Tuesday, March 9, 2021

17 Player Franchise Tag Crash Course

 The NFL's Franchise Tag deadline has come and gone. 9 Players received a Franchise Tag before today's deadline, with about 4-5 players hitting Free Agency who could've gotten the Franchise Tag today. While I am personally opposed to the whole concept of the Franchise Tag, it's interesting to analyze these moves from a roster-building standpoint.

Here's a crash course of the 17 moves we saw in the NFL, broken down into 4 different tiers.

Franchise Tagged: Not batting an eye

Jaguars OT Cam Johnson: Johnson is going to get a nice pay raise from this Franchise Tag. Even if many didn't see the move coming, it's the Jaguars and a pretty solid Offensive Lineman. Moving on.

Giants DT Leonard Williams: There was little indication that Williams and the Giants would get a long-term deal done. Williams will probably play 2021 on the Franchise Tag and hit Free Agency next year.

Washington OG Brandon Scherff: Washington and their star RG should have a deal done in the coming days/weeks for Top 3 money at the position. Scherff is great, and he'll be paid as such. The two sides just needed more time to get the deal done.

Panthers OT Taylor Moton: Moton had an amazing season at the perfect time. There was never any question he would get the Franchise Tag and play on the Franchise Tag.

Broncos S Justin Simmons: Simmons was never going to hit Free Agency, and it's still up in the air on whether or not Simmons gets a 4 or 5-year contract from the Broncos. If not, he'll get that big contract in Free Agency next year.

Franchise Tagged: Surprising Moves of the Day

Bears WR Allen Robinson: ARob has been a huge bright spot on a crappy Bears offense for years. All indications seemed that Robinson wanted to hit Free Agency, securing the 2nd big contract of his career at 27 years old. The Bears ended up tagging Allen Robinson today, which can't make Robinson a happy camper.

Robinson is still a candidate for a tag-and-trade situation, but it appears that Robinson will be a Bear for 2021. Robinson has been resistant to signing a long-term contract with the Bears, so unless the money dramatically changes, Robinson will be stuck in an ugly situation with a team that doesn't have a quarterback.

From Chicago's point of view, they couldn't afford to lose Robinson for nothing, right?? They'll get him at a discounted rate for 1 year, but the Franchise tag will push the Bears up against their salary cap threshold. I didn't think Robinson and the Bears would still be together since one party appears interested in a breakup. If Chicago tags-and-trades Robinson, then the move was great for Chicago going forward. If not, it may lead to an unpleasant 2021 for Robinson and the Bears.

Buccaneers WR Chris Godwin: Godwin is one of the biggest losers of Franchise Tag day because he was going to get a record-setting contract in Free Agency. Now, Godwin will play a discounted year for the Buccaneers, still proving his future contract. Godwin proved his worth in 2019 and 2020, but now he may have to prove it again in 2021. This is one of the textbook cases for why Franchise Tags shouldn't exist: Godwin may lose tens of millions of dollars from this 2021 tag.

Jets S Marcus Maye: Maye's Franchise Tag makes a lot of sense for both parties, but Maye wasn't a player most people had plagued as a Franchise tag kind of player. Maye is still young enough where this can work out wonderfully for him heading into 2021, but also move him into the middle class before next year. I think Maye is best served to get that long-term deal with the Jets since they seem to value him above market value.

Saints S Marcus Williams: Nobody saw this move coming at the start of the day. The Saints may work out an extension with Williams, and they may trade him for cap space/draft picks. There are still so many questions in store for the Saints offseason at large.

No Franchise Tag: Not Batting an Eye

Seahawks RB Chris Carson: The Seahawks don't plan to spend big money on the RB position, thus Carson and the team will head their separate ways after 4 years

Packers RB Aaron Jones: While Jones and the Packers may have been candidates for a Franchise Tag, today felt like the culmination of months of rumors confirming the Packers wouldn't be bringing Jones back. On to Miami Jones shall goes.

Patriots OG Joe Thuney: The Patriots don't plan to pay big money for Thuney. It doesn't seem to be their gameplan except with Kickers. They traded for Trent Brown today, which sealed Joe Thuney's free agent fate in stone early this morning.

Steelers LB Bud Dupree: Dupree tore his ACL while playing on the Franchise Tag (reason #13271 why the Franchise tag sucks) in 2020. The Steelers are strapped for cap space, and Dupree will get a nice deal from a team like the Giants or Jaguars in Free Agency.

No Franchise Tag: Surprising Moves of the Day

Lions WR Kenny Golladay: #FreeKennyGolladay has come true. Golladay had no intention of staying in Detroit, but it was still up in the air over whether or not Detroit would tag Golladay. Fortunately for everyone (NFL Fans included), Golladay will be the big money Free Agent available this offseason for whoever is ready to pony up $80 million.

Chargers TE Hunter Henry: The Chargers tagged Henry last offseason, and Henry didn't quite produce at a high level in 2021. Still, his $12.1 million Franchise tag number was fairly reasonable, and the Chargers decided to go to a draft/cheaper route at the TE position. The purging of the old Chargers, from Philip Rivers to Melvin Gordon and Anthony Lynn, is completed with the Free Agency of Henry.

Buccaneers LB Shaq Barrett: The Bucs tagged Barrett last offseason, then tagged Chris Godwin this offseason. While Barrett and Godwin are both gigantic Free Agents this offseason, I genuinely thought the Bucs would risk losing Godwin to keep Barrett under a 2nd Franchise Tag. My guess is that Barrett will get a record-setting deal from another team, but the Bucs should be in the market for Barrett regardless of his non-tag today.

Titans TE Jonnu Smith: Smith was passed up for a $9 million Franchise Tag, and the Titans don't really have an in-house option to replace Smith. While I'm really happy Smith will get to reach Free Agency, I don't know why the Titans didn't tag Smith for a reasonable cap hit.

No comments:

Post a Comment