Thursday, November 26, 2020

The Raiders Need to Find their "Patrick Mahomes"

 Derek Carr is at the "Alex Smith Chiefs" stage of his career. His next starting job will likely be for a rebuilding team, moving from their franchise QB (maybe even Kirk Cousins in Minnesota, like Smith for the Racial Slurs). The Raiders offense has been highly effective with outside runs complimented with a passing attack that has made Nelson Agholor a #1 WR. If Jon Gruden weren't so old, we'd be thinking about him the same way we think about Sean McVay and Kyle Shanahan in regards to offensive playcalling.

What Gruden and the Raiders need now is their version of Patrick Mahomes. The Raiders need their young, cheap QB with a higher ceiling than Derek Carr (who to his credit, will probably finish Top 12 in the MVP Voting). While their QB probably won't be as good as Mahomes, it's not like Mahomes was this otherworldly talent. Mahomes was regarded as the #3 QB in his draft class. He was drafted at Pick 10 because the Chiefs were willing to sell the farm to get Mahomes. Mahomes also benefits from being in a system that tailors to his gifts, with the best run organization in the NFL not named New England. Had Mahomes been drafted 1 pick earlier by the Cincinnati Bengals, I doubt Mahomes is viewed nearly as highly as he is now.

For the Raiders, there will be no shortage of Quarterback options in the 2021 Draft Class. There are 7 "Patrick Mahomes" 1st Round QB's available for grabs in this offseason. 6 Rookies are expected to be drafted in the 1st Round of the NFL Draft: Trevor Lawrence, Justin Fields, Zach Wilson, Trey Lance, Kyle Trask, and Mac Jones. The 7th is the availability of 2018 #3 Pick Sam Darnold for a 2nd Round Pick. All of those QB's represent the Raiders version of "Patrick Mahomes" to their Alex Smith, that being Derek Carr.

Carr, the Raiders longest tenured QB, has looked as good as the teams he's played for. Carr was an MVP candidate in 2016, when the Raiders snapped a 14 year playoff drought. In 2018, Gruden took over and tore down the Franchise and rebuilt it. Talented players like Khalil Mack and Amari Cooper were traded for 1st Round Picks. Carr looked perfectly average without any of the talented players of 2016. Famously, Carr began crying after taking a sack in London. Now, the Raiders have talent again, and cheap talent. They are one of the brightest futures in the sport, and Gruden finally has pieces to run an effective offense spearheaded by Carr and 1,000 yard Running Back Josh Jacobs.

If the Raiders are ever going to reach the mountaintop, it is going to be via the strength of their offense. Carr is a fine QB, better than all but 16 or so QB's in the sport. He's also making $25 million a year to be the Bengals Andy Dalton of 2020. The Raiders need to be thinking bigger than Andy Dalton.

The logical choice for finding their "Patrick Mahomes" actually comes from the guy who is 37 year old Mahomes: Aaron Rodgers. Sooner or later, the Packers are going to move on from Rodgers, and the Raiders should give up the farm to acquire Rodgers. In the meantime, Carr is a nice contingency plan, but you won't be winning AFC West's and Super Bowls with Derek Carr at the helm.

If the Raiders draft QB in the 1st Round of 2021, they don't have to dump Carr right away. Much like with Mahomes in Kansas City, Trey Lance/Mac Jones can sit behind Carr for a year/8 weeks, before taking the keys to a high powered offense. QB's are not innately "busts", the infrastructure around them makes them into great QB's. It's why the Browns went through 20+ QB's in 20 years, while the Patriots turned their Backup QB into an NFC Champion with San Francisco. Or why Sam Darnold is a bust and Mahomes is a HOFer, despite the fact ALL draft scouts had Darnold graded higher than Mahomes.

The Raiders, for all the shit they've gotten over the last 2 years, are a very well run organization. Mark Davis is a more hands-off owner now that he's given Gruden the keys to the Death Star. Gruden has proven he is still a GREAT offensive mind. His playcalling and schemes this year have been right up with the Shanahan's and Stefanski's of the NFL. 

I have very strong conviction that, no matter which QB the Raiders end up with, he will be at least a serviceable NFL Starter. That's basically what Carr is at this point. The difference for Las Vegas: This rookie QB will make $13 million over 4 years, with a higher growth potential than a 30 year old Carr who, like Andy Dalton, will not be an NFL starter in 4 years.

Whether or not the Raiders make the playoffs (30% chance right now) doesn't have an impact on their plan going forward. No more Alex Smith. No more Derek Carr. Think bigger, take some risks. That's how the Raiders can take the next step and become Super Bowl contenders.

No comments:

Post a Comment