Thursday, June 11, 2020

Carson Wentz Is Special. Get Over It

When evaluating QB's in the NFL, I find it easiest to divide them into these categories

ELITE, Tier 2, Tier 3, QB Purgatory, Too Early to Decide, Fringe Starters

What separates the elite and Tier 2 is actually a HUGE gap. Tier 2 consists of players who have the perfect systems in place for them to succeed. The Tier 2 QB's are Tier 3 QB's whos teams are getting the most out of their gifts. Think Matt Ryan, Lamar Jackson, Dak Prescott, and recently Drew Brees

Elite QB's are the ones who give their team a chance to win every single week. If you put Patrick Mahomes on the Jets, they could win on any given Sunday, despite their notable shortcomings. These QB's are Mahomes, Russell Wilson, Deshaun Watson, Aaron Rodgers, and Carson Wentz. Most people watch these guys and know they have gifts that can't be replicated.

Most likely, you didn't have any problem with anyone on that list except for Carson Wentz. Most people don't view Carson Wentz in the same prism as Mahomes and Wilson. The biggest reason for this is easy to understand: For most sports fans, their fondest memory of Wentz is the Eagles winning the Super Bowl without him.

In Wentz's 2nd Season, he was the 2017 NFL MVP without argument through November. Then, on December 10th, he tore his ACL diving for a go-ahead TD against the Rams. Since then, the trajectory of Wentz's career has never been the same. He was supposed to be the Super Bowl Hero in Year 2. He was set to become the heir apparent to Tom Brady as the face of the NFL after defeating him head to head in Super Bowl LII. He would have won MVP, a Ring, and Super Bowl MVP at a younger age than Mahomes was when he won last season.

Now, injuries have ended each of the last 3 seasons for Wentz, all of which led to Eagles Playoff Appearances. This is a cruel twist of fate not seen since Marcus Mariota's body betrayed him in Nashville. Yet, Wentz is even MORE gifted than Mariota was being drafted #2 fresh off a Heisman at Oregon. This kid is THAT GOOD!!!!

When healthy, Carson Wentz gives the Eagles a chance to win every single game they play, sometimes in resounding fashion. The "When" part is becoming a big concern for the Eagles, hence their selection of Jalen Hurts as an insurance plan. This is a real shame, because for 12 shining weeks, Wentz was Patrick Mahomes before the Super Bowl MVP had ever taken a snap of NFL Football.

In his first 28 games, Wentz was putting up better numbers than every QB in NFL History. Then, one big hit in Los Angeles and the ensuing Nick Foles magic made everyone toss him to the side. This is the power of memory, because it is the first analysis Sports Fans go to in terms of determining your reputation or legacy. By looking at the numbers and following reported injury news, we can see that Carson Wentz has been otherworldly when healthy. However, he has only been "healthy" in 60% of the possible games in his career. If we remove the 16 games from his rookie season, when the Eagles went just 7-9, Wentz has been "healthy" for just about 45% of his possible starts during the Eagles Super Bowl window.

To be clear, this year is NOT make or break for Wentz. The Eagles gave him a massive extension following 2018, and they are committing to him for the long term. What I'm saying is that the injuries are cause for legitimate concern. Once is a Fluke, Twice is a Pattern, Three is a Tendency. And his seasons have ended from injuries 3 years in a row, in 3 different, gruesome ways (Torn ACL, Spinal Fracture, Concussion).

If he's healthy, the Eagles are right at the top of the NFC East. All we can do is hope for the best, because Wentz being healthy is a gift for Football Fans as a Whole.

No comments:

Post a Comment