Tuesday, September 22, 2020

Christian McCaffery's Injury is Carolina's Blessing In Disguise

 In their Week 2 Loss to the Bucs, the Panthers lost Star Running Back Christian McCaffery to a high ankle sprain. McCaffery will be lost for 4-6 weeks for a team that, with little expectations to start the year, has started the year 0-2. McCaffery is the same star RB who is under contract for the next 6 years, making $83 million in total at a Position that provides next to zero value in salary cap evaluations.

In case you couldn't tell, yes, I'm not a fan of the Panthers trajectory. In fact, I Wrote 5000 Words on the Topic Last Year when the Panthers fired Ron Rivera and it seemed clear they were moving on from Cam Newton. The Panthers should've gone for a full rebuild, because they are short of talent at many, MANY positions. No amount of Christian McCaffery 2000 yard seasons are going to help the Panthers return to the Super Bowl (assuming that is the ultimate goal, because many times that isn't the case).

Which is why the CMC injury is a blessing in disguise for the Carolina Panthers. Yes, the Panthers should've traded McCaffery this offseason with 2 years of control left. I proposed 3 of so trade scenarios that netted them 2 1st Round Picks, or 1 1st Rounder and a Young Player. In the scenario we have, a silver lining for Carolina is Christian McCaffery not playing for the Panthers.

The Panthers need to stop delaying the inevitable. Any 4-12 or 5-11 season in 2020 does them no good. Especially in a year like this, where there are 3 Good QB prospects and 8-11 teams interested in their services. If the Panthers don't end up with Trevor Lawrence, it isn't the end of the world. They should still do everything in their power to get him. Matt Rhule was given the job security of 6 years for this very scenario. 

The Panthers can't be content with finishing 4th in the NFC South (which they will in 2020.) They need to be worse than the other last place teams if they want to do this rebuild right. I have no argument if the Panthers don't want a QB this year: They are still 2-3 years away from being competitive again, and it is imperative to maximize that "Rookie Contract Window" as long as possible. If they convince themselves they can be good soon, that's where they are making a mistake.

Which bring us back around to McCaffery. From the second McCaffery's contract was signed, I viewed his deal as a "sunken cost". The Panthers are now paying McCaffery to be the #1 Running Back in the League, at which point his value against the cap is gone. McCaffery undoubtedly makes the Panthers better, and that's not what the Panthers can afford right now. They'd be better served with the Draft Picks and young players that a McCaffery trade would net them. None of them will be better than McCaffery, but against the Salary Cap, they will be more valuable than McCaffery at a time in which the Panthers will actually be a competitive football team.

Carolina won't trade McCaffery, and that's to their detriment in being a great team. With his injury, they have a chance to keep losing Football Games in 2020. The Panthers defense is the youngest in football, with 3 rookies and 2 2nd years starting for them. They have not looked good to start the season, but with time more young players will come in with more 1 year veterans, and Carolina will find some talent. This is what a rebuild is all about. The defense is sticking to a rebuilding plan.

Their offense is actually pretty good: Teddy Bridgewater and Robby Anderson are a great deep threat connection, or at least better than Anderson and Darnold. Obviously, McCaffery is the best RB in the NFL, and he is also their #1 Reciever. The Panthers scored 31 Points and 24 in their 1st 2 games of the season, which puts them in the top half of the league through 2 games.

McCaffery's injury will hopefully force them to come to grips with the fact they are REBUILDING!!! They don't need the big time play of McCaffery and Anderson, they need to find diamonds in the rough that will play well above their contracts. This includes the QB position. The Panthers know Bridgewater is a Bridge QB, and they paid him $63 million over 3 years to be that QB (they can cut him after 2 years with a minimal cap hit). The Panthers don't need a QB this year, but wouldn't it be nice?? If they can get Trevor Lawrence, there's no question what they do here. If it's Lance or Justin Fields, you can make the argument either way for drafting/waiting.

There are franchises that are "Perpetual Rebuilders". The Buccaneers are one of those teams, and so is Washington. The Jets are about to experience a 3rd straight rebuild after they fire Adam Gase. The Browns have been doing it 5-6 times since 2002, and are 1 more bad season away from another one. With the loss of Saquon Barkley, we can add the New York Giants to that list. Nobody want to be a perpetual rebuilder, because you can go Decades at a time without success, even in a sport that legislates parity better than all the rest.

What do all of these Franchises have in Common?? More than Bad Ownership, these Franchise all have never had a vision for the future that they STUCK to. The Browns hired Sashi Brown to do a "Process" Style Rebuild, and they fired him after 2 seasons. Then, they replaced him with John Dorsey, who made mistakes like trading for Odell Beckham, Olivier Vernon, and hiring Freddie Kitchens (time will tell on Baker Mayfield). The Jets hired Adam Gase, then fired their GM, then replaced him with Joe Douglas, then will fire Gase all at the expense of Sam Darnold. The Giants have gone through 2 coaches and an array of draft picks with Dave Gettleman, who probably made a mistake drafting a RB at #2 and tying his future to Daniel Jones.

The Panthers don't want to become a perpetual rebuilder. This is why having a rebuilding plan is so important to getting back to success. The Panthers are sending too many mixed signals to make me think they have a vision and are sticking to it. One minute they're replacing Cam Newton with Teddy Bridgewater, and signing Robby Anderson to pair with DJ Moore. Then, they're giving Christian McCaffery a 6 year contract, while also purging their defense and drafting 7 Defensive Players.

Maybe Matt Rhule and David Tepper's vision differs from mine, and I'm willing to accept that both realities can lead to success. Where I struggle with this is why the Panthers feel that being 5-11 and 6-10 is what will lead to success. One of these next couple seasons, they're gonna have to be really bad in order to lock down the most important position on the field: The Quarterback. There are some good ones this year, so why not make it this year. McCaffery is hurt now, so there's no question which direction they should go: Up in the Draft Order.

The Panthers must be confident in their ability to develop talent. However, the Top Quarterback will put this whole rebuild together. Carolina should make that happen in 2020. It's why McCaffery's injury will keep them from blowing themselves up. It is a blessing in disguise.

No comments:

Post a Comment