Monday, July 20, 2020

How Do the 49ers Rebound from Super Bowl LIV

Collectively, our lasting memories of the 2019 NFL season (which, might I mention, feels like an eternity ago) involves Jimmy Garoppolo throwing 4 straight incompletions in a 4 point game. That sequence put the nail in the metaphoric coffin for the San Francisco 49ers, a coffin that was buried in the ground by Damien Williams just 20 seconds later.

Kyle Shanahan has now dropped 2 Super Bowls in the last 4 seasons. 3 years ago, the Falcons biggest question was around how they were going to replace Shanahan and their offensive scheme. The 49ers face no such questions, but they do have a number of lingering concerns around their team. Many of these concerns are out of their control, like trying to remain healthy and navigating the COVID-19 storm. Other questions, like their running back system, creativity in schemes and the volatility of defense year to year, will define how the NFC's model franchise bounces back from a 20 game season ending just 7 minutes short of the Lombardi Trophy.

Being the defending NFC Champions has not been beneficial over the last century. Since 2000, only 1 team has been back-to-back NFC Champs (the Seahawks in 2014). Over the last 14 years, 11 different organizations have represented the NFC in the Super Bowl. Only the Seahawks, Giants and the 49ers themselves have doubled up, but only Joe Staley remained from that Super Bowl 47 team, including the Coaching staff and front office. 

A large part of this trend comes from how deep the NFC has been over the past 10 years. The NFC doesn't have a Patriots-esque team that had a 1st Round Bye every season in the 2010's. They've seen depth that leads to massive turnover among both division winners and Super Bowl representatives. In 2015 it's Cam Newton and the Panthers beating Arizona to go to the Super Bowl. The next year it's Atlanta taking down Green Bay. Then it's the Eagles and Vikings. Then the Rams and the Saints. Then the 49ers slaughtering Green Bay. In the last 5 years, 9 different organizations have played in the NFC Championship Game, and the Packers are the only team to double up. This a testament to just how deep the Conference is.

Unfortunately for San Francisco, the 49ers fit the bill of a defending NFC Champion perfectly. Their offense lacks an elite QB, and lean heavily on Shanahan's schemes. Their team is built on defense, and defense is volatile year after year. This trend has been universally true over the last 5 seasons, which doesn't bode well for the 49ers.

After showing out in 2017, the Eagles and Vikings saw significant regressions on defense in 2018, thus impacting their records by 4 games each. In 2018, the Bears were the gold standard and gave everybody new contracts. They only 5 spots, from 1st to 6th, in 2019, but that lack of firepower exposed their vulnerability on Offense, thus leading to an 8-8 record. The same thing happened with Jacksonville in 2018 following an AFC Championship Game appearance in 2017.

Even the Legion of Boom, who went to the Super Bowl in back to back seasons, fell apart in 2015. Fortunately for the Seahawks, they had an immensely talented QB there to help cushion the landing.

The bright side for San Francisco: This defense reminds me a lot of the 1 defense that bucked this trend: The Denver Broncos "No Fly Zone". They are young enough that they didn't have to replace many pieces, and the ones they did had a lot of depth at the position. Big money Free Agent Kwon Alexander might struggle to find the field with the emergence of Fred Warner. Solomon Thomas still finds himself behind Dee Ford and Arik Armstead (The 49ers tried trading Ford, with not much luck).

Their offense gives me more hope that the Trevor Siemian-led team the Broncos walked out with for not 1, but 2 SEASONS. Last year, Kyle Shanahan had the golden touch, I don't think he ever made a bad play call. But, by the end of the season it became evident the gameplan was to hide Jimmy G for 3 quarters and jam the ball down the other teams throat. And it worked PERFECTLY.... until Patrick Mahomes completed a 45 yard pass on 3rd and 15 to Tyreek Hill, blowing up their cool, calm collective nature. 

Shanahan can't bring the same strategy to every game, because it's impossible for the 49ers to dominate equally talented teams for a quarter. Last year's Saints game gives credence to the fact that Shanahan can outcoach, outthink and outplay-call any coach in the game, and I anticipate he will do the same next year. With that being said, it would be wrong to take that level of dominance for granted, no matter how talented his roster is.

The NFC West is going through a transition period. Traditional powers are having to find new ways to retool on the fly (Seahawks, Rams) and new powers are emerging slowly but steadily (Cardinals). This should leave the 49ers in a position to control the present. The question then becomes their standing within the rest of the conference. 

How does a healthy Cowboys offense stack up against that defense?? Or what about a Falcons defense that strikes a minimal level of fear?? And the game of the year will be the 49ers rematch against the one team we know to be equally talent to them: The Saints.

Making it back to the Super Bowl will be a tall task for San Francisco. If I were a betting man, I wouldn't like my odds. However, they are still one of, if not the best team on paper, so they will get a fighting chance at repeating. And their cap space puts them in an good position, despite bad contracts for Kwon Alexander, Jerrick McKinnon and, dare I say, Jimmy Garoppolo.

Time will tell what the 49ers will look like, but anything short of the Super Bowl will feel like a wasted season for a team starting to feel a few pounds from the everlasting weight of expectation. 

No comments:

Post a Comment