This time, it really feels like the end of the road in Cleveland. For years, Cleveland could coast to the playoffs by virtue of playing in the disgraceful AL Central. Then, the Twins surpassed them in 2019. The White Sox have surpassed them in 2020. An 11-2 drubbing by the New York Yankees in Wild Card Game 1 made all of this painfully clear for Cleveland. Even more painful was the fact they did it off of the 2020 AL MVP/CY Young, Shane Bieber.
With all that context, I don't suspect Cleveland will stop making playoff pushes. Not when the playoff format shrinks in 2021. Not when Francisco Lindor leaves via Free Agency following next season. Cleveland has kept tinkering and toying and turning over a roster that was 1 game from a World Series in 2016.
One of if not the biggest mistakes Front Offices make is overpaying players they hold an emotional connection to. This is especially prevalent in Baseball, where depending on your Owner's wealth 1-2 bad contracts can mess your team up for an entire decade (just ask the Tigers and Orioles about that). After Cleveland lost Game 7 of the 2016 World Series, they were susceptible to these mistakes in paying guys like Mike Napoli, Danny Salazar, Jason Kipnis, Andrew Miller, etc. All winning franchises must make these tough decisions, and those built on sustainability models must make these tough decisions. To be a sustainable organization, you almost always must subscribe to the principle of "To make an omelet, you're gonna have to crack a few eggs".
Cleveland has built an entirely new model of sustainability based on this ideology. Cleveland holds very few emotional attachments to the players of past successes, which is a credit to sticking to analytics. They've become sellers while still competing for the playoffs. They've traded players with 2-3 years left on their contracts, because it is an advantage for them. Baseball organizations place a premium on Controllable MLB assets, and often will dramatically overpay for those assets.
Cleveland has capitalized on this by trading some of their controllable assets, and having the belief those players can be replaced. Cleveland dealt Corey Kluber, their washed up 2x Cy Young Winner, for a starting CF in Delino Deshields. They traded Trevor Bauer 2 years before his Free Agency, and got back their .950 OPS starting DH, a reliever and 2 months of Yasiel Puig. They dealt star pitcher Mike Clevinger to San Diego for their 23 yo starting LF, a backup catcher with control, a young starter in Cal Quantrill, and prospects. And, they still boast the best pitching staff in Baseball.
Their player development has been off the charts. In 2017, Cleveland has the #1 Pitching Staff in Baseball. In 2020, they had the #1 Pitching Staff in Baseball. Only 1 of their 5 starters were on both of those teams (Carlos Carrasco). In exchange, they've netted 3 batters in tonight's Game 1 Playoff lineup, added a closer, 2 relievers, and bolstered their farm system in the process.
Regardless of how this week goes, Cleveland is going to keep committing to making these early roster adjustments. Lindor's name has been floated around for years, and I suspect tomorrow may be his final game in a Cleveland uniform. Zach Plesac is a controllable arm they can trade for assets. Maybe they add one more superstar and make a big run in 2021. I'm not sure how long this thing will last in Cleveland, and they for sure won't be winning a World Series anytime soon (they don't have the bats). But, they've been telling me to F**K off for years now. It'll be interesting to see how long they keep it up past their Wild Card exit in 2020.
No comments:
Post a Comment