Tuesday, December 1, 2020

How Does One Dismantle a Dynasty???

How do you dismantle a dynasty?? It's something we don't really think about in Sports enough, mostly because there's so much nuance involved in these situations. Yet, every great run (even those that don't end in any level of meaningful success) comes to some sort of end, often very quietly.

Sometimes it's Gregg Popovich forcing Kawhi Leonard to want to leave San Antonio, ending the longest dynasty in modern NBA history. Sometimes it's an array of bad contracts that lead to trading Mookie Betts, a generational superstar, to the Dodgers. But sometimes, it's more subtle. It's a 6-10 season bouncing around from Blake Bortles to Cody Kessler to Gardner Minshew. It's Tom Brady departing in Free Agency, leaving you with a depleted roster with minimal cap flexibility. Or it's quietly and without any publicity trading Paul Goldschmidt to the St. Louis Cardinals for 3 young prospects.

As I think about the breaking up of teams and restarting again, I realize there is no one model of success. There's far too much nuance in situations to say, for instance, everyone should do what the Houston Astros did in 2011 by losing more games in 3 straight seasons than anyone in history (FYI, it's the greatest rebuild in American Professional Sports). The Jazz, for instance, simply can't tear the team down to it's bare bones and go full Process. They have a 23 year old All Star in Donovan Mitchell. 

I've deduced the best way to go about this conversation is to look at 4 different dynasties, in the loose form of the term, across 3 different sports. Look at the patterns we see in each, which will help us understand how to engage with tear downs in sports. I mentioned the Astros rise earlier, and they're the first place I'd like to start in the looming tear down.

Houston Astros

In 2017, the Houston Astros traded much of their farm system for Justin Verlander at the August Waiver Trade Deadline. From there, the Astros won the World Series on the backs of Verlander, Charlie Morton, and their "Core 4" from their long, winding rebuild of 6 years. Those players that made up the "Core 4": Alex Bregman, Jose Altuve, George Springer, and Carlos Correa.

Over the next 3 seasons, the Astros would experiment with other pieces around that Core 4. They'd trade for Gerrit Cole, turning him into one of the 2 best pitchers in Baseball. They'd sign Michael Brantley, bring in Josh Reddick, and recall 2019 ROY Yordan Alvarez. They'd make a big trade in 2019 to get Zack Grienke from the Arizona Diamondbacks, then make it to Game 7 of the World Series 3 months later. Then Verlander and McCullers would have Tommy John, Cole would leave for New York, and Yordan Alvarez would miss almost all of 2020.

Through it all, the Core 4 remained intact. The players who had come up through the Astros organization, and represented the fruits of their long and successful rebuild. The greatest sign that the Astros run of success is done (more than their 29-31 record in 2020) is that Core 4 is finally breaking apart. Springer is about to leave in Free Agency within 2 months. Carlos Correa is set to make $250 million+ in free agency, and Houston has been floating his name around in Trade talks. Altuve had a tough 2020, a byproduct of his age and him struggling initially to embrace the villain role he's now become. The only 1 of the 4 with a long term, productive future in Houston is Bregman, who will anchor the Franchise at 3B into the future.

This is not to say the Astros won't continue to be a good, if not great team. It's going to be interesting to see what happens after MLB cut off the head of the Astros snake, when they fired Jeff Luhnow following the sign stealing scandal. What we know for sure is that the next version of the Houston Astros will look very different than the teams of the past 4 seasons, of whom have had more playoff success than any team since the 1990's Yankees.

The Astros have lots of assets, especially Correa and Altuve. They can improve their prospects for the future by moving them now. In the case of Correa, you risk losing him for nothing a year from now in Free Agency, with no guaranteed replacement waiting in the wing. For Altuve, another bad season in 2021 will erase his trade value all together, given he still has 4 years and $120 million left on his contract. Lot's of questions exist in Houston, but they have the assets to make some magic happen, especially after the lose Springer and possibly Michael Brantley in Free Agency this year.

Chicago Cubs

The end of the Cubs' Dynasty, which 4 years ago brought Chicago it's 1st World Series in 108 years, came much more loudly than the end of the Astros. It came when Chicago got swept out of the Wild Card Round 2-0 to the upstart Miami Marlins. In 2019, the Cubs finished 3rd Place in a Weak NL Central, missing the playoffs. Theo Epstein, the architect of this Cubs team, left town last month, becoming the 1st person to officially jump off the sinking ship in Wrigleyville.

Like the Astros, the Cubs have 4 young players coming up on new contracts. MVP 3B Kris Bryant, 1B Anthony Rizzo, SS Javier Baez, and LF/DH Kyle Schwarber are all on the last year of their contracts. The only one the Cubs have seemed interested in negotiating with is Baez. Willson Contreras, the Cubs All Star Catcher, won't be a Free Agent until 2023. Jed Hoyer is left to his own devices on whether or not to trade his 4 core pieces, and which to resign to new deals. All of this comes with the fact that Chicago is already pushing the luxury tax thanks to big contracts for Yu Darvish and Jason Heyward.

It seems the Cubs have already made up their mind on Kris Bryant. Bryant will not be returning in Free Agency, and the Cubs are going to maximize value on him. Baez, who is younger than Schwarber and Rizzo, will likely get a big, record setting contract this offseason from the Cubs. All the signs are pointing to that getting done before Opening Day. Rizzo and Schwarber are where things get interesting for the future of the Cubs. They won't command the same value as Kris Bryant, but what the Cubs decide to do with those two players will signify their intentions for how this team breaks apart.

If the Cubs do decide to move on from Rizzo and Schwarber, does that mean Yu Darvish is now on the table?? After a CY Young season in 2020, the Cubs can actually trade Darvish and his 3 year, $60 million contract for a lot of future capital. What about Contreras?? Or Kyle Hendricks??

While the MLB offseason progresses slowly, I'm surprised more hasn't been made about what the Cubs are going to do to shake up the MLB landscape. They hold a lot of chips for a team that, from 2015-2018, was a perennial power atop MLB power rankings. As the ship goes down, it's time to see what can be recouped as things get reset in Chicago.

Houston Rockets

The best gifts in the NBA are the Superstars. The Rockets have one of those, albeit for just the short term. James Harden represents the balance of power in the NBA for the 2021 season. If he, and by extension Russell Westbrook remain in Houston, it signifies a lot about where the Rockets go and what kind of value they want or need when restarting their franchise.

For a team that was 1 game from the NBA Finals, breaking apart was never going to be an easy task. Yet the Rockets moved with near lightning speed moving on from Mike D'Antoni and Daryll Morey, replacing them with a 1st time Coach and GM in Stephen Silas and Rafael Stone, respectively. First order of business was to trade Robert Covington for 2 1st Round Picks, 1 of which they flipped for Christian Wood. For now, the Rockets are hanging onto what they have, which won't get them farther than their 5 game loss in Round 2 to the Lakers in the NBA bubble.

In reality, the Rockets have time on their side. They are waiting for the right offer to move on from James Harden, and subsequently Russell Westbrook. Since Harden is under contract for 2 more seasons, they can wait this out for a bit. The only downside is if Harden begins to regress in 2021, thus driving down his value along with 1 less year of control. The Rockets decision is to play the waiting game, even though it's clear their window of success has come to a close. This is the right thing to do, especially if your Rafael Stone, a GM who's entire career will be defined by how he transitions from Harden to the next great Rocket. He's in a similar position to Jed Hoyer with the Chicago Cubs, where patience is the key for now. After their next respective season starts, time begins to start ticking for both Stone and Hoyer to recoup their value.

Los Angeles Chargers

The Chargers were smart enough (smarter than me, at least) to recognize that their 5-11 2019 season was a trend and not a fluke. They immediately pivoted from Melvin Gordon and Philip Rivers, who had been together for 5 years in San Diego/Los Angeles and won 1 playoff game in 2018. Instead of trying to do anything dramatic, they simply let both of them walk in Free Agency. For the Chargers, the cap flexibility was better than any value they could've gotten from dragging out the situation with a Franchise Tag to either Rivers or, more likely, Gordon.

The Chargers committed to a model version of the 3 year rebuild. Following Year 1 of that rebuild, they drafted their QB Justin Herbert. The QB that GM Tom Telesco is staking his job on. Anthony Lynn will be in the same position if Telesco decides he wants to keep Lynn (he can fire him and not lose his own job at this point). In Year 2 of their 3 year rebuild, they've lost enough games to start rebuilding their defense. The Chargers are in line to get the #5 pick in 2021. They should either A. Trade down to a QB needy team willing to overpay to move up to get Zach Wilson B. Select Micah Parsons from Penn State (assuming he doesn't go at #4 to the Cowboys).

Herbert is going to win the ROY this year, and anyone who watches him feels confident the Chargers are going to have themselves a cheap, really good QB for the next 4 years (when Herbert's contract comes up). This is the cheat code to rebuilding in the NFL: Nailing the QB and getting him cheap for the first 5 years of his career. The Chargers have hit on that, so now they can focus on drafting Offensive and Defensive Lines, much like the 49ers did with most of their top picks. The multiple assets can be a great thing for the Chargers, because it's more chances to hit on top players. 

That strategy, trading a valuable assets for lots of future assets, has been a staple of many NFL rebuilds of the last 5 years. The Browns traded down from Picks #2 and #12 in 2016 and 2017, respectively, so that Philly could take Carson Wentz and Houston could take Deshaun Watson. Those trades netted them Nick Chubb and Denzel Ward, along w/ Jabrill Peppers whom they traded for Odell Beckham Jr. The Bills traded Pick #10 so KC could take Patrick Mahomes. They got Tre'Davious White out of those picks. The Jags traded Jalen Ramsey for 2 1sts. Same with the Raiders for Khalil Mack. And the Dolphins for Laremy Tunsil. All of those 3 teams turned those picks into bright futures w/ lots of young, controllable assets.

The Chargers can absolutely do that with the #5 Pick. QB hungry teams will always overpay to move up in the Draft. The Chargers now have a Jalen Ramsey-esque asset at #5, and they should do their due-diligence and, ultimately, trade that pick to get lots of future assets on the Offensive and Defensive Lines.

No comments:

Post a Comment