The Cleveland Browns are going to the playoffs. The Cleveland Browns are no longer perpetual rebuilders. They are the NFL's version of "The Process", set in place by Sashi Brown, neutered by John Dorsey, and polished off by Andrew Berry. It took 3 head coaches, 4 Offensive Coordinators, a 0-16 season, and a 1-31 stretch of Football from 2016 and 2017.
It's now time we stopped evaluating the success of the Browns by "Browns standards" and start evaluating them by "NFL Standards". First and foremost, by NFL standards the Cleveland Browns are a CATASTROPHIC disappointment for the amount of talent they have. The idea that, following a 7-8-1 rookie season with Baker Mayfield, the Browns are on the verge of only 1 playoff appearance and 0 playoff wins in 2 seasons is a major indictment of the organization (which, when talking about the Browns, is taken for granted).
Much like the 2019 Bills, the Browns will be the #5 Seed in the AFC Playoffs, and go on the road for a playoff game they will likely be underdogs in. While the Bills did hold a 17-0 lead vs. the Houston Texans, they did ultimately lose that Wild Card playoff game 20-17. If the Browns exit in the Wild Card via defeat to either Indianapolis or Tennessee, they will have 0 playoff wins to show for one of the most talented teams in the NFL.
As fun as the Browns success is, we're talking about a team with 49ers, Rams and Steelers levels of talent. Myles Garrett is a guaranteed Top 5 Defensive player in the NFL, much like Von Miller was in his first 4 years in the NFL. Denzel Ward is a really talented CB, and from those 2 cornerstones the Browns build out the rest of their defense. Oliver Vernon, Sheldon Richardson, Mack Wilson, Sione Takitaki, Terrence Mitchell, and others compliment the two cornerstones Garrett and Ward the same way Donald and Ramsey compliment the rest of the Rams defense, which is presently ranked #2 in the NFL.
In total fairness to the Browns, they have battled injuries all season, especially with Denzel Ward. Myles Garrett then missed two games due to COVID. They've kept winning anyways. And now all those pieces are coming together at exactly the right time. Cleveland's defense has the legitimate chance to blank playoff caliber opponents, and they're offense helps keep the defense on the field as little as possible.
The Cleveland Browns are the #1 Rushing Attack in the NFL. They are the only NFL team that boasts 2 1,000 Yard Rushers in Nick Chubb and Kareem Hunt. Right now, both running backs are on pace to rush for 1,000 yards again in 2020, with Chubb on pace for 1,200 and Hunt for 985 yards. The Browns Offensive Line allowed only 2 pressures on 26 snaps in the 1st Half against the Titans, a 7.8% clip. The league average is around 30% of snap pressures. The Browns rank #3 in QB pressures allowed by the O-Line, and their unit has been together for most of the games this year. Their investments in OT Jack Conklin (Free Agency) and Jedrick Wills (1st Round Pick) have proven to be 2 of the best acquisitions of the offseason. Combined, their offensive line has missed 5 total starts this season.
The Browns are at their best offensively when they run 2 WR, 2 TE sets. These sets bring out the best in Baker Mayfield, who's play invokes strong emotions on both sides of the isle. The Browns kept David Njoku for a reason, who requested a trade this offseason. He, Harrison Bryant and Austin Hooper all have found their share of targets and Touchdowns in 2020. This offense is how the Browns turn Baker Mayfield into a QB who throws for 354 yards and 4 Touchdowns in the 1st Half against the Titans. Jarvis Landry is always the safety blanket (as he's been for his entire career), along with either Kareem Hunt or Rashad Higgins in the slot position. Since the departure of Odell Beckham, the Browns offense has increased it's output nearly 45%, and Baker Mayfield has improved his QBR (in non rain/snow games) by 25 Points.
In year 3 of the Baker Mayfield experience, the Browns should be competing for the Super Bowl like the Rams and 49ers did in 2018 and 2019, respectively. Unfortunately, they had a major hiccup with the failed Freddie Kitchens/John Dorsey experiment. With the level of talent they have on this team, which is now being utilized correctly by Kevin Stefanski, this is not even an unreasonable request. When healthy, the Browns have a defense comparable in talent to the Rams, who are ranked #2 in team defense in 2020. They have a Top 5 offensive Line, with the #1 rushing attack in the NFL, along with a QB who, when asked to, can throw 30 TD's in a season. Yet, thanks to some bad decisions and tough breaks, the Browns find themselves in a position where A. They might have 0 Playoff wins to show for all their efforts B. They have a QB who is not Deshaun-Watson Special who is coming up on a contract extension eligibility.
The question looming over the Browns head is the Baker Mayfield decision. Baker Mayfield is, no question, a better QB than replacement level options like Teddy Bridgewater, Mitchell Trubisky, or his highly paid backup Case Keenum. But he's not as good as Deshaun Watson, Russell Wilson, or Josh Allen. He's somewhere in the middle, we just don't know where. Good enough to be a starter, but not good enough to win games singlehandedly like Mahomes, Wilson, Rodgers and Watson.
The question of "whether or not to extend Baker Mayfield" comes down to a simple question: How much we talking?? For me, I set a hard line in the sand at $100 million over 4 years, with all the guaranteed money in the 1st 2 1/2 years of the contract. I'd feel comfortable extending him at about $21-22 million a season, again with all his guaranteed money in the 1st 3 years of the contract, so I can move on without a question after year 3. Anything more and I'm letting Baker walk out the door.
Since we don't know the value of Baker Mayfield's 5th year option (it will be anywhere between $18-27 million based on the new CBA and the Salary Cap figures that are messed up by COVID), so it's too early to decide whether or not I'd accept the 5th year option (there's like a 75-25 chance I would accept the option just to buy me time before signing that contract extension). The Browns just need to avoid digging themselves into a Jared Goff or Carson Wentz level hole like the Rams and Eagles did with record setting extensions. I'd structure the deal for Mayfield similarly to the 49ers Jimmy G deal, where they could get out of the deal after year 3. It's a small stepping stone where, if done wrong, could hamstring the franchise like the Rams and Eagles find themselves now.
No comments:
Post a Comment