Saturday, December 26, 2020

The Kirk Cousins "Good, Not Great" Experience

 First and foremost: HOLY SHIT Alvin Kamara!!!!!! Subsequently, HOLY SHIT the Vikings defense is worse than I thought, which is one of the statistically bottom 25% in the NFL.

Anyways, the Vikings were statistically eliminated from the playoffs on Christmas via an embarrassing 52-33 loss their greatest non-NFC North Rivals, the New Orleans Saints. The Vikings were already going to miss the playoffs after their loss to the Bears last Sunday. With a win, the Vikings would've had a chance to move within striking distance of the Arizona Cardinals for the 7th Playoff Spot. The Vikings defense got torched by the Bears for 198 rushing yards and 2 rushing Touchdowns. The Vikings had one last chance to make magic happen, with 1 minute left, and they couldn't keep their season alive, even though it felt like they had been dead for the entire game.

The Bears loss was the nail in the coffin that came after, one week earlier, the Vikings lost to the Buccaneers by 12 points. Kicker Dan Bailey missed 4 Field Goals which, times 3 points each, equals the 12 points they lost to vs. a sputtering NFC Wild Card team. 2 weeks earlier, the Vikings went to Overtime with the 1 win Jacksonville Jaguars, a game they ultimately prevailed in but showed the Vikings weren't really that legitimate a threat, and any playoff game they played in would come after fighting for the last playoff spot.

In the Jaguars game, Kirk Cousins went 28/43 for 305 yards, 3 TD's and 1 INT, for a QBR or 99.5, which would've ranked him 12th in the League. Good, not great. 

Against the Bucs, Kirk was 24/37, with 1 TD, 0 INTs and 225 yards. His QBR: 90.5. Good, not great. 

Against the Bears, it was 24/35, 271 yards, 2 TDs and 1 INT, for a QBR of 98.6. Good, not great.

And on a day where Alvin Kamara scored 6 TD's for the Saints, Kirk went 27-41 for 291 Yards, 3 TDs and 0 INTs. Kirk's Passer Rating went up to 110.9, which puts him in the Top 7 in the league. It also raised his season average to 103.1, which ranks him 9th in the NFL. However, Kirk also has an adjusted QBR (which takes into account when and how yards were recorded). Kirk is ranked 20th in the league at 62.5, which means most of Kirk Cousins numbers are disproportionately coming in garbage time.

Again, Kirk Cousins is good, not great. And the Vikings have sold their souls to good, but not great. And, with Mike Zimmer's Final Reckoning Coming Soon, the Vikings will either keep riding out their mediocrity as long as they can or start over RIGHT now. I suspect they will choose to keep riding this out, but here's what it will look like either way.

IF THE VIKINGS KEEP IT TOGETHER: The Vikings signed Mike Zimmer and Kirk Cousins to extensions this offseason. For Kirk it was a 2 year extension. For Zimmer, it was a "3 year deal", but because coaches never coach on the last year of their deal (Jason Garrett was an exception that proves the rule), it's essentially a 2 year extension. It makes perfect sense that, since Cousins and Zimmer are under contract through 2022, the Vikings hope they can turn their ship around.

They'll keep everyone in place next year. They gave Dalvin Cook an extension this offseason. Theilen and Jefferson are under contract. They're good to go next year.....

Except, they have the Free Agency of Anthony Harris impending. They could franchise tag him a 2nd time, or sign him to a long extension, pushing them further behind the salary cap. Also, Starting OLB Eric Wilson is a Free Agent, and he'll get a 3x salary upgrade from the Vikings. Let's not forget about starting Left Guard Dakota Dozier. He's making $1 million this year, and he'll upgrade that to about $7 million if the Vikings want to keep him. 

The Vikings will have to replace George Iloka at Safety. And Defensive Tackle Jaleel Johnson. You could either spend more money or address those issues in the draft for cheaper, lesser players. Add all those together, and the Vikings find themselves about $36 million over the salary cap for next year. 

So, let's try to lower that number a little bit. The easiest place to start is by cutting aging former defensive captain Harrison Smith. That should save about $11 million. Then, let's trade Kyle Rudolph to the Jaguars for a 3rd Round Pick. That saves around $6 million. Then, if we restructure a contract with Michael Pierce, that should get that number down to a manageable -15 million. Let's also say we don't resign Eric Wilson, saving another $7 million. That gets the Vikings down to around $8 million over the salary cap. The owner will pay that luxury tax bill for the 2nd year in a row, and they don't have to be in the repeater tax.

Now, let's turn to the NFL Draft. The Vikings will have the #17 pick in the Draft, and they'll probably just pick someone who addresses a positional need on defense. It might be a OLB to replace Eric Wilson. Maybe it's a Safety to pair along with Anthony Harris. In the 2nd Round, let's say they pick a Defensive or Offensive Lineman. Danielle Hunter will come back healthy, so you hope that your team looks a bit better with an All Pro talent rushing the passer. With the Jaguars pick, they'll draft another Tight End to pair with Irv Smith Jr.

The Vikings will plug holes on Defense with band aids, while not really addressing their offensive line. The hope is CB Jeff Gladney gets better with more experience, and maybe that anchors the secondary that has been wavering since losing Xavier Rhodes and, now, Harrison Smith. On offense, Dalvin Cook will again go for 1,000 yards, but he'll battle injuries again throughout the season. He'll leave early from 2 games, then miss 2 more recovering from an injury. Kirk Cousins and Alexander Mattison will be asked to do more, and the offense will blow up in their face. They'll again rank in the Top 10 in Passing and Rushing, and Top 6 or 7 in scoring.

Thanks to better injury luck, the Vikings will be a bit better on defense. On the last week of the season, they'll be in the 7th Wild Card Spot, needing 1 win to make the playoffs. They might win, they might not. The larger point is that the Vikings will be what they've been for the last 4 years under Kirk Cousins. Good, not great. Worst case scenario, injuries blow up in their face and they make a 4-12 or 5-11 fall just like the Atlanta Falcons did in the last 2 years of the Dan Quinn era, before they made their inevitable rebuild.

IF THEY BLOW IT UP: Let's say the owner of the Vikings says that mediocrity is no longer acceptable. He blows it up after this game (unlikely, but should be much more likely with another missed playoffs in 2021). The Vikings will move on from GM Rick Spielman and Mike Zimmer, not because they were bad but because the Vikings don't want to lock them in for another 6 or 7 years together. It's better to let someone new, with fresh perspective, try to run the organization. Zimmer and Spielman should both land on their feet rather easily with other franchises, maybe even with more promising futures.

The first order of business will be trading Kirk Cousins. As a 32 year old QB in the Top Half of QB's in the league, Cousins commands the most value on the Vikings roster not named Danielle Hunter. There would be a number of suitors for Kirk Cousins as well. The 49ers are the leaders in any conversation, and Kyle Shanahan, Cousins' OC during his breakout year in Washington, was feeling out signing Cousins in 2018 before the 49ers traded for Jimmy Garoppolo. Maybe the 49ers will overpay for Kirk, giving up their 1st Round Pick and a few other picks. Maybe the Vikings could get one of those defensive players in a trade as well (2019 Pariah Akhello Witherspoon, for instance???). Other suitors include the Colts, Raiders, Broncos, Patriots, and Carolina Panthers.

Then, the Vikings will trade Riley Rieff for another 2nd or 1st Round Pick, with 1 year left on his contract. The Vikings will spend that draft pick on his replacement, either in the early 2nd Round or late 1st Round. If I were in the GM chair, I would trade Dalvin Cook to anyone willing to give up a 1st Round Pick and a young player, much like the Odell Beckham trade from a couple years ago. This trade hurts the cap, but trading Dalvin Cook is about accruing future value when we want the team to be good.

So, who would I sign to be my starting QB in 2021?? Well, how about Marcus Mariota??? He's a fringe level starter who can succeed with Alexander Mattison, who should take the next step towards becoming an 800 yard rusher in this offense, along with a running QB in Mariota. With our 2021 Picks (I count 8 picks in the 1st 3 Rounds, 3 1st, 2 2nd, 3 3rd), here's who I would draft:

1st Round: Left Tackle, Defensive Tackle, Guard

2nd Round: Safety, Offensive Tackle/guard

3rd Round: Cornerback, Tight End, Linebacker,

So, the Vikings would now be under the salary cap. We can sign one of these 25 running backs in Free Agency (Frank Gore?? Marlon Mack?? Maybe James Connor if you're really feeling yourself). Mariota would have a new Offensive Line, and the running game would again be the staple that sets up Theilen and Jefferson. The Offense would only regress slightly, while making a commitment to rebuilding their defense.

This is a longer rebuild. The Vikings won't be very good next year. They'll get another high draft pick, which they may use on a QB, or wait until 2023 to take that future Franchise QB. It depends how long this rebuild will last. The Vikings may finally break their trends of mediocrity once and for all. They probably won't but this is what it would look like

No comments:

Post a Comment