Wednesday, September 23, 2020

NFL Division Retractions

 Any conclusions about the NFL Season through two weeks often end up being loud wrong. However, there are some situations, whether it be injuries, bad projections, or any myriad of smaller reasons, many Preseason Projections end up being loud wrong. The more conviction we have on preseason evaluations, the more prone we are to being loud wrong. So, without further ado, here are a few retractions that are necessary before we get to Week 3, as we update information when we have more results.

NFC South

Is it possible that the NFC South is the Worst Division in the NFC??? Unfortunately not, the NFC East still exists. However, this has been a VERY shaky start for the Saints, Falcons and Buccaneers. The Panthers were expected to finish a distant 4th, and will still finish a distant 4th.

If you were to pick a best unit in the NFC South, you'd have to go with the New Orleans Saints' Defense. Through 2 games (very early) the Saints have the 5th Best Defense in the NFL, even with a 34 point drubbing at the hands of the Raiders. Last week, we hypothesized about whether or not the Saints would be alright without Michael Thomas. They don't really have another Wide Receiver who is a go-to short yardage threat. In Week 2, the Saints tried to do an array of check downs to Alvin Kamara out of the backfield, then handing the ball to Kamara and Murray to pick up first downs. If this is going to be the Alvin Kamara train in New Orleans, it's gonna be a long season for their offense.

We've known for years now that Drew Brees' arm is shot. His success in his HOF Saints career has been that he is the most precisely accurate QB to ever pick up a football. Whenever they've called upon a big time pass play, Taysom Hill is the guy to make the play. Otherwise, the Saints hope to draw Pass Interference Calls by coming back to the ball on deep plays. The Saints offense is very limited, it's what allowed Michael Thomas to break the all time receptions record in 2019. As we saw against Las Vegas on Monday, Brees has now become the weak link of that team.

The Buccaneers might sneak into the playoffs by default in the NFC. For a decade, the NFC was a conference defined by it's depth. 11 Different Franchises Have made the Super Bowl in 14 years, and no team besides GB has made more than 1 NFC Championship since 2013. So far, you'd be hard pressed to find 5 teams that look legitimately good in the Conference. The Lions and Vikings have sputtered out the gate. The Eagles have fallen apart due to injuries. The Falcons defense is atrocious once again. The NFC West is 7-1, but eventually those teams will all start playing each other, either splitting games that will lower everyone's win %, or eliminating one 1-5 team (probably the Rams). Even Dallas has been a disappointment to start the year. The Bucs have been about the same as last year's Bucs, who were only 2 games out from the playoffs. In 2020, that 9-7 or 8-8 might just be good enough to make the NFC Playoffs.

Much more will be clear once the Bucs play the Falcons twice. The Falcons look like the same team they've been for 4 years: Matt Ryan will throw 400 yards, the defense will continue to suck, and both teams will score in the 30's or 40's. It's as if the Falcons are still trying to recapture the magic of 2016 again, but they haven't had anything more than a playoff upset over the Los Angeles Rams and beating the 49ers in San Francisco last year. This year could fall apart if the lose to the Bears this weekend, but Atlanta should win that game (For the record, both teams should be 1-1 headed into Week 3). I was very high on Atlanta early on, but it's clear that they are the exact same team they've been for the last 4 years... and that will get them near .500, depending on how they do in 1 possession games. They can still make the playoffs with a 3 or 4 wins against the Panthers and Bucs, but this will be more of a challenge than previously anticipated.

AFC West

Like the antithesis of the Carolina Panthers, we all assumed the Chiefs will win the AFC West. We can give them a 95+% chance of winning the division (Fun Fact: Patrick Mahomes has never been outside of 1st place in his starting career). The Rest of the Division was a toss up-- and it felt like many of those toss ups would be settled in head-to-head matchups. The team that got X number of wins would have a crack at one of those Wild Card Spots. That picture in the AFC West has become a bit more clear, and a big part of that is 1 team dropping out of the running.

The Denver Broncos  lost Von Miller before the season even started, which stumped a defense that was already middle of the pack. They may have a QB in Drew Locke. They may not. Nobody knows. Not John Elway, not you or me, not even Drew Locke. Now, we know the Broncos don't have a QB: They have a Jeff Driskell and a Blake Bortles for the next 6 weeks. Drew Locke's separated shoulder hurts them a lot, any QB loss would. What stings even more is Cortland Sutton, the most hyped up WR of the Offseason, has torn his ACL and will miss the rest of the season. This is all compounded by the fact that the Broncos are already 0-2, with upcoming matchups against Tampa Bay, New England and Kansas City before getting Locke back.

Denver will get Drew Locke back in time for their Chargers-Raiders matchups, and that might not matter bc the Chargers and Raiders are both showing a lot of promise. Las Vegas is 2-0 with wins against the Saints and Panthers. The Chargers Defense dominated Patrick Mahomes for 3 quarters, before salting away the game in OT. All of us expected Mahomes to go right down the field and tie the game with 2:30 and a 3 Pt deficit, and the Chargers can only view that game as a success. They are already well ahead of Denver, with the gap only poised growing larger this weekend: The Chargers have Carolina, the Raiders have NE (tough) and Denver has Tampa Bay. Maybe Jeff Driskell pulls off an upset at home, those games happen. Maybe the Raiders and Chargers will be 2-1, with Denver in striking distance at 1-2. All Denver can hope for is things staying afloat for a while, only to return to the hopes of Drew Locke, which nobody knows what he's capable of. I initially thought Las Vegas would be the team falling off in the AFC West, turns out it's the Broncos.

No comments:

Post a Comment