Monday, October 5, 2020

The Eagles have failed Carson Wentz

 I'm just gonna be frank with this one: The way the Philadelphia Eagles have treated QB Carson Wentz is a downright abomination. The Eagles have not been a competitive football team, trotting in at 1-2-1 after the 49ers gave them a game back with Duck Hodges--- I mean Nick Mullens. The Eagles WR core is the greatest NFL atrocity since Andrew Luck had to spend 3 seasons in 2015-17 behind the Colts O-Line. Wentz is in a strange purgatory among the NFL's generational talents, the same way Derrick Rose was in the NBA after 2013, and how Andrew Luck was preceding his retirement.

The reason the Eagles are 1-2-1, instead of 3-1, is the play of Wentz. He has the worst QBR among all NFL QB's, including Daniel Jones. He has thrown 4 TD's and 6 INT's on the season. The Eagles are paying him $110 million guaranteed. Wentz will get better as the season progresses, this is guaranteed. At the same time, as Wentz starts playing better the Eagles will start to lose more games.

How is this possible, you may ask? This is the result of a strange trend known as the "Post Super Bowl Blues", where franchises have to make tough decisions about which pieces of a championship core get extended. Most GM's in the NFL are prone to risk aversion, and they pay as many of their safe players as are willing to resign. For the Eagles, this included Malcom Jenkins, Alshon Jeffery, Jason Kelce, Brandon Brooks, Jason Peters, Lane Johnson, and Tim Jernigan. 

When a team extends a great player, they extend the position they play on their roster. Once these players get paid, they no longer provide value to the team, only their expectations. Example #1: If Lane Johnson is the #2 Highest Paid LT in the NFL, he can only equal the value he's being paid by being one of the 2 best LT in the league. When Lane Johnson tears his ACL, or Brandon Brooks tears his Achilles, they still get paid. Now, the LT position is costing the Eagles $20 million in 2020 while being filled by Jordan Mailata, who ranks as PFF #40 Tackle in 2020. Conclusion: The Eagles are paying Top 2 Money for the #40 Tackle in the NFL.

This problem extends well beyond the Eagles, and I'll list some of those teams in a bit. This problem has hit the Eagles especially hard in the last 3 seasons. Example 2: The Eagles paying #3 RG money in the NFL for Matt Pryor, the #27 G in the league. Example 3: Paying Top 10 WR money for Alshon Jeffery, which has now become Greg Ward and 3 Practice Squad Players.

At the same time, the Eagles gave their QB a record setting 2nd contract. This is the ultimate sign of A. Your belief in building a champion around this QB or B. Your risk adverse tendencies and extending someone who can't play up to what their being paid. In the case of Wentz, he falls under an unprecedented C category, because his situation hasn't been all black and white.

The Best Example in the last Decade of an A team is the Indianapolis Colts. Ryan Grinson was hired in 2012 as the Colts GM, and inherited the #1 Pick that led to Andrew Luck. The Colts were flushed with Cap Space to sign Free Agents, had tons of openings for Rookies to develop and grow. When all 3 of those things are combined with the NFL's unique ability to legislate parity, it's a guarantee that your team will be good within 3 years, even if Mitchell Trubisky or Jared Goff are your QB. 

When you have an elite QB under a rookie contract, it's almost impossible for a GM to mess up. Even when you trade a 1st Round Pick for Trent Richardson. The Colts made an AFC Championship Game in 2014, then all fell apart very quickly. The Colts had little available cap space, and an Offensive Line that was either old or injured or both. For 2 seasons, Grinson simply refused to address the Offensive Line, in part bc he had no money (Luck got a $25 mil a year contract extension, a record at that time for both dollars and % of cap) and because he did a poor job at drafting (Drafting Philip Dorsett and Djoun Smith in 2015, combined with the aforementioned Richardson Trade).

As a result, Andrew Luck was sacked more times in 2 seasons than any QB in the NFL. The Colts limped to 7-9 in 2016, Grinson was fired, and Andrew Luck had botched surgery that ended his 2017 season before it even started. Chris Ballard was hired and, after all of the bad contracts expired, purged the salary cap and had one of the best drafts in NFL History (Quenton Nelson and Darius Leonard w/ your 1st and 2nd Picks). All in all, Luck retired bc the Colts ruined his shoulder and love for the game all at once.

There are infinite examples of B teams and their QB's. In fact, most of the QB contracts handed out in the post Jay Cutler/Joe Flacco contracts are teams paying whatever it took for the safe option. Philip Rivers, Ben Roethlisberger, Matthew Stafford, Derek Carr, Jimmy Garoppolo, Kirk Cousins, Cam Newton, Matt Ryan, and Jared Goff were all the #1 Paid QB's in the NFL. Every single one of their contracts made their GM's lives infinitely harder. The reason those contracts kept being handed out was because, as strange as it seems, those contracts helped all those GM's buy more time at the job. All of the aforementioned QB's were paid because your favorite team's GM's goal was to keep their job, not to win a Super Bowl.

The only QB's who's big contracts that pay out are the 4-5 who's game transcends roster: The truly elite talents of the sport. We're talking about Andrew Luck, Patrick Mahomes, Russell Wilson, Deshaun Watson and Aaron Rodgers. It is only for those HOF talents where we can start talking about paying them at market value.

Which brings us back to Wentz. Less you had forgotten, Carson Wentz in 2017 was "The White Patrick Mahomes". He was Patrick Mahomes before Patrick Mahomes. Wentz had over 3,200 passing yards, 300 rushing yards, 33 TD's and only 7 INT's. He also did that in 12 GAMES!!!! He was the lock for MVP, the Eagles were the #1 seed and would've won the Super Bowl with him instead of Nick Foles. He was a Torn ACL from being MVP, Super Bowl Champ, and Super Bowl MVP at 23 years old. Mahomes didn't accomplish all that until he was 24.

His 2018 Eagles team wasn't nearly as healthy as 2017, and Wentz hurt his back after 13 games. At that point, the Eagles lasting memories were of Wentz and his Mahomes level gifts on display in 2017. Wentz was truly an elite QB, and if healthy he could recapture that again. Just the hope of Wentz recapturing that Mahomes-before-Mahomes ability should've been enough to sign him to a record contract. Howie Roseman and the Eagles were one of the lucky ones. They drafted one of the 2-3 QB's of his generation. They were right to extend Carson Wentz. In the aftermath of that Super Bowl/Extension, the Eagles signed all the aforementioned players, leaving them with the highest paid team in the NFL, along with one of the oldest in the league. A deadly combination. They desperately needed to influx young talent to keep that ship afloat.

Everyone was crushing the Eagles for drafting Jalen Hurts in the 2nd Round of the 2020 Draft. They had so many holes across their roster, why were they drafting a QB when QB felt like the most stable position they had?? The truth is, the Eagles have TRIED to draft at every other position in the last 3 years, desperate to influx their young talent. They drafted an edge rusher in Round 1 of 2018, Derek Barnett. Solid, but not a standout player. They drafted a TE to help Wentz in Dallas Goedert. He's now on IR. To protect Wentz, they took a LT Andre Dillard in 2019. They drafted a Running Back in Miles Sanders. They drafted a Linebacker. They drafted a standout corner. They traded picks for the Lions Star Corner. They drafted Sidney Jones. They drafted Jalen Mills. They spent 2020's 1st Rounder on Jalen Reagor as a WR. Most of those picks have either been underwhelming, injured, or flamed out spectacularly. 

The Eagles have failed to fill their gaps with young talent, but it hasn't been for a lack of trying. By the time the Hurts pick rolled around, they deemed their biggest hole was a Backup QB for the Oft-injured Wentz. Now, it's becoming apparent that Wentz will struggle to regain that once-promising form, starting the season with the 4 TD-7 INT ratio and a team that has 2 healthy O-Lineman, 3 Practice Squad WR's, nothing sexy on Defense, and Boston Scott.

Watching Sunday Night Football, I marveled at just how bad a team Carson Wentz and Miles Sanders had around them. They won bc the 49ers entire D-Line is hurt (what a season, huh) and Mullens-Beathard are the new Mason Rudolph-Duck Hodges. Through all this, the Eagles could be 3-1 and coasting in a Weak NFC East. The reason they aren't is because of Wentz's poor performance.

I haven't been able to separate whether this is the new Carson Wentz or the Eagles are just so broken around him. I tend to think that if this is the new Wentz, the Eagles will limp their way to a Matthew Stafford-esque 5-10-1 season. I'll leave that up to the rest of you to make the call for yourself on the Wentz vs. Eagles blame game.

Regardless, the Eagles have no doubt failed Carson Wentz miserably over the last 4 seasons. This season is going to be a long one for a guy I so desperately want to see regain his MVP form. Much like Andrew Luck's early retirement, we would all be losing a Carson-Wentz sized hole in our football hearts by missing out on one of the 3 generational Quarterbacks from the last 7 years. Like Derrick Rose in the NBA, I will ask 5 years from now what Carson Wentz would've been if indeed we never get that MVP player again.

All questions would be resolved if we had a stable, healthy Eagles team. Unfortunately, it appears we are years away from that happening again.

No comments:

Post a Comment