Let's acknowledge the dominance of the New England Patriots. Over 20 years, they won 19 AFC East titles and never lost fewer than 10 games every year for 20 years. Who are some of the other great, sustained dynasties of recent NFL History??? The Green Bay Packers come to mind. Apart from 2 sub-.500 seasons, the Packers were a playoff team 15 seasons. Mike Tomlin has never had a losing season in his 15 years as Pittsburgh Steelers Head Coach, despite only 1 Super Bowl to his name. After that, you can think of teams like the Saints, Colts, Chiefs, or even the Falcons.
All of these teams had different era built within the same eras of success. The Steelers went from Hines Ward and Jerome Buss to the Troy Polamalu, Big Ben and Santonio Holmes led Super Bowl. That blended into the "Killer B's" era with Ben, AB and LeVeon Bell, defined by high powered offensive teams. The next version is built by a deep, young defense and weapons aplenty on Offense. While this year may be that Steelers' teams best chance at winning, that's not who I want to focus on right now. That would be the Indianapolis Colts.
It's been 3 years since the Colts winning window officially "opened". This window opened following a 9-1 finish to 2018 that saw A. Andrew Luck rated #1 in QBR over 10 games B. The Colts defense ranked #1 in the league in scoring defense C. The Colts having the highest PFF rated Offensive Line. The Colts staggered the Houston Texans in the Wild Card, before losing to the Chiefs in the Divisional Round. The Colts had one of the best Rookie Draft Classes in NFL History: Both Quenton Nelson and Darius Leonard made All-Pro 1st Team as Rookies, the 1st time that happened in 50 years. The Colts had an undisputed elite QB in Luck, along with the protection Luck was missing for 2015-2017, where Luck missed 16 games, including all of 2017. The Colts had tons of cap space ($80 million to be exact) and had found Frank Reich as a diamond from the Philadelphia Eagles. The Colts were on their way to becoming a Super Bowl Contender in 2019 and beyond. Their winning window was open.
Then Andrew Luck retired.
2 years later, the Colts feel like their still reeling from that monumental decision. It's clear now that Philip Rivers did exactly what the Colts thought he would: Get them by, nothing more, nothing less. Now, the Colts need help from their counterparts (either the Texans, Bengals, Bills, or Mason Rudolph) just to even make the playoffs. From being in the Final 8 teams in 2018, where this franchise is now can only be described as a monumental disappointment for the Colts.
The Colts are going to keep the core of their team together next year, but the question becomes... how do they retool again??? As we described earlier with the Steelers, the shelf life for an NFL teams "window" is around 3 years. Sometimes more, sometimes less. But the natural cycles of the sport leave you about 3 years to win with the current core of your team. The way that window gets extended is by drafting and trading for more generational talents (since signing them is really, REALLY difficult).
For the Chiefs, their window was coming to a close with the core led by Alex Smith, Justin Houston and company in 2017. They went from losing in the Wild Card in 2015 (to a 34-10 blown lead vs. the Colts) to making the 2nd Round in 2015, before losing to the Steelers at home, then losing in the Wild Card Game to the Titans in 2017. The way the Chiefs extended their window was by drafting a generational talent at Quarterback and pairing him with Tyreek Hill (while holding over Travis Kelce from the last core). These versions of the Chiefs are a different version than the Alex Smith teams. The same will be true for the Colts, sooner or later.
The Colts are in Year 3 of this present version of their team. Anthony Castanzo, the franchise Left Tackle, is succumbing to injuries and is pushing retirement. Marlon Mack is on his way out, while being replaced by an equally serviceable Jonathan Taylor. T.Y Hilton appears to be all but washed, and any multi-year extension Indy give him will be because of his past accomplishments. The fractures are starting to show up in what was, at one time, the defined core of this Colts team.
While it's true that Quenton Nelson, Darius Leonard, Kenny Moore, and now DeForest Buckner are all really good, they are no longer CHEAP and really good. The Colts gave Moore an extension last offseason. Indianapolis gave up a 1st Rounder and $105 million. Darius Leonard will receive an extension making him the highest paid MLB in the NFL this offseason, as he 100% deserves. The same will be coming to Nelson after next season. While those players are still good, they are getting paid like they are now. They aren't generating Value against the cap anymore, and the Champions of every sport are the ones who generate the most value relative to the cap.
Indianapolis may make the playoffs this year, but I'm sure that, if they were going to win the Super Bowl, this year and last year were their best chances to happen. We'll never know what would've happened if Luck never retired, and I'm convinced he aborted a future dynasty in Indianapolis. But the Colts season is already a disappointment, no matter what the end result is on Sunday. It's a hard pill to swallow, but it appears the Colts have officially missed their Super Bowl window. If they wanted to extend that window, I don't think even Matthew Stafford or Carson Wentz is enough to achieve that. I believe Wentz could still be an extremely serviceable, even Tier 2 Quarterback with the right weapons and time to progress through reads. We saw some of that when he was at his healthiest in 2017. Maybe he gives the Colts a special run in 2021, IF the Colts can get him in the 1st place. If not, it's over in Indianapolis. I feel it's probably over anyways.
No comments:
Post a Comment