary cap so that you have flexibility when the team actually wants to maximize their Super Bowl window. 3. Figure out your QB situation, either through the Draft or Free Agency.

Rare is the team who gets a chance to rebuild their roster with as many valuable players as the Saints have. One of those biggest assets is Michael Thomas. Swapping him for a 1st Round Pick is a easy way for the Saints to establish a youth base.

After Michael Thomas, let's look at which of the Stars will make up the Saints core going forward. Marshon Lattimore is a must keep, lockdown corner. Ryan Ramczyk is a franchise Left Tackle, so let's keep him around. I'd personally see if someone would give up a 1st and 2nd Round Pick for Alvin Kamara (never pay the RB is slipping with the Derrick Henry example), and I understand people who think he should be a Saints through the rebuild. For now, Cam Jordan and Demario Davis are also keepers.

Other than those players, everyone else should be shopped around for a good price. We mentioned Michael Thomas already as an easy trade piece. Trey Hendrickson is a great Franchise Tag and Trade candidate. Jared Cook is another player who could go for 1 or 2 mid-late round picks. Janoris Jenkins is another player you can get a pick for. Kwon Alexander, Andrus Peat, David Onyemata, Marcus Davenport, Malcom Brown, all represent future picks and younger assets.

The Saints having anything short of 11 Draft Picks in this upcoming draft, as well as two 1st and 2nd Round Picks, would be doing themselves a disservice. The pivot is going to be really important for trying to win a Super Bowl in the near future. Say, for instance, the Saints draft a Defensive End and Defensive Tackle in the 1st Round. Then they pick a Wide Receiver, Tight End, Linebacker and another Defensive Tackle on the 2nd Day of the Draft. The Saints are beginning the process of getting younger, adding value at positions where value is going to be maxed out.

Which brings us to the 3rd Part of any rebuild: Figuring out your QB situation. The Saints are going in with Taysom Hill and Jameis Winston next season, with what I assume will also be a Day 3 QB like Sam Ellinger on the practice squad. For a rebuilding team, think of this period like the Gardner Minshew era in Jacksonville: These are highly capable backup QB's who, in the case of Jameis Winston, can look something like what Ryan Tannehill looks like for the Tennessee Titans.

Since next year is a transition time in New Orleans, I think the best case scenario is to see what you have in Taysom and/or Jameis in the future search for a QB. In Jameis, I think everyone will be taken aback by what Winston looks like in a Sean Payton offense. All of this will buy the Saints enough time to make a decision on the future of the QB situation either in 2022 or 2023, depending on how the rebuilding process goes.

In the modern NFL, Quarterbacks have never been easier to find because of the developments at the High School and College Level. QB's hit Free Agency at a higher rate than they have in my lifetime, and you can find, for example, a Ryan Tannehill or Tom Brady for anyone to have. Both of those QB's made the Conference Championship Games in their 1st Seasons. Jimmy Garoppolo made the Super Bowl while being available for anyone with a Late 1st Round Pick. The Saints don't necessarily have to go through the Draft to get their QB. A Tannehill, Garoppolo, or Kirk Cousins-type QB will come available for cheap at some point

Sunday, January 17, 2021

The Ravens will be Back, but Looking Very Different

 The Baltimore Ravens won back-to-back AFC North titles in 2018 and 2019. In 2020, they experienced a COVID-19 outbreak that limited them to 11 wins and the 1st Wild Card spot in the AFC. Given all the Ravens problems with injuries at linebacker to a COVID outbreak to one of the worst receiving cores in the NFL, the Baltimore Ravens were one of the NFL's 5 best teams (better than Browns, Bucs and Rams) at the end of the season.

After missing the playoffs in 2017, John Harbaugh was on the hot seat and HOF GM Ozzie Newsome was going to retire. When it felt like Baltimore was about to blow everything up, they traded back into the 1st Round and draft a Future Hall of Fame Quarterback with the 32nd Pick in the Draft. Lamar Jackson has gone 30-7 in his career as an NFL QB. That's an average of 13 wins per season for 2 1/2 seasons. Since wins aren't a QB stat, the Ravens have also built one of the best Defenses in the NFL and one of the strongest offensive lines in the NFL.

The Ravens have been remarkably successful to have a lack of success in the playoffs. Most people know about this if you follow any NFL page on Instagram or Twitter. Last year's divisional round loss to the Titans was one of the most shocking upsets in recent NFL History. The Ravens were unbeatable through the 2019 season, and the Titans beat Baltimore at their own game. Lamar Jackson also went 2 hours of a Wild Card game without completing a pass as a rookie in 2018.

This year, it was an MVP Lamar Jackson trying to desperately carry an average roster over the finish line. Anyone making Lamar slander on the internet is doing it for clicks (like myself) without recognizing how amazing it was that Lamar Jackson made this Ravens team the best team outside of the NFL's elite tier.

Which, at this point, might be the way we all describe Lamar Jackson: He is not quite Patrick Mahomes. Or Aaron Rodgers. Or Deshaun Watson. He's hanging around that 2nd Tier with Russell Wilson and Josh Allen and (maybe) Dak Prescott. The Ravens will look back fondly on this era, but have to feel like every single season, they lost 1 round earlier in the playoffs than they should've (and maybe 2-3 playoff rounds early in 2019, when they were the #1 team in Football).

The Baltimore Ravens have to reshape their roster, and it begins with big decisions this offseason. Lamar Jackson will get a record setting contract extension this offseason, and while that contract may not go into effect until 2023, the Ravens must start preparing to build a team where Jackson makes up 15-20% of their salary cap.

Matthew Judon is a Free Agent this offseason, which could be an expensive mistake if he starts declining like many 29 year old Free Agent Linebackers. Replacing him may cost you one of your top draft picks, plus a good chunk of your available $23 million in cap space. Signing him means there may be no room for recently acquired Yannick Ngakoue, whom you gave up a 3rd Round Pick to acquire. What about OLB Pernell McPhee??? Derek Wolfe???

Then, there's the atrocity of a Wide Receiving Core the Ravens have. Against a Cover 2 Zone, the Ravens went after Buffalo with 1 WR, a Tight End, and JK Dobbins as their only weapons. There's so much that needs to be addressed to make sure the offense isn't as one sided as it was last year. Probably 1 Draft Pick and 1 Free Agent signing are in order for the Ravens (imagine if they sign Juju Smith Schuster!!!)

The Ravens best option is to use some of their cap space and bring in a Top WR with one of their 1st two draft picks. There's one option they could land right now from a team that has shopped their star WR twice in the last 8 months. I'm talking, of course, about Saints WR Michael Thomas, who you would have to pay a hefty price for (4 years, $85 million and a 1st Round Pick). That WR core is so atrocious that the investment could be just enough to help put Lamar Jackson back over the edge to MVP Lamar. It may cost you some of your defensive depth, but that's where strategic signings and draft picks come in handy.

The Ravens, based on the structure of the NFL salary cap, will have to evolve and overhaul their roster. Teams mess up in this phase all the time, either by keeping players too long (Cowboys, Falcons, Vikings) or by making poor draft picks/personnel decisions (Texans). The Ravens have earned my trust by being, behind the Patriots, the best run organization in all of the NFL. I expect they will remain competitive into the near future.

At the same time, this is the beginning of the Ravens' pivot. Until now, Lamar Jackson has been the Ravens best player while being the 43rd, 34th, and 27th highest paid player on the roster. Now, Lamar will become one of the 3 highest paid players in the entire NFL. How will the Ravens pivot?? And can they make another run to wipe the bad taste of the last 3 postseasons out of their mouth??

Time will tell.

Friday, January 15, 2021

Jets, Lions and Falcons Hire their Head Coaches

 3 more NFL Head Coaching jobs have been filled in the last 24 hours. After Robert Saleh choose to join the New York Jets, the teams that had major interest in Saleh, the Detroit Lions and Atlanta Falcons, swooped up their coaching candidates before they each got away. Let's break down the new coaching hires, but instead of giving out letter grades in a cliche article that tells us nothing, I want to give out a different grading system: 

Instead of a 0-10 star system, let's give these hires "LaFluer's", based on the Packers hire of Matt LaFluer that everyone thought was crazy, but ended up being the best hire of his offseason. Similar situations with Brian Flores, Sean McVay, Kevin Stefanski and others have arisen as shocking, yet excellent hires over the last 3-4 offseasons.

Robert Saleh to the Jets: 7.5 out of 10 LaFluers

So, the Jets hired the coach everyone wanted in the offseason coaching search. Let's look at who those coaches were each of the last 4 offseasons:
2017: Kyle Shanahan, 49ers  2018: Matt Patricia: Lions   2019: Wasn't really anybody, but I guess Kliff Kingsbury/Vic Fangio were closest      2020: Matt Rhule, Panthers

Saleh was the trendy 1st time coaching hire whom a number of teams respected as a candidate. As recent history shows, there isn't really any pattern for success among the coaches everybody wants. The ones who haven't worked out so far (Patricia and Fangio) both come from the defensive side of the ball. However, the biggest problem for those two coaches was the rosters the Lions and Broncos assembled around them. Patricia was a 3 years and out coach who never got his offense turned around. Fangio will be a 3 and out coach next offseason, given Drew Locke as his franchise QB and a team without a ton of great draft history in the last few years.

While Saleh is a totally different coach and person, it doesn't bode well for him that he's joining an organization with one of the worst owners in the NFL, that hasn't been to the playoffs more than once in the last 10 years. They are flush with cap space and have the #2 pick in the NFL Draft, which is great, but mind you the Jets also had a similar situation 3 years ago, when the team traded 4 picks and drafted Sam Darnold, signed LeVeon Bell, CJ Mosely, and Jamison Crowder, while trading Leonard Williams to the Giants.

I commend Saleh for the decision, Head Coaching Offers don't come along often. I don't think the Jets are guaranteed anything at this point.

Dan Campbell to the Lions: 5 out of 10 LaFluers

Wow. The Lions pulled a bit of shocker with this hire. While the deal isn't official, it will be once Campbell's Saints get eliminated from the playoffs. When the Lions cancelled their interview with Todd Bowles today, that confirmed the reports that were already out.

Anyways, the Lions want to go full Man Campbell?? No, that wasn't a typo. Man Campbell became a bit of a meme when he filled in for fired Dolphins coach Joe Philbin during the 2015 season. After the Dolphins hired Adam Gase, Man Campbell became the Assistant Coach for the New Orleans Saints for the last 5 years. The Saints won more games over the last 4 years than any team.

Campbell was a little bit of a surprise, as you may have guessed based on the "Wow" at the start. Surprise hires have tended to work out well in the last few years, from Sean McVay to Brian Flores and Kevin Stefanski. Some have also flopped, like Adam Gase and the Jets. The Lions are in this interesting position where they can go both ways.

Here's why the Lions got 5 LaFluers. 1. I wanted them to hire Campbell.... Matt Campbell!!! Oh well. At least if Dan flops in Detroit, I can always laugh that they should've hired the other Campbell from Iowa State. 2. The success of Campbell and new GM Brad Holmes will be determined immediately on whether or not they'll be allowed to pick their QB. If the Lions tie these two to Matt Stafford (and possibly Darrell Bevell) the experiment is guaranteed to fail in Detroit. If the Lions move on from Stafford, letting Holmes pick his new QB at a cheap price, it could still fail. It's why Detroit was the least desirable job in the NFL this coaching cycle. But it still might succeed if given total freedom and room to make some mistakes along the way.

Arthur Smith to the Falcons: 8.5 out of 10 LaFluers

The Falcons zigged while I thought they would zag. The Falcons hired a defensive minded Head Coach, which means Dirk Koetter will be looking for a new job. Koetter is one of the better offensive minds in the NFL, so I thought the Falcons might retain him and make a defensive hire at Head Coach.

Instead, the Falcons picked another fruit off of the Sean McVay-Matt LaFluer-Kevin Stefanski coaching scheme. Make that 8 NFL teams now getting ready to use the zone rushing schemes of years past, adding the Jets with new OC Mike LaFluer.

As for the Falcons, this hire is eerily similar to when the Rams hired Sean McVay to coach Todd Gurley. While there's no guarantee that Gurley will return to the Falcons next year, there weren't exactly people lining up to sign him last offseason. By hiring Smith, the Falcons are hiring the scheme that led to emergences of Derrick Henry, Dalvin Cook, Nick Chubb, Aaron Jones, the 49ers 6 RB committee, and... Todd Gurley with the Rams!!!! The Falcons are going to look dramatically different than they did last year on offense.

Whether or not Matt Ryan is still on the Falcons shouldn't matter on what they run offensively. Maybe the Falcons spend the #4 pick in the Draft on a QB, trade Ryan, and give Smith all the tools to succeed. Alternatively, the Falcons could keep Ryan and disguise him in play action passes and make him look something like a Jared Goff or Kirk Cousins, compared to the 5,000 yard QB he's been for a few years now.

I love the move of any team to bring in that zone running scheme of the Titans. It worked out super well for the Packers when they hired Matt LaFluer, even when people thought it would be strange. The Falcons may not be great immediately like the Packers, and that will be because they lack talent. The Falcons will be the most interesting team of the three to check in on in 3 years.

Thursday, January 14, 2021

The Brooklyn Nets Are Going to be So Much Fun for Everyone

 The new Brooklyn Nets trio of James Harden, Kevin Durant and Kyrie Irving averaged over 90 PPG this season before yesterday. No trio in NBA history (even the 50 PPG Wilt Chamberlain season) have ever scored more points among 3 teammates than the Nets Big 3. Not the Big 3 Heat. Not the Durant/Curry/Thompson Warriors. NOBODY!!!

I felt it was safe to assume that Harden, Durant and Irving had worked out who would be "getting" shots and who would be "taking" shots for the Nets. Durant would be the #1, Harden the #2, seeing a decline in usage rate, and Kyrie Irving being the best #3 to ever play in the NBA. Based on what's gone on with Irving in recent days, it seems they may not have worked this out. If they haven't, it's gonna be super entertaining to watch them try.

If Durant/Harden/Irving don't have an understanding, either A. We'll get to watch them figure it out in real time. B. It'll be a lot of trading off shots. One night will be Irving's time to go for 45, then Harden will have a 50 Point Triple double, then maybe Durant will go for 48 on 25 shots. C. It's all gonna crash and burn in front of our eyes.

No matter which way it goes, it's going to be wildly entertaining to watch the Brooklyn Nets. James Harden's trade to the Brooklyn Nets is a win for every Basketball fan from coast to coast. This is a version of basketball nirvana we got accustomed to with the Warriors, then took for granted once the Warriors broke up, and we went 18 months without any true Super team in the NBA. Now, we have a legitimate superteam again, with 3 players in their early 30's, 2 MVP's, plus a perennial All Star who's one of the best 3-4 Point Guards of his generation.

Note how I said "basketball fans" win with the Harden trade. NBA fans in Boston, Miami, and Philadelphia are cursing visibly at the knowledge that their season just became wholly irrelevant. And Lakers fans... well, you've got some competition for the crown now. Notice how being a "superteam" doesn't mean you're going to win the Championship... the Warriors should've only won 1 title in their 3 years of Kevin Durant (2018 Rockets missing 0-27 shots to lose by 7 in a Game 7).

We have a legitimate competitor to the Bucks and Lakers (and maybe the Clippers) to shake things up in the NBA. No major stars changed teams this offseason, which meant the NBA's landscape, at least at the top, was exactly the same as the 2020 season.

James Harden represented the balance of power in the NBA. If we went to the 76ers, the power would have shifted the same way as joining the Nets does. Only on the Brooklyn Nets (or a Warriors/Clippers trade that wasn't going to happen) does James Harden one of the 5-6 elite players in the NBA, become the 2nd best player on his team. 

Like Anthony Davis on the Lakers, two of the NBA's superstars of today reside in Brooklyn and Los Angeles. The Nets have that balance of power in order, but they need time to assimilate with one another. Regardless of whether the Nets get on the same page, it should be really, REALLY fun to watch it all play out. Yesterday was a victory for basketball fans everywhere, especially if the Nets play a style of basketball akin to the Warriors of championships past. When you have 3 players that can go for 50 any given night.... good luck to opponents.

If this all implodes, like some people religiously believe it will, it's gonna be fun for NBA fans and those who love the storylines around the transactions/games. No two players are more scapegoated across the NBA than James Harden and Kyrie Irving. Most of that comes from the fact that neither players give a shit what anyone else thinks about them. People with little care for the opinions of others tend to be very polarizing among those others. You either love those players or you hate them, and the more they show indifference, the more you get angry at them. Like Trevor Bauer in the MLB or Odell Beckham in the NFL, the "I don't give a shit" players are extremely polarizing figures.

Now, you've put those two players together with Kevin Durant, who is polarizing for the exact opposite reason. Kevin Durant DESPERATELY cares what you think about him, and his image has improved dramatically post-Achilles injury (probably bc most KD Haters felt guilty when they all saw his Achilles snap on the court in the NBA Finals). In the Kyrie drama, Kevin Durant continues to take the high road, which is a really smart call by him. He should do the exact same thing with James Harden, especially if he wants to see an improved image of himself.

So, the Nets might implode, and it will be fun to watch. Or they'll figure out how to play together, and it's going to be REALLY fun to watch. There is no way we Basketball fans can lose. Only when we allow ourselves to be losers (like so many people choose to do when Durant joined the Warriors in 2016) can this Nets' team not be fun.

The NBA delivered us with a gift: A gift of a Superteam. And it came at a really great time; 19 months and a global pandemic after Durant tore his Achilles, ending the Warriors Superteam.

Tuesday, January 12, 2021

Offseason 1 of The Eagles' 3 Year Rebuild

 The Philadelphia Eagles are rebuilding. Team Chairman Jeffery Lurie told us that much yesterday when, after Doug Pederson left amid disagreements with ownership, Lurie told us the Eagles had a "longer term vision" than what Pederson had in mind. By all accounts, Lurie is one of the best owners in the NFL, and he showed why yesterday: Lurie has no disillusions about what his team is and what his team isn't.

Many NFL Franchise go years hanging on to what they have, keeping themselves in what is known as "9th Seed Purgatory". The Vikings have been doing that ever since they brought in Kirk Cousins. The Falcons did it for 3 years after Super Bowl 51, where they went 24-24 in the 3 years after losing to the Patriots. The Cowboys gave out big contracts to everyone, and they will continue to go 8-8, 7-9, and 9-7 for as long as Dak, Zeke and Amari Cooper are their 3 best players. The Chicago Bears have also hung around the 7th and 8th seeds for years after it became clear Mitch Trubisky was not the answer. Washington did it with RGIII, Kirk Cousins and Jay Gruden for almost 5 full seasons.

When it comes to a reality check, most teams prefer to remain average instead of pivoting to a new era. Mostly, this is because the GM and Head Coach know that 90% of the time, they will be relieved of their duties in what might be their only coaching opportunity. The GM's hope that, with enough time, they can draft a generational talent and save their jobs by taking their team back to the playoffs. And this is a strategy that has worked a number of times in the past.

The most recent and best example of this is John Harbaugh with the Baltimore Ravens. In 2018, Baltimore started the season 4-5. It was reported that the Ravens had already decided to fire Harbaugh at the end of the season, and GM Ozzie Newsome would be retiring after the NFL Draft. Harbaugh inserted rookie QB Lamar Jackson for Joe Flacco, and the rest is history. Jackson won the AFC North, Harbaugh got an extension, and the marriage will remain for many years going forward.

The Eagles are not in the Ravens position. Philadelphia has no illusions about where they stand in the grand scheme of the NFL. Philadelphia had been riding that "Post Super Bowl" mojo for a couple years. They made it back to the playoffs in 2018 and 2019. They won a playoff game against the Bears on the "double doink". The Eagles won the NFC East in 2019 as well.

This year, it all fell apart on the Eagles. And many owners want to envision how their team could turn this around in 1 offseason, improving 8 wins and making it back to the playoffs as 12-4 NFC East Champions. It's the way fans often think about their teams. And most fans want an owner who is like them: A fan of the team they own.

Jeffery Lurie is the type of owner I want for my team: A realist. Lurie sees the writing on the wall, as is painfully obvious if you watched the Eagles in 2020. This team needs an influx of young talent very, VERY badly. The Eagles have needs on the offensive line, Wide Receivers, and every defensive position except for Defensive Tackle Fletcher Cox. The Eagles salary cap is bloated, and they need to reset that so they can sign more players when they'd like to be competitive.

The Eagles so all the signs of a franchise in need of a 3 year rebuild.

The good news: Year 1 is already done of that rebuild. The Eagles have their QB to take them through a rebuild, even if nobody is really sure whether it's Jalen Hurts or Carson Wentz. Philadelphia has the #6 Pick in the NFL Draft, which the Eagles should 100% look to trade down from. If they keep the pick, there's a good chance, based on how the first 5 picks fall, the Eagles will end up with the best defensive player in the Draft, CB Patrick Surtain from Alabama. 

The Eagles are already in a rebuild, and the best rebuilds are the ones that STICK TO A PLAN. Rebuilding in the NFL is not as difficult as it seems, as long as you are willing to ride out some losing seasons. When that willingness is there, even the Cleveland Browns can becoming a Top 8 team in the NFL.

Let's point out it was a rebuild much like this that led to the Eagles winning the Super Bowl in 2017. Chip Kelly laid the foundation with draft picks (Fletcher Cox, Mychel Kendricks, Zach Ertz, Vinny Curry Jordan Hicks) and Free Agent signings (Lane Johnson, Desean Jackson, Chris Long). Doug Pederson and Carson Wentz came in for the 2016 season, and two years later Nick Foles and a strong offensive line won a Super Bowl. If anyone should believe in the power of a rebuild, it should probably be Eagles fans and Jeffery Lurie. It got you your first Super Bowl less than 3 years.

I'm not sure who the Eagles will hire to coach Jalen Hurts (most likely). Arthur Smith is a great offensive schemer, but the Eagles don't have a strong offensive line. Joe Brady makes sense to me. The Eagles have tried to contact Lincoln Riley too (I know Hurts is your QB, but good luck with that one). Whoever the Eagles hire will should be given a large say over personnel, since the Eagles will be building up this roster from the bare bones. That includes trading the final pieces of this Super Bowl roster, specifically Zach Ertz, Brandon Graham, Miles Sanders, and, yes, Carson Wentz.

Lurie has no disillusions about what his team is. Eagles fans will thank him many years from now, but for now they're gonna have to swallow expectations of a 5-11 season in 2021.

Monday, January 11, 2021

Have the Tennessee Titans Peaked??? Yep.

Have we witnessed the best of the Tennessee Titans??? To be fair, I did say in March that if Tennessee resigned Ryan Tannehill and Derrick Henry that the Titans would go 7-9 and miss the playoffs. Oops. I also thought the Texans would go 8-8 too. The AFC South was a weird division this year.

Anyways, back to the Titans. Tennessee lost a Home Playoff Game in the Wild Card vs. Baltimore yesterday. The Titans find themselves at a crossroad in their franchise, given that I can say (with 95% certainty) the Tannehill-Henry Titans will not make it back to the AFC Championship Game like they did last year. It took 2,051 of Derrick Henry rushing yards just for the Titans to limp their way to 11 wins that, had they lost to the Texans in Week 17, would've also cost them the AFC South title.

So, where do the Titans go from here. They have the best RB in the NFL. They have the 4th best QB in the AFC. They have a Top 15-20 WR in the NFL in AJ Brown. And they have a Franchise LT returning from injury in Taylor Lewan. They have a HC and one of the best offensive schemes in the NFL. What else do they have???

Offseason: The Titans enter the offseason with 4 Massively Important Free Agents: They are also only $6 million below the cap, as things presently stand. Jadeveon Clowney will try and get a multi year deal from someone, and it would be a tough decision the Titans have to make about bringing him back (as it was a tough decision for the Seahawks). Let's say the Titans bring Clowney back on a 3 year, $42 million contract. Let's assume the Titans also resign Desmond King, who they acquired from the Chargers at the deadline, on a 1 year deal.

The Titans then have 0 TE's on their roster. Delaine Walker is out. Jonnu Smith is one of the best TE's available on the market. Anthony Firkser is a RFA, and will assume a bigger role next year for the Titans.

The big question mark facing the Titans is Corey Davis, who went for 1,000 yards in 2020. The Titans declined his 5th year option, and it's likely Davis will get overpaid by some cap-flushed team in Free Agency (let's be honest, probably the Jaguars). The Titans can replace in house with a healthy Adam Humphries, but then the Titans need to replace Humphries role in some way shape or form. The best way to do that is to run more 2 TE sets with Firkser and..... maybe Jonna Smith or his replacement??

NFL Draft: The easiest way to get solid replacements below market value??? The NFL Draft. The issue for the Titans is they need NFL caliber starters right now. And, well, every NFL team is looking for those in the draft. The Titans have found those before in the aforementioned AJ Brown in the 2nd Round. They've also drafted some reclamation projects, like Corey Davis and 2020 1st Round Pick Isaiah Wilson, who was suspended for violating team rules earlier in his rookie season.

The Titans have so many needs they'd like to address, and not enough valuable picks to do all of that. The Titans future would look so much better if they could get a 3rd or 4th Round Pick that give immediate contributions at, say, Wide Receiver or Linebacker. Again, every team is looking for one of those players, and there's a 10-20% chance of finding those players in any given draft.

With their 1st and 2nd Round Picks, the Titans should look to address these key positions: LB (Middle and Outside) Edge Rusher, WR, and/or interior offensive line.

The Tannehill Question: This is the biggest of the question marks, isn't it. Ryan Tannehill ranked 5th in the NFL in QBR in 2020, and finished higher than Deshaun Watson in key stats like Yards/Completion. Do you trust Ryan Tannehill the way you trust Deshaun Watson?? Of course not.

Why don't we trust Ryan Tannehill??? Because he could play like he did against the Ravens on Sunday. The Ravens stacked the box and committed all of their heavy linebackers and defensive lineman to stopping Derrick Henry at all costs. Because the Ravens have the personnel to, you know, actually STOP Derrick Henry, the 2,000 King rushed for zero 1st Downs and 40 yards. His longest carry of the game was for 8 yards.

The Ravens put Marlon Humphrey, All Pro CB who just got the highest contract for a CB ever, on AJ Brown, and kept him to a manageable 8 catches for 63 yards and a TD. The Ravens DARED Ryan Tannehill to beat them through the air. And in the 1st Quarter, Tannehill did just that. He started the game passing 6/6 for 69 yards and a touchdown to AJ Brown. 

The remainder of the game, while the Ravens were letting Tannehill throw the ball, Tannehill went 12/20 for 96 yards, 0 TD and 1 INT. And that's the Ryan Tannehill we knew in Miami. It's the Ryan Tannehill who beat the Ravens in last year's playoffs by throwing for 83 yards. Or beat the Patriots by throwing for 72 yards. That Tannehill didn't cut it this time around, with an ineffective Derrick Henry who the Ravens eliminated as a threat.

Tannehill has 1 year left on his $30 million extension (unless the Titans inexplicably accept his $33 million 3rd year option). Henry hasn't slowed down, but rare do we find a running back entering his late 20's who keeps up his early-mid 20's rushing paces. Tannehill will be 33 the next time he picks up a football, and it's not like we all didn't agree Ryan Tannehill was nothing special in Miami. 

We aren't really sure what Ryan Tannehill is, but we're starting to figure out who the Titans are. And they need to keep filling the ranks with young talent to avoid the inevitable decent of all NFL dynasties. From the Jaguars, Falcons, Cowboys, Vikings, Eagles, Steelers, to even the Patriots, Packers and Ravens, it's really, REALLY hard to make the playoffs 3 straight years in the modern NFL. The Titans got a 2nd wind of opportunity because of the emergence of Tannehill. As they head into year 3 of this run, much of his 2019 is starting to wear off as the realities of sustainability in the NFL set in.

Thursday, January 7, 2021

The Texans Aren't As Bad as They Appear. Deshaun Watson Still Needs to Get Out of Houston

The Houston Texans limped into the finish line of 2020 with a 4-12 record. As has been mentioned to no end, the Texans do not have their #3 pick to show for it. It seems very clear that JJ Watt, aka "Captain America" will be leaving the Texans as a Free Agent this offseason. Today, reports came out that Deshaun Watson has hinted that he may request a trade this offseason. The Houston Texans, for all their failures, aren't as bad as their record actually shows. At the same time, Watson and Watt should both get the holy hell away from Houston as fast as they can.

Based on their point differentials, 1 possession games played in, and projected output The Houston Texans were the 3rd Unluckiest Team in the NFL this year. Only the 1-15 Jaguars and 4-12 Atlanta Falcons were unluckier than the Texans this year based on expected win total. Even if you don't like the analytics side of evaluations, let's just point to 4 brutally unlucky Texans losses in 2020:

Week 6: Lost in OT to the Titans who scored 2 TD's to end the game without Deshaun Watson being able to touch the ball

Week 13: Botched snap at the 1 yard line with 14 seconds left leads to loss vs. the Colts

Week 15: Fumble with 40 seconds left at the 1 yard line that would've forced OT vs. Colts 

Week 17: Titans score GW FG in 18 seconds after kick hit upright and went in

The Texans were really a 7-9 in a 4-12 teams body, which is usually a good thing for a team to get a higher draft pick. However, as mentioned before, the Dolphins have Houston's 1st Round Pick. The Texans should be a little better next year unless they went into a full rebuild, which is almost impossible when you have an Elite QB on your team who, at the very worst, is guaranteed to win you 7-8 games a season (like Houston should've this year).

But, why should Deshaun Watson put up with "the very worst" possible situation in the NFL. The Texans messed up really badly around Watson, and with Watt departing as well (which we'll get into later), Deshaun is seeing some of the writing on the wall that Houston has really let things go bad.

Houston just hired Nick Caserio, who spent 12 years as the #2 to Bill Belichick, to be their GM and pick the new Head Coach. I really hope Caserio's first task in Houston is being forced to start over and trade Deshaun Watson for a Larger-than-Ricky-Williams package of players and picks. For Deshaun Watson's sake and his sake only, I desperately want this to happen.

While player empowerment has taken the NBA by storm in the Post-LeBron Decision era, but we are yet to see an NFL player of Deshaun Watson's pedigree flex his power like what could be in the works. First, let it be noted that NFL players don't have as much power in Collective Bargaining as their NBA counterparts, and the Texans have zero incentive to actually trade Watson. Deshaun's only leverage in this case is to make things ugly with the Texans like James Harden. If you know anything about Deshaun Watson and his Leadership, I doubt he'll be doing that ugly breakup anytime soon.

There are two cases in recent memory of a star player demanding his way out of a crappy situation. Both of them ended with those two players losing their good name. The Antonio Brown-Raiders saga has been well documented before, considering it was only like 16 months ago and was just absolute insanity as AB had a public mental breakdown in front of our eyes. The 2nd case was Carson Palmer and the Bengals back in 2011. Carson Palmer forced his way out of Cincinnati after an ugly saga of playoff losses and fights with ownership, and people really crushed Palmer in the media and in the NFL fandom (pre-Twitter fights as well). The only other leverage players have in these disputes are the threat of retirement, which Barry Sanders, Calvin Johnson, and Marshawn Lynch all used to avoid playing for bad situations. Yannick Ngakoue, LeVeon Bell, and Trent Williams had to sit out entire seasons before their trade requests were ultimately granted 

So, while I don't think Deshaun Watson could be traded even if he wanted to (he's under contract for 5 years and about $180 million right now), Deshaun should do everything in his power to voice his unhappiness with the Texans, at the very least to put pressure on the Texans to make some moves. If Deshaun gets fined by the league, then so be it. If his teammates back him up, then Deshaun would absolutely be making the strong leadership ploy to put pressure on his ownership. Deshaun won't have JJ Watt around next year too, and that makes the whole situation in Houston more volatile.

There are infinite reasons why someone wouldn't want to play for the Texans. But why specifically would Deshaun Watson, star QB of Houston, not want to play for Houston. First and foremost, the departure of Watt means Deshaun is the sole leadership figure for the entire Texans organization. Their Head Coach will be in their 1st Year, and barring a hire of Marvin Lewis this will be that coaches 1st ever NFL Head Coaching job. Deshaun is obviously playing for the worst possible version of the Texans (they went 4-12 WITHOUT him when he tore an ACL his rookie year) and they don't have the capital to acquire another generation talent to turn them around from a 7-9 or 8-8 team like they will be next season with Deshaun.

Watson is seeing the writing on the wall that this will be a long turnaround project for the Texans, and much like Andrew Luck, Watson is going to get bruised, battered and beaten time and time again in the next 2 seasons. By then, Deshaun Watson will have lost 2 of the best years of his NFL prime, and who knows where he and the Texans will be at that time. Deshaun is going to at least work to get himself out of that Andrew-Luck type of situation before it ever sets in. And let's hope he makes his way out.

Wednesday, January 6, 2021

The NFL is not Prepared to Tackle This Cleveland Browns Situation

 Why the Hell are we not talking about this Cleveland Browns story more??? Is it because the NFL just wants to keep things moving?? Because we all need our dopamine rush from watching playoff football, COVID-19 be damned. Is it that the Sports' World's Major news outlets, such as ESPN and Fox Sports, are in partnerships with the league and aren't investigating deeper into the story??? Is it that the NFL simply can get away with it??? Any one of these could be part of an explanation to a question I don't have an answer to.

Since December 26th, 17 Browns players have been placed on the COVID-19 reserve list, either from positive cases or contact tracing. This constitutes the 2nd largest COVID-19 related outbreak in the NFL this season, only behind the 22 Positive Cases that forced the Tennessee Titans to postpone a game back in Week 5. We can now add HC Kevin Stefanski and at least 2 other coaches to that COVID-19 list with confirmed positive COVID-19 cases.

The Browns are hanging on by a thread. But they'll play at 8:15 EST on Sunday Night, even if they have to suit up with 0 WR's like they did against the Jets. To add onto the controversies, the Browns interim Head Coach for Sunday will be Mike Priefer, who's name resurfaced today after Anti-LGBTQ+ comments he made back in 2014 were brought back to our attention. Priefer denies these allegations, but the story was corroborated by an investigation in Minnesota in 2014-15. Priefer received a 3 game suspension, 2 of which he served after taking "sensitivity training". 

While Priefer has served his "punishment", it is rather alarming that this exists in his past and we didn't know about it. This isn't quite like a Gregg Williams-scandal where it involves something on the field, but one the NFL and the Cleveland Browns are still equally unfit to tackle. I don't know how Priefer's positions on LGBTQ people has evolved over the last 6 years, and I'm not giving him an undeserved benefit of the doubt on the issue. It's overall a bad look for the Browns, and one they were going to have to absorb at some point when Stefanski brought him from Minnesota to be 2nd in line to the Head Coach.

So, the Browns may or not have a homophobe coaching their team on Sunday (not that homophobia is super uncommon in the NFL). On the field, 9 players, the Head Coach, and other coaches are on the COVID-19 reserve list for the Browns. Denzel Ward, the team's 2nd best defensive player, is a toss up to play Sunday based on if he can get 3 negative COVID tests and maybe practice one time. 

Problem about that is... the Browns facilities have been closed 4 times in the last 3 weeks. The Browns are just going through weight training and Zoom meetings for the last 3 weeks, unless their running some Titans-style secret practice. Right now, the Browns are without Starting TE Harrison Bryant, Starters at Linebacker (Malcom Smith and BJ Goodson), S Andrew Sendejo, DB Kevin Johnson, G Joel Bitonio, and backup WR KhaDarel Hodge, along with the questions about their star CB Ward.

But, we're just gonna keep it moving, right?? The Browns caught a tough break, but what can the NFL do about it?? Reschedule the game??? HAHAHAHAAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Don't be ridiculous, there's way too much money riding on these 2 extra playoff games that didn't exist last year. The NFL put the Browns and Steelers in the latest possible window: Sunday Night at 8:15, Game 6 of 6 in the 1st ever "Super Wild Card Weekend". Whoever can suit up for the Browns at that time will play. 

And they may get crushed by the Steelers. Or they might win. Who knows, Football is weird like that. One game sample sizes don't tell us very much about the teams we're watching. The process the NFL, the Browns, and their media partners are going through to get to the end game was laid bare earlier this summer. 

And that's ok. Just acknowledge (and I know this will never happen) that the Browns caught an unlucky break and will have to play at 70% strength against the Steelers. Or that the NFL is unprepared and unqualified to deal with issues involving homophobia and how to address it. Everyone was willing to forgive and forget when Goodell made that statement from his basement on Black Live Matter Protests in June, after NFL owners was the leading corporate instigator on anti-BLM by blackballing Colin Kaepernick and (for a time) Eric Reid. 

By the way, Chris Kluwe, the punter who brought Mike Priefer's comments about "nuking the gays" to light, feels he was released by the Vikings because of his advocacy for same-sex marriage. The NFL is wholly unprepared to tackle COVID-19. They get a pass on that, nobody really knows what they're doing anymore. When it comes to the LGBTQ+ issues, the league has had years to evolve and shed their various ignorance's. They haven't showed any level of competence in the situation, and so it is going to be buried down with the headlines of this weekend's Wild Card action.

Monday, January 4, 2021

The Miami Dolphins and Taking a Leap Of Faith

 The Miami Dolphins were eliminated from the playoffs with their 56-26 point loss to the Buffalo Bills. Thanks to the Houston Texans' 4-12 season, the Dolphins hold the #3 and #18 picks in April's NFL Draft. There have been more than a few people and scenarios pointing to the Dolphins selecting Justin Fields or Zach Wilson one year after drafting Tua Tagovailoa with the 5th pick in the Draft.

People saying the Dolphins should move on from Tua this fast for another rookie QB are not crazy. They also aren't correct, but let's not be so judgmental here. There is a legitimate case the Dolphins should trade Tua and draft another QB the same way there's a case the Jets should trade Sam Darnold and draft Justin Fields or Zach Wilson. The only difference: Most people almost universally agree on trading Darnold, but spit on the people who say Miami should move on from Tua.

Here's what Darnold and Tua's Rookie Seasons both looked like:

Darnold: 13 Starts, 57.7% completion, 2865 yds, 17 TD's 15 INT's, 77.6 Passer rating, 6.9 yrd/attempt, 

Tagovailoa: 9 Starts, 64.1% completion, 1814 yards, 11 TD's 5 INT's, 87.1 Passer rating, 6.3 yrd/attempt

Tua undoubtedly is better in his rookie year than Sam Darnold was. It's not by a ton, but it's definitely better. It's not like very many people are sold on Tua, but if this is a rebuild, Tua's a rebuilding type of QB for the Dolphins.

Let's compare Tua's numbers now with the Offensive Rookie of the Year, Justin Herbert, who was taken one pick after Tua.

Herbert: 15 Starts, 66.6% completion, 31 TD's, 10 INT's, 98.3 passer rating, 7.3 yrd/attempt

Tagovailoa: 9 Starts, 64.1% completion, 1814 yards, 11 TD's 5 INT's, 87.1 Passer rating, 6.3 yrd/attempt

As most of you suspected, Tua is not as good as Justin Herbert. But he's not as bad as Sam Darnold. He's somewhere in the middle. Yet the gap between Justin Herbert and Sam Darnold, by NFL standards, is a lot of guessing room. Unfortunately for Miami, they have no more time to evaluate Tua before making any kind of final decision on his future.

The Dolphins can go in an array of different directions in this draft. As outlined on the Take It Easy Podcast, the Dolphins can sign any number of running backs this offseason for cheap, from James Connor to Marlon Mack to even... Aaron Jones??? They have that #18 pick to use on either an offensive lineman, a star RB like Najee Harris, or another TE to run more 2 TE sets with Mike Gesecki (they were significantly more efficient in 2 TE sets vs. 3 WR sets, but that may have been attributed to their lack of WR Depth this year).

Most importantly, that #3 pick sets the Dolphins up to take LSU WR Jamar Chase, who was better in 2019 than his LSU teammate Justin Jefferson, who just broke the Rookie record for receiving yards. Chase opted out of this season, and his draft stock remains equally high. Or Miami could, you know, add 2 more 1st Rounders by trading down with a QB needy team. The options are literally unlimited for Miami.

Here's the catch. This is the Dolphins last chance to draft that premier QB and hack the NFL's salary cap. The way to do that: Getting the star QB on their rookie deal. The Chargers just did that, and they have a chance to catch the Chiefs in the next half decade because of it. The Cardinals did it too, and they have 3 years of a cheap Kyler Murray to build on an 8-8 season that was somehow disappointing.

This is why the Darnold and Tua cases are so similar: Sam Darnold has improved very little from his rookie year. He lost 6 games in 2019 to Mono, then the Jets stripped all his talent before the 2020 season while Darnold battled shoulder injuries. I have no question Sam Darnold can be a serviceable, cheap QB for any number of contenders from the Colts to the Steelers to the 49ers, given the right infrastructure. Cheap, young, 1st Round QB's don't become available that often.... at least they used to.

In the last 3 years, we've seen 2 1st Round Picks (2018 draft or later) get dumped by the teams that drafted them. Josh Rosen was traded for a measly 2nd Round Pick to the Miami Dolphins, and it turned out to be a bad trade for the Dolphins (and Arizona, they used that extra draft pick to draft WR Andy Isabella over DK Metcalf). Last Monday, the Washington Racial Slurs dumped 2019 #15 pick Dwayne Haskins, who hasn't been claimed since. The Jets are about to dump Darnold, from 2018's class, to make it three times in 3 years.

The new NFL says it's better to cut bait with a bust than try and make them a "reclamation project", like the Bears are trying to do with Mitchell Trubisky. Word to the wise, anything the Bears are trying to do with their QB's, you should probably do the opposite until proven otherwise. It's simply not worth it, especially if you're gonna have to pay Trubisky $15 million or more this offseason. The reason it's being done is so Ryan Pace and Matt Nagy can keep their jobs, which adds to why reclamation projects are not great ideas: The years are too short on that rookie deal to spend 2 years trying w/ that same QB.

Instead of spending those 2 years trying to rebound your QB, why not just try again with another 1st Round Pick and reset the clock on their contract??? The answer is: It won't be you, GM who just picked a bust QB, who will be making that 2nd 1st Round Selection.... unless??????

You're the Miami Dolphins. GM Chris Grier is in the running for Executive of the Year in 2020 for building a 10 win team out of a team that was 0-7 and tanking 14 months ago. Brian Flores might win coach of the year as his praises get sung from coast to coast about the job the Dolphins did. You're jobs are as secure as any in the sport. Take that leap of faith, if you aren't sold on Tua, of course. You have a better chance of finding another Jamar Chase than you do of finding another Justin Herbert in the draft.

Here's the final reason why urgency is high in Miami: They will not have a draft pick this high for (hopefully) a very long time. The Dolphins are getting better, not worse, as we speak. The Dolphins can secure a cheap, great QB in the draft, or at the very least have the hope of one. If Tua doesn't end up working out, then 2 years from now you will be stuck in the same purgatory the Chicago Bears are in now, or the Las Vegas Raiders have been in for the last 4-5 seasons with Derek Carr.

While I still believe in the idea of doubling down on Tua, the warning signs are upon us. Again, he's better than Sam Darnold, a fringe starter at best, but not Justin Herbert, maybe a Top 10 QB right now. The Dolphins have to project, to their best of their abilities, where Tua falls on this spectrum. Maybe that means drafting Justin Fields or Zach Wilson with their #3 Pick bestowed upon them from Bill O'Brien.

Saturday, January 2, 2021

Tom Herman, Texas, and a Uniquely College Football Situation

3 weeks ago, Texas beat Kansas State 69-31 to cap off a 6-3 regular season in 2020. The Longhorns finished 3rd in the BIG12, which meant they were likely going to San Antonio to play in the Alamo Bowl as the best BIG12 team that didn't make a New Year's 6 Bowl Game (Oklahoma and Iowa State were ranked #10 and #6, respectively). 

The Longhorns Athletic Director Chris Del Conte put out the statement that "Tom Herman would return as Head Coach in 2021 for the Texas Longhorns". This came as a shock, since all we had been hearing out of Texas was that Herman was a dead man walking following their losses to TCU at home, along with the aforementioned Iowa State and Oklahoma (the latter of which went to multiple Overtimes and might've changed Herman's fate altogether).

Today, Herman was fired and his replacement is pretty much already decided. What changed things?? It wasn't a recruiting problem, Texas is again ranked in the Top 20 early on in 2021, and Herman recruited Top 10 recruiting classes each of the last 2 years. It isn't the on field product, Texas destroyed an overwhelmed Colorado Buffaloes team 55-23 in the Alamo Bowl. The story of Tom Herman is a uniquely College Football story, because it requires definitive and absolute power to make it happen. It also needs those with the absolute power to be a little bit crazy. It's fairly similar to an Owner in Sports like Mark Davis and what he did to Jack Del Rio.

First of all, Texas does not have a problem with identifying talented coaches to take their jobs. Mack Brown was the Texas coach for 16 years before he retired. In Basketball, Shaka Smart has been the Head Coach at Texas since 2015, and the school has showed an immense amount of patience to Shaka in seasons where they didn't make the tournament. The results: Texas is now a Top 5 team in College Basketball who just beat Kansas by 30 points at Allen Fieldhouse. 

Even Herman, who just got fired, was the best coaching candidate available in 2016. He turned the Longhorns into a BIG12 power again after a 6-7, 5-7, and 5-7 season with Charlie Strong. Texas won the Sugar Bowl in Herman's 2nd year, when his recruits began to fill the ranks in Austin TX. The Longhorns finished 3rd in the BIG12 in 2019, behind Matt Rhule's Baylor and Lincoln Riley's Oklahoma. They finished 3rd this year as well. They were on pace to win 10 games had this been a non-COVID season. The Longhorns were back... to what they could reasonably expect to be.

For the past month, Texas was obviously and clearly flirting with other coaches who were a whole lot sexier than Tom Herman. Texas didn't view themselves as a 2nd team to Oklahoma, they had to be better than Oklahoma. First, it was the connection in reports of Urban Meyer to the Texas job. For that story to be written, either Urban Meyer or Texas had to leak that story to the press. Based on what we now know, it seems very clear that Meyer was the party who leaked the story of Texas' interest. Given that Meyer will not be the coach at Texas, it's clear he never wanted that job in the first place. Also, he's now been connected the Jaguars coaching job, which, considering Doug Marrone is still under contract, means he also leaked that story to the press.

After the Meyer saga, the Texas administrators starting getting stars in their eyes. After seeing all the positive publicity of Meyer leaking the rumors to the press, Texas got a big head and became dead set on making a "big splash" hire. So, Texas started surveying the landscape of who they could possibly land. I assume they checked in with Michigan on whether or not Jim Harbaugh was on his way out. I assume they pitched calls to a 2nd tier of candidates, like David Shaw at Stanford, before being immediately turned away. By this point, they were set on making a HC hire, but didn't have any splashy candidates at their disposal. 

I assume Steve Sarkasian was the only major coaching candidate who showed significant interest in the job. Sarkasian was a successful, although very predictable play caller at Alabama and with the Atlanta Falcons for the last 4 years. Like with Kirby Smart (Georgia), Mike Locksley (Maryland) and Jeremy Pruitt (Tennessee), another Nick Saban coordinator gets a big job in College Football.

Except, Texas was not like Georgia, who had Mark Richt retire after 3 straight disappointing seasons (finishing unranked, #9 and #24 in the country after a #4 finish in 2012). Or Maryland, who's coach was fired in disgrace following the death of Jordan McNair and abuse allegations within the program that finished 4-8. Or Tennessee, who went through Greg Schiano, Mike Leach, Mike Gundy, and 2 other HC candidates before settling on Pruitt.

Texas is not going to be able to become Oklahoma with just money and reputation. Oklahoma has both of those things too. Getting Texas back to the top was going to take longer than 4 years no matter what. Herman was either on his way towards that Sugar Bowl, or needed a couple more years to prove that he wasn't going to get it. Texas got stars in their eyes, and parted way with a coach who won a Sugar Bowl for a HC with a similar career win % to Herman. Sarkisian may work out for Texas, but it's going to take another 4-5 years to catch Oklahoma no matter what. If they ever get there.