The Patriots had the Bills in their grasp. Josh Allen has been tamed like a lion in the no-longer-existing circus vs. the Chiefs and Titans. The Patriots took care of John Brown, daring Josh Allen to beat them without the homerun ball. Their offense, led by 2nd year Damien Harris, did just enough to get NE to a 24-21 deficit. Then, we all watched Cam Newton fumble the ball away on a drive where New England was already in chip shot field goal range. A fumble that, when picked up by Buffalo, was a metaphoric passing of the torch in all the senses of the cliché.
This was, by all measures, a winnable game and the Patriots lost. FPI now projects the Patriots to win only 6.6 games in 2020, playing them in 10th place in the AFC and securing the 13th pick in the NFL Draft. At a 6-10 mark, the Pats would secure as high as the 8th Pick in the NFL Draft.
Before Sunday, we knew the Patriots were resetting in 2020. We're now watching to see how far the Patriots will freefall before then.
During the Patriots 10 year hiatus of Super Bowls, they never had a season worse than 10-6. The last time they were sub .500 was 2000, Bill Belichick's first year. They've had down years before, but never quite like this. Something had to have changed decade over decade, champion over champion in Foxboro.
Conventional Wisdom suggests the thing that changed was Tom Brady. However, Tom Brady is not the difference between 11-5 and 5-11 year over year. In fact, Tom Brady was a big part of why New England wasn't BETTER in 2019. As we also know by now, conventional wisdom is easy, straightforward, and 95% of the time WRONG.
The bigger explanation is what was going on while the Patriots were hoisting Lombardi Trophies in 2014, 2016 and 2018. And it involves "The Patriot Way". The "Patriot Way", quite simply, is the most sustainable roster construction model in Sports History. After 15 years, the Patriots front office, led by Bill Belichick, couldn't keep sustaining the rosters they'd been doings for decades. Bill Belichick has simply been BAD at evaluating young talent.
During the late 2000's-early 2010's, Bill Belichick was accumulating players who would be instrumental in the Patriots 3 titles in 14/16/18. Rob Gronkowski was a 2nd Round Pick turned HOFer. Jamie Collins: 2nd Round of 2013. Donta Hightower was the Star MLB drafted 1st Round Pick in 2012. Nate Solder and Marcus Cannon were 1st and 5th Rounders in 2011 to replace Super Bowl OT's Sebastian Vollmer and Matt Light. 2010's 1st Rounder: Devin McCourty. 2009's Picks: Patrick Chung and Julian Edelman. Even Aaron Hernandez was worthy of the richest TE contract in NFL History.
After the 1st Super Bowl, the Patriots stopped drawing good prospects in the 1st and 2nd Round. The late round gems were still showing up (Trent Brown, David Andrews, Rex Burkhead, Chris Hogan, and Malcom Butler were all undrafted) and it appears (with hindsight) those players were compensating for a lack of talent coming into Boston.
Beginning in 2015, the Patriots took a DT named Malcom Brown. Brown started in 2 Super Bowls for the Patriots, and was a fantastic piece on the Patriots Defense. After 4 years, Brown signed with the New Orleans Saints, where he has started for the last 2 seasons. From there, the Patriots have not only missed on great players like Hightower, Chung and Solder. They've actually picked a large number of straight BUSTS.
In 2018, the Patriots were forced into a trade for Jimmy Garoppolo, another 2014 2nd Round Hit. Instead of waging a bidding war between the Browns and 49ers, both of whom were desperate for a QB, Belichick took less to send Garoppolo to a good home w/ Kyle Shanahan (The Browns would draft Baker Mayfield 6 months later).
Belichick then mixed and match draft picks around, famously turning that 2nd Round pick into 7 different players. During the 2018 Draft, everyone praised Belichick for netting 7 picks for a soon-to-be-Free Agent, calling it a "classic Bill Belichick move". Fairly enough, we never did circle back around to what became of that Jimmy G trade. Until this research, even I assumed the Patriots got back some good fortune from Jimmy G. I'm guessing most of you assumed so too.
What could've been a perfect "Patriot Way" trade, 7 Day 2/3 Draft Assets for an expiring contract, turned into a whole lot of nothing. This for the coach famous for pulling Pro Bowlers out of Walmart Shopping Lines and the 7th Rounds of Drafts. The best thing the Patriots ended up with was Damien Harris, who, to be fair, has emerged as a legitimate #1 Running Back for the Patriots in 2020. At the same time, Harris is becoming a #1 because of the shortcomings of Sony Michel, the 1st Round Pick from that same 2018 Draft.
The rest of the picks turned into Jarrett Stidham, backup CB JoeJuan Williams, and 4 players (Yodny Cajuste, Christian Sam, Byron Cowart, and Duke Dawson) who no longer play for the Patriots. Those 6 players have a combined 0 starts for the New England Patriots, and only Stidham and Williams still have a chance to start.
After Super Bowl 53, the Patriots lost Chris Hogan and Danny Amendola to Free Agency, leaving only Super Bowl MVP Julian Edelman on the roster. The Patriots used a 1st Round Pick on WR N'Keal Harry, who in 2 seasons has played in 11 games and has 31 career receptions. Belichick then traded NE's 2nd Round Pick in 2020 in exchange for the last 9 games of Mohamed Sanu's Contract. Sanu, meant to temporarily fill a hole for 1 more Super Bowl run, was a no show apart from 5 games during his short stay in Foxboro.
Which brings us all the way back to 2020. The Patriots 1st and 2nd Rounders from 2009-2014, a 6 year period, netted 13 Pro Bowl Seasons (only Chandler Jones outside of New England) 5 All Pro Seasons, and 7 Full time starters with the Patriots. From 2015 until 2020, the Patriots have turned in just 2 Full Time Starters (a third potentially in SS Kyle Duggar) 0 Pro Bowls, and a handful of bad busts of Picks. The Patriot Way fell apart because the Patriots couldn't add the young talent necessary to sustain winning.
No single player can add 7 wins one way or another to a team, not even Tom Brady or Patrick Mahomes. The Patriots holes go well beyond the QB position, and Tom Brady at times helped to mask some of those issues on offense. The Patriots had the #1 Defense for 11 weeks in 2019, and that helped them outlast the Buffalo Bills in 2019. Without that defensive safety net, (6 players, including Hightower, opted out due to COVID) combined with 3 catastrophic fails at Wide Receiver (Antonio Brown, Mohamed Sanu, N'Keal Harry), the Patriots finally succombbed to what all NFL franchise have for years: The Difficulty of sustaining winning.
After two decades, it happened to the San Antonio Spurs and Gregg Popovich too. They drove out Kawhi Leonard after being so singularly focused on the 2018 season. For the Patriots, they lost their edge because of their draft picks, which are the NFL's version of a "Max Contract" in the NBA. Draft Picks are the way to beat the flaw in the NFL's system, because you can get the amazing talent for cheap. The same hack is true in Baseball, and the Astros have exploited it better than any franchise in MLB. In the NBA, their loophole is getting the Superstars at less than market value (whatever the Max contract is in a given year).
If you can't keep sustaining the hack, then all of a sudden you become just like everyone else. This is what happened to the Pats. The explanations for this are plentiful and all intersect in some way. Maybe the Patriots couldn't dedicated enough time to the Draft Process bc of Super Bowl seasons. Maybe it was Belichick losing an edge on evaluation. Maybe it was a lack of opportunities for top picks to see the field. All are plausible, and I don't have the data to find any conclusions either way.
For the foreseeable future, it appears Bill Belichick and the Patriots have become just like everyone else, no matter how many Walmart employees he can start at Linebacker. The core of talented players simply isn't there anymore in New England, and that is how we got to where we are now with the Patriots.

No comments:
Post a Comment