Sunday, May 30, 2021

Brown Turnaround: How "The Process" Fixed America's Most Broken Sports Franchise

In the NFL record books, Sashi Brown will go down as the worst General Manager in the History of the NFL. For a sport where success is determined (rather incompletely) by Wins and Losses, Sashi Brown was the worst among them all. In his 2 seasons as Cleveland Browns GM, only a 45 Field Goal caught in the December wind of Northeast Ohio prevented Sashi Brown from never winning a game in Cleveland. 

He officially finished 1-28 as Browns General Manager, but colloquially, Sashi Brown is the GM who led the Browns to a 1-31 record, the worst stretch of Football by any NFL Franchise since the Tampa Bay Buccaneers lost their first 26 games as a Franchise in the late 1970s.

Yet, what Sashi Brown and now Browns GM Andrew Berry, whom Brown hired in Cleveland, exposed a "market inefficiency" in the NFL: That while Football itself is a finite game; with defined rules, agreed objectives, and clear winners and losers, the NFL is an infinite game. There is no "winning" at being a GM or an NFL Head Coach. It's all about advancing to the next week, the next Free Agency or Scouting Combine. 

Who's ever heard of the coach that wins a Super Bowl at 50 and says "Alright, I've accomplished everything. That's it for me." There's always the next season, and those who drop out don't wish to continue in this field (totally understandable). In infinite games, the "Process" is far more important than any wins and losses, and the Cleveland Browns' "Process" broke a 25-year drought in the NFL by simply doing things differently than they'd ever done them before.

The Browns had never been the same since their Franchise moved to Baltimore in 1996. The organization still hasn't won a Division title since the Reagan administration, and apart from one Butch Davis playoff game in 2002, the Franchise had been nothing but a doormat since Al Lerner paid $530 million to recreate the Browns in 1998.

That trend continued when Jimmy Haslam purchased a majority stake in the Cleveland Browns in 2012. It was more of the same for the Browns: A franchise with little direction that was able to win 4, 5, or 6 games. Every 5 or so years, the Browns would naturally accumulate enough talent (since it's almost impossible to stay bad in the NFL) to win 7 games or even have a magical 10 win season with Derek Anderson at Quarterback. Then, they'd tear it down again, with the guise of "rebuilding" when the franchise was really shedding salary to save money and be terrible and profitable again.

The Browns had some laughable "only in Cleveland" moments with Jimmy Haslam as owner. From a Homeless man convincing him to sign Johnny Manziel in 2014, to the Bengals botching an AJ McCarron trade that would've had Cleveland trading a 2nd and 3rd Round Pick, to accidentally playing porn across all of the TV's in their Office. The Browns were the same dysfunctional Browns with no direction and being mismanaged for years and years.

The Browns were a Franchise nobody wanted to take on. Most of their hires had to come from developing their own talent since they were likely to get underqualified or desperate candidates from other NFL Franchises. Fortunately for Cleveland, Sashi Brown was an "analytical guy" from the only Franchise worse than the Cleveland Browns: The Jacksonville Jaguars. Brown was hired in Cleveland right after Jimmy Haslem bought the Browns in 2012. He was an underling in Cleveland during the forgettable tenures of Pat Shurmur, Rob Chudzinski, and Mike Pettine in Cleveland.

The Browns were making boneheaded mistakes all throughout those 5 years. In 2011, the Greatest Draft Class of the last 20 years, the Browns traded down and lost out on the pick that became Julio Jones, while JJ Watt and Tyron Smith were on the board. They got nothing of substance in return, and it's widely regarded as one of the worst trades in NFL History. They traded up to #3 and Picked Trent Richardson in 2012. Then took Barkavious Mingo #6 overall in 2013. Then picked Johnny Manziel in 2014. They went from Brady Quinn to Colt McCoy to Brandon Weeden to 5 other QB's I don't have time to name in a 4 year period. Yet STILL, the Browns won 7 games in 2014 under Mike Pettine, which is a testament to the NFL's ability to legislate parity in their sport.

After the 2015 season, Sashi Brown took over as the defacto GM of the Browns. His job title, coming off a 3-13 season where the Browns cleared the house, was essentially just "Primary Decision Maker". The Browns had the #2 Pick in the Draft. The Browns were very clearly in Offseason 1 of a 2-3 year rebuild, a death sentence for an incoming GM in Cleveland. What Sashi Brown did with that #2 Pick would come to define Sashi Brown's tenure in Cleveland: Royally f*ck things up, but make moves that reflect a "Process" that would one day bring success to the Browns. 

How long that would take was anyone's guess, and that's how the infinite game works. The Browns may have been playing the infinite game poorly, but at least they were finally playing the right game for the 1st time. The Browns had a Plan.

Being years away from competitive Football, Sashi Brown deferred his draft picks to future seasons. Cleveland traded down to #8 with the Eagles. They netted an extra 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th Round Draft Pick across the next 2 drafts. Then, Sashi Brown traded down AGAIN, this time from Pick #8 to Pick #15 with the Titans, who had a ton of Picks to work with after trading with the Rams for the 1st Overall Pick. The Titans got Jack Conklin and the Eagles got Carson Wentz. Cleveland ended up with Corey Coleman, whom they would cut in 2018 after he went ape shit on Hard Knocks. Not great. (It does look a little better in hindsight, given Carson's struggles and the fact that, ironically, Jack Conklin is now the star RT for the Cleveland Browns)

The Browns acquired 5 additional picks for that One #2 Pick, which is really important to remember here. According to the Sam Hinkie school of thought, nobody is "smarter" at drafting than anyone else in this sport. Everyone has their share of busts, and lots of bad organizations luck their way into Hall Of Famers. The Bills got lucky in landing Josh Allen at Pick #7, but they also traded the Pick that became Patrick Mahomes one year earlier.

If the NFL Draft is like a game of darts, and everyone is working with the same skill level, then you're the best chance of winning the game is to get as many darts on the board as possible. Accumulate as many chances as possible is an effective strategy for rebuilding a young core through the Draft. Some of them may bust, but some will also be diamonds in the rough. Sashi Brown and Jimmy Haslem were embarking on their own version of the Sam Hinkie Process, and they already started by turning the #2 Pick, a great chance at scoring a bullseye on one throw, into 6 different darts to try and hit the bullseye. (or a triple 20, since that's the most valuable point in Darts)

The Browns walked away with 14 hits at the board in the 2016 Draft. That's the most draft picks by any NFL team in the 21st Century!!!! This was also coming off a 2015 Draft where the Browns led the NFL with 12 Draft Picks. That's 26 Picks in a 2-year span, an NFL Record.

The Browns turned those 14 picks into almost nothing but busts, led by the two Coleman's (Corey and 3rd Round Pick Shon Coleman), Cody Kessler, Emmanuel Ogbah, and Carl Nassib. The final two have gone on to have solid careers outside Cleveland, just as Cleveland has picked up some solid players from the scrap heaps of other NFL teams. Such is the process of filling out a 52 man roster in the NFL.

The Browns were still trying to play the "Sam Hinkie Game" better than any NFL team, even if none of those Draft Picks from those seasons ended up being higher than Pick #15. 

And THAT problem was going to be fixed across the next 2 seasons. The infamous 1-31 run of Browns Football overseen by Sashi Brown. The best way to get your team turned around was to land the #1 Pick in a year that has a once-every-5-years talent. The Jaguars took advantage of this to perfection last year when they traded Jalen Ramsey, stripped their roster bare, and lost enough games to land a once-in-5-years QB like Trevor Lawrence. Washington did it in 2019 when they landed once-in-5-years defensive talent Chase Young with the #2 Pick.

The Cleveland Browns Have Never Lost As Many Games As They Did in 2016.....

And They've Never Had a Player As Talented As Myles Garrett In Their Franchise History.

This is the trade-off of building a young core through the Draft, one you can later complement with Big-Money Free Agents to build a Championship Team. The Browns were in the market for one of those once-in-a-generation (I define generations as 5 years) players. And odds were if they got the #1 Pick twice, they were almost certain to get one of those players.

The Browns entered the 2017 NFL Draft with 10 Picks, one of them set to be Myles Garrett. They had the Eagles' #12 Pick from the Wentz Trade and a Titans 2nd Round Pick from the Conklin Trade, along with their own Draft Picks.

What did the Browns do?? They traded down for MORE hits on the board.

The Texans were looking for a QB in the 2017 Draft. After Patrick Mahomes was picked at #10, the Texans had to go up and make a move. Once the Saints drafted Marshon Lattimore, the Texans parted with their #25 Pick and the Texans 2018 1st Round Pick (remember this pick for later on). The Browns used that #25 Pick to take Jabrill Peppers, then traded back up into the 1st Round to pick David Njoku.

After doing business with the Texans for Watson, the Texans were desperate to offload Brock Osweiler's contract of 3 years and $45 million. They attached their 2018 2nd Round Pick to Osweiler's contract and sent him to Cleveland. The Browns used cap space they weren't going to spend as an asset, buying a valuable pick for $40 million.

Sashi spent his bonus pick from the Titans at #52 to draft the most peculiar pick of this entire rebuild: QB Deshon Kizer from Notre Dame.

What Brown did to Deshon Kizer's career is one of the downsides of these long "Process" style rebuilds. Brown took Kizer as a "flyer" a bonus hit on the board where, if Kizer got lucky, the Browns might have a solid QB for the future. The Browns rolled out RGIII in 2016, and they didn't have a QB beside 3rd Rounder Cody Kessler on the roster next year. Kizer was drafted and given a 15-week "sink or swim" chance in the NFL with a roster where they're 3 best players had never played an NFL game.

Kizer went 0-15 as Browns quarterback. Myles Garrett only played 9 games in a season where their best player was Duke Johnson. They had signed no Free Agents, kept no holdovers from the Mike Pettine regime. The Browns were a team of 3rd and 4th Round Picks who were either rejects from other teams, soon to be on other teams, or soon to be out of the NFL. It was the closest thing to a minor league Football team as has ever existed, and the Browns went 0-16. 

Sashi Brown was fired, but Head Coach Hue Jackson got to stay for half of next season and the most memorable Hard Knocks in NFL History.

The Cleveland Browns were a laughing stock, and their Process needed more time. John Dorsey, the fired GM of the Chiefs, came in to reset everything to "order" in Cleveland, which meant changing the "Process" in Cleveland.

The good news for John Dorsey and company: Sashi Brown's Process had left them with a treasure chest of assets for the 2018 NFL Draft. The Houston Texans got a Superstar in Deshaun Watson, but he tore his ACL in October of his rookie season. The Texans bottomed out. They went 4-12 in 2017, and their 1st Round Pick turned into the #4 Pick in the NFL Draft. Remember the Brock Osweiler Pick: That turned into the #35 Pick in the NFL Draft, a 1st Round Talent at 2nd Round Prices. And the Browns also had the #1 Pick and #33 Picks for all their losing. The Browns could draft Franchise changing players at multiple positions if they hit right.

Sashi Brown's losing and careful trading came together with John Dorsey's Excellent Draft Selections to create the Draft Class that changed the Cleveland Browns forever:

#1 Pick Baker Mayfield

#4 Pick Denzel Ward

#33 Pick Austin Corbett (Now Playing for the Los Angeles Rams)

#35 Pick Nick Chubb

An All-Pro Cornerback, 1,500 Yard Running Back, and Franchise Quarterback ended up turning around the Browns' fortunes immediately. The Browns also swindled the Dolphins out of Jarvis Landry, only parting with a 4th Round Pick to land the 2x Pro Bowl WR.

They went 7-8-1 in that dysfunctional Hard Knocks 2018 season. The Browns traded their #17 Pick and Jabrill Peppers, whom they acquired from the Deshaun Watson trade, to the New York Giants for Odell Beckham Jr. The Browns were the leading pick to make the Super Bowl in Vegas going into 2019. They hired Freddie Kitchens as coach and.....

Everything went to shit. The Browns finished 6-10. Myles Garrett hit Mason Rudolph with his own helmet. It was just like every Browns team before. 

Except for this time it wasn't, and that started with the Owner who had earned a reputation as the kook that was ruining the Browns.

This is where our story takes a detour 2 hours Southwest to Columbus. While the Cleveland Browns were enduring losing season after losing season, the MLS's Columbus Crew were fighting off relocation to Austin, Texas (which in hindsight might've been a good idea for the MLS). 

The economy of Columbus is built on Ohio State University, and Ohio State is their NFL and NBA team. In the downtown, they do have an MLS team and an NHL team, the Columbus Blue Jackets, who most people forget even play in the same city as Ohio State University.

But, when the MLS was fighting to move their team, the city fought back. They demanded the team sell to another owner who would be willing to help invest in a new MLS stadium for the Columbus Crew. That owner ended up being none other than Jimmy Haslam.

Haslam married into a business of trucking stops and Gas pumps that, across 4 decades, he helped turned into a multi-billion company that later sold to Marathon. Haslam had no ties to the Cleveland area or Ohio, but the Browns were the only team he had a chance of purchasing to enter the elusive NFL circles. Why he was interested in keeping the Crew in Columbus is really interesting, but unknown.

Haslam was a very hands-off owner with the Columbus Crew while trying to stay involved in the process of the Cleveland Browns. Haslam lives in Cleveland and also lives in his hometown/college town of Knoxville, Tennessee. Haslam basically told his Soccer people "I'm gonna help you stay in Columbus, but you do you". Then, 2 years into his ownership, something unbelievable happened.

So, as Freddie Kitchens and John Dorsey were getting the can, the Columbus Crew started winning and winning a lot. Then the COVID-19 Pandemic happened and the season was put on pause. The Crew came back from COVID and did very well in the "MLS is Back" tournament. They qualified for the expanded playoffs as the 3rd seed in the Eastern Conference. They beat New York in the 1st Round, while the #1 and #2 seeds, Philadelphia and defending Champions Toronto FC, lost in 1st Round Upsets. The Crew then got Nashville in the 2nd Round and won. Then they beat New England to advance to the MLS Cup Final. They were underdogs against the Seattle Sounders and beat the shit out of Seattle 3-0. 

In their 2nd season under Jimmy Haslam, the Columbus Crew were MLS Champions. The same Jimmy Haslem who was ruining the Cleveland Browns. Haslem's hands-off approach may have had something to do with it, and 2 months later, he would see his success replicated in Cleveland.

The Browns under Kevin Stefanski went 11-5 last year, breaking an 18-year playoff drought. They destroyed their long-time rivals Pittsburgh in the Wild Card Round, winning their 1st Playoff Game since 1994. They were one Chad Henne 3rd and 15 away from beating the Chiefs in the Final 8, putting them 1 game away from the Super Bowl. The Browns have a great team again.

The core of the Browns team came from Sashi Brown's Picks, and new GM Andrew Berry, who was behind Sashi Brown during those rebuilding seasons from 2016-2017, got a lot of credit for polishing the team off in his 1st season.

Now, the sky is the limit in Cleveland. There are no longer talks of a team that is stuck in the mud. The Browns long nightmare is a thing of the past. They started playing the right game, got better along the way as they learned more, and now they want to make that final push from relevancy to elite. 

The Sashi Brown rebuild took a lot of winding turns, and it involved more losing and bad draft picks than anyone in NFL history. But there is no doubt that the Browns are better off for it. They won a playoff game!!

The thing about the infinite game is that we can't put a time frame on these things. They are all about advancing in a game where others above us drop out and choose not to keep playing. The Browns kept advancing across a half-decade, through 5 Head Coaches, 3 GM's, and a handful of bad mistakes. 

Yet here they are, ready to unleash a really fun team through the NFL.

No comments:

Post a Comment