Thursday, July 23, 2020

A 16 Team Playoffs in Baseball

Just hours before the opening of the MLB season, the players and MLB agreed to a one time exception to allow the MLB Postseason to have 16 teams in 2020. I suspect this will become an official standard when labor negotiations resume this offseason. Finally, it looks as if the MLB has finally embraced the revenue possibilities and broken off of tradition.

Let me be very clear about this: Any Baseball fans that are opposed to this idea are A. Purists to the fullest extent, which raises a whole separate set of societal issues or B. Haters to the fullest extent. There is no nuance or alternative. Why? Because, plain and simply, this new format is absolutely AMAZING!!

As if Baseball's new 60 game season wasn't already crazy enough, this whole season just got SUPER wacky. In the 1st round, each team will play a 3 game series as the "Wild Card" round, which will then lead into the normal playoffs as we know them before. It's much like the NHL playoffs, and just like the NHL format, anything goes in baseball.

Are the best teams going to win each series?? Of COURSE NOT!!! That wasn't happening even when Baseball had a 10 game Postseason. Every (reasonable) baseball fan agrees that, on paper, the Houston Astros were a far better team than Washington Nationals. Yet, the Nats will host the Yankees to kick off their championship defense today, after a World Series in which the Road team won all 7 games. October Baseball, like the Stanley Cup Playoffs, is totally random.

In this new 16 game playoff, it is inevitable that at least one 14 seed will beat a 3 seed. A 3 game sample size tells us NOTHING about which team is better in a series. But that is precisely what draws casual fans into playoff baseball. When you add stakes to Baseball, there is no sport that gets more intense (Hockey is right up there on the medal stand). Baseball's biggest problem is that for 6 months and 160 games, there are no stakes to the games. Now, a 60 game season changes all that, BECAUSE 60 games is not enough to determine who the best teams in the sport are. It does, however, give us a pretty good idea.

Now, were giving a lot of middle of the pack teams a shot in the postseason. Based on previous results in the Wild Card Era of Baseball, there is a 77% chance 1 team who is the newly created "6-8 seed" will make their League Championship Series. There's a 20% chance 2 "6-8 seeds" make it to the LCS. This is a perfect concoction of chaos, and the biggest winners are the fans who are watching. Why? Because teams that wouldn't normally get the chance now could make a magical run through the postseason.

In 2015, the New York Mets came out of nowhere to win the NL East and, thanks to the heroics of Daniel Murphy, made it to the World Series. They faced off against the Kansas City Royals, who just a year earlier had gone from a 12th inning walk off in a 1 Game Wild Card to Game 7 of the 2014 World Series. Even if that series turned out to be all KC, the buildup was so overwhelming that even ESPN led their programming for 5 days with the World Series (this in the heart of the NFL season).

Now, imagine Mike Trout getting the chance to be the next Daniel Murphy. Or the Cincinnati Reds pulling off a massive upset on the Atlanta Braves in the Wild Card Round. Or, (to my personal delight) the San Diego Padres getting a matchup with the Los Angeles Dodgers in the NLDS. The possibilities are endless, and each and every one provides an enticing situation, simply because anything can happen in October Baseball.

For those who traditionally watch the NBA, where the 1st Round Matchups are just wash over series, Baseball is not the case. The 8 seed very much has a chance to knock off the 1 seed. In the 2019 Stanley Cup Playoffs, all 1 and 2 seeds lost in the 1st Round, and Baseball has just as random odds. The Nationals and Cardinals both won Game 5's on the road to make the NLCS as 4 and 3 seeds, respectively. October Baseball gets crazy, and that is what Baseball hangs it hat on every year for ratings.

Finally, they've made the 2020 season totally random, and everyone will benefit from it.

No comments:

Post a Comment