Also lost in the news on Sunday: Trevor Lawrence and Justin Fields will be playing each other for the 2nd Year in a Row in Primetime for the College Football Playoff Semifinal Game. Last year, Justin Fields threw an INT in the endzone to close out a comeback victory for the Clemson Tigers, 29-23. At that time, I talked about how Fields and Lawrence's careers will be joined at the hip for the next 2 decades. From their CFB Semifinal matchup, to the fact they were the 2 leading Heisman Candidates for 2020, to them being the surefire #1 and #2 Picks in the 2021 Draft since Last December. I then readdressed this during the Pandemic Hiatus from Sports on the Take It Easy Podcast.
Now that we've seen all of this play out, from the Clemson-Ohio State Round 2 on January 1st to Weekly #TankforTrevor trackers between Jaguars and Jets games, let's revisit how Fields and Lawrence will never be able to escape one another for the next 20 years. And the best way to do that is to look back at an identical situation from a Decade ago.
There are similar situations to what were seeing between Fields and Lawrence. In 1998, Mel Kiper Jr said Ryan Leaf and Peyton Manning were the same prospects, and it was a toss up which one should be taken #1. The Colts took Peyton Manning #1 and the Chargers took Leaf #2. Leaf had a tortured life following his flameout in the NFL (which you can read about above and watch the E60 90 minute Documentary on ESPN). Through his tortured past, battles with addiction to painkillers, and multiple arrests, Leaf's name is always synonymous with Peyton Manning.
In 1999, Tim Couch was selected with the #1 Pick by the Cleveland Browns. The 2nd Pick that year was Donovan McNabb, who would go on to make 6 Pro Bowls with Andy Reid and the Philadelphia Eagles. While Couch is better known in Browns' lore for his shortcomings, he is very much synonymous with McNabb's Name.
When Eli Manning and Philip Rivers were traded for each other in 2004, their career arch became intertwined, compared time and time again to each other. Then it was Alex Smith and Aaron Rodgers, the Top 2 QB's taken in 2005. We like to make simple comparisons because we are infatuated with the NFL Draft Process and the uncertainties that gets more certain over time.
Andrew Luck and Robert Griffin III were the two QB's who closest resemble what we're seeing with Lawrence and Fields. They were the 2 leading Heisman trophy candidates in the 2011 College Football Season, Griffin at Baylor, Luck at Stanford. RGIII ended up winning that award, and there was much speculation that Luck and RGIII could swap Picks 1 and 2. In reality, the Colts were going to take Luck at #1. Like Lawrence, Andrew Luck was graded as a 98 rated Prospect, making him the #1 Overall Prospect in the NFL Draft, regardless of position. The Colts were going to Pick Luck at #1, as long as they could get the Draft Picks to make that happen.
Peyton Manning missed the entire 2011 season with a Neck injury many people felt would end his career as an effective NFL starter. The Colts were 0-13 to start the 2011 season. Curtis Painter was QB for the Colts, and they were trying to avoid being just the 2nd 0-16 team in NFL History. Many Colts fans were sinking into the Idea of being 0-16, and having the certainty of picking Andrew Luck with the #1 Pick. The Colts were fighting off the St. Louis Rams for the #1 Pick. The Rams had already won 2 meaningless games in a 2-11 2011. Does all of this sound familiar, cause it probably should.
All of a sudden, the Colts started winning games. They beat the Titans to move within 1 game of the Rams. Then, in Week 16, they won again, this time against the Houston Texans. The Colts and Rams had the same 2-13 records with one game to play. The tiebreaker belonged to the Rams, which meant the Colts had a very simple equation: Lose and you get Andrew Luck. Win, and you'll be picking Robert Griffin at #2.
The final matchup for the Colts: The 4-11 Jacksonville Jaguars. The Jaguars, led by Blaine Gabbert and Maurice Jones-Drew, were themselves positioned to secure the #3 Pick in the Draft with a Loss to the Colts. The Jaguars scored the only TD of the 1st Half, leading 10-6 at Halftime. Colts fans felt the same levels of anguish Jets and Jaguars fans have felt since Week 11: Do we want to win or lose this game to secure a brighter future???
On Jacksonville's 1st Possession of the 2nd Half, Jones Drew broke off a 60 yard run that set up another Jacksonville Field Goal. 13-6 Jaguars. Dan Orlovsky, who replaced Curtis Painter due to injury, threw an INT that gave Jacksonville 3 more points. Then a fumble by Orlovsky led to another Jaguars field goal. 19-6, 4th Quarter.
The Colts were on the brink of getting the #1 Pick. Their #SuckforLuck campaign was almost complete. By this point, those Colts fans still rooting for victories had accepted their fate. Following 2 punts, the Colts got the ball down 2 scores, with 5 minutes left. And Orlovsky took them right down the field in 2 minutes. Touchdown Colts. With 3 minutes left, the Colts had brought the game within 6 points. With 1 defensive stop, the Colts were going to get the ball, 2 minutes left, and a 2 minute drill away from winning the game.
The Colts called timeout on 1st Down. Again on 2nd Down. They were out of timeouts, with a 3rd and 4 upcoming for the Jaguars. A stop, and they would get the ball again with 2 minutes left. A 1st Down, and the Jaguars were in victory formation. Jacksonville calls a Draw play with Jones-Drew, who earlier became the Jaguars' All Time Rushing Champion with 1,600 yards in 2011. MJD dove forward from a yard short of the marker, and the ball was spotted right at the line to gain. Game Over. The Colts lose.
What followed was the Indianapolis Colts drafting Andrew Luck with the 1st Pick in the Draft. The Rams traded Pick #2 to Washington for RGIII. RGIII's career arch was cut short by injury, but he had one of the most spectacular rookie seasons in NFL History. Luck would be statistically more impressive, but he himself famously retired from Football at Age 29. With Luck, that retirement will come to define his career. With RGIII, every time someone mentions him often comes in conversation with Andrew Luck.
From all of our examples, it appears that the QB who ends up being the worse pick is the one we always compare to who was picked before him. In the case of Tim Couch, he was #1 but flamed out of the league. Based on all of our context clues, it appears Lawrence will be better than Fields, but Fields will still be an amazing QB. Much like with Philip Rivers and Eli Manning, we will simply acknowledge that both were great. However, because of this 2020 #TankforTrevor season, Fields is framed as a consolation prize to Lawrence. That part may not be escapable for him, no matter how great his career ends up being.
No comments:
Post a Comment