Sunday, August 16, 2020

Big Ben and The Pittsburgh Steelers

 The Question/Phrase "Why Not Us?" has been cliched in sports every year for decades by franchises to garner belief.

For the 2020 Pittsburgh Steelers, this question actually has a pretty definitive answer: If they don't see success in 2020, they will have to blow up and completely reinvent their offense.

Back in 2018, I got into an Instagram War with Antonio Brown, claiming the Steelers need to trade the aging star, let LeVeon Bell walk (this was his holdout season), and commit to a team of Mason Rudolph, James Connor and Juju Smith-Schuster. Low and behold, I was proven right. The Steelers traded Antonio Brown, let Bell walk, saw Big Ben injure his elbow, and still won 9 Games in 2019!!!

Where I was wrong was how the Steelers got to 9 wins in 2019. Their youthful, futuristic offense of Rudolph, Connor, and Juju didn't carry them near the playoffs. Pittsburgh's success was built on the backs of their defense, with guys like Joe Haden, TJ Watt, Minkah Fitzpatrick, Devin Bush, and Bud Dupree.

Mason Rudolph was benched for Duck Hodges, who won 4 games before being benched for Rudolph again. James Connor was a major disappointment, and is now headed into a contract year the Steelers certainly don't want to pick up. Juju Smith Schuster went from 111 Catches for 1426 yards in 2018 to 42 catches and 552 yards in 2019. The Steelers finished 28th in team offense in 2019, just above teams like the Washington Racial Slurs, Miami Dolphins, and Cincinnati Bengals.

In 2020, the Pittsburgh Steelers are putting all their chips into one man: Ben Roethlisberger. The Steelers are betting (without much of an alternative) that the 38 year old Roethlisberger can come back from elbow surgery and revive an offense that was tremendous in 2018. For the 1st time in 5 years, the Steelers have a Top 10 defense to compliment Roethlisberger and the Offense, which has been the strong suit of the Steelers for the entirety of Big Ben's career.

There are two very likely scenarios this season could go for the Steelers:

1. Big Ben is such an improvement over the Rudolph/Duck Hodges tandem that Pittsburgh's offense becomes respectable again. The Steelers defense + a Top 15 offense is enough to improve the Steelers to 10-6 or 11-5 vs. the 9-7 seasons of 2018 and '19. This (in all likelihood) won't be enough to catch Baltimore for the AFC North title, but it will get the Steelers back to the playoffs for the 1st time since 2017. Once they get to the playoffs, they'll match up with a team they have a fair shot at beating, probably the Bills, Patriots, Colts or even the aforementioned Ravens. With Big Ben under contract through 2021, the Steelers can replace the departure of James Connor with a combination of Benny Snell, a Rookie RB, and/or give a 1 year contract to someone from a LOADED 2021 RB FA class (Todd Gurley, anybody?? Maybe a Marlon Mack??)

2. The Steelers are forced to confront the fact their offense is broken, similarly to what the Los Angeles Chargers did in 2019 by releasing Phillip Rivers, Melvin Gordon, and Ken Whisenhunt. They will finish 3rd in the AFC North, losing a couple times to an up and coming Cleveland Browns team. James Connor will walk in free agency, and the team will look to find trade partners for Juju Smith Schuster 1 year before Free Agency. 

Then, the Steelers will COMPLETELY retool their QB room. First, the Steelers must figure out what the plan is with Big Ben. The Steelers can either: 

A. Coax him into retirement so he finishes his career a Steeler (a la Eli Manning). 

B. Cut Ben and take a $22.5 million dead cap hit (vs. the $41 million they're scheduled to pay him in 2021). 

C. Keep him for 1 final "hoorah" season, only to watch him become the leagues most expensive backup QB in history around Week 7 or 8.

Even if the Steelers choose the 3rd option, I'm going to operate under the assumption they have an empty QB room (Ben will be their version of Case Keenum in 2021). Due to Ben's massive dead cap space, Pittsburgh will enter free agency looking for a QB on a 1 year deal to add to the QB room. 4 really good options for Pittsburgh are Marcus Mariota, Dwayne Haskins, Josh Rosen, and Derek Carr. The Steelers can only take Carr if Gruden is willing to eat some of Carr's salary in a trade for a 3rd Round Pick (a la Nick Foles to Chicago).

After Free Agency, the Steelers will be looking for a QB in the 2021 NFL Draft. In reality, this might happen even if the Steelers make the playoffs in 2020, considering they have no plans for the future of the position. Due to the high demand for Trevor Lawrence and Justin Fields, the Steelers probably won't be able to trade up and get one of those two players, unless they REALLY collapse in 2020 and finish 4-12 (possible, but highly unlikely).

The odds are that Pittsburgh will be drafting from the 2nd crop of QB's from the 2020 class. This includes the likes of NDSU's Trey Lance and Minnesota's Tanner Morgan, along with some other 2020 CFB standouts. While I'm sure these QB's don't entice a ton of optimism for Steelers, Pittsburgh has been such a steady organization that the pick won't be as catastrophic as Haskins in DC or Josh Rosen in Arizona.

And honestly, that's all the Steelers can ask for at this point. They're doing everything in their power to avoid a total rebuild, and they succeeded in doing so on defense, adding Pro Bowlers through the draft at 3 different positions. They've found massive value in guys like Watt, Bud Dupree and Terrell Edmunds.

They just need a respectable offense to be very competitive, and unfortunately the team seems to be a ways away from that. As strange as it may seem, Connor and Juju's tenure in Pittsburgh has reached it's maximum, and they will either have to move on from them or suffer the repercussions of making awful contract mistakes at highly replaceable positions. Ask the Rams, Jaguars, Jets and (soon to be) the Titans about how tough those repercussions are.

Sure, guys like Dionte Johnson, Benny Snell and Chase Claypool are fine pieces, but none of them really jump off the page more than Connor and Juju did back in 2018, and their run together isn't gonna last very long. The Steelers are giving this one more try in 2020, and if it doesn't work, then their broken offense post Killer B's will finally catch up to them and force a Chargers-type overhaul before 2021.

No comments:

Post a Comment