Saturday, January 30, 2021

Superstars Flexing Their Power: Nolan Arenado, LeBron James, James Harden and Deshaun Watson

We are living through an era of athlete empowerment. In a Post-LeBron "Decision" world, in combination with the rise of social networking, it has never been easier to take control of your own brand and your own fate. This has especially become true in the NBA, where the best players make more money than any other sports league, and more money = more power.

From LeBron James (3 times) to Kevin Durant in 2016, to Chris Paul, Kyrie Irving, Kawhi Leonard, Jimmy Butler, Kyrie Irving again, the NBA superstar has used their free agency to their own power, and decided to push their way to the city they want to play in.

Now, Anthony Davis and James Harden have taken that power to a new level. Davis and Harden forced trades out of their previous homes, with multiple years on a contract, and were able to achieve everything they wanted and more. For Davis, that meant getting a trade, an NBA Championship, and a new $180 million contract playing for the Los Angeles Lakers. For Harden, that was a trade to Brooklyn while continuing to be the face of Adidas (other than Messi) and make $45 million a season under the supermax he signed with Houston.

Because of the NFL's popularity, it was only a matter of time before this trend trickled on down to the NFL. That first major star to take control of his fate, just like James Harden and Anthony Davis, is Deshaun Watson. Watson got his $200 million extension from the Texans, with a full no trade clause. And he is going to be traded from the Texans before the contract ever goes into effect. He's going to be able to have his cake and eat it. No matter what, Deshaun Watson will make the max amount of money and play for exactly the team he wants to.

Yet, because of it's declining popularity, we missed the fact that Major League Baseball players make more money than the NFL Players (thanks to Collective Bargaining Agreements) but less than NBA players. And right underneath the noise of Deshaun Watson, Nolan Arenado just did the exact same power move to the Colorado Rockies.

Arenado flexed his power with the Rockies, got traded to the team he wanted in St. Louis, and even got a restructured contract for an extra year. And this isn't even the 1st time this has happened in recent MLB history, either.

The first real case of an MLB player flexing their leverage came in 2017, before Anthony Davis and James Harden getting everything they wanted, when Giancarlo Stanton was coming off of his 60 Home Run MVP season for an 81 win Marlins team. The Marlins had been sold to the Bruce Sherman-Derek Jeter group, and the new ownership was intent on moving Stanton's 10 year, $280 million contract while his value was the highest.

2017 was Giancarlo's first fully healthy season since 2014, when he earned his 13 year, $325 million contract in the first place. The Marlins wanted to move all of Stanton's money as he entered his age 29 season, so that the franchise could cut costs and start a rebuild with new President Derek Jeter. The Marlins negotiated a deal with the St. Louis Cardinals, where St. Louis would take every penny of Stanton's contract and give back some prospects in return.

And then Stanton decided he didn't want to live in St. Louis, which has an awful history of racism.

And the deal died right there. Stanton used his power of a no-trade clause to void a trade that took months to create.

Next up, the San Francisco Giants set up a deal to take on Stanton's contract. Stanton was a California kid, so the idea of returning to the West Coast was believed to be intriguing.

Stanton rejected the deal, because the Giants had the 2nd worst record in the MLB in 2017. He wanted to be traded to a winner.

So the Marlins went back to work, this time asking Stanton where he wanted to play. His list: The Astros, Yankees, Dodgers, and Cubs. The 4 Teams who made it to the ALCS and NLCS the previous season.

So Stanton would only accept a trade to one of the 4 best teams in Baseball, knowing that there was a 0% chance he was playing another game with the Miami Marlins. Ultimately, he got a deal done with the New York Yankees, who took every penny of his $280 million, paid out until Stanton turned 38.

Then, 3 years later, the Nolan Arenado situation came along. While there had been other trades in the between (Mookie Betts, Yu Darvish, Francisco Lindor), none of them contained a No Trade clause AND a 10 year contract already signed, sealed and delivered.

Back in March 2019, after the crazy offseason where Manny Machado got $300 million from San Diego and Bryce Harper got 13 years, $330 million from Philadelphia, Nolan Arenado got a 9 year extension for $324 million from the Colorado Rockies. It was clear that the Rockies were not going to be contenders in 2020, as they purged their roster that lost in the NLDS to Milwaukee to make room for Arenado's contract. But Arenado knew he was risking a LOT of money playing out the final year of his contract in Colorado.

Predictably, the Rockies finished 4th place in the NL West at 71-91. Then, the Pandemic hit, and the Rockies finished 4th in the NL West again, 4 games out of the final playoff spot and 12th place out of 15 in the NL.

The Rockies knew they needed to rebuild after Arenado's extension. The Rockies couldn't kid themselves into believing they could build a winner around Arenado with 1 year contracts and a bottom 10 farm system in Baseball. Arenado knew he wanted a trade out of Colorado, since they weren't going to be contending for 4-5 years, if ever again, under his contract.

Plus, after seeing how well the Marlins rebounded after moving Stanton's contract (and Stanton predictably playing 41 total games over the last 2 seasons), it was clear the Rockies and Arenado needed to go their separate ways. In all honesty, they needed to do that back in 2019, but Arenado was willing to sacrifice a year or 2 in order to get that record-setting money.

The truth is, Nolan Arenado knew that no franchise valued him as much as the Colorado Rockies did. It's where he was going to get the most money on his one big chance at Free Agency. When Colorado offered him the most money per year of any player in MLB history, along with a full no-trade clause, he would've been idiotic to not sign on the dotted line.

In the changing landscape of sports, players with real leverage and power can have their cake and eat it. LeBron James did it. So did Kevin Durant. And Anthony Davis and James Harden. And Giancarlo Stanton. They got the ridiculous record setting contracts, AND got to navigate trades/salary caps to go to EXACTLY the team they wanted!!!! 

So, after 2 years of a failed marriage going south, combined with a poor 60 game season from Arenado, Colorado realized they had to trade Arenado this year. The Rockies either A. Went to Nolan and asked him who he'd like to play for, at which point Nolan said the Cardinals. or B (and Most Likely): Negotiated a deal with the Cardinals, before going to Nolan, for $278 million, instead of the $324 million the Rockies valued Nolan Arenado at.

After negotiating the terms of the money (and getting 4 of Blake Snell signature "slapdick prospects") the Rockies went to Nolan Arenado and asked him if he would wave his no trade clause to join the St. Louis Cardinals. To which Nolan likely said that, in order to wave the no trade clause, the Cardinals would need to add an extra 1 year and $33 million to set up a full 10 year, $360 million contract (Arenado played the 1st year of that contract in 2020). The Cardinals agreed, and a deal got done.

And THAT is the power that the modern athlete possesses. Deshaun Watson is going to flex the same power on the Houston Texans, and he's going to join exactly the team he wants to. James Harden made the same flex two weeks ago. And, right under all of our noses, Nolan Arenado just flexed that same Harden-Watson-LeBron power on the Colorado Rockies. 

Not only did Nolan get traded to a contender, with an all-MLB teammate in Paul Goldschmidt, but he got an EXTRA YEAR extended on his record setting contract, coming off one of the worst seasons of his career at a time when players start to decline.

And he deserved every penny of it. Because Nolan Arenado has power. And Nolan Arenado has leverage. And he used all the power he had to get everything he wanted and more. Just like James Harden. Just like Anthony Davis. Just like LeBron James. Just like Giancarlo Stanton. And, in the coming 6 months, just like Deshaun Watson.

When you have a gift like these players, you should use every ounce of your leverage to your advantage. And we're seeing that power finally being flexed, birthed by a LeBron James Decision from 2010.

No comments:

Post a Comment