Sunday, August 1, 2021

Where the Raiders Stand Post-Rebuild

Last July, I did a 2 year report card about Jon Gruden's tenure with the Las Vegas Raiders.

Now, 1 year later, Gruden is starting to lose my patience. The Raiders are now into Year 4 of Gruden's 3 year rebuild, and it looks like the Raiders roster got appreciably worse since the last time we were here. The Raiders salary cap space has been used on poor contract after bad contract. Some of those draft picks we were really optimistic about in 2020 haven't quite panned out the way we thought (Maxx Crosby, for example). And the Raiders didn't exactly make an effort to replace Derek Carr, essentially lobbing him into a QB purgatory situation without a roster ready to make a deep playoff run.

So, 12 months after our Raiders' Report Card, it's time to reevaluate where Jon Gruden and company stand headed into a period where, theoretically, their rebuild is complete.

Here's the Grades on the Raiders' Rebuild from July 14th, 2020.

Accumulating Assets: A
Resetting the Salary Cap: B
Figuring out your QB: If a rookie QB starts Week 1 2021: A
                                     If Derek Carr starts Week 1 2021: F

Obviously, Derek Carr is going to be the Raiders' starting QB in Week 1, and while Marcus Mariota is getting a lot of money as a high-end backup, he isn't quite what I was thinking as a Backup plan. While saying an 'F' to Derek Carr might be harsh, there is some truth behind this disappointment for the Raiders.

Carr is the Raiders' highest-paid player. He's been the Highest Paid Raider for each of Jon Gruden's 4 seasons as coach. Next year, he will make just over $22 million, making him the 8th Highest paid QB in the NFL. This means, in the simplest terms possible, the Raiders are getting poor value for Derek Carr, since you'd be hard pressed to find anyone arguing Derek Carr is a Top 10 QB in the NFL. Top 15, probably, but even Stafford struggles to crack that Top 10.

Derek Carr is a QB whose play correlates with the rosters he's given. When having a Playoff Roster in 2016?? He finished T-3rd in the MVP and got his 5 year, $125 million contract extension. And with a roster torn apart by Jon Gruden, Carr finished 27th in QBR for a Raiders team that went 4-12.

In 2020, the Raiders finished 9th in the AFC. Derek Carr had the 7th Highest QBR in the AFC, just ahead of Ben Roethlisberger and Philip Rivers, subpar QB's that made the playoffs with stacked defenses and skill position players.

Carr is a starting QB in the NFL for a decade, and he's also an unremarkable starter. He's a QB who, across the last 25 years of NFL history, typically plays for 4 franchises across 13 seasons until he ends up on a really crappy team and becomes a high-end backup. His career projects more like Matt Schaub than it does Matt Ryan, who has a borderline case for the Hall of Fame. And the Raiders gave Derek Carr the same contract as Matt Ryan back in 2017, after Ryan was coming off an MVP season and another 4,500-yard season.

So, Gruden didn't end up moving off of Derek Carr, despite knowing exactly who he is for years. What about the other two categories??? 

Let's start with Accumulating Assets. Here's my quote from July 14th, 2020 about why the Raiders got an A in this category:

"The Raiders have done a fantastic job in bringing in the young assets. They've had 5 first round picks in the last 2 seasons, and another 5 picks on the 2nd Day of the Draft. They've gotten great payouts from guys like Darren Waller, Damarious Randall and Hunter Renfrow, among others."

With hindsight as our friend, let's go back and look at Jon Gruden's track record with those 10 Draft Picks from the last 2 years:

2018 Draft: Kolton Miller, PJ Hall, Brandon Parker, Arden Key, Nick Nelson

2019 Draft: Clelin Ferrell, Josh Jacobs, Jonathan Abram, Trayvon Mullen, Maxx Crosby (Traded for Antonio Brown w/ Pick that became Steelers WR Diontae Johnson)

2020 Draft: Henry Ruggs, Damon Arnette, Lynn Bowden, Bryan Edwards, Tanner Muse

That comes out to 2 Pro Bowlers (Kolton Miller, Josh Jacobs) 4 NFL Starters (Clelin Ferrell, Maxx Crosby, Jonathan Abram, and Henry Ruggs for now) with a handful of looking-like-busts mixed in (Trayvon Mullen, Damon Arnette, PJ Hall) and one player who Gruden traded before he ever played a game with the Raiders (Lynn Bowden).

The Raiders didn't do terrible with their draft picks, they have Kolton Miller and Josh Jacobs. But the prize of their rebuild was Ferrell, drafted #4 in 2019, and he's looked pretty good, but not remarkable in his time with the Raiders. The duo of Crosby and Ferrell on the edge was ranked #25th in the NFL last year in pressures, and the Raiders signed Yannick Ngakoue this offseason to start over Crosby, a diamond in the rough prospect.

But the Raiders didn't find any gems (so far) with 16 Day 1 and 2 draft picks. With an extra year to evaluate, the Raiders probably come in around a B- or C+ in their "asset accumulation" through the draft. Not bad, but about average.

Now for the Raiders "salary cap reset". Here's what I wrote in 2020:

The Raiders have been great at resetting their books, but not great at NOT spending said money too early. Trent Brown? Fantastic signing!!!! Cory Littleton?? Looks good. Tyrell Williams?? Meeeehhhh... Lamarcus Joyner??? Oh Crap. Antonio Brown???

It gets even worse 1 year later. Of those big-money Free Agents listed above, only Cory Littleton is even still playing for the Raiders!!!

The Raiders felt the wrath of their poor cap management this year. Rodney Hudson was traded to Arizona for a 3rd Round Pick (a bit of an undervalue by Gruden). Gabe Jackson was traded to the Seahawks for a 4th Round Pick. And Trent Brown, who only played 5 games in 2020, was cut loose as a bad contract this offseason.

Las Vegas has been TERRIBLE with Free Agent signings across the past 3 years. So they didn't buy themselves any leeway when they used most of their cap space to sign Ngakoue, at a position they invested tons of draft capital in over the last 2 years, RB Kenyan Drake to backup Pro Bowl Work horse Josh Jacobs, and John Brown to a 1 year deal while letting 2020's #1 WR Nelson Agholor walk in Free Agency.

Some of those moves might work out for the Raiders, since they lack high-end talent right now and Ngakoue has once been a top edge rusher. But the Raiders made a lot of people scratch their heads again, at a time where people have already lost a lot of faith in Jon Gruden's ability to spend money. 

The one thing keeping the Raiders from getting a D or F in salary cap management is this fact: They get a 2nd chance in 2022. The Raiders have set their contracts up where they have $48 million available in Free Agency next offseason, 5th most in the NFL. They also have a path to acquire $20 million more with some cuts/trades, which would only put them only behind the Steelers and Colts in available cap space.

With some smart moves, the Raiders could have a Patriots-esque spending spree next offseason to bolster their roster for 2022. And fortunately for Jon Gruden, his 10 year contract sets him up to still be the one to make the moves next year, at a time when most coaches would be fired after another missed playoff appearance.

I don't think the Raiders can make the playoffs in 2021, and I could see them even ending up with a Top 10 pick. The AFC West got better while they either stayed the same or got worse. And we don't expect Derek Carr to elevate the Raiders to a new ceiling because.... he's just not that QB.

New Raiders 3 Year Report Card:

Asset Acquisition: B-
Salary Cap Management: C-
Figuring out your QB: D

Diagnosis: Gruden probably deserves to be fired, but the Raiders spent so much to get him that he'll get a 2nd chance

No comments:

Post a Comment