3 more NFL Head Coaching jobs have been filled in the last 24 hours. After Robert Saleh choose to join the New York Jets, the teams that had major interest in Saleh, the Detroit Lions and Atlanta Falcons, swooped up their coaching candidates before they each got away. Let's break down the new coaching hires, but instead of giving out letter grades in a cliche article that tells us nothing, I want to give out a different grading system:
Instead of a 0-10 star system, let's give these hires "LaFluer's", based on the Packers hire of Matt LaFluer that everyone thought was crazy, but ended up being the best hire of his offseason. Similar situations with Brian Flores, Sean McVay, Kevin Stefanski and others have arisen as shocking, yet excellent hires over the last 3-4 offseasons.
Robert Saleh to the Jets: 7.5 out of 10 LaFluers
So, the Jets hired the coach everyone wanted in the offseason coaching search. Let's look at who those coaches were each of the last 4 offseasons:
2017: Kyle Shanahan, 49ers 2018: Matt Patricia: Lions 2019: Wasn't really anybody, but I guess Kliff Kingsbury/Vic Fangio were closest 2020: Matt Rhule, Panthers
Saleh was the trendy 1st time coaching hire whom a number of teams respected as a candidate. As recent history shows, there isn't really any pattern for success among the coaches everybody wants. The ones who haven't worked out so far (Patricia and Fangio) both come from the defensive side of the ball. However, the biggest problem for those two coaches was the rosters the Lions and Broncos assembled around them. Patricia was a 3 years and out coach who never got his offense turned around. Fangio will be a 3 and out coach next offseason, given Drew Locke as his franchise QB and a team without a ton of great draft history in the last few years.
While Saleh is a totally different coach and person, it doesn't bode well for him that he's joining an organization with one of the worst owners in the NFL, that hasn't been to the playoffs more than once in the last 10 years. They are flush with cap space and have the #2 pick in the NFL Draft, which is great, but mind you the Jets also had a similar situation 3 years ago, when the team traded 4 picks and drafted Sam Darnold, signed LeVeon Bell, CJ Mosely, and Jamison Crowder, while trading Leonard Williams to the Giants.
I commend Saleh for the decision, Head Coaching Offers don't come along often. I don't think the Jets are guaranteed anything at this point.
Dan Campbell to the Lions: 5 out of 10 LaFluers
Wow. The Lions pulled a bit of shocker with this hire. While the deal isn't official, it will be once Campbell's Saints get eliminated from the playoffs. When the Lions cancelled their interview with Todd Bowles today, that confirmed the reports that were already out.
Anyways, the Lions want to go full Man Campbell?? No, that wasn't a typo. Man Campbell became a bit of a meme when he filled in for fired Dolphins coach Joe Philbin during the 2015 season. After the Dolphins hired Adam Gase, Man Campbell became the Assistant Coach for the New Orleans Saints for the last 5 years. The Saints won more games over the last 4 years than any team.
Campbell was a little bit of a surprise, as you may have guessed based on the "Wow" at the start. Surprise hires have tended to work out well in the last few years, from Sean McVay to Brian Flores and Kevin Stefanski. Some have also flopped, like Adam Gase and the Jets. The Lions are in this interesting position where they can go both ways.
Here's why the Lions got 5 LaFluers. 1. I wanted them to hire Campbell.... Matt Campbell!!! Oh well. At least if Dan flops in Detroit, I can always laugh that they should've hired the other Campbell from Iowa State. 2. The success of Campbell and new GM Brad Holmes will be determined immediately on whether or not they'll be allowed to pick their QB. If the Lions tie these two to Matt Stafford (and possibly Darrell Bevell) the experiment is guaranteed to fail in Detroit. If the Lions move on from Stafford, letting Holmes pick his new QB at a cheap price, it could still fail. It's why Detroit was the least desirable job in the NFL this coaching cycle. But it still might succeed if given total freedom and room to make some mistakes along the way.
Arthur Smith to the Falcons: 8.5 out of 10 LaFluers
The Falcons zigged while I thought they would zag. The Falcons hired a defensive minded Head Coach, which means Dirk Koetter will be looking for a new job. Koetter is one of the better offensive minds in the NFL, so I thought the Falcons might retain him and make a defensive hire at Head Coach.
Instead, the Falcons picked another fruit off of the Sean McVay-Matt LaFluer-Kevin Stefanski coaching scheme. Make that 8 NFL teams now getting ready to use the zone rushing schemes of years past, adding the Jets with new OC Mike LaFluer.
As for the Falcons, this hire is eerily similar to when the Rams hired Sean McVay to coach Todd Gurley. While there's no guarantee that Gurley will return to the Falcons next year, there weren't exactly people lining up to sign him last offseason. By hiring Smith, the Falcons are hiring the scheme that led to emergences of Derrick Henry, Dalvin Cook, Nick Chubb, Aaron Jones, the 49ers 6 RB committee, and... Todd Gurley with the Rams!!!! The Falcons are going to look dramatically different than they did last year on offense.
Whether or not Matt Ryan is still on the Falcons shouldn't matter on what they run offensively. Maybe the Falcons spend the #4 pick in the Draft on a QB, trade Ryan, and give Smith all the tools to succeed. Alternatively, the Falcons could keep Ryan and disguise him in play action passes and make him look something like a Jared Goff or Kirk Cousins, compared to the 5,000 yard QB he's been for a few years now.
I love the move of any team to bring in that zone running scheme of the Titans. It worked out super well for the Packers when they hired Matt LaFluer, even when people thought it would be strange. The Falcons may not be great immediately like the Packers, and that will be because they lack talent. The Falcons will be the most interesting team of the three to check in on in 3 years.
No comments:
Post a Comment