Monday, January 4, 2021

The Miami Dolphins and Taking a Leap Of Faith

 The Miami Dolphins were eliminated from the playoffs with their 56-26 point loss to the Buffalo Bills. Thanks to the Houston Texans' 4-12 season, the Dolphins hold the #3 and #18 picks in April's NFL Draft. There have been more than a few people and scenarios pointing to the Dolphins selecting Justin Fields or Zach Wilson one year after drafting Tua Tagovailoa with the 5th pick in the Draft.

People saying the Dolphins should move on from Tua this fast for another rookie QB are not crazy. They also aren't correct, but let's not be so judgmental here. There is a legitimate case the Dolphins should trade Tua and draft another QB the same way there's a case the Jets should trade Sam Darnold and draft Justin Fields or Zach Wilson. The only difference: Most people almost universally agree on trading Darnold, but spit on the people who say Miami should move on from Tua.

Here's what Darnold and Tua's Rookie Seasons both looked like:

Darnold: 13 Starts, 57.7% completion, 2865 yds, 17 TD's 15 INT's, 77.6 Passer rating, 6.9 yrd/attempt, 

Tagovailoa: 9 Starts, 64.1% completion, 1814 yards, 11 TD's 5 INT's, 87.1 Passer rating, 6.3 yrd/attempt

Tua undoubtedly is better in his rookie year than Sam Darnold was. It's not by a ton, but it's definitely better. It's not like very many people are sold on Tua, but if this is a rebuild, Tua's a rebuilding type of QB for the Dolphins.

Let's compare Tua's numbers now with the Offensive Rookie of the Year, Justin Herbert, who was taken one pick after Tua.

Herbert: 15 Starts, 66.6% completion, 31 TD's, 10 INT's, 98.3 passer rating, 7.3 yrd/attempt

Tagovailoa: 9 Starts, 64.1% completion, 1814 yards, 11 TD's 5 INT's, 87.1 Passer rating, 6.3 yrd/attempt

As most of you suspected, Tua is not as good as Justin Herbert. But he's not as bad as Sam Darnold. He's somewhere in the middle. Yet the gap between Justin Herbert and Sam Darnold, by NFL standards, is a lot of guessing room. Unfortunately for Miami, they have no more time to evaluate Tua before making any kind of final decision on his future.

The Dolphins can go in an array of different directions in this draft. As outlined on the Take It Easy Podcast, the Dolphins can sign any number of running backs this offseason for cheap, from James Connor to Marlon Mack to even... Aaron Jones??? They have that #18 pick to use on either an offensive lineman, a star RB like Najee Harris, or another TE to run more 2 TE sets with Mike Gesecki (they were significantly more efficient in 2 TE sets vs. 3 WR sets, but that may have been attributed to their lack of WR Depth this year).

Most importantly, that #3 pick sets the Dolphins up to take LSU WR Jamar Chase, who was better in 2019 than his LSU teammate Justin Jefferson, who just broke the Rookie record for receiving yards. Chase opted out of this season, and his draft stock remains equally high. Or Miami could, you know, add 2 more 1st Rounders by trading down with a QB needy team. The options are literally unlimited for Miami.

Here's the catch. This is the Dolphins last chance to draft that premier QB and hack the NFL's salary cap. The way to do that: Getting the star QB on their rookie deal. The Chargers just did that, and they have a chance to catch the Chiefs in the next half decade because of it. The Cardinals did it too, and they have 3 years of a cheap Kyler Murray to build on an 8-8 season that was somehow disappointing.

This is why the Darnold and Tua cases are so similar: Sam Darnold has improved very little from his rookie year. He lost 6 games in 2019 to Mono, then the Jets stripped all his talent before the 2020 season while Darnold battled shoulder injuries. I have no question Sam Darnold can be a serviceable, cheap QB for any number of contenders from the Colts to the Steelers to the 49ers, given the right infrastructure. Cheap, young, 1st Round QB's don't become available that often.... at least they used to.

In the last 3 years, we've seen 2 1st Round Picks (2018 draft or later) get dumped by the teams that drafted them. Josh Rosen was traded for a measly 2nd Round Pick to the Miami Dolphins, and it turned out to be a bad trade for the Dolphins (and Arizona, they used that extra draft pick to draft WR Andy Isabella over DK Metcalf). Last Monday, the Washington Racial Slurs dumped 2019 #15 pick Dwayne Haskins, who hasn't been claimed since. The Jets are about to dump Darnold, from 2018's class, to make it three times in 3 years.

The new NFL says it's better to cut bait with a bust than try and make them a "reclamation project", like the Bears are trying to do with Mitchell Trubisky. Word to the wise, anything the Bears are trying to do with their QB's, you should probably do the opposite until proven otherwise. It's simply not worth it, especially if you're gonna have to pay Trubisky $15 million or more this offseason. The reason it's being done is so Ryan Pace and Matt Nagy can keep their jobs, which adds to why reclamation projects are not great ideas: The years are too short on that rookie deal to spend 2 years trying w/ that same QB.

Instead of spending those 2 years trying to rebound your QB, why not just try again with another 1st Round Pick and reset the clock on their contract??? The answer is: It won't be you, GM who just picked a bust QB, who will be making that 2nd 1st Round Selection.... unless??????

You're the Miami Dolphins. GM Chris Grier is in the running for Executive of the Year in 2020 for building a 10 win team out of a team that was 0-7 and tanking 14 months ago. Brian Flores might win coach of the year as his praises get sung from coast to coast about the job the Dolphins did. You're jobs are as secure as any in the sport. Take that leap of faith, if you aren't sold on Tua, of course. You have a better chance of finding another Jamar Chase than you do of finding another Justin Herbert in the draft.

Here's the final reason why urgency is high in Miami: They will not have a draft pick this high for (hopefully) a very long time. The Dolphins are getting better, not worse, as we speak. The Dolphins can secure a cheap, great QB in the draft, or at the very least have the hope of one. If Tua doesn't end up working out, then 2 years from now you will be stuck in the same purgatory the Chicago Bears are in now, or the Las Vegas Raiders have been in for the last 4-5 seasons with Derek Carr.

While I still believe in the idea of doubling down on Tua, the warning signs are upon us. Again, he's better than Sam Darnold, a fringe starter at best, but not Justin Herbert, maybe a Top 10 QB right now. The Dolphins have to project, to their best of their abilities, where Tua falls on this spectrum. Maybe that means drafting Justin Fields or Zach Wilson with their #3 Pick bestowed upon them from Bill O'Brien.

2 comments:

  1. Good read. Well written peace and definitely a good take. Keep it up

    ReplyDelete