Monday, June 1, 2020

Is Buffalo the Most Overrated NFL Team???

I'm gonna argue that for a large group of Buffalo Bills fans, there has never been a better time to be a Bills Fan. Sure, the team had a stretch of dominance in the early 1990's where they made it to 4 straight Super Bowls, but that was 30 years ago now. That doesn't even include those that were too young to understand what was happening in Buffalo. That fact makes the age 35 or yonger, and if the average NFL Fan is 47 years old, then much older people drive up the average...

Anyways, you get the point. There has not been this big of an anticipation in the air in Western New York in a long time. We don't need to drive home the point Tom Brady is gone, and the Bills have made the playoffs twice in 3 years. We know the reasons why there's excitement in the air.

I'm not trying to be a downer here... well actually I kind of am. When you look at things on the surface, I wonder why people are so excited about the Bills?? I suspect that most people think the Bills will win the AFC East by default, considering the Jets, Dolphins, and Patriots all appear to be non-playoff teams. People assume that because of this, Buffalo will win 11 or 12 games by virtue of being in a crappy division and winning 11 games in 2019.

However, the Buffalo Bills appear poised for a major regression themselves in 2020. And this isn't some hunch of mine, the numbers greatly support this notion.

Let's begin with the Bills Defense. According to Pro Football Focus, the Buffalo Bills had the 2nd ranked defense in the 2019 season, only behind the aforementioned Patriots. Better than the 49ers. Better than the 14-2 Ravens. Better than Chicago, who basically carried the worst offense in the league to 8-8. As much as we talked about how great TreDavious White, Ed Oliver, Tremaine Edmunds and company were in 2019, they were actually UNDERVALUED by analysts.

As we know (or should know) elite defensive units are hard to replicated year to year. Just ask the 3 teams in the 2018 Conference Championship Games: Jacksonville, Minnesota, and Philadelphia. These units are very hard to replicate year in and year out, especially when expectations are at their highest. Now, I think Buffalo's defense is still great, but so is the rest of the league's defenses. And, it's REALLY hard to have the leagues #2 defense once, and even harder to repeat that the following season.

How Many of these Teams can you say, with confidence, the Bills Defense will be better than in 2020

Pittsburgh Steelers    Chicago Bears    San Francisco 49ers   New England Patriots
Baltimore Ravens     Denver Broncos    Indianapolis Colts   Los Angeles Chargers
Minnesota Vikings   New Orleans Saints    Houston Texans    Green Bay Packers

I could make a CASE for all of these teams being potentially better than Buffalo next year. Not to mention, the Bills were remarkably healthy in 2019 as well. We can ask the Rams what happens when injuries finally plague a team.
There's no way to know for sure, but worst case scenario the Bills will be a Top Half Defense.

Now, we get to the offense. The addition of Stephon Diggs was a big splash move, and clearing the way for Devin Singletary to be the clear RB1 is a fantastic move, considering their leading rusher in 2019 was QB Josh Allen.

Speaking of Allen, I don't trust Allen the same way everyone else is ready to. If he can't prove that he can be an accurate QB, it doesn't matter how many weapons the Bills have. And a mobile, running QB is useless if he can't be an accurate passer. So many people like to make the Lamar Jackson comparisons, but forget to acknowledge that Jackson was a very accurate 66%. Allen was a league worst 52% in 2019. Without accuracy, Allen is a hulking QB that teams will be content to allow to sit back in the pocket. This makes him more of a Cam Newton or Jameis Winston, both of whoms services are no longer wanted in the NFL.

If Allen turns 52% into 70% in one season, then the Bills will have no questions on offense. However, that kind of jump had never happened until Joe Burrow and Jackson did it in College and the NFL, respectively last season. Both of them benefited from completely changed systems by Joe Brady and Greg Roman. The Bills, as far as we know, have undergone no such restructure of the offense.

An average offense combined with an elite defense equals.... the 2019 Minnesota Vikings. Being honest, that's probably enough to win the AFC East. But an average offense with a Top 12 Defense equals... the 2019 Denver Broncos?!?! That's a 7-9 team that won some questionable games in 2019. Plus, people are also assuming the Miami Dolphins are gonna lie down to Buffalo when they play twice a year. Historically, it makes sense for two teams of their calibers to split a season series. If Miami can put up a strong showing in the AFC East, including two wins against the Bills, it might just be enough to steal the divison from right underneath them. Also, the Patriots have done crazier things in the past.

There are so many signs pointing to an underachieving season for the Bills.

No comments:

Post a Comment