Monday, June 29, 2020

Saquon Barkley and the Perpetually Rebuilding Giants

Over the last 4 seasons, very few teams have been worse than the New York Giants. In fact, I'll go out on a limb and say no team has been worse than the Giants. First, they committed to Eli Manning 2 years too long. They spent $80 million on a defense that was great for 1 season, and since then they've never been able to reset their salary cap. Then they paid Nate Solder $16 million to be one of the worst LT in the NFL for 2 seasons. The results are the #2, #6 and #4 picks in 3 consecutive seasons, yet they don't seem to be in any kind of brighter position.

At the same time, Odell Beckham, the teams lone shining star, was starting to fall apart physically. Back to back seasons ended with injury for Beckham, including a Torn ACL in Week 6 of 2017. Coincidentally, the Odell trade last offseason may have been the only great move the Giants have made since 2015. They shed a massive contract for Jabrill Peppers and the pick that would become Dexter Lawrence, two promising young, valuable players.

Regardless of whether or not there is an NFL season in 2020, the Giants can't expect much. They'll be last place in the NFC East, and the only reason they won't be is because the Washington Racial Slurs are doing a full rebuild the correct way. This reality is extremely problematic, because being competitive in 2020 was the whole reason that the team drafted Saquon Barkley with the 2nd pick in the 2018 draft. Running backs are the least valuable position players in all of football. The best teams in Football either A. Have a great one on a rookie contract OR B. An interchangeable RB they don't have to pay, and benefits from a great Offensive Line and Scheme. Drafting a running back in the First Round is already rare enough. Drafting one with the 2nd overall pick, ahead of the likes of Sam Darnold, Denzel Ward and Quenton Nelson??? Forget about it.

To be clear, this is not to say Barkley isn't better at RB than those players are at their positions (with the exception of Nelson). This is strictly based on the position that Barkley plays, and the fact that even an average QB like Darnold is more VALUABLE to a team than Barkley. Just look at Leonard Fournette in Jacksonville or Todd Gurley with the Rams. Running Backs don't supply the value teams are looking for in roster construction, assuming everyone's ultimate goal is to win the Super Bowl (this is not always the case).

If the Giants were going to draft Barkley and commit 30 million guaranteed to the position, they were supposed to be ready made to compete for the Super Bowl before Barkley reached the end of his contract. Now in Year 3, it's clear the Giants have a long way to go to reach that point. Sure, they have a franchise QB in Daniel Jones, but nothing he showed us in Year 1 convinced us he's the next Patrick Mahomes or Carson Wentz. This team is rebuilding in circles, with a number of decisions that continuously delay their progressions.

Imagine this too: By the time the do turn a corner, let's say 2021 at the earliest, Saquon Barkley will 1 year away from Free Agency. Barkley will either be getting a contract extension from the Giants or create irreparable damage to their relationship. If history has shown us anything, there is NO reason anyone should be paying a running back over $10 million a year, and Barkley will command nearly $20 million a year on his next contract. It's a lose-lose situation for the Giants.

Their best option would be to trade Saquon before his contract comes up as to avoid making a mistake that could set the franchise back 3 years (ie the Rams with Gurley's extension or the Cardinals with David Johnson). But, if you're options are 1. Have to trade Barkley right as your window opens or 2. Risk closing that window by making a huge contract mistake I ask you....

What is the Point of Drafting Barkley in the First Place????

This is one of the many reality checks the Giants must face as they go forward, because right now, they seem to be rebuilding in circles, with a roster than does not look like it will be in great shape once it comes time for them to compete. As I said earlier, the BEST case scenario for the Giants is to be competitive in 2021. At worst, they will keep rebuilding in circles into a 5th coach and 3rd GM since their last playoff appearance.

No comments:

Post a Comment