Sunday, October 11, 2020

How We Got to Now: New York Giants

The phrase New York Football Giants now feels more sarcastic than a namesake we've previously associated with success and 4 Super Bowls. The New York Giants have fallen into that territory no franchise wants to enter, and it takes a really long time to escape from. The Giants have become Perpetual Rebuilders.

With their (anticipated) loss to the Dallas Cowboys on Sunday, the Giants are 0-5 on the 2020 season. Playing in the worst division in Football, the Giants now have the #34 ranked QB in the NFL (based on PFF and QBR ratings across 6 platforms). After the firing of Dave Gettleman and (anticipated) firing of Joe Judge, the Giants will have gone through 4 Head Coaches, 3 GM's and 4 QB's in a 5 year stretch that won't be ending anytime soon, because they have to rebuild to get there.

How did we get to this point? Well, it's been as straightforward as any descent Sport's have seen among a model franchise. Ironically, the starting point for this decent begins on a Yacht in Miami, the week before the Giants most recent playoff game in 2015.

Background: The New York Giants were one of the model NFL franchises for decades. They were the Steelers but with slightly less winning. The Mara family has owned the team since it's founding, and the franchise has seen success translated over decades. The Giants have made a Super Bowl in every decade since the 1970s, winning 4 of them. Since the turn of the century, the Giants have been the only success New York City has in Sports, they've won 2 of the cities 3 Championships since 2001.

After their Super Bowl title in 2011, the Giants fell into the trap nearly all Super Bowl Champions fall into: Playing risk aversion and overpaying your champions. The Giants gave big contracts to Justin Tuck, Jason Pierre-Paul, Hakeem Nicks and, of course, Eli Manning. As great a QB as Eli Manning was, he was an extremely limited QB who was never really in the Elite QB discussion in the NFL. He'll be a HOF because of his Championships and his family, but trying to build a team around him as the highest paid QB post-Super Bowl became a futile effort.

The Boat: While the Giants were mediocre following their Super Bowl (missing the Playoffs from 2012-2015 w/ a 30-34 record) they weren't doing things wrong. What they needed was to reset their books, and that they did over their 3 year retool. In the Draft, they netted a generation Superstar at Pick #13 (no, not Aaron Donald) in Odell Beckham Jr.

After the 2015 season, with a 6-10 record and a 4th straight missed playoffs, the Giants were flush with Cap Space and an owner ready to make it back to the playoffs. The Giants did what mediocre franchises always do with cap space: Hired Ben McAdoo to replace Tom Coughlin, then gave all their money to mid-level free agents. Janoris Jenkins, Snacks Harrison, Johnathan Hankins and Oliver Vernon all joined the Giants on Top 5 contracts. These contracts bought the Giants wins, but didn't buy them any value. The Giants went 10-6 in 2016, netting the #5 Wild Card Spot behind Dak and Zeke's Rookie Cowboys, and got a Wild Card Matchup w/ the #4 seed Green Bay Packers.

That week, the Giants WR's and DB's were spotted on a Yacht in Miami. While the "crime" in question was only a crime in the court of public opinion (OBVIOUSLY the Giants didn't do anything wrong), that moment does serve as a symbolic turning point for the organization. The turn into perpetual rebuilding.

In that Wild Card Game, the Giants lost 38-13. The score wasn't so much symbolic as was the play of Eli Manning. Manning completed 23-43 passes for 293 yards, putting up a mediocre QBR of 72. He was the weak link of a young offense including Victor Cruz, Sterling Shepard, and of course Odell Beckham, one of the league's 3 best WR's.

In 2017, the Giants fell apart because, you know, that defense was predictably overpaid and mediocre.

The Eli Manning-Ben McAdoo Debacle: While Ben McAdoo has become a perpetual punchline, I struggle to name a coach that got screwed over more than Ben McAdoo. When the Giants hired Ben McAdoo, it would seem the Mara's were adamant that Eli Manning was their QB. But nobody told Ben McAdoo that. In fact, McAdoo was certain that he was gonna have the say in who the new QB was for the Giants. Why else would the Giants hire him? 

McAdoo was realistic in the fact the Giants weren't Super Bowl contenders. And of course they weren't. Jenkins and Snacks and Odell are great pieces, but obviously that team wasn't as good as the Eagles, Cowboys, Seahawks or Vikings. The Mara's convinced everyone that they were Super Bowl caliber, and that Eli Manning was still an Elite QB when, in reality, he never was.

Before a game vs. the Oakland Raiders, McAdoo benched Eli Manning for Geno Smith for ineffectiveness. It broke Eli's Ironman record of 234 straight starts to begin a career, and it wasn't even for injury. The Giants, and more specifically Mara, was PISSED!!! The Giants lost, because of course the Giants lost. They were a rebuilding franchise. The benching of Eli Manning was not because he was worse than Geno Smith (even if he was 1 year later), it was because the Giants wanted a high enough draft pick to draft Baker Mayfield or Sam Darnold, whom McAdoo could mold into his QB of the future.

Instead, the Giants made McAdoo the fall guy. They cleaned house with him and their GM, and brought in that grizzly bearded face we all can't ignore now.

The Dave Gettleman Experiment: Strangely, the Mara's had no problem letting Dave Gettleman pick the new QB of the Giants after Ben McAdoo got fired for trying to do so. With the 2nd Pick in 2018, the Giants didn't take Sam Darnold or Josh Allen. They took Saquon Barkley, an amazing player for whom it was immediately impossible for him to match his value at where he was drafted. RB's just don't add that much value to your team, and their primes are usually the 1st 4 years of their career.

For context on RB's in the Draft, Ezekiel Elliott was a bad value for the Cowboys at Pick 4. His pick looks a whole lot better than Saquon bc A. Elliott's Cowboys won 13 games in his Rookie Season. The Giants won 5. B. Zeke's production has not declined significantly after getting his big 2nd Contract (FO ranks him as the #5 RB in the league over the past 1 1/4 seasons.

The thing that dug in the Giants officially was picking the wrong QB. That decision to draft Daniel Jones was a byproduct of Bad Free Agent Signings (Nate Solder... Ouch) and bad Draft Picks (Eli Apple is gone, Oshane Ximines is a 3rd Round Pick, and Will Hernandez/Dexter Lawrence are good-not-great).

The Daniel Jones-Saquon Barkley Experiment: The Giants desperately want Saquon and Daniel Jones to work out. Under the 3 year rebuilding model, they were supposed to win the NFC East this year (one of the reasons the NFC East is so bad, the cycle has been broken). For the 2nd straight season, Saquon Barkley is hurt by a combination of bad O-Line/Bad Luck usually associated with Running Backs. The Giants have zero offensive line, and it's not for a lack of trying. Their defense is below average, with no discernable stars apart from Blake Martinez.

I give Daniel Jones a lot of slack for the bad numbers he's putting up. Look at the team around him. At the same time, it's not like he's actually that good to begin with. There's a lot missing in Jones' game, and it gets pressed on a lot. There's also a lot to like in Daniel Jones' game. The reality is, however, that as good as Jones' perks are, there are about 20-25 franchises that have or are about to draft a Daniel Jones-or better player. The Giants have a QB. So do about 27 other NFL Franchises. He's just another guy with a lot of crap built around him.

There is hope for the Giants to escape from Perpetual Rebuilding. It only takes 1 Good GM hire to right the ship of decades of failure. The Bills got that recently with the hire of Brandon Beane, and now they look to be on the precipice of a deep playoff run. The bad news for the Giants: They don't have that hire right now. Not Dave Gettleman. Not Joe Judge.

This means the Giants are another 3-4 years away from being competitive. They are going to have to hire a new coach, hire a new GM, Draft new Rookies, and clear their salary cap again. I know that's not what any fan base wants to hear. However, it's that lack of listening that F***ed up the Giants back in 2017, and put them years in the hole with a failed regime.

The Giants are going to have to swallow their pill and start all over again. If they don't have that plan, we'll be having this same conversation again in 3 years. Such is the cycle for the perpetual rebuilders.

No comments:

Post a Comment