Wednesday, June 24, 2020

Why do People Care so Much About Reggie Bush

It has been 10 years since Reggie Bush was "indicted" by the NCAA for breaking their rules. So much has changed in the landscape of College Sports since then: On the field, off the field and in the way the public perceives the NCAA and Shamateurism. Bush was the high profile case that started a conversation around these topics, given his stature and in the legacy of College Football. I wanted to figure why people are still so infatuated with Reggie Bush and his story, despite the fact his case hasn't mattered to anybody in over 10 years, and the legacy has been mostly restored.

There are the 4 main reasons:

1. Reggie Bush was the story that shifted public opinion on College Athletics. According to the Law of Diffusion of Innovation, when the early majority decides to get behind a topic, the chain reaction is dramatic and fast. Overnight, the conversation shifts to a completely new place, sometimes even 180 degrees from where it was before. Just ask Drew Brees about that following the murder of George Floyd.

After the NCAA announced their decision to remove USC's championship, Bush's Heisman Trophy, and punish the 2011 USC team retroactively, the conversation had reached it's tipping point. The early majority, usually semi-progressive people, saw this unfold and, as if I light switch had gone off, changed their tone. What once was "College Athletes should be playing for fun and getting an education" became "Why the hell are we punishing an adult for buying his impoverished parents a home??"

2. It was the beginning of the fall of the NCAA and Shamateurism. After public opinion shifted, people directed their anger towards the NCAA for enforcing their "bylaws" to an extent greater than the law. With public opinion shifted, scrutiny only grew stronger every time we saw an assistant coach get fired, a school get a 1 year ban, etc. This all led to a battle within the legal system, when Christian Dawkins and a bunch of assistant coaches were scapegoated by a botched FBI investigation. Then, FBI wiretaps sent everything spiraling out of control, destroying the reputation of the NCAA among College Recruits and young people alike (hence the trend #F---theNCAA). In Basketball, it led to 3 of the Top 5 recruits in the 2020 Draft skipping out on the College Basketball season, in one of their lowest rated seasons in history (Before March Madness got cancelled).

In 2019, California passed NIL legislation, making all athletes able to profit off of their Name, Image and Likeness beginning in 2022. Florida took it one step further, making it legal beginning in 2021. The NCAA was resistant to California's NIL laws, initially saying that California schools could be barred from NCAA championships. This was dumb, considering Laws are stronger legislation than NCAA bylaws, nonetheless the fact they have no ability to police College Football Playoff events. Even though they backtracked, they still revealed their true colors.

We can draw a direct correlation from the Reggie Bush decision to the Name, Image Likeness legislation that legally puts an end to Shamateurism.

3. Forthcoming Sanctions led to Pete Carroll leaving USC to create an NFL dynasty. On the field, USC's decision changed an entire Decade or more of NFL football. Pete Carroll left USC for Seattle in January of 2010. One month later, he was testifying in front of the NCAA subcommittee on USC allegations. The timing of these decisions was close enough where it would have to be one of the weirdest coincidences in the history of coincidences, or Pete Carroll saw the storm in the distance and put his name out for considerations of an NFL return.

Within 4 years of leaving USC, Pete Carroll and Jon Schneider built maybe the greatest defense in NFL history. They also drafted Russell Wilson, a QB who's emergence led to a complete reinvention of the way we think of Quarterbacks in the NFL, paving the way for the Baker Mayfield's, Kyler Murrays and Patrick Mahomes' of the world to become top draft picks. They were also Super Bowl Champions, en route to a 2nd consecutive NFC championship. They never saw a losing record this decade. All that wouldn't have happened had Carroll not decided to leave USC when he did.

4. Reggie Bush is one of the faces of College Football. Being in the public eye makes it easier for us to accept "disgraced" stars. Tiger Woods is now a beloved figure all across America. LeBron James went from the most hated player in Miami to most loved in Cleveland/Los Angeles. Alex Rodriguez is now the voice of baseball both on Sunday Night Baseball and the Fox World Series studio show.

Reggie Bush is a well liked guy. Part of that is his personality, another part is the "scandal" that messed with his legacy. The fact he and teammate Matt Leinart are on Fox's College Football Show shows that public perception has totally come around to Reggie. I will argue this is for the better, since it's already bad enough that his legacy has been tarnished in the way that it has.

No comments:

Post a Comment