Wednesday, February 17, 2021

The Franchise Tag

 The NFL's Franchise Tag is unlike anything in any other Pro Sports league. An NFL team can have exclusive negotiating rights with one of their star impending Free Agents, paying them top 5 money at their position if they can't come to a long-term deal. The power of the Franchise Tag has become an amazing bargaining tool as NFL teams move into a new way of thinking about roster construction.

The term "Franchise Tag" has entered the NFL fan's lexicon over the past few offseasons, specifically when it comes to key players like Kirk Cousins and Dak Prescott looking for long-term contracts. This is not a coincidence: The Franchise Tag is being used like never before in the NFL.

When the Franchise Tag started in 2009, teams were more than eager to use the Franchise tag as a 1-year extension. In 2012, a record 19 teams used the franchise tag, extending none of those players to long-term contracts. Teams were using the Franchise tag just for the sake that they could. 

Some of the examples were rather strange, in hindsight. The Chargers gave Darren Sproles a franchise tag in 2009. The Jaguars franchise-tagged Josh Scobee during that same offseason. The Dolphins gave the tag to somebody named Randy Starks, and Washington gave a Franchise Tag to some guy named Fred Davis, a Tight End who never made a single Pro Bowl.

Teams finally got strategic about when to use the Franchise Tag. In 2013, the number of Franchise tags went from 19 to 8. In 2014 and 2015, that number was 6 Franchise Tags each year. 

As the years went on, teams decided that they should use a Franchise tag on a player as a negotiating tactic for a long-term contract. The man who set this trend in motion was none other than Jerry Jones, who gave Dez Bryant a Franchise Tag in 2015, only to sign him to a 5 year contract weeks later for less than $70 million, at the time a record but less than what people thought Dez was worth.

All of a sudden, 4 of the 9 Franchise Tagged players got long-term extensions in 2016. In 2017, only 5 players got a Franchise Tag, two of which signed long-term extensions (A 3rd was LeVeon Bell, who sat out the whole season).

By 2019, all 6 players who got Franchise-Tagged were either traded or signed to long-term extensions before Week 1 of the 2019 NFL season. 

The changing math around long-term commitments changes again around this time, which can be mostly attributed to 3 main shifts:

A. The Kirk Cousins Experience B. The Rise of "Long Term Cap Flexibility" C. Declining Value of the 1st Round Pick

Let's start off with the Kirk Cousins experience. Cousins played his 5th and 6th seasons in Washington under the Franchise Tag. Cousins made it his ultimate goal to hit Free Agency, since no Franchise Quarterbacks ever ended up hitting Free Agency. Those two seasons netted Cousins nearly $50 million, at the time making him the 2nd Highest Paid QB in the NFL, and Cousins got the most guaranteed money in NFL History in a Free Agency deal with the Minnesota Vikings.

Kirk Cousins' situation proved that two things: A. Teams can't help themselves from spending in Free Agency. B. The Franchise Tag was a viable way to get an extra year or two on your largest contract window. All of a sudden, players were content to play out the Franchise Tag because Kirk Cousins proved that somewhere, somehow, some team would be desperate enough to still pay out a record-setting contract in Free Agency.

From a management standpoint, the 1-year contract was becoming a viable option to maintaining this newly important goal of "long-term salary cap flexibility". The most recent model of roster construction says that teams can always find a way around the NFL salary cap. Signing long term extensions with opt-outs for teams is a new norm, and many teams find themselves $30 million, $50 million, even $95 million over the cap headed into offseasons (such as the New Orleans Saints are right now). Teams have continued to push the envelope, and with strategic releases, dead cap hits, and trades, NFL Franchises can spend big and still stay within the salary cap rules season-to-season.

As a result, the Franchise Tag become a viable model for roster construction. For example, the Tampa Bay Buccaneers will likely Franchise-tag Chris Godwin this offseason. They have $21 million in cap space. However, they have budgeted in an extra franchise tag because, last offseason, the Buccaneers Franchise tagged edge rusher Shaq Barrett for $16 million. Godwin's Franchise Tag this year.... $15.8 million. Instead of worrying about Godwin, the Buccaneer's focus can be intensely on resigning Shaq Barrett, which they most likely will. However, if Shaq Barrett had played poorly this year, the Bucs could've let him go and transferred his Franchise tag money from 2020 on to Godwin, whom they can also take another year to evaluate before resigning him.

The Franchise Tag strategy has become an effective form of roster construction for NFL Front Offices across the league. More players are staying on the Franchise tag because, quite frankly, teams simply aren't trading high draft picks for these players anymore. In 2019, the season where every tagged player was either traded/resigned, the 3 players who were traded were all worth 1st Round Picks. 

The Chiefs got a 1st Round Pick from San Fransisco for Dee Ford. The Seahawks got a 1st Round Pick from the Chiefs for Frank Clark. The Texans could've gotten a 1st Rounder or High 2nd Rounder for Jadeveon Clowney, but team pastor Jack Easterby traded him for a 3rd Round Pick and Barkavious Mingo just to get rid of him.

Teams would rather tag and hang onto their own Franchise players instead of trading for new ones. And more teams than ever before are Franchise Tagging players: Last offseason, 15 players received a Franchise Tag, up from that 6 number in 2019, and only 1 player got a long-term contract extension. Another, Yannick Ngaokue, got traded twice and still will probably get the Franchise Tag this offseason.

In this year's season, 15 or so players are slated to receive the Franchise Tag, from Dak Prescott Hasson Reddick to Kenny Golladay to repeat players like Dak Prescott, Justin Simmons, and Ngakoue. That number could give or take 2 players (Allen Robinson is a question mark move, as is Aaron Jones in Green Bay). But the Franchise Tag market in 2021 is unique vs anything we've seen in the NFL, as this offseason promises to be.

No comments:

Post a Comment