Matthew Stafford and the Lions are headed for an amicable divorce, which I told y'all was going to happen 8 months ago. Anyways, the Lions are looking for trade partners before March 11th, when Stafford's final 2 years and $64 million becomes guaranteed for the Lions. The market dictates that Matthew Stafford is worth 2 Mid-Late 1st Round Picks, plus additional compensation. It's a great time for the Lions to make the move, considering Stafford is coming off of back-to-back injury plagued seasons and enters his late prime at 33 years old.
So, if 2 1st Round Picks is what it will take to land Stafford for 2 years at $32 million a season, for which teams would such a move be worth it??? Let's evaluate
Here's the NFL Teams who would consider making a QB change this offseason: Patriots, Dolphins, Jets, Colts, Steelers, Broncos, Washington, Saints, Panthers, Falcons, Bears, 49ers, Rams (I'd personally include the Raiders and Giants, but it seems clear they won't be making QB changes).
1. Salary Cap Space
The key with any Stafford trade: Which NFL teams have created enough cap space to take on a $32 million Quarterback?? Stafford is not an ideal option for a team struggling with cap issues, since they won't be able to make other improvements around Stafford. This takes out the Falcons, Rams, Saints, Steelers and Chicago Bears (not that Detroit would've traded Stafford to Chicago anyways).\
Teams Left: NE, MIA, NYJ, IND DEN, WAS, CAR, SF
2. Willingness to Part with Draft Picks (AKA Winning Window is Open Right Now)
The price tag for Stafford is high for a player with an extensive injury history that can walk in just 2 seasons. The Seahawks gave up 2 1st for 2 years of Jamal Adams, and I have a feeling that contract is not going to age well. The Rams did the same for Jalen Ramsey, and they were able to resign him. The Rams have been able to remain semi-competitive with the #1 rated Defense in 2020. I'd say that deal was a win for the Rams.
In the case of Stafford, no team should part with a Top 10 pick to acquire Stafford. He's a win-now option, and losing that draft capital would lead to a Lions-esque situation all over again. So take out the Panthers, Broncos and Jets.
Teams Left: NE, MIA, IND, WAS, SF
3. Would Stafford be a Worthy Upgrade at QB??
Football fans (myself included) like dreaming up all the different teams a player can join and how great a fit they would be. What doesn't get asked enough... is it worth it for (insert X team) to make the trade?? For some of these teams, you'd be going all in on Matthew Stafford. If you can't meet your goals with Stafford, probably in 2021, you have no real room to pivot.
By trading for Matthew Stafford, your fate would be essentially carved in stone for 2021 AND 2022. With that in mind, answer each of these questions for yourself:
Would you trade 2 1st Round Picks to upgrade from Jimmy G to Matthew Stafford??? My answer is no. Your answer may be different. If that's the case, I'll knock out the 49ers.
Would you trade Tua Tagovailoa and the #17 pick in the Draft for Matthew Stafford???? My answer is, surprisingly, yes. Your answer may be different, so maybe take the Dolphins off the board..
The Case for the Indianapolis Colts
If I'm the Colts, I'm asking for the Lions price and taking the deal immediately (within reason, no Anthony Davis 3 1sts and 3 2nds for Stafford).
Andrew Luck was 1st in QBR in the last 12 games of 2018. He's Andrew Luck, he was an elite QB. With the same O-Line and weapons, Philip Rivers finished 17th in QBR in 2020. Philip Rivers was a fringe starter who looked washed behind a bad Chargers O-Line one year earlier.
Stafford is not Andrew Luck, but he's a significant upgrade over Philip Rivers. With, if my rough math is correct, makes Matthew Stafford a Top 7 Quarterback in the NFL on the Colts. Yes, the Colts won't be able to Draft a Left Tackle to replace Anthony Costanzo, but guess what: Even by adding Stafford's $32 million contract, the Colts still have 4th Most Cap Space available in Free Agency.
The Colts have no QB on their roster, and they are firmly within their Super Bowl winning window. You get Matthew Stafford and you overpay for Matthew Stafford. Either that or trade 3 1st Rounders to go up and get Zach Wilson at Pick #3. I very much prefer a surefire Top 10 QB for 1 less 1st Round Pick.
The Case for the Washington Racial Slurs
Like the Colts, the Washington Racial Slurs do not have a QB on their active roster. There's not much of a route to a top draft pick, and unless you want to hope Trey Lance falls to Pick 20, I'd suggest thinking big swing with your Draft Picks.
For all the crap going on in the Racial Slurs organization (hence why I continue calling them the Racial Slurs), they've already nailed 2 of the 3 steps to any great rebuild: 1. Acquire Cheap, Young Talent, so that they all enter their primes at the same time. and 2. Reset your salary cap, so that you have money to spend once your window opens.
The 3rd step of any rebuild is find a solution for your QB Position. Sometimes that happens through the Draft (Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen), Free Agency (Tom Brady) or both (Carson Wentz and Nick Foles). For the first time in recent memory, the NFL trade market is finally opening up for Quarterbacks, and the Racial Slurs can capitalize on this opportunity, given that Deshaun Watson DEFINITELY doesn't want to play for your team.
In the case of Stafford, he has a legitimate #1 WR in Terry McLaurin, a Top 10 ranking offensive line in 2020, and a defense who's Front 7 ranked #2 in the NFL. Stafford has never had a Top 10 ranked O-Line and 1 Top 10 defense in his entire career. He can get both in Washington. Washington would have to part with some draft picks, but great drafting over the last few years means they have the young talent to survive those losses.
The Case for the New England Patriots
Let me preface Stafford talks with this: If the 49ers find a QB to take over Jimmy G, it'll be an easy decision for New England to sign Garoppolo and keep their Draft Picks. If he stays in SF, I would use my 1st Round Pick to draft a QB if I were the Patriots.
With that said, here's the case for the Patriots. The infrastructure is there to build a winner. The Patriots won 7 games with a team that had a 3 week COVID outbreak, had no cap space, and will get back Donta Hightower, Patrick Chung, and Marcus Cannon from COVID opt outs. The Patriots are probably in a winning window right now.
They have reset their cap space to, if they so choose, having nearly $71 million available to sign players with. And, because they have #15 Pick in the Draft, New England will get to keep some of their 2nd and 3rd Round picks. They can also flip Stephon Gilmore to get back their 1st Round Pick, who has become kind of expendable with the breakout of JC Jackson as a Top 5 PFF Corner in 2020.
New England can lock down the QB position, then use some of their extra $40 million in cap space (assuming Julian Edelman retires) to sign a WR like Kenny Golladay, Allen Robinson or Corey Davis. The Patriots also have a Top 10 Offensive Line, which Stafford has never had, and a defense that just 12 months ago was ranked #3 in the NFL.
With a top WR, Jakobi Myers, and one of these 1 year old guys like AJ Green or T.Y Hilton, Stafford can be the Top 10 QB we all know he could always be, regaining that Pro Bowl form we all know he has.
No comments:
Post a Comment