Saturday, December 5, 2020

We Can't Blame the Eagles for the Carson Wentz Contract

 The Eagles have found out, quite rudely, that Carson Wentz is not the elite QB they saw in 2017. He might not even be a Franchise QB that they'd like to hitch their caboose to. Wentz's contract guarantees that he'll be the Eagles starter for the rest of 2020, and that Wentz will be the Eagles opening night starter in 2021. After that, it becomes more reasonable for the Eagles to move on from Wentz, if that's what they so choose.

Through all of this mayhem and falling apart that is the 2020 Philadelphia Eagles, there's no way I, the person would would only pay top dollar for 5-7 QB's in the NFL, can blame Howie Roseman and the Eagles for giving that albatross contract to Wentz. From where Carson was in 2017, the MVP of the NFL at 23 years old, and only playing 10 games in a 2018 where Philadelphia made the playoffs, the Eagles felt they had seen enough to, at the very least, take a chance on Wentz becoming an Elite NFL QB.

We could play the results, knowing now that Wentz is a limited QB with whom most people watching Football think should go to the bench behind Jalen Hurts. We can claim that Howie Roseman and Doug Pederson are incompetent for giving Wentz a big contract, when 98% of us would pick Carson Wentz in 2018 over 20-25 QB's in the NFL. We can say that Philadelphia made an unforgivable mistake, when we all saw that Wentz was an ACL injury away from being NFL MVP and Super Bowl MVP at 23 years old.

The Eagles are going to have a lot of regrets about their Post-Super Bowl roster construction. This offseason, the Eagles are going to trade pieces like Zach Ertz, Alshon Jeffery and Brandon Brooks a year too late instead of a year too early, losing out on nearly 85-90% of their value. The Eagles obviously regret the Wentz contract now, and it's with good reason. Wentz is ranked 34th in QBR (worse than some replacement level backups) and has thrown more interceptable passes than any QB in the NFL. He's thrown more than 2019 Jameis Winston, now relegated to the 3rd String QB for a stacked QB room in New Orleans.

Revisionist History confirms, as I firmly believe, that there are only 5 QB's of which Franchises should be paying $30-40 million a season. Mahomes is one, as are Russell Wilson, Aaron Rodgers, and Deshaun Watson. We already see the signs in some QB's of a CHANCE of getting to that elite threshold. The Eagles were faced with this dilemma in March of 2019. What the Eagles had seen in 2017 was Carson Wentz playing AT an elite level. While playing at an elite level for 1 season doesn't make you an elite QB (*cough cough Jay Cutler cough cough), it does set the stage for that player (potentially) becoming an Elite QB, the greatest gift the NFL can bestow.

In the coming months, the Ravens and Bills will have to make similar decisions around Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen, respectively. Both contracts have the same chance of blowing up as spectacularly as Carson Wentz and the Eagles. But ask yourselves right now, today, whether or not you would pay $30-40 million a season for Lamar Jackson or Josh Allen. Look back in 2 years to see if you were right or not. That's where we all are with Carson Wentz right now. That's why I choose not to play revisionist history and act like we all wouldn't have done the same if in the same situation.

No comments:

Post a Comment