I don't think Phillies Owner John Middleton is a very good CEO. I don't know this for a fact, but every message the Phillies have given for the last 3 MLB offseason's reveal a feeling of being overwhelming. First, he coined the now famous phrase "Stupid Money" that the Phillies intended to spend. With their relative cap flexibility, the Phillies signed Andrew McCutchen for $50 million, signed David Robertson for $11.5 million a season, and dropped a cool $330 million for 13 years of Bryce Harper, a generational talent who, apart from 1 MVP season, never finished in the Top 10 of the MVP (not to diss Harper at all, just pointing out that level of money is destined to flop over time).
Along with those $400 million in signings, the Phillies traded Jorge Alfaro and Sixto Sanchez, key pieces in a Marlins NLDS run in 2020, for 2 years of JT Realmuto. They also acquired Jean Segura from Seattle for Carlos Santana and JP Crawford, the first of which is the cleanup hitter on Cleveland and the latter is the leadoff hitter and SS for the Mariners. All of this bought Philadelphia a whopping 1 Victory more from 2018 to 2019, going 81-81 and missing the playoffs.
The 2nd offseason, 1 year ago, the Phillies doubled down on their efforts to spend "Stupid Money", to make the playoffs in 2020. They signed Zack Wheeler for 5 years and $118 million. They signed Didi Gregorious to a $14 million, 1 year contract (a year after trading for Segura at the same position). Rhys Hoskins, the big power rookie partly responsible for the 80 win 2018 season, has regressed to an above average 1B in the MLB, with a large contract coming up after 2022. The COVID Phillies finished 28-32, getting eliminated on the last weekend of the season from a playoff bracket that added 6 extra teams in 2020. GM Matt Klentak, an executive universally regarded as "good at his job" was fired for not winning enough games with pricey Free Agents.
Now, the Winter Meetings are here, and the Phillies are in payroll slashing mode. Reports came out that the Phillies were shopping Wheeler to anyone who would take his 4 year, $90 million left on his deal. If Harper's contract were tradeable, the Phillies would be happy to offload their 11 year commitment to a relationship already on a train south. It's also universally understood that the Phillies will not be resigning Realmuto, the league's best catcher with whom they never made a playoff appearance with, and Gregorious, a lone bright spot in an overall shitty 2020.
With all of this going on, Middleton, the outrageous owner with a team stuck between relevance and pricey mediocrity, took to the mic and made one of the strangest statements I've heard (no exaggeration). Middleton said the Phillies weren't shopping Zack Wheeler, and that the Phillies "wouldn't trade Wheeler for Babe Ruth". Now, media relations 101 says that if someone is denying a story (w/ negative consequences for them) it's very likely that the reports are even truer than we thought. In this case, Middleton's torching left me confused and stunned, trying to piece together why he would go this far to protest the report, especially for a 2nd or 3rd Starter he probably doesn't want to pay.
Middleton and the Phillies underline the theme of MLB's Winter Meetings: Everyone wants to offload their big contracts onto another team. The COVID-19 pandemic accelerated a market correction in MLB around the 5, 6, 10 or, in the case of Harper, 13 year deals either given out or soon to be given out. Cleveland is 100% intent on moving Francisco Lindor. The Reds are set on trading Sonny Gray. The Astros are going to try and trade Carlos Correa a year before Free Agency. As are the Cubs with Kris Bryant. The Rockies would like to move Nolan Arenado's contract and start a rebuild w/ those prospects. And the Phillies are trying to dump most of their roster to the highest bidders.
Philadelphia spent 5 years losing and building up one of MLB's best farm systems. In 1 year, they went from losing 99 games to going 80-82. They felt their window was opening. Now that window feels closed, and it's going to be a while before the Phillies are any kind of competitve again (in terms of winning the division). The Braves are still the NL East gold standard. The Mets have a 3 year plan and infinite resources under Steve Cohen. The Marlins just made the NLDS a year ahead of schedule, a similar place the Phillies were in after 2018. The Nationals aren't great, but they just might be better than the Phillies. That leaves the Phillies fighting to stay relevant, and 1 bad year away from 4th or 5th Place NL East mediocrity for the next 3 years.
So yeah, the Phillies failed. They look kinda stinky, and they might turn it around. Again, they have a lot of talent on their team. They just need to find cheap talent that compliments those nasty contracts they've given out to Wheeler, McCutchen, Segura (who might get traded too) Arrieta and Bryce Harper (who finished 4th in the MVP in 2020).
No comments:
Post a Comment