Saturday, January 23, 2021

The Case for Trading Nick Chubb, Plus 4 Playoff Teams Selling And Remaining Competitive

 The Pivot is one of the hardest tasks ever great NFL team is faced with. It's nearly impossible to sign every player from your elite core to a contract extension, and it often goes poorly for the teams who try (I'm looking at you, Cowboys and Falcons fans).

So, here's 4 trades playoff teams can make as sellers, while still remaining competitive in the near future. Some of these names might be more shocking than others... including a legitimate NFL Superstar.

Ravens Trade Matthew Judon to the Bills for Ed Oliver and a 2nd Round Pick

    So, the Ravens are the sellers in this trade, but they are negotiating with another AFC powerhouse. In fact, it's the same team that just eliminated the Ravens last weekend.

The Ravens franchise tagged Matthew Judon last offseason, and despite a few injuries, he was extremely productive in 2020. Judon made it known (in a report his camp likely leaked) that Judon is looking for a contract around $20 million a season. The Ravens made it pretty clear they don't intend to give Judon that contract.

Instead, the Ravens can tag-and-trade Judon to the Buffalo Bills, who are very much looking for Linebacker help this offseason. The reason the Bills deal seems more enticing than even a 1st Round Pick is those two potential starters on defense. Oliver, who seems headed towards a breakup with the Bills, can be placed next to Calais Campbell and the Ravens can run some 4-3 defense next season. That 2nd Round Pick could be another defensive player who, sooner than later, can become a starter on the Ravens.

For a player headed for a departure anyways, the tag-and-trade strategy makes too much sense for the Ravens. For Buffalo, they have the cap space to invest big money to lock down the OLB position and improve the defense that will (probably) be what keeps them from making the Super Bowl.

Steelers Trade Bud Dupree to the Buccaneers for the 29th Pick in the NFL Draft

The impending Free Agency of Shaq Barrett means the Tampa Bay Buccaneers are in the market for an Edge Rusher. Enter Bud Dupree, the Steelers Linebacker who was having an amazing season before tearing his ACL. 

Dupree is also a free agent, and like Matt Judon the Steelers would be really smart to tag-and-trade Dupree, allowing him to pick the team he'd like to play for, and allowing that team to negotiate a deal for him. This deal closely resembles the Dee Ford trade from a couple years ago, where the Chiefs sent Ford to the 49ers for the 33rd Pick in the NFL Draft.

As for Dupree's contract, I assume Bud Dupree will get a smaller contract than the record setting deal Shaq Barrett is set to get from some team (probably the Giants). Dupree is a plug and play guy for a team that we all assume will be a Super Bowl favorite in 2021. When healthy, Dupree could replicate the production of Shaq Barrett almost identically. It would be a worthwhile investment for the Bucs' 1st Round Pick, given Tampa Bay shows very little pressing needs right now (They could also tag and trade Barrett and get their 1st Round Pick back)

As for the Steelers, it's time to pivot into the next era of Steelers football. There are still tons of pieces on your defensive core, the best of which being TJ Watt, Minkah Fitzpatrick, and Devin Bush. Pittsburgh needs help rebuilding their offense, and 2 1st Round Picks will go a long way to replenishing some of their young talent.

Buccaneers trade Chris Godwin to the Colts for Michael Pittman, a 4th Round Pick and a 5th Round Pick

Most NFL people suspect the Buccaneers will franchise tag Chris Godwin this offseason. Either Godwin will play next season on the Franchise Tag or the Bucs and Godwin will reach a contract north of $15 million a season. If Tampa did extend Godwin, he would be the 2nd WR making over $15 million on their team.

Let's say, just by chance, Godwin makes it clear he does not intend to play 2021 under the Franchise Tag. What could the Bucs get for him in a tag-and-trade??? Maybe a team would give up a 1st Round Pick (Baltimore??? Tennessee?? Miami???) but I don't think such a deal is in the works. Plus, I assume Tampa Bay wants to win now, so draft picks may be less enticing than proven commodities.

Enter the Indianapolis Colts. The Colts are flush with cap space, as they tend to be every year under the frugal (I mean the good kind) Chris Ballard. T.Y Hilton is a Free Agent, and appears to be something close to washed at this point. Let's assume the Colts give Hilton a 1 year contract at WR2 money to be their WR2. At this point, that means Michael Pittman Jr. is expected to be the Colts WR1, as he was for much of the season last year.

Why not use some of your cap space to upgrade at the WR position??? Clearly a WR isn't highest on Indianapolis' list of priorities in the 2021 offseason, that would be finding a Left Tackle, QB, and extending Darius Leonard. But in this trade, the Colts wouldn't have to give up any top draft picks. Godwin, Hilton and Zach Pascal sounds like a formidable WR trio for whoever the new Colts QB ends up being.

As for the Bucs, Michael Pittman is a better compliment for Mike Evans, Antonio Brown and the TE gauntlet they have. Many times, Chris Godwin was getting lost in the WR shuffle during the season, and much of that had to do with Brady's tendencies of throwing the ball down field. Pittman represents a strong horizontal threat that may work out well for the flow of the Bucs offense. Plus, there's a chance they lose Godwin for nothing. Might as well add a 23 year old WR with 1 season and 500 yards under his belt.

Browns Trade Nick Chubb and a 3rd Round Pick to Atlanta for the #4 Pick in the Draft

Alright Cleveland, how much do you believe in the Kevin Stefanski system??? Because Nick Chubb has 1 year left on his contract, and paying the running back is the single riskiest proposition in the NFL. Regardless of how the rest of Nick Chubb's career goes, Chubb's value will never be higher than it is right now, and the Browns can make an epic pivot to keep themselves competitive for many years to come.

What is Atlanta's motivation for making this trade??? The opportunity for Nick Chubb to be Derrick Henry. To have an Arthur Smith offense that dominates on the ground and gets Matt Ryan in play action. It's not like the Falcons defense is going to be fixed overnight anyways, so just say f*** it and build an elite offense right now. Plus, it's not like the Falcons weren't a 7-9 team that happened to have 3 historically bad collapses in the 2020 season. They may not be as far off as we think, and if Atlanta is going to commit to Matt Ryan being on the team beyond the NFL Draft, they better COMMIT to Matt Ryan right now.

So let's say the Cleveland Browns get that #4 pick in the NFL Draft. What next?? First and foremost, start a bidding war for anyone who wants Zach Wilson or Justin Fields. Accumulate more and more and MORE draft picks. Not because you are starting a rebuild, but because you can replace Chubb with a rookie RB, make Kareem Hunt the RB1, AND build a defensive core around your Top 3 edge rusher (Myles Garrett) and Top 10 CB (Denzel Ward). If you keep the #4 pick, take best Defensive Player available, but if picking by position, take Linebacker.

The Browns could buck the trend of awful RB contracts, which to be fair is being bucked by Derrick Henry and, to an extent, Ezekiel Elliott. They had the best RB duo in 2020, but I feel confident they could replicate Top 2 production with Hunt, D'Ernest Johnson and another Day 2-3 running back.

No comments:

Post a Comment