Saturday, September 5, 2020

The REAL Story of Drew Brees, Nick Saban and the Dolphins

 In 2015, Nick Saban was quoted saying that "I'd still probably be in Miami if they'd let me sign Drew Brees". Most people that know the story of Drew Brees failing a physical for Nick Saban's Miami Dolphins in 2006, leading to him signing with the New Orleans Saints, then Nick Saban departing for Alabama before 2007 say some version of the same thing as Saban. I mean, we're talking about the greatest coach in College Football history with the NFL's All Time leading passer. The Dolphins would've been competing with the Patriots for a decade for NFL Supremacy. Conventional Wisdom says the Dolphins lost, Saban and Brees won, and the story will long live as an intriguing "What If"

When discussing this "What If", I ask you "What If this ISN'T how things would've normally gone down???" As I've said time and time again, Conventional Wisdom is easy, straightforward, and 95% of the time... LOUD WRONG!!!!!!

Truth be told, the truth behind this "What If" story is more cynical than most people would like to think. So, I'd like to discuss 2 storylines today: A. The classic story of Saban/Brees succeeding in Miami is not what would've actually happened and B. The actual story is even more intriguing than the one we constantly tell.

    Here's the 5 "parties" to focus on for this "What If" Story:

    The Miami Dolphins, Drew Brees, Nick Saban, New Orleans Saints, and Alabama

Drew Brees was ready to sign with the Miami Dolphins after the San Diego Chargers did not renew his contract after 2005. Nick Saban was coming off a 9-7 season in Year 1 with the Dolphins with NFL journeyman Gus Frerotte at QB. After Brees signs with the Dolphins, it's safe to assume the Miami Dolphins make the playoffs in 2006. Let's say the Dolphins go 11-5, improving by 2 games and tying the Patriots for the Division title. The Dolphins play New England in the 5-4 Wild Card Matchup, which ends up being a game of epic proportions. The Patriots win, but Miami shows major signs of improvement from 2005. Nick Saban does not leave the team to take the Alabama coaching job.

From here, most people assume that Brees and Saban, two of the best at what they do, make their assent up the AFC and win the Super Bowl in 2009, just like the Saints did with Sean Payton. What people forget is this: In 2007, Drew Brees was a middle-of-the-road QB returning from a major injury. Saban was not the greatest coach in College Football history, either. He was a coach with 1 national championship who jumped to the NFL. Basically, he was Steve Spurrier.

Speaking of Spurrier, he was the only other coach named in the running for the Alabama job. He was the 2nd option for the Crimson Tide, after Saban, and turned them down after being forced to wait for the NFL regular season to end. Without Saban in the mix, Alabama uses their infinite resources to hire Spurrier away from South Carolina. More on that later.

Back in Miami, the Dolphins enter 2007 with hopes of improving from 11-5. However, Nick Saban has never been an offensive minded coach, nonetheless an offensive play caller. Those duties fell to Offensive Coordinator, Mike Mularkey, a coach famous for his extremely boring play calls and commitments to a power running game.

You see, people underestimate just how much Sean Payton's offensive transformed Drew Brees into the HOF QB that he became. Drew Brees has never been an MVP, and we don't view Brees as the QB of his generation like we talk about Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, and Aaron Rodgers. The thing is, Drew Brees was the perfect QB for SEAN PAYTON. Why? Because his greatest strength is his ACCURACY. And Sean Payton has run an offense for years designed around short, quick passes that require a major amount of accuracy to move the ball down the field. Drew Brees' HOF Career has benefitted far more from having Sean Payton than Sean Payton has benefitted from having Drew Brees. The truth is, there were about 15 QB's that could've done what Drew Brees did in the 2006-2019 runs the Saints have had together. It just happened to be that Brees was the only QB that could Saints could acquire before the 2006 season.

In 2007, the Dolphins improve their defense, as all Saban teams do, and finish with a respectable 10-6 record. However, 2007 was that weird season where the Titans, Browns and, now, Miami all finished with equal 10-6 records for 1 playoff spot. Miami misses the playoffs in 2007. In order to keep QB's coach Jason Garrett from taking the Cowboys OC job, the Dolphins fired Mularkey and made Garrett the offensive coordinator for the 2008 season.

Things don't go much better in New Orleans. They finish 2007 with a 4-12 record. They get the #2 Pick in the 2008 NFL Draft, and after the Rams take Chris Long with the #1 Pick, the Saints draft.... Matt Ryan!!!! Yes, the famous Atlanta Falcons QB actually ends up with their archrival New Orleans Saints and Sean Payton. With Matt Ryan in Sean Payton's offense, the Saints immediately turn their ship around. They go 6-10 in 2008, then 9-7 in 2009 and 13-3 in 2010, a year in which the QB's in their division were Joe Flacco (taken by Atlanta after the Saints got Ryan), Josh Freeman and a rookie Cam Newton.

In Miami, 2008 goes a little better than anticipated, finishing with an equal 10-6 record with a new offense from Jason Garrett. For the 2nd year in a row, 10 wins isn't enough to get the Dolphins to the playoffs (the Ravens finished 11-5 as the 6th seed). In year 2 with Garrett, the offense finally starts revving for the Miami Dolphins. Miami goes 12-4, winning their 1st Division title in the Saban/Brees era. The Dolphins get the 3 seed in the AFC, and their Wild Card matchup is... the 10-6 New York Jets with Mark Sanchez.

In real life, this 2009 Jets team played Tom Brady in the Wild Card Game. This was the only time Tom Brady lost a Wild Card game in Foxboro in his career. While we can never know what would actually happen, I'm going to be an optimist and say that the Dolphins win this game behind Brees' 380 yards and 4 TD's. Miami then goes into San Diego and upsets the 13-3 San Diego Chargers (the Jets did this after beating New England), before losing to the 14-2 and eventual AFC Champions, the Indianapolis Colts (like the Jets). Instead of playing New Orleans in the Super Bowl, the Colts defeat Brett Favre's Minnesota Vikings, giving Peyton Manning his 2nd Super Bowl Ring. He'd win #3 years later in Denver.

Following the massive improvement of the Dolphins' offense, Jason Garrett is hired as the Head Coach of the Dallas Cowboys (which Jerry Jones actually did following 2 years of Garrett's OC Job in Dallas). History follows almost exactly the same way for Garrett and the Cowboys. However, the loss of Garrett as OC, combined with the aging defense headed by a 35 year old Jason Taylor, means this is the end of the road for Drew and Nick. The Dolphins finish well behind the 14-2 Patriots and 11-5 Jets, coming in with a sputtering 5-8 record to start the season. Saban is fired with 3 weeks left in the season, and Miami sputters to a 5-11 record.

Here's the final fates of each of our 5 Parties:

Nick Saban

Saban returns to the College Ranks following his firing in 2010. However, Alabama does not come calling this time. You see, Steve Spurrier has taken Alabama to 4 straight bowl games in his 1st 4 years at Alabama. Nothing to impressive other than a win in the Capital One Bowl and Cotton Bowl. Alabama is still 4th in the SEC behind 2009 National Champions Florida, 2010 National Champions Auburn, and the soon-to-be 2011 National Champions at LSU

At the same time as Nick Saban's firing in 2010, there are 2 MAJOR College Football Job openings. Up the state, Urban Meyer had retired as the Head Coach at Florida. The team was coming off 2 national championships and looming NCAA Sanctions headed their way. The other job was a sputtering program with a rich football history... The University of Michigan.

Based on the fact that Florida was Meyer's program, Saban obviously chooses building the program at Michigan. The next 10 years follow a fairly similar timeline as Saban's time at Alabama. The Wolverine's make the initial College Football Playoff in 2014 with a victory over Ohio State, then B10 title the following week. Just like Ohio State did in 2014, Michigan goes on to win the 2014 National Championship. They win again in 2015 over Clemson, just like Saban did in real life.

Alabama

Don't worry, things work out pretty well for Alabama, too. Sure, Steve Spurrier keeps them competitive for a while, and he's a beloved figure in Tuscaloosa. Spurrier retires following his first Sugar Bowl Victory at Alabama in 2015, just like he did in real life at South Carolina (minus the Sugar Bowl).

Alabama makes the biggest splash College Football had seen since Saban landed at Michigan in 2010. They bring home a former son of the Alabama Program, a kid who was a walk-on in the 1980's for the Crimson Tide. A kid who grew up in Alabama with nothing to his name, and rose to one of the most prominent coaches in the Sport. Despite the pain in leaving the program he built from the ground up, he eagerly says yes to his dream job: Head Coach at the University of Alabama.

I'm talking, of course, about Dabo Swinney.

So, with Brent Venables as the Clemson Head Coach, the Tigers win the National Championship over Nick Saban's Michigan team on a last second TD from Deshaun Watson. Without Dabo's recruiting, Clemson doesn't become the powerhouse they would've been with Swinney. They do win the ACC each of the next 5 years tho. 

Pained by the loss, Nick Saban recruits his QB of the future in Tua Tagovailoa to join him at Michigan. Dabo counters by turning Jalen Hurts into a rising star of the Sport, making his 1st CFB Playoff in 2017. Michigan wins it all in 2017, despite a loss to Ohio State. In 2018, Dabo replaces Jalen Hurts with #1 recruit Trevor Lawrence. History progresses fairly similarly with Saban and Tua at Michigan and Dabo and Lawrence at Alabama, with a Dabo-Alabama title in 2018 and LSU winning it all in 2019.

New Orleans Saints

Let's go back to 2010, now. The Saints were 13-3 in 2010 with Matt Ryan and Sean Payton. With the #2 seed, they lose that year in the NFC Championship to the eventual champion Green Bay Packers. The Saints and Packers are heavy favorites headed into the 2011 season, and they do not disappoint. Payton and Matty Ice go 12-4, while Rodgers and the Packers go 15-1. New Orleans beats the 49ers in the Divisional Round, then benefit from the Giants upsetting the Packers (like they did in real life). The Saints roll through the Giants, unlike Alex Smith and the 49ers did that year, and advance to Super Bowl 46 against the Patriots. If the Giants beat the Patriots by 4, then Sean Payton and Matt Ryan should win by about 7-10 points. Tickertape falls all throughout NOLA as the Saints celebrate their 1st Championship.

The following season, the Saints claimed the #1 seed in the NFC. However, they would fall in the NFC Championship Game to Colin Kaepernick and Jim Harbaugh (just like Ryan's Falcons did in 2012). The next year, the BountyGate "scandal" would riddle the Saints, leading to 3 straight 7-9 seasons.

The Saints rebuilt and won 3 straight division titles from 2017-2019. I'll leave it up to you to decide whether or not Matt Ryan throws that INT in OT against the Rams in the NFC Championship Game...

Miami Dolphins

The Miami Dolphins story Post-2010 doesn't waver that much from the real life Dolphins. In 2011, the Dolphins hired Mike Tannenbaum as GM and Joe Philbin as Head Coach, just like they did in real life. They finish 6-10 in 2011, and end up with the #7 Pick. Just like they did in reality, they draft Ryan Tannehill with the #7 pick in the 2012 NFL Draft. Dolphins history progresses exactly the same way it did in the 2010's with 7 years of Ryan Tannehill.

Drew Brees

Drew Brees kind of becomes the big loser out of this whole story. Saban goes on to have success without him, the Saints win a Super Bowl with Matt Ryan, and now he's a Free Agent QB headed into his 30's with only 1 12 win season to his name.

Fortunately for Brees, he finds a place that allows him to have a career renaissance. You see, 2012 was the perfect year for Brees to become a Free Agent, because it was the same year as Peyton Manning's Free Agency Spectacular. Brees and his agent market himself as "the backup plan" for any team that loses out on the Peyton Manning sweepstakes, and he gets a couple offers to be a starter in 2012. Drew Brees ends up filling the Carson Palmer role with the Arizona Cardinals.

Brees finds a connection with Larry Fitzgerald and Bruce Arians, and they revive the end of his career just like they did in real life with Carson Palmer. The Cardinals make the NFC Championship Game in 2015, but again fall short to the Carolina Panthers and 15-1 MVP Cam Newton. They also win a magical game against the Green Bay Packers to get there.

Unlike the Cardinals of Carson Palmer's time, Drew Brees keeps the team competitive after 2015's NFC Championship Run. They make the Playoffs again in 2016, losing in a Wild Card Game against the Seahawks. They just miss the playoffs in 2017 by 1 game, ending at 9-7. A theme of Drew Brees' career.

After that 2017 season, Brees decides it's time for him to call it a career. After 16 seasons, Brees never did get that Super Bowl Trophy. No Hall of Fame Induction. No All Time Passing Yards record (although he still finished in the Top 15). Just 2 AFC Championship Games to his name and a lifetime of memories with the Chargers, Dolphins, and Cardinals. 

His career compares almost identically to the QB who replaced him in San Diego back in 2005: Phillip Rivers. It's funny how things come full circle like that in these kinds of stories.

No comments:

Post a Comment